Avatar: Shaman’s Review of the Sci-fi Experience of the Decade!!!

Avatar: Shaman’s Review of the Sci-fi Experience of the Decade!!!

After the over-hype, the reviews, the acclaims and the film’s fast generated numbers at the box office, what can finally be made of James Cameron’s Avatar?

Since Avatar has now beaten Titanic's record, here's a repost of my review for the people who haven't seen it yet and are now contemplating to go and find out what all the buzz is about.

Review Opinion
By Shaman - Jan 26, 2010 12:01 AM EST
Filed Under: Sci-Fi



Most of you knew that I wouldn’t have paid to see this film until it came out and dropped down to the DVD bargain bins. But once again, my femme fatale tugged on the leash and dragged me to the movies. This time however, it was to be my very first 3D experience in theatres. After the god awful after taste that was left in my mouth from the over-hype regarding this film’s release, I was adamant in not paying for it in order to do my part at showing the industry that it is in my opinion, wrong to over fluff a book’s cover in order to sell it. I firmly believe that nature should be allowed to take its course. The reviews would have been as positive if not more so, were we not already tiered of hearing about the film prior to its release. Alas, Avatar will always carry the stain of having been over-hyped. But was the term “over-hype” appropriately used, you’re all asking? Of course it was. Hype is all in good fun until there is so much of it to the point where people go right past “scepticism” and straight down to “pessimism”, even before having seen it and no matter how good the film actually is. Moderation is Key.



What is so revolutionary about it? The film making is, period. Sorry to sound so “negative”, it isn’t my intention here, I’m just telling the truth. You’ve all seen similar special effects, action sequences, inventive nature settings and imaginary species before. And the story itself has been over used to a point that it seems they’ve blown the bottom of the barrel to smithereens! Even though Zoe Saldana outshined everyone on set, the acting is nowhere above decent. No Oscar worthy performances in sight. Which is fine and was to be expected since the movie did not primarily focus on its drama scenes. Worthington did fine but nothing Keanu Reeves couldn’t imitate. And his accent slip ups were as irritating as ever especially since there was no valid reason why Cameron didn’t let Sam use it throughout the film. If his Australian accent is inconsequential to the plot, why unsuccessfully try to hide it? Sigourney Weaver was as decent and as sexy as ever. Ribisi seemed to have given us his best ever performance which is to say “only decent”. Stephen Lang was just as decent even though playing the highly clichéd military antagonist. But he did seem like he was missing something. Even though the man had crazy scars, tripled his girth and wielded a freakin’ Mech Warrior, he still didn’t scare me shitless as much as he used to in passed favourites of mine such as Fire Down Below and The Hard Way. But he still delivered what I believe the director wanted. And quite frankly, I don’t feel the director was as demanding of his actors as he should have been. It’s obvious that his main focus was on the effects and action which were brilliantly done as always but it made many supporting performances seem insignificant even though their characters were labelled as “vital” to the plot.



Well, did this movie succeed or not? That would have to depend on their goal. Since the film was meant to be a thrilling sci-fi fantasy experience, I’d have to say… “You can bet your sweet ass, it did!” But there was something that could have been improved on before the film’s final cut. The pacing in itself was a bit off. Most people that have seen it have said that the whole 162 minutes passed by in a flash. Could it be because they simply enjoyed it? I think there’s something more to it. My experience even though enjoyable, actually felt rushed. We were taken from one scene to another without so much as a breather as if we were pushed to move forward. From beginning to end, this film felt like “let’s cut to the chase”. It’s probably why I felt like most of the supporting performances could have been taken away from the film without much notice even though it would create major plot holes. There was little to no character development even in the lead’s case. It’s not so much of a negative aspect of the film per say but it felt like a mild nuisance. There seemed to be very little thought which compensated with only reaction. That’s pretty much the lead’s whole concept but for a 162 minute feature, I would have wanted a bit more elaboration in that department. Other than that, they did exactly what they set out to do which was to immerse you whole into a different world and let your senses tingle with excitement and awe as if we had gone back to our childhood innocence. The world they have created did not only look stunning but also felt REAL. Along side the on par action scenes, what I appreciated the most about this film was the whole “lore” that they created with the world of Pandora as well as the connection its inhabitants have with it. As a Shaman myself, I was very pleased with the message that was attached to the film. But it is unfortunate that it’s tied to a “fantasy” setting.



In retrospect, I can’t wait for this film to get to those bargain bins because I can’t wait to see how it will look without the 3D effect. The 3D in itself bothered me at first until it pretty much faded away beyond my perception. Roughly translated, it didn’t do its job. The most impressive 3D scene was the “REAL D” advertisement before the opening of the film where we saw the robot dog playing with the techno type ball. During the film, every single moving 3D part looked fuzzy. The still parts were fine but there were very little of those in a living nature environment. I firmly believe that the 3D element should be kept for fully animated features such as A Christmas Carol which I’m told worked very successfully with the 3D. I’m very happy to hear that Ironman 2 and Prince of Persia weren’t shot in 3D. It would have made the experience too awkward for me. But where Avatar truly succeeded was with its revolutionary CGI special effects. The “emotion” capture system they have created successfully incorporated a computer generated lead character into a live action motion picture. I can’t help but grin at the possibilities for the next Hellboy film or maybe even a Never Ending Story remake, wink-wink. Mickey Rourke sir, you no longer have an excuse to not return for another thrilling Marv story in a future Sin City flick!

So was I completely blown away? No, but I was indeed pleasantly surprised. I give it 3.5 stars out of five. So go ahead and make your Battle Angel Alita film, James. You sure did create the correct technology to give the concept justice. But don’t forget to cast Ellen Page as Gally ;)

HIT MAN Star Glen Powell Spotted On Set Of Edgar Wright's THE RUNNING MAN; Movie's Logo Revealed
Related:

HIT MAN Star Glen Powell Spotted On Set Of Edgar Wright's THE RUNNING MAN; Movie's Logo Revealed

SQUID GAME Season 2 Trailer Sees Lee Jung-jae Embark On A Bloody New Mission As Player 456
Recommended For You:

SQUID GAME Season 2 Trailer Sees Lee Jung-jae Embark On A Bloody New Mission As Player 456

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

InTylerWeTrust
InTylerWeTrust - 1/5/2010, 2:23 PM
Good review Shaman. I do agree with it.

I wrote my review as soon as I got home from seeing the movie, so my thoughts have settled more now.

I think that it is still an awesome experience, like going through any fantastic, amazing new world is.

I don't criticize it as a film as much now though, because, as I said, my thoughts have settled now.

The plot and characters are generic, but they work I guess, and maybe that's what counts. They just seem so lazily made, but they work in the movie.

I am willing to guarantee that if you took the fancy effects/3D away, the reviews wouldn't nearly be as good as they are.

I've steered clear of pretty much all Avatar-articles lately, because it's so aggravating to try and have an actual discussion with some of the people who absolutely loved the movie and can't accept anything less than a glowing opinion of it. That and they're drinking way too much Kool-Aid and feel like they need to be all victorious and make fun of those who have criticized the movie.
ecksmanfan
ecksmanfan - 1/5/2010, 2:34 PM
Great review Shamen. I, along with Tyler and yourself, was able to see past the hype. I think it's a movie worth watching, in the sense that Cameron was able to create a new world for us to experience. But the film as a whole was just mediochre...at best.
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 1/5/2010, 3:19 PM
[frick] me Shaman, thats some intensive reviewing! Im gonna have to step my game up:)

I agree pretty much completely..although I thought the performances were closer to very good than just decent.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 1/5/2010, 5:03 PM
Lol @ SHAMAN i see your not hating on it as much now! ; P

I agree with ROR they was very good!

Nice review though and a hell yeah for ELLEN PAGE as GALLY!!

Hey i thought you wanted her for GHOST IN THE SHELL (Though that wouldn't work) but yeah perfect GALLY!!!!

BATTLE ANGEL needs to be made fast!!
superdog
superdog - 1/5/2010, 5:11 PM
great review. pretty much what i expected. those of us posting here pretty much seem to be the group with the closest set of taste and mentality about films so we pretty much all agree on this one. you should get out more and do more reviews instead of always waiting for the bargain bin :)
superdog
superdog - 1/5/2010, 5:12 PM
my bad, i posted my comment right before lee77 did, so i have to retract my statement about all of us having the same taste in movies......i now mean all of us except lee77 :)
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 1/5/2010, 6:49 PM
DOGS BREATH!!! ; D

Yeah we all luv [frick]ing BORIGINS don't we lol!
superdog
superdog - 1/5/2010, 6:53 PM
and we all think gijoe was the dark horse of the summer
ecksmanfan
ecksmanfan - 1/5/2010, 7:40 PM
@teabag- You mean it won't? I'm devastated.

@superdog- by dark horse you mean horse sh!t, right?
superdog
superdog - 1/5/2010, 7:59 PM
Yes. Although I am looking forward to human target. That and 24 back to back will be a good night for t.v.
Shaman
Shaman - 1/6/2010, 7:34 AM
HA HA HA!!!!! Love you guys so much! Thanks for the compliments!!!

Tyler- I wrote my review three days after i saw it. I just didn't have access to a computer LOL. But i get what you're saying and it was THE point i couldn't agree more with from your review (even though your whole review was right on the money). The film is an "experience" in itself. It's a must see. Not for the acting or the fight scenes or the effects alone but as a whole, it's a great experience. Like i said, there wasn't much "negative" aspects about this film. Not a great film but a great experience ;)

ecksmanfan- I totally agree with you!

Teabag- EXACTLY!!!! For me, about half way through, the 3D was almost non existant. It seemed to revert back to 2D but to continue watching it we needed to keep the damn glasses on. I already need to wear my glasses so i had two of them on which wasn't too comfortable. But a fully CGIed movie would be AWESOME in 3D!!! And yeah, Worthington's accent was damn annoying only because he couldn't hide it well. It's the "effort" that's cringing to me. Why not let him use his australian accent fully??? It would be less DDDIIIIIIIISSSSSSSSTRAAAAAAAACTIIIIIINNNNNGGG LOL. BTW, Sherlock looks awesome to me!!! That's one i'd love to go see before it's out on DVD.

Ror- Thanks dude!!! Yeah i knew from the start that the performances would be the only thing we wouldn't see eye to eye on, so to speak. Don't get me wrong though, to me decent is good. I don't see decent as mediocre. Decent is what i at least expect to see when i go to theaters. Good to me is actually great and Great is award winning. Saldana was good to me while the rest was decent. But don't change a damn thing about the way you do your reviews!!! I love em to death!!! My only beef with them is that they are never long enough, not because you don't write enough but because i never want them to end LOL :P You're awesome, Ror!!! Don't change a thing ;)

LEEE- LOL i never "hated" the film, only it's over-hype. And that goes for any film really. Avatar just went way overboard with it. It's a very enjoyable film, one that i wouldn't go see twice and wouldn't pay full price for when it gets out on DVD/Blu-Ray. I'll grab it for 10$ ;) Oh and i never suggested Ellen Page for Ghost In The Shell. Don't hate me but that's ONE role i think Angelina Jolie would nail, hands down.

superdog- Thanks bud, since i don't have much funding to throw at the theaters, i rarely get the chance to go. I'm the kind of guy that really enjoys watching the same film multiple times so i rather buy a movie for 10$ than only see it once. And i agree about us here with the exception of LEEE. But he's just a very passionate fellah LOL. Us here including a fair handful more are able to see something for what it truly is and discuss it inteligently without going to each others throats. I enjoy a good discussion even though i don't always agree with the majority. Not everything has to be a debate.
loganoneil
loganoneil - 1/6/2010, 11:19 AM
Shaman - "Worthington did fine but nothing Keanu Reeves couldn’t imitate." Was that a slam on Worthington or a compliment to Reeves (LMAO!)? I totally agree with everything you said. As for waiting for the 2D DVD to come out, you KNOW Cameron will probably release it only in 3D (with glasses included) for full effect!
THEHAWK
THEHAWK - 1/6/2010, 12:47 PM
Well, we have a different view on the film, but you gave a fair and honest review, which I respect.

I was actually surprised by the fact that i liked teh film, I had LOOoooowww expectations for it.

I will probably write a review for it later.
ThunderCougarFalconBird
ThunderCougarFalconBird - 1/6/2010, 1:19 PM
Shaman! You called and I answered! Did you use the sea shell horn? It gives me a warm feeling (much like that of a good rum) that you noticed my absence. I have simply been snowed under with hospital appointments for the family. But I did manage a 2 week trip to Orlando to keep check on the Disney/Marvel merger. I was thinking of posting a spoof article about it but that would just be shamlessly throwing my holiday snaps in everyone's faces! To cut a long story down into what is already a lengthy waffle, I now have a phone that will let me post comments on here!

Onto your fine work here. Your opening paragraph pretty much sums up how I feel about this movie. I am yet to see it, and although I'm sure it will be good I'd rather wait for the hype to clear before seeing it. I'm also concerned with the possible involvement of "lucas syndrome". Some movies have too much in the way of effects that the world lacks believability and the director becomes so embroiled in the way the film looks he looses sight of the foundations that make a good movie.
Shaman
Shaman - 1/6/2010, 2:04 PM
Teabag- LMAO

loganoneil- Kinda both LOL. But it would actually suck if they don't even have the cheap 2d/one disc version :(

HAWK- HEY BUDDY!!! Welcome back :)) I replyed to you on my Myth sketch article ;) And you totally SHOULD write your review!!! For some reason, i never get tiered of reading people's views about it :) You need to shoot me an e-mail with your new one ;)

Ron- Buddy, pal, 'stach, glad to have you here... AND BACK!!! Hey, i voted for you in the CBM awards. I don't remember which category, it was ages ago and i don't know who the winners were or if they even got announced LOL. I had a feeling you were swamped with that unfortunate stuff but i'm really glad you can still come on here so we can bask in the greatness of your 'stash! In regards to avatar... i thought Lucas and Cameron were the same guy??? Seriously though... he put everything aside for his effects. But strangely enough... it kinda worked. If you take one thing at a time and analyse it, every aspect of this film sucks individually (except the effects and fight scenes of course). But it's weird how it's actually enjoyable when they're all put together. It could have been a million times better but i have to fess up and say that it's worth seeing at least once. If you like 3D, go for it, if not then stick to 2D. The 3D isn't any better than any other film, i find. I would have prefered it in 2D myself. Oh and i'd love checkin' out your snaps ;)
superdog
superdog - 1/6/2010, 5:03 PM
teabag@ yes 24 is still on and its still awesome!!!!!! gonna revolutionize the t.v. industry, then when the 3D movie with a cgi jack bauer comes out it will revolutionize the movie industry too........JACK IS BACK BITHCES!!!!! :)

i cant imagine this movie would be worth getting on regular DVD or even 3D dvd. the consensus is that it was an experience cause of the effects, imax, 3D etc.....theres no possible way to replicate that in your living room.
ThunderCougarFalconBird
ThunderCougarFalconBird - 1/7/2010, 8:25 AM
there were CBM awards!? I missed that! I am honered by your vote but I'm baffled at the inclusion of "best 'stash" award on a comic website!
Shaman
Shaman - 1/7/2010, 10:51 AM
Yep!!! (which apparantly means "sex" in russian...) Here are the links for the award article as well as the award finalist polls. I guess they forgot to announce the winners or somethin'.

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/Poniverse/news/?a=12428

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/Poniverse/news/?a=12559

And just to show my appreciation of yourself and your 'stach, i love your avatar but we don't see the 'stach well enough!!! Here are five avatars for you to use :))



Enjoy, my friend ;) Oh and you can change your username to "Ron" anytime you wish in the "editor's tools" :))
DarthKyrat1
DarthKyrat1 - 1/7/2010, 11:29 AM
@ Shaman i'm glad to see you enjoyed the film my bud sure the plot was predictable but still the 3d effects were amazing and not only that but zoe as a blue alien was hot and managed to pull of a decent performance

Stephan Lang not so much i liked his character but i felt there was something from him and i hear there's already talk of a sequel on a couple of sites in which there going to explore the entire galaxy sweet anyways way great job man on the review

and a hell yes to Ellen Page as Gally Canadians show your support for her and other actors and actresses with our support they wouldn't have their jobs and we wouldn't have these amazing talented individuals

peace



Shaman
Shaman - 1/7/2010, 1:54 PM
DarthKyrat1- AMEN!

Ron- This one's for you!!!

Hal Jordan is none other than...

RON BURGUNDY!!!

ThunderCougarFalconBird
ThunderCougarFalconBird - 1/8/2010, 5:21 AM
Wow Shaman! I am humbled and honered at the time and effort you put into bringing a smile to this old war horses face! I was contemplating changing my username but will now do so in your honor!

Oh, and best editorial thinginy nomination?! Wow! I haven't done many but (not to blow my own jazz flute) I think all my editorials have ended up on the main page!
Shaman
Shaman - 1/8/2010, 10:13 AM
HA HA!!!! Good man!!!! It is only fitting that you should use your REAL name ;)

And i totally meant it!!! I always did love your editorials best! Naturally they'd end up on main, you scallywag ;)
superdog
superdog - 1/9/2010, 6:32 PM
Why don't you just go back to your home on whore island
Shaman
Shaman - 1/12/2010, 12:09 PM
I wouldn't mind a trip there, actually... oh wait, it's not a dream resort, it's Thailand. Never mind.
CRITIC17
CRITIC17 - 1/26/2010, 1:41 PM
Nice review man!!! Now I will send you the Special Edition Unrated Cut!!!!
Shaman
Shaman - 1/28/2010, 6:51 AM
HAHA!!! Good man, critic ;))
TheMyth
TheMyth - 1/28/2010, 10:28 AM
Shaman, Glad you finally got to see it! I have to agree with you 101%. It was odd reading the review as it felt like I'd written it myself. THAT is my main problem with Worthington! He can't maintain a non-Aussie accent and it totally kicks the shit out of the illusion created. Clash of the Titans is his last chance for me. If he hasn't improved by then, I'll shit on Sam Worthington's name EVERY time I see someone post it for ANYTHING. I don't understand why Hollywood thinks he is 'leading man' material anyway. I wouldn't follow his ass across the street for a beer run, let alone into battle. I also agree about the treatment of the supporting cast. What the [frick] did we need Michelle Rodriguez for, that role could have been played by a red-shirt, and she ain't the only one. Something you left out of the review I feel should be addressed about this movie; what the [frick] is going on with the Bluetooth braids?! I know many people liked this, but I thought it to be EXTREMELY over done. I found myself constantly wondering, "Soooo, what happens if I give a Na'vi a haircut?" Being able to psychically network yourself with a horse by plugging your braid into it is just retarded. This entire moon is the definition of 'Primal' yet every species has spontaneously evolved this ability to be 'networked' biologically. One could argue that this ability to connect with nature is the very reason the Na'vi haven't evolved much technologically, but I say that where free will is involved, such nobility would be impossible to maintain for very long within a society.
Scarface
Scarface - 1/28/2010, 2:16 PM
The small town I live in just showed Avatar last week with no 3D and I gotta say after one and a half hours me and my 6 year old son were bored silly and left.
I agree 100% with you once again Shaman. If this movie only works in 3D. I can say with confidence that I will never watch Avatar again. I don,t think this movie matched the hype at all

P.S. Hell no to Worthington as Captain America he,s has legs like a swamp moose
Shaman
Shaman - 1/29/2010, 8:23 AM
Thanks for reading, guys :))

Myht- Very interesting point!!! I guess i didn't think of it much since i was taken aback by the rest that i included in my review. But great point! Only makes the movie even more over rated IMO. It has truly become the most OVER RATED film in the history of the movie industry.

Scarface- HAHA!!! Swamp Moose LMAO Yeah he is probably the very worst choice i've heard so far for Cap. And that goes even though he buffed up for Clash. I'm really not holding my breath for Clash, as Myth said, it is his last chance for me aswell. After that, boycott ATW.
TheMyth
TheMyth - 1/29/2010, 10:22 PM
Shaman, I been reading my lady's college books. Right now it's 'Theory Into Practice: An Introduction to Literary Criticism' Basically a text for literary analysis, and the entire idea of this biological wonder I'll forever call 'BlueTooth-Braids' in congruence with the social structure of the dominant, sentient race... it's a totally ludicrous concept. Cameron tries to justify this by stating that 'Eywa' simply ensures they don't evolve beyond a paleolithic society even though the Na'vi have existed in sentience for a millenia. That's like saying typhoons and microbes and thunderstorms (oh my!) should have stopped us from evolving beyond the Na'vi. I'm not sure this isn't 'Ego, the Living Planet' we're dealing with here. lmao. Apparently on Pandora, Mother Nature is a bitch! Hey, maybe every planet is a God and ours just raised more devils than it can lay down hehe, shoulda brought that next Ice Age on a few hundred years early, lmao, but I digress. I refuse to accept a sentient race to have existed in their self awareness for a MILLENIA and yet have not evolved beyond a paleolithic culture, let alone with the advantage of 'BlueTooth-Braids'.
Scarface
Scarface - 1/30/2010, 5:04 AM
I figured you would like that one Shaman. Sam does not have the chops to play Cap, after watching half of avatar i,m sure of that.
Remind me never yes I said never to debate with you Myth. You disected Avatar down way to far for me brother.
I,m glad to here TheHawk is alive and well as I was to here rumours of you demise were greatly exagerated Myth.
And I hope you get the financial compensation you deserve. I to am on the disabled list with an injured back and 10 months later I found a doctor who told me what is wrong. For well educated people doctors sure can be idiots.
TheMyth
TheMyth - 1/30/2010, 12:10 PM
Scarface, lol I've also been reading 'Rhetorical Argumentation' so a debate with me while this knowledge is fresh would be fun ;) Don't get me wrong, Avatar was visually BEAUTIFUL and the action was awesome, so much so, I'd pay to see it again in theaters, as I am also a person who is easily capable of suspending disbelief in order to enjoy a film. I even enjoy the subaltern styling in which the story is told, and am sort of a neo-Luddite myself, as I feel our capacity for war and death is too much for the technologies we wield. It's a wondrous idea, a race that has developed a near perfect equilibrium with the environment, but it is also totally illogical, and anyone reading my comments here needs nothing more for an example than our own human race. Ha! Are you from the American South, too? Ahhh, it's good when doctors [frick] up up and DON'T kill you... well, not really... but your on my page I think lol.
Scarface
Scarface - 1/30/2010, 4:37 PM
No I,m a northern canadian boy our health care is free and we get what we pay for lol. The southern states have always been on my list of places to visit
View Recorder