EDITORIAL: GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY's WGA Nod Shows How Strong The CBM Genre Is

EDITORIAL: GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY's WGA Nod Shows How Strong The CBM Genre Is

Earlier today, Guardians Of The Galaxy received a nomination from the Writers Guild of America for ‘Best Adapted Screenplay’. Join Minty, as he explains why awards recognition like this is great news for the superhero genre as a whole…

Editorial Opinion
By Minty - Jan 07, 2015 02:01 PM EST

 
The WGA gave us a small, yet very pleasant, surprise today in handing James Gunn and Nicole Perlman’s Guardians Of The Galaxy a shock nomination for ‘Best Adapted Screenplay - a phenomenal achievement in a major awards category. Whether that success could be replicated in a ceremony as high-profile as the Oscars is another question entirely – but the nomination alone is cause for much celebration.
 
Indeed, the fact that this film even exists is arguably the biggest shock overall! With their script, James Gunn and Nicole Perlman managed to turn Andy Dwyer, two green aliens, a talking raccoon and a tree into global superstars overnight. It was a unique and, more importantly, fun concept that more than its fair share of heart as well. The nomination was a well-deserved nod for the creativity and ambition involved in this project.
 

 
However, many would argue that the wrong CBM got the nomination. 2014 was a prime-example of just how high the standard of these movies has become. Marvel’s other venture, Captain America: The Winter Soldier, was arguably the more technically superior film overall, balancing a complex premise, a talented cast of characters and a tour-de-force leading performance from Chris Evans as Cap.
 
Bryan Singer’s X-Men: Days Of Future Past also had it’s fair share of fans, with many claiming it to be the best X-Men movie yet. It boasted inventive action sequences, breath-taking visuals, and, without doubt, the most impressive acting ensemble in CBM history. There was another big superhero movie from last year, but the less we talk about that one, the better, I feel.
 
Personally, I believe any one of these three films could have justifiably bagged that WGA nomination. These are quality movies that transcend a variety of other genres too - from political thrillers (Cap), to classic sci-fi time-travel (X-Men), to magnificent space operas (Guardians). Regardless of which movie was ultimately your personal favourite, their collective success is a shining example of the strength of the genre they share.
 

 
A decade ago, superhero hits like Guardians would have been few and far between, sandwiched by more mediocre affairs that only existed to sell toys. While the latter type of film does still exist today, it’s far less common, as the majority comic-book movies are consistently strong. Gems such as Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy and Raimi’s Spider-Man 2 will no longer be ‘one-offs’, as we usher in a new ‘Golden Age’ of superhero movies.
 
So what’s next for the genre? May sees the return of Marvel’s premiere superhero team in Avengers: Age Of Ultron – the sequel to the highest grossing non-James Cameron movie in box office history. Joss Whedon’s 2012 mega-hit was almost universally adored by both critics and fans alike, and there’s no reason to expect any less from the sequel. Unfortunately, it still doesn’t feel like something the awards would go for.
 
In light of Guardians‘ recent success as a ‘fresh and original’ property, there’s no upcoming project that looks quite as enticing as DC’s Suicide Squad – due for release August 2016. In a very strong year for CBMs, David Ayer’s take on ‘Task Force X’ just stands-out - thanks to its edgy premise and the pedigree of its cast & director. With Academy Awards favourites such as Viola Davis, Jared Leto and Will Smith set to play vital roles, could we be looking at the genre’s first major awards contender since The Dark Knight?
 

 
It’s fair to say the genre can go either one of two ways. Market over-saturation is a danger down the line, but for the moment, superhero films can only continue to improve – so long as the quality remains high, of course. By introducing creative concepts and exploring new genres, Marvel Studios has pioneered this prospective Golden Age – yet the competition has the potential to be just as strong (as Days Of Future Past proved). If 2016’s slate of films is anything to go by, the future looks very bright indeed.
 
To paraphrase X2’s Professor Charles Xavier:
 
Comic Book Movies are here to stay.


 
Thanks for reading guys! I want to know what you think? Did Guardians deserve the nod – or should the superhero genre just stick to dominating the box office? Let me know in the comments below, and hit that big red thumb if you enjoyed this!
 
You can also check out my blog if you’re really bored ;)
 
Amanda Seyfried On Rejecting Offer To Play Gamora In GOTG: [I Thought] It Would Be Marvel's First Bomb
Related:

Amanda Seyfried On Rejecting Offer To Play Gamora In GOTG: "[I Thought] It Would Be Marvel's First Bomb"

GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY's Chris Pratt Is Aware He's Playing Different Versions Of The Same Character In Movies
Recommended For You:

GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY's Chris Pratt Is Aware He's Playing Different Versions Of The Same Character In Movies

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
GinjaNinja
GinjaNinja - 1/7/2015, 2:41 PM
I think this could be the first ever multiple oscar winning CBM. Makeup, Sound, Soundtrack, Visual effects, Costumes. I think all of these give it a chance.
yonny616
yonny616 - 1/7/2015, 2:45 PM
But its the one with the weakest screenplay this year? Captain America and Days of Future Past both had better screenplays.
Tars
Tars - 1/7/2015, 2:55 PM
Screenplay for Guardians was very generic, not worthy of the nod imo
SauronsBANE
SauronsBANE - 1/7/2015, 3:04 PM
Totally agree with the sentiment here - you can argue about which CBM deserved it more or whatever, but just the fact that we're here talking about Guardians of the Galaxy being nominated for such an award is incredible. Hell, you said it yourself Minty: just the fact that this movie EXISTS in the first place is almost mind-blowing. Just look at the debate we're having over Days of Future Past, The Winter Soldier, AND Guardians...it really speaks to the quality (and quantity) of CBMs we're getting right now. What a time to be alive!
SauronsBANE
SauronsBANE - 1/7/2015, 3:11 PM
But just to indulge myself in the debate, I would say Guardians is PLENTY deserving of a Best Adapted Screenplay nod. It's easy to dismiss the entire script simply because of the jokes and humor...but each joke and humorous situation was impeccably designed and implemented in order to establish/develop the characters and advance the plot.

I've said this before: Guardians was basically given the exact same task of The Avengers, except WITHOUT the benefit of a series of solo movies beforehand. The fact that they managed to transform from a group of strangers who hated each other and come together as a team/family and, even bigger than that, that we managed to be convinced of that and buy it, speaks to the strength of the screenplay.

You can talk about the strengths of the other CBMs, but I think it's unfair to undersell everything Guardians gets right.
Minty
Minty - 1/7/2015, 3:34 PM
@SauronsBANE - Yeah man, choosing between the three is hard enough, I really think we'll look back on last year as a big one. Personally my favourite's The Winter Soldier, but that doesn't stop me from loving both GOTG & DOFP either. Whether it's got this nod because of all the hype around it - that's probably the case. But the hype was largely very well-deserved. I'd agree what's most impressive is its achievement - turning five nobodys into such popular characters.

And you... indulging yourself in a debate? That's so unlike you man ;) Hahaha I kid, cheers mate, always good hearing from you
MsDarkPhoenix
MsDarkPhoenix - 1/7/2015, 3:35 PM
It's good to see CBMs getting nominated, they are not just movies for a few fans anymore, many people like them and the critics do as well!
MrBlackJack
MrBlackJack - 1/7/2015, 3:40 PM
tokens
tokens - 1/7/2015, 3:42 PM
.... im Tempted to click on you blog....



...buuut... I feel like it may lead me to inappropriate pictures and the sweaty, heavy breathing, moist corner of the internet...
DEVLIN712
DEVLIN712 - 1/7/2015, 3:42 PM
I think that what made TWS and DOFP so special for me was how large the event was but how you still saw the progression of the inividual characters. Both films had finales that I felt were bigger in scale than The Avengers yet managed to feel small scale at the same time.
MrBlackJack
MrBlackJack - 1/7/2015, 3:46 PM
It's great to see not only comic book movies but more main stream movies be taken seriously over the last couple of years. I the Lord of the Rings trilogy really helped break down some of the stigmas, and as time has gone on films like The Dark Knight, The Avengers, Guardians of the Galaxy have further helped that cause. At this rate, with the number of comic book movies increasing and the quality doing seemingly the same, it's only a matter of time before another mainstream film snags itself a big time award.

Awesome write up Minty!
tokens
tokens - 1/7/2015, 3:47 PM
.. I clicked on it... its cool... its cool..


but now... now Im getting sweaty, moist and starting to breath heavy...





....what are you doing to me, minty?
SauronsBANE
SauronsBANE - 1/7/2015, 3:58 PM
@Minty Yeah, 2014 was crazy! For me, I think The Winter Soldier was the best-made, highest-quality CBM...but Guardians was definitely my favorite. I don't know if that makes sense or not, but I'm sticking to it!

I wouldn't be surprised if the hype was what got it the nomination, but the movie really DID have a massive impact on pop culture. During its immediate release, everywhere I went I kept hearing people making references to Groot or Rocket. Heck, this past weekend I talked to someone who readily admitted that she HATES superhero movies, but couldn't get enough of Guardians. The success and recognition is more than deserved.

And heh, you know me too well it seems =P
Minty
Minty - 1/7/2015, 3:59 PM
@MsDarkPhoenix - Exactly! The days of critics bashing them is (mostly) over!

@DEVLIN712 - Yeah I agree Dev. They were oddly personal, and somehow had enough time to focus on their huge cast of characters. Both are great examples of avoiding the 'too many chararcters' problem

@MrBlackjack - Yeah, it's crazy to think how influential the LOTR films were. Aw man, I'd love for a CBM/SciFi film to do what The Return Of The King did! Haha and cheers for the gif MrBlackjack - love it :)

@cinnamon

bropous
bropous - 1/7/2015, 4:00 PM
@Minty:

Well done.
bropous
bropous - 1/7/2015, 4:02 PM
But I THOROUGHLY disagree with you on the imending shit-stain of a mistake Suicide Squad. I think it is a TERRIBLE idea that WILL set back CBMs, especially for the DC brand, which will suffer from a VERY disappointing box office.
JorL5150
JorL5150 - 1/7/2015, 4:08 PM
Maybe next time they'll pick a GOOD cbm.

Like suicide squad.
MsDarkPhoenix
MsDarkPhoenix - 1/7/2015, 4:11 PM
@Minty Well there are still many critics in Greece who never give CBMs more than 2 out of 5 even if they like them... Assholes.
JorL5150
JorL5150 - 1/7/2015, 4:21 PM
Ugh.

I just adopted a dog. And it's bropused all over the rug.

Any more bropus and ill have to put it down.
SageMode
SageMode - 1/7/2015, 4:27 PM
A screenplay of a more serious film doesn't make it better. Everything counts. And GOTG stood out more. It was unique, refreshing and engaging with characters that you cared for. And it was a very fun film which adds to its appeal.

Kyos
Kyos - 1/7/2015, 4:28 PM
@SauronsBANE

"For me, I think The Winter Soldier was the best-made, highest-quality CBM...but Guardians was definitely my favorite. I don't know if that makes sense or not, but I'm sticking to it!"

I think it makes perfect sense, if only because that's exactly how I think and feel about these movie. :)
SageMode
SageMode - 1/7/2015, 4:29 PM
I second @powercosmic 's comment
JosephKing
JosephKing - 1/7/2015, 4:35 PM
Not really. The WGA also nominated The Hangover five years ago, following a similar logic.

The point is simple: you have a lot of blockbuster guys voting and the Industry is pretty tough for screenwriters, so now and then they give these nods to pop/commercial films because it's just good for them. They all know Guardians of the Galaxy can't compete with Gone Girl, but GotG is a huge box office and critical hit and perhaps the biggest cultural impact in movies this year, so hey, let's give it a not and keep the business warm. It's kinda like "valuing future jobs". You know, fight for the category.

That's not to say the super-hero genre is not powerful, because it is the most powerful commercial genre these days and it's going to be like that at least until 2020. But really, Guardians of the Galaxy getting a nomination from the WGA means nothing about the genre getting more award recognition. Looper is a genre movie and was nominated in 2013. Bridesmaids was nominated a year before.

By the way, Guardians of the Galaxy is an awesome movie, but it is regardless this nomination.
Chewtoy
Chewtoy - 1/7/2015, 4:36 PM
I'm sure that GOTG is getting extra credit (and deservedly so) for successfully adapting such a bunch of gonzo ideas into a rip-roaring mainstream hit. Putting that kind of craziness together and up on the screen really isn't that easy... The film just made it seem like it was.
JillyMcBean
JillyMcBean - 1/7/2015, 5:19 PM
Suicide Squad will generate at least $700 Million. I don't expect a certain few to think so, because they are extremely biased against DC Entertainment. Not related to that fact, these same users are probably missing a few braincells and just trying to sit something up. You know who you are, and no one gives a [frick] what you think.
COREY6487
COREY6487 - 1/7/2015, 5:27 PM
JillyMcBean

i dont think so. man of steel only got 700m
JamesMan
JamesMan - 1/7/2015, 5:33 PM
Jilly is the real MVP.

Oh and Minty is pretty neat too ;)
JorL5150
JorL5150 - 1/7/2015, 5:45 PM
Jilly >>>>>>>>>>>the rest of cbm users except gusto >>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>bropus and cosmic
JillyMcBean
JillyMcBean - 1/7/2015, 6:02 PM
COREY

DC will correct the mistakes they made with MoS. BvS will generate at least 1.5 Billion. Suicide Squad will ride the momentum off of that.
sanyaya
sanyaya - 1/7/2015, 6:04 PM
Thats great dont know about oscar nom tho.
JorL5150
JorL5150 - 1/7/2015, 6:09 PM
Man of steel was awesome.
But jilly is right - batman v superman is going to own.

JorL5150
JorL5150 - 1/7/2015, 6:11 PM
Fox's x men was a more faithful adaptation of the comic than GOTG was by orders of magnitude.
huexolotl
huexolotl - 1/7/2015, 6:19 PM
I dont think the ga cares about dc...its been done. (Better, by Marvel)
1 2
View Recorder