ComicBookMovie.com Start A Fansite!
You are not currently logged in. Login

Top Three Contenders for Captain America Revealed?

A supposedly trusted source has pointing out three contenders Marvel Studios is considering for the lead role in The First Avenger: Captain America. Follow the jump to see who they are. . .


According to BigShinyRobot.com, their reliable source in the Paramount/Marvel confirmed that the studio is indeed only considering unknowns/television actors to portray Captain America on the big screen.

"Apparently, when the script came in with World War II sequences (featuring the Invaders), the studio heads decided it was beyond their means to make this movie AND afford A-listers like Brad Pitt and Matt Damon."

The source, who remains unnamed, specifically pointed out Chad Michael Murray (One Tree Hill), Ryan McPartlin (Chuck) and Jensen Ackles (Supernatural) as being among the top choices.




We've already heard from other sites that both Murray and McPartlin have potentially read for the role, but this is the first (albeit unofficial) word that fan-favorite Jensen Ackles is in serious consideration.

It looks like we'll have to wait until March 1st to find out solid news regarding this casting. Until then let's follow an age-old CBM tradition and put it to a vote!


11 Yes
5 No
MultiPurposePoni
2/8/2010
BigShinyRobot

DISCLAIMER: This posting was submitted by a user of the site not from Comic Book Movie editorial staff. All users have acknowledged and agreed that the submission of their content is in compliance with our Terms of Use. For removal of copyrighted material, please contact us HERE.

274 Comments

My, they sure are pretty


MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 4:59 PM
LOL Go Jensen Ackles.
Dmon - 2/8/2010, 4:59 PM
Jensen ackles!!!!
Urban8er - 2/8/2010, 5:00 PM
I was gonna post this, but I figured someone else was going to. Interesting trio. My problem with this is that they said that they wanted an "unknown" to play the part. I'm not sure I'd call these guys "unknown."

Great stuff. Looks like we're getting closer.
ecksmanfan - 2/8/2010, 5:00 PM
LEEE's gonna be happy lol :P

Go Ackles :)
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:01 PM
Good find Multi...who do you like out of these guys :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:02 PM
@eks: No way! Why didn't you do it? I just got this info via email and thought I'd throw it up. I'm waiting to hear back from MY source to see if it's viable.

@teabag: Option D) None
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 5:03 PM
id pick ackles for sure outta those 3...chad is no!
mcpartlin i cant see doing this action bit...he hasnt convinced me as jensen has with his utter thumbs up role as dean on supernatural...plus mcpartlin sounds so monotone...if he yelled assemble....i think it'd sound like the horn of gondor...lol
jensen is best of the 3...
but again chris pine, matt damon or leo would be better...age aint that big a deal with my 3 picks...plus we know they can be the leader and act the socks outta steve rogers:)
Anil Rickly - 2/8/2010, 5:05 PM
We'll wait and see. Honestly, they aren't my ideal choices, but if the story is good you won't hear a peep from me.
thwhtGuardian - 2/8/2010, 5:05 PM
Go ackles!!! im not a big fan of the other two though??? My only problem with getting an unknown is the international market. Without a big name actor idk if Cap will do well outside the us...but who cares!!! lol America!!!!!
SandMan101 - 2/8/2010, 5:05 PM
Oh [frick] [frick]ing JENSEN TACKLES!!!!!


LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:07 PM
@Multi- I saw it over on darkhorizons who had linked back to BigShineyRobot as well. I just figured one of you all-stars would post it. LOL, I guess I need to sack up and just go for it next time.

I'm not huge on any one of them, I guess Ackles is the lesser of evils, but he's bow-legged. I don't want a bow-legged Cap!
ecksmanfan - 2/8/2010, 5:08 PM
I'm happy with McPartlin or Ackles Just not Murray!

Cant wait til the 1st though!! Wonder if they'll choose a 4th name and surprise us all!
TheAnswer - 2/8/2010, 5:08 PM
ARMIE HAMMER, RYAN McPARTLIN or TEDDY SEARS all the way!!!


LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:08 PM
Sandman@ RDJ wasnt exactly a crowd pulling lead before Iron Man and having "the guy who was Kirks Dad in THOR" doesnt seem to be a problem so unknown is fine with me :)


teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:09 PM
If they go for Ackles... my wife will sure be happy.




ACCESS - 2/8/2010, 5:10 PM
Jensen Ackles
Sanfordpunk - 2/8/2010, 5:11 PM
If TACKLES plays CAP, im never watching it!!!
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:11 PM
LEEE@ I thought Marvel wanted Lewis? lol and you will watch it :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:12 PM
My preferences go directly from left to right in those pictures. McPartlin is the best visually, we simply haven't seen him in enough stuff to gauge his versatility, but he's got the physical presence and looks. Ackles is okay, he just doesn't quite seem like he can carry off the part, but I'd be willing to give him a chance. Chad, though? Please don't make me throw up. Sorry Chad is an absolute no-go.
mwmcintyre - 2/8/2010, 5:12 PM
I smell this is BS considering they all ready said they want an UNKNOWN!
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:13 PM
Holy Shit!!!!!! Jensen Ackles Is actually in the top 3 choices for Captain America. WOW. I guess Marvel is intrested in pulling off a CW actor and give him the role of Captain America. lol. It would be great news for the fans who wants him to play the role. Jensen Ackles already address the issue of the rumor back in September.

PASTE the LINK below

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kc-L3W1K0zw&feature=PlayList&p=EAE377E63216EE09&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=26

If this is completly true I hope Jensen Ackles gets it.
TDKR11 - 2/8/2010, 5:13 PM
TEA @ I wont dude, he'll DOOM the franchise!
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:14 PM
LEEE@ Unknown basicly means non A lister or tv actor who isnt a recognised movie actor ;P..cheer up sounds like were getting a great movie :)

And how do you know any of your guys wouldnt doom it?? sometimes you have to put personal feelings aside and see what happens ...your telling me if it comes out and is an amazing movie you will sit at home cus your boys didnt get picked lol :)
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:16 PM
how can Ryan be in the top 3 when Johnson said the 5 or 6 guys they are juggling 32 is the oldest ryan is like 34 or 35

sounds fishy
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 5:16 PM
I like Ackles out of the 3. Chad Murray just isn't right for the role, and McPartlin doesn't seem to have that spark to him. So, here's hoping for Ackles!
TheQuestion - 2/8/2010, 5:16 PM
how can Ryan be in the top 3 when Johnson said the 5 or 6 guys they are juggling 32 is the oldest ryan is like 34 or 35

sounds fishy
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 5:19 PM
NO TO THIS = ****




This is BS anyways, he ain't an UNKNOWN, an a sh1t over the top actor! : P
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:19 PM
LEEE@ No to Ackles as Hawkeye!?! ok yeah :P

he looks like he's taking a dump on your hopes and dreams LEEE lol :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:20 PM
I like Ackles out of the 3. Chad Murray just isn't right for the role, and McPartlin doesn't seem to have that spark to him. So, here's hoping for Ackles!
TheQuestion - 2/8/2010, 5:22 PM
Ackles probably got the read because all of us here yes i say US cuz JOSH pulled me to the darkside (sorry lee) AWESOME either Ackles or Ct. Awesome i dont care : ]]]
Set2Fallfirst - 2/8/2010, 5:23 PM
WOW CBM you guys turning words around guys go read the article. It does'nt even say they are the top 3 it just says they read for the part.


here is the transcript :

According to MY studio guy, the rumors about Chad Michael Murray (One Tree Hill), Ryan McPartlin (Chuck), Jensen Ackles (Supernatural) and other unknowns/television actors reading for Cap are true.

Apparently, when the script came in with World War II sequences (featuring the Invaders), the studio heads decided it was beyond their means to make this movie AND afford A-listers like Brad Pitt and Matt Damon.
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 5:23 PM
TEA @ Ackles can pull HAWKEYE off but not a big character like CAP!




HELL NO...

I'd rather see that ONE TREE HILL dude than him, total BS lol!

RYAN McPARTLIN or ARMIE HAMMER!!!
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:24 PM
P862010 @ Whew thanks dude! ; )


I knew it was BS lol!
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:26 PM
lmao
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:27 PM
@LEEE: You're so cute XD You gotta respect a guy that sticks to his guns!

@P86: And what about this article is misleading exactly?
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 5:28 PM
I have 2 problems with this news.

1. It was only yesterday or the day before when Johnston himself said we are tossing arround 5 or 6 names we are down to.

2."Apparently, when the script came in with World War II sequences (featuring the Invaders), the studio heads decided it was beyond their means to make this movie AND afford A-listers like Brad Pitt and Matt Damon."

If they are afraid of this situation with the Captain America movie, what the Hell are they expecting The Avengers to cost them?
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 5:29 PM
@LEEE- That pic is hilarious!!!
ecksmanfan - 2/8/2010, 5:29 PM
I like all three but No to Murray as Captain. And yes they aren't unknown but they aren't getting the BIG roles either. So I can consider them unknown. I like both Ackles and Captain Awesome. So who ever gets it I'll be happy with I just want to know who they are gonna cast.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 5:30 PM
what were the ages of the actors i think he said the youngest was 24 and the oldest was 32 right
jimthefan - 2/8/2010, 5:30 PM
MultiPurposePoni

what is misleading is they are saying they are the top 3 candidates when the actual source they are citing says otherwise.
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 5:30 PM
P86@ you should read this article before quoting another brother lol :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:30 PM
Even though I don't care for Eckles , him and ryan have similar features voices and acting chops.

What director would group Murray in with those two? He doesn't fit at all.
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 5:32 PM
@Hawks: Since the budget for the Avengers movie hasn't even been established (hell, the movie itself is still conjecture) I'm pretty sure that isn't an issue that they are worried about right now.

We don't even know if Thor or Cap are going to be successful. I'm sure that if they are, the Avengers movie will have an Avatar sized budget.

@P86: Did you read the content I wrote in the article (yes, it's my article not CBM's), or did you just read the title?

I didn't say anywhere in the article that the source linked those three actors as THE top three, only as top choices. The title is posed as a question to the reader, not a quote from the source. The use of the term 'top choices' is based off of the dozens of actors that have been linked to the role. If the studio is considering 6 candidates, and these three or included, then they are top choices.

@tea: LOL I'm glad I'm not the only one confused
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 5:32 PM
@LEEE I like you man but you make me worry; anytime someone mentions Ackles you post these erotic pics in response to them. Do you somehow have a secret man crush on Ackles? Do you want to tackle Ackles in the sack? lmao. jk.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 5:33 PM
ackles is 32
mcpartlin is 35
murray is 29
jimthefan - 2/8/2010, 5:33 PM
I'm not in favor of any of them. It'll make the modern Cap look younger than Toby Maguire. Why the hell would Thor or Iron Man remotely listen to this guy as a legit member of the Avengers, let alone follow him into a battle? Maybe decent casting for a young smartass Hawkeye (who I would prefer to round out the Avengers cast as the black sheep of the group), but not Cap. But I am torn, because the mention of the Invaders as part of the WWII story-line does make me happy and if I have to choose between Pine/Damon or Invaders, I'm honestly forced to lean towards the Invaders.
iwantmyPuckspinoff - 2/8/2010, 5:33 PM
so i think its safe to say mcpartlin is out

jimthefan - 2/8/2010, 5:34 PM
good catch P862010

Seriously, the one time I don't read a source link. Never again will I skip that.

Don't take to much offense MPP, it's just that in your article it seems suggested that these are the only contenders where as the source mentions that they are just the ones confirmed from the wider pool.
thwhtGuardian - 2/8/2010, 5:34 PM


Takles is sh1t!!! : P


Multi @ ; D

Ecks @ Instigator @ : D
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:36 PM
Igril@ lmao :))

LEEE@ Is that in bed or?? :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:36 PM
@whtGuardian: I guess that all depends on the perspective of whoever is reading the article, don't you think?
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 5:40 PM
I wonder if Leee666 wants Ackles as Cap
Urban8er - 2/8/2010, 5:40 PM
Ackles for cap ackles for cap...




Ackles for cap ackles for cap... :P


Multi@ Dont worry bud your article clearly says they are 3 of the contenders not the only 3 :)
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:42 PM
I hate to stir the pot but "Top Three Contenders" and three among others who have read for the part are nowhere near one and the same.
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 5:49 PM
Really? Are you yanking my chain right now?

McPartlin I thought was out because of the age range, CMM just doesn't cut it (but not surprised he's in there, because of the rumor earlier), but ACKLES?! Really?

I'm pleasantly surprised, to say the least. I don't know if this is true or not (considering the talk of Johnston wanting an unknown) but if it is, I have to say, bravo Marvel and Johnston. If it's between these 3, Ackles all the way. The other 2 don't have the chops to pull this role off.

I would prefer an unknown, but if I had to choose between these 3, Ackles, hands down. He's the only one up there that has the leadership, commanding presence, and dramatic talent for Cap.

Wait until Shaman sees this, good Lord, I think his screen's going to need a good clean after he logs on :)
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 5:50 PM
Come on ARMIE and TEDDY where the hell are you????



CLICK THIS = ARMIE HAMMER!!!




I hope its an UNKNOWN!

tea @ Lol! : D

LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:51 PM
oh ok this article is fake, they havent ready lol
ottoevans - 2/8/2010, 5:51 PM
Oh god TYLERS having a w**K LOL!


: D
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 5:53 PM
Hawks@....



lol......the question mark gives a big giveaway plus since these three are the only ones named in the original source its not a bad question to ask :)


LEEE@lol ... i like the Teddy guy but amy there looks like a ladyboy :)
teabag - 2/8/2010, 5:54 PM
Hey Hawks buddy, do you remember a few weeks ago when I put that Will Smith/Cap rumor article up? Do you remember why I told you I put that article up?

MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 5:56 PM
Lee: If you think I'm having a "w**k", I have no idea what you'll think Shaman's going to be doing...:P

Hey, at least we can all agree that it's awesome to finally get Cap news almost every day, it makes up for the months with 0 news :)
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 5:56 PM
LMAO @ tea: Sorry Multi, I did all that reading and completely missed the friggin question mark.
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 5:57 PM
sorry if i misread you should worded it different you made it sound like they were the final 3

also how can Ryan be a top choice if he is older than the oldest actor Johnson is looking at
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 5:58 PM
Hawks@ lol....all this talk of wa***ng is making me sleepy :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:00 PM
I am tired of these people saying that if Cap is young then Thor or Iron Man will not listen to Cap. Leadership can transcend age. Its about how he stood up to become a leader during WWII and the experiences he got during that time. Through out WWII there are stories of young men leading older men into battle hell all through History ever heard of Alexander the Great!

Go Jensen Ackles! :D
Dmon - 2/8/2010, 6:01 PM
Multi: I remember that. You should play poker bubba.:)

tea: Me hangin from last nights Superbowl party is making me sleepy. I'm not gonna last long tonight.
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 6:01 PM
edit
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 6:02 PM
@LEEE. No offense sir but I call that bluff you made about not seeing it. You WILL because you are a fanboy! I didn't like Heath Ledger as Joker when I first heard it and I was completely boycotting it I was also convinced all his praise for the role was coming from the fact he died but then I saw it and HOLY SHIT! I was amazed so don't sell this flick short just because of who they cast.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 6:02 PM
I dont think chad was ever confirmed that he did audition for Cap. This seems more like a fake rumor, no matter how good the rumor seems (well except the whole Chad Michael murray thing). More than likely they will cast an UNKNOWN rather than a fan-favorite.
Diamond1995 - 2/8/2010, 6:03 PM
dude from chuck.
grif - 2/8/2010, 6:04 PM
@Dmon: Audie Murphy. Boom!

@teabag: Get some rest, you'll need it for Domination Tuesday :D

@Hawks: I do actually, it's one of my favorite hobbies. How do you think I pay for all my costume materials?

@P86: So, I should reword my article because you misread it? Thanks, but no.
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 6:05 PM
Dmon@ tellem my friend :)

Hawks @ yeah plus its gone 1am here.....im getting old :P

Multi@ Ive got the horse ready :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:05 PM
dont have to be an ass your article made no sense

who writes this :

The source, who remains unnamed, specifically pointed out Chad Michael Murray (One Tree Hill), Ryan McPartlin (Chuck) and Jensen Ackles (Supernatural) as being top choices.

your source must be pretty crap seeing as ryan cant be one of the top choices .Since Johnson himself said the oldest actor they are looking at in a group of 5 or 6 is 32 and Ryan is older than that.

now does that make sense
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 6:09 PM
@teabag: Sweet! I just put I'vebeenharduptogetlaidbeforeyouall in his leathery gimp suit.

@P86: It's not my source, buddy, it's the original author's source (hence 'unnamed').

I already pointed out that the reason I refer to them as top choices is because Johnston himself whittled the grouping from about a dozen actors to 5 or 6 this week. If these three are in fact included in those 5 or 6, then they are 'top choices.' I wrote the article from my point of view, and put down what makes sense by my deductive reasoning. I included the rumor connotation as many times as I could so people wouldn't get the wrong impression. The article itself is even filed under Scoops, where it should be wince it's a rumor. I'm sorry if you misread the information I put out, but that's on you bud.


BTW, BigShinyRobot just updated their site to reflect that they don't denote these actors being the official top three choices as fact. Apparently, other sites are implying that speculation comes from them.

That's why I never quoted them as saying such :)
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 6:09 PM
It was in how I read it, you're right. I meant no offense man, it just seemed to focus more on them where as the other article's focus was on the fact that their comments about reading for Captain America weren't total BS and that they were indeed under actual consideration, rather than top choices.

Great article man, I wouldn't have known at all had you not written it as I don't frequent big shiny robot. Oh and thanks for getting my fanart submission up there!
thwhtGuardian - 2/8/2010, 6:11 PM
Tyler @ Yeah lol! : P

But id rather zero CAP news if ackles is in it! : D


Instigator @ Trust me i will NOT watch it IF tackles is CAP, never.... Hell, id rather it flops and they have to recast for AVENGERS, becoz i hate the idea of him in AVENGERS, totally hate it!! Him with the likes of RDJ, NORTON, SLJ just make me cringe! : D

I still say UNKNOWN is a perfect choice, no CW boys!!

LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 6:15 PM
Armie Hammer has everything going for him

23
6'5
blonde hair
blue eyes
deep voice
has the classic 40's look going for him
P862010 - 2/8/2010, 6:17 PM
P862010 @ You da man!

ARMIE HAMMER all the way!!!
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 6:19 PM
Hahaha, this is the best [frick]ing news EVER!!! :D

MULTI, thank you for finding this - you have made my day dude!

I'm not a fan of the One Tree Hill guy as Cap but my original choice Jensen Ackles and newer choice Ryan McPartlin are both in the running?

Win/Win!!! :)
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 6:21 PM
well, i guess its official, i am for Ryan McPartin all the way. ive been thinking and i think he's got the best all american good look to him, and seems like he'd have great charimsa as a leader of troops. plus he's got the build

murray wouldnt be able to pull off the acting without doing that stupid squinty eyed face he does all the time, and ackles is better but is still too much of a pussy to play cap with believability

and lee just cause its an actor from a tv show doesnt mean he wont be able to hold well alongside the rest of the avengers cast!!! silly
Duhdaduh - 2/8/2010, 6:21 PM
No to Amy...ive seen straighter springs lol


teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:22 PM
i just wish he looked a little older but hey what can u do
Duhdaduh - 2/8/2010, 6:22 PM
Except Hammer isn't that great an actor and looks like he can't take a punch.

Lee: I guarantee, if Ackles was cast, you'd still watch it. I don't give a shit what you think about him, you'll watch both First Avenger and Avengers.

No to McPartlin, no to Murray, and no to Hammer.
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 6:23 PM
Since I'm an Instigator at heart I'll just come out and say it.
Multi GREAT ARTICLE man! All you bitchers leave Multi alone!!!
Photobucket

LMFAO!!! I had to do it.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 6:23 PM
HELL YEAH!!! :)

Avengers1

Cap America
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 6:23 PM
@Igirl: That dude makes my pants fit funny. Teabag, help!
MultiPurposePoni - 2/8/2010, 6:24 PM
Jensen Ackles all the way,
Bandrews1 - 2/8/2010, 6:25 PM
Lets get those off you first :O
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:26 PM
HELL YEAH!!!! Though my heart goes out for Sam Worthington (LEEE, you traitor...), I have to say that Ackles has the voice, looks, and power to play the star-spangled Avenger that represents what we all stand for... Ackles for Cap!!!!
TheCritic17 - 2/8/2010, 6:26 PM
I'm ok with Ryan McPartlin or Jensen Ackles. Fk, it's a better casting that the Spider-Kiddo contenders.
CaptainProg - 2/8/2010, 6:27 PM
Wait I missed something... Whats happening March 1st?
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 6:28 PM
@Critic. You know I was leaning towards him being Captain too. I like him more and more I see his films.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 6:29 PM
IGIRL: Johnston has to have someone locked in for Cap by March 1st, it's the day he leaves for Europe (to start sets and location and all that jazz, most likely)
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 6:29 PM
First of all @Leee buddy, calm down!!! You
are gonna have a coronary! lol

Wow, I hope this is for real cuz if we really
do have a choice between those three then I have
to go back to Jensen as my number one pick!
But I thought he said he wasn't involved!

BTW, Ryan McPartlin is 34 and Joe Johnston
probably just got his age wrong, 32 and 34
are very close together! Ryan can easily
pass for younger! So can Ackles!

But Chad Michael Murray looks too young to be
Cap, IMO! But he does look the part!
DDD - 2/8/2010, 6:30 PM
...However, looking at things from a realistic point of view, I dont see how Ackles could play Cap as he'll be filming a sixth season of Supernatural? I mean I'm sure he could do both but I do find that a little hard to imagine! Still, I'll be just as happy, if not more so, with Ryan McPartlin!!!

UCap
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 6:30 PM
Perhaps Ackles may know more than we do about Supernatural season 6? :O

No to McMurrammer!
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 6:32 PM
DDD: Yeah, if I had to choose out of the three I'd probably go back to having Ackles as my #1 choice!

Photobucket

TYLER: Lol! :)
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 6:33 PM
First post here, just registered because I just wanted to say something that I'm not sure others have noted. I'd be very surprised if it were Ackles who ended up being Cap for one reason: It's looking more and more like Supernatural will be renewed for a sixth season. On its own, the news doesn't seem to relate but, it would most likely cause conflict. Supernatural usually starts filming in early-July and the Cap movie starts filming in June. Unless they film all of his parts in one month (which seems like it'd be impossible) or unless they delay the start date for Supernatural filming (really unlikely,) the two schedules won't mesh.
DudeLove721 - 2/8/2010, 6:33 PM
Thank you Tyler. ^_^
Josh Now that you mention that I don't know if I want Ackles to get the part because I want more Supernatural... SO TORN!!!! T_T
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 6:33 PM
Josh@ many have done it before L(
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:33 PM
First post here, just registered because I just wanted to say something that I'm not sure others have noted. I'd be very surprised if it were Ackles who ended up being Cap for one reason: It's looking more and more like Supernatural will be renewed for a sixth season. On its own, the news doesn't seem to relate but, it would most likely cause conflict. Supernatural usually starts filming in early-July and the Cap movie starts filming in June. Unless they film all of his parts in one month (which seems like it'd be impossible) or unless they delay the start date for Supernatural filming (really unlikely,) the two schedules won't mesh.
DudeLove721 - 2/8/2010, 6:34 PM
Yeah, @Josh, Ryan does seem like the most probable choice!

For me its a toss-up between Ryan & Jensen but I lean
towards Ackles, myself!
(Now no wisecracks about me 'LEANING" towards Jensen!)
DDD - 2/8/2010, 6:36 PM
Same here, lol! :P Still, if I had to choose between Supernatural Season 6 and Jensen Ackles as Captain America, I think I'd have to go for Cap!

I havent said this in a while but...

JENSEN ACKLES FOR CAPTAIN AMERICA!!!!!

CaptainAmerica1

tea: Good point...here's hoping! :)

DDD: Lol! To be honest, I'll be overjoyed with either Ackles or McPartlin in the role! Thanks the heavens we havent heard Sam Worthington or Jason Lewis' name thrown about in these rumours!
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 6:38 PM
I doubt this is true but I can't wait to find out who the cap is played by!!!
blankofthedead - 2/8/2010, 6:38 PM
@DudeLove Actually I could see CW changing Supernatural to a Summer viewing because if One of their people is staring in a flick like Captain America AND it does WELL more fanbase might come. I could actually see them delaying the filming to give Ackles that oppurtunity. Also in the words of CW's Random Facts "Wayne's World was filmed in 2 weeks!" lol.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 6:38 PM
DDD:Chad Michael Murray looks too young to be
Cap, IMO! But he does look the part!

I can't believe you said that. I don't think I've ever read an opinion of yours I disagree with but Hell no to Murray.

I think he looks like a street punk at best.


Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 6:38 PM
Dean Winchester > Captain Awesome > Some guy on One Tree Hill

Just sayin' :)
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 6:39 PM
First post here, just registered because I just wanted to say something that I'm not sure others have noted. I'd be very surprised if it were Ackles who ended up being Cap for one reason: It's looking more and more like Supernatural will be renewed for a sixth season. On its own, the news doesn't seem to relate but, it would most likely cause conflict. Supernatural usually starts filming in early-July and the Cap movie starts filming in June. Unless they film all of his parts in one month (which seems like it'd be impossible) or unless they delay the start date for Supernatural filming (really unlikely,) the two schedules won't mesh.
DudeLove721 - 2/8/2010, 6:39 PM
why are people complaining about a no name actor...i have never heard of hemsworth before thor and i never saw people cryin about him
simonsays2109 - 2/8/2010, 6:39 PM
Ryan should get it hands down. He looks the part and he'll put more into the character. Thumbs down to Ackles. Ackles acting skills are to cheesey.
SirPrize - 2/8/2010, 6:39 PM
DudeLove@ Welcome :)

If Welling can make the fricken Fog and Snoreville Ackles can do this :)
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:40 PM
ARMIE HAMMER



Or RYAN!!

Note these arn't the top 3, so [frick] ONE TREE HILL BOY and Kn*b chops! : D

And HELL NO i wont watch it @ TYLER, not in a million years, just like the SPIDEY reboot if it goes total ultimate lol.

DDD @ : D
LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 6:40 PM
Ackles is a clown. You can't expect him to hold his own against Downey Jr. Don't know about the other two but the guy on the right will need some super soldier serum.


Simonsonrules - 2/8/2010, 6:43 PM
Hemsworth = Capt Kirks pop's in the opening badass sequence in the new Star Trek movie. When I saw that movie I yelled there's Thor. nuff said
SirPrize - 2/8/2010, 6:43 PM
why does everyone think ackles is gonna make such a great captain america??!?!?! ive seen him on supernatural and he's not a bad actor at all...but Captain America???
thats a negative, soldier!!
Duhdaduh - 2/8/2010, 6:43 PM
As I said in my editorial about McPartlin being perfect for Captain America...

He's the right height (6'3) and build for Captain America and in my opinion, he sure looks the part! As well as that (and I know this sounds a little odd) he actually has the voice that I actually imagine Steve Rogers having! If you look through his mainly comedic lines in Chuck and listen carefully you'll hear a voice that you can easily imagine shouting, "Avengers Assemble!"

He may in fact be exactly what Marvel are looking for. McPartlin is relatively unknown and doesnt have any other roles in his past that his take on Cap would be compared to!

There's also a good chance that Marvel already have their eye on him. They must have checked out Chuck when Zachary Levi was being considered for Fandral.


Image and video hosting by TinyPic

:)
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 6:43 PM
This sucks, I leave Monday for about two weeks worth of 12 hour a day work in New York. Thats a good thing, but I will have no computer access until I get back.

I wait all this time and I'd bet a zillion bucks they announce Cap while I'm away.
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 6:45 PM
i love it when people say " He cant hold his own against Downey Jr" lmao.....RDJ probably begged to get on Ally McBeal :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:45 PM
Lee: Sure, whatever you say... :)

No to McPartlin, no to Murray, and no to Hammer!
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 6:45 PM
McPartlin looks like Steve Rogers. Hands down.
SirPrize - 2/8/2010, 6:47 PM
I think that CW would have to push back filming of Supernatural for this to work. Supernatural films in Vancouver and Cap is filming in the UK. Also, unlike Smallville, Jensen Ackles and Jared Padelecki are the only two main leads of the show... they have long hours and film 5-6 days a week, as opposed to an ensemble cast like say Lost where the cast films maybe three days a week. I just don't see how he could manage both unless they delay Supernatural filming. Last movie he did was when he was on break from Supernatural filming -- My Bloody Valentine 3D.
DudeLove721 - 2/8/2010, 6:47 PM
Ackles = CHEESE!!!

Only the g*y parade supports tackles!

Sorry TYLER i wont support that **** no matter what!


LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 6:47 PM
i love it when people say " He cant hold his own against Downey Jr" lmao.....RDJ probably begged to get on Ally McBeal :P
SirPrize - 2/8/2010, 6:48 PM
McPartlin looks the part, but he doesn't have the chops.

Lee: Okay, sure man, I believe you... ;)
InTylerWeTrust - 2/8/2010, 6:49 PM
What SirPrize said :)
teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:51 PM
Ditto
SirPrize - 2/8/2010, 6:51 PM
LEEE: Every time you post Armie Hammer I think of baking soda.:)


Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 6:52 PM


I guess its OK to say this now....
ACKLES FOR CAP!!!!!!!!!!


But Ryan would be fantastic too!
DDD - 2/8/2010, 6:52 PM
I'm Fairly certain if I bashed Ackles in the face a few times maybe he would have a more rugged look to him. The only benefit of him getting the role is that gays will be overjoyed at the thought of a Capt. America that looks like he takes it from behind. This guy does not have a tough look to him. I'm sure most would f**k him before they ever would salute him, that's f**king sad.
ASSASSIN666 - 2/8/2010, 6:53 PM
What ?! Serious !?
If this is for real, I think I've already written this film off.
Sad, but true.

rawshark - 2/8/2010, 6:54 PM
@Hawks, I didn't say I want CMM for Cap...I just was saying I
can see why Johnston would consider him...but he looks a
little punkish to me too and I would never want him as Cap!
DDD - 2/8/2010, 6:56 PM
DDD: Whew!! Me and you have always been pretty much eye to eye. I thought you were wiggin out on me bud.:)
Hawksblueyes - 2/8/2010, 6:58 PM
Hawks@ lmfao :D


teabag - 2/8/2010, 6:58 PM
Assassin@ So what we need is a good looking blonde hair blue eyed fella with a muscular build and NOT look gay.......mmmmmm good luck :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 7:04 PM
I know the camps are extremely divided on Ackles
but I honestly can't see why the haters hate him!

He's a prety good actor and kicks ass on Demons and
Vampires on Supernatural! He was a serious ass-kicker
on Dark Angel with Alba, he played a part-animal
super-soldier on there so Caps right up his ally!
(I know, I know, ALLEY'S a poor choice of words! lol)


DDD - 2/8/2010, 7:07 PM
BOOOOOOOOO!

i'm with LEEE! ARMIE! ARMIE! ARMIE!
RockNRollCC - 2/8/2010, 7:09 PM
why does everyone think ackles is gonna make such a great captain america??!?!?! ive seen him on supernatural and he's not a bad actor at all...but Captain America???
thats a negative, soldier!!
Duhdaduh - 2/8/2010, 7:09 PM
Teabag- I think you should be the first cloned human, this world could use more of you, God help us all!
ASSASSIN666 - 2/8/2010, 7:10 PM
I simply can't see any of these guys leading RDJ or Ed Norton around. I pick D also. Good way to stoke the fire though Poni.

Maybe they can all three roll around in the sandbox with eachother for a while, and the one who comes out on top will get it. Plus then they'll look more rugged lol...

Will just leave it in Johnston's hands in the end.
48and2 - 2/8/2010, 7:13 PM
We could just freeze Teabag and thaw him out when time comes =)
48and2 - 2/8/2010, 7:16 PM
WTF!!! I'm sorry but this is wack. There are soo many actors who look much more like Cap and can act. This is looking like the Green Lantern casting:( Although I have faith in Ryan Reynolds cus he kinda looks like Hal and is a pretty good actor. But this is jus weird casting for Cap. Well from these 3 I'm gonna give it to Ryan M. Still, this is jus dissappointing.
DGr8Nova - 2/8/2010, 7:19 PM
Tackles for A$$ FACE!!!!





RockNRollcc @ Good man!!!


This will NEVER be CAP AMERICA!!!




LEEE777 - 2/8/2010, 7:26 PM
The world does need more tabagers ASSASS@ :P

48@ IceTea huh :P
teabag - 2/8/2010, 7:27 PM
"Only the g*y parade supports tackles!"

Sigh, the rantings of a broken man! ;) Face it LEE - Jensen Ackles is gonna be Captain America!!!
JoshW - 2/8/2010, 7:31 PM
Here's Jensen blasting demons!
He doesn't look very gay here!
He looks pretty tough to me!
Not all good lookin' guys are gay!
His girlfriend is Danneel Harris
(Lucky Basterd!).


DDD - 2/8/2010, 7:31 PM
He's just got to have more grit to be leading a God around. With these guys I think they're rebooting brokeback mountain for tweens.

*edit* Ice T LMAO! best laugh I've had all day.
48and2 - 2/8/2010, 7:32 PM
I really hope its not of those guys. If it has to be a TV actor, let it be someone we haven't seen in anything shite! Supernatural is alright, and so is Ackles, Cap? No way. Chuck is awful IMO, I have watched 3 episodes now and that was enough..that McFartlane dude is very meh. Murray? Do I even need to comment.

I dunno, at this point I'm sure it will be a relative unknown, even on a tv basis.
RorMachine - 2/8/2010, 7:34 PM
@DDD Correction she is his fiancee now.
Seriously. WTF? Quit with all the hating! [frick]ING HATERS! I hate you all!! lol. jk.
InstigatorGIRL - 2/8/2010, 7:34 PM
Who the hell is this Murray guy and when did he jump into the running?
Layperson - 2/8/2010, 7:35 PM
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.