Josh Wilding Reviews: Transformers: Dark Of The Moon 3D

Josh Wilding Reviews: Transformers: Dark Of The Moon 3D

A franchise which people seem to either love or hate, how did the final movie from Michael Bay stack up against both the past two and the rest of 2011's epic blockbusters? Hit the jump for my in-depth, spoiler free review...

Review Opinion
By JoshWilding - Jun 29, 2011 12:06 PM EST
Filed Under: Transformers



The interstellar war between the Autobots and Decepticons shifts onto overdrive following the discovery of Sentinel Prime in this sequel from director Michael Bay. Only a precious handful of officials in the government and military realize that the 1969 moon mission was the result of an event that threatened profound repercussions for the entire human race. When the Apollo 11 astronauts discover the wrecked remains of Sentinel Prime on the surface of our natural satellite, they bring him back to planet Earth. But Sentinel Prime wasn't the only alien object on the moon, and when a malevolent new enemy makes its presence known, only the Autobots can save mankind from certain destruction.


While I’ve made the upmost effort to ensure there is nothing in this review which qualifies as a spoiler, if you want to know nothing about the movie before it’s released across the world over the next few days, you may want to turn away now!

If you've seen the other two Transformers movies, you should know by now not to go in expecting an Oscar worthy masterpiece. If you're looking for another Black Swan or True Grit, then why the hell are you even reading this?! No, you go in knowing you're going to get a couple of hours of action packed, explosive fun, and that is exactly what director Michael Bay delivers in what is surely the best movie of the franchise. That's right, the trilogy curse is avoided here (see Spider-Man 3 and X-Men: The Last Stand if you don't know what I'm talking about) and we instead get a movie which is equally as good, if not better, than the first, and miles ahead of the sequel.

As you can probably tell from the above synopsis and the numerous trailers and TV spots we’ve seen over the past six months, the story is fairly straightforward. There are however plenty of surprises, and while I wouldn’t necessarily praise the script for being overly clever or ground-breaking, it is definitely far more cohesive and enjoyable than the past two movies. That’s not taking anything away from either Transformers or Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen (I personally enjoyed both for the most part) but this time the stakes feel higher, the mission is clearer and the tension continues to build throughout to a satisfying and amazing finale. The movie is perhaps a little too long, and this can be blamed on…well…John Turturro. He and every other actor brought in for comic relief in fact. If this franchise has always fallen flat in one area, it’s comedy, and the same happens again here. Dark of the Moon would have been much better off had they cut out the over the top and unnecessary return of Turturro’s Simmons, not to mention the numerous other cameos from the likes of Alan Tudyk and Ken Jeong. Tudyk is downright silly, and left me cringing in my seat praying that he would hurry the hell up and get off the screen, while the latter was ok for the most part, but I surely can’t be the only one getting bored of seeing the same thing again and again from him? It’s like he plays the same damn character in every movie, and it just does not fit in here, especially considering the fact he’s supposed to be playing a guy involved with NASA. Oh, and then we have John Malkovich. Again, he’s just about tolerable, but the fact that he and the actors I’ve mentioned above are so blatantly thrown in your face and meant to be funny just ends up falling flat. And do I even need to mention Sam’s parents? Yes, they’re back again, but this time they’re not quite in it as much as before. They make up for that by being twice as annoying. Highlighting certain actors as comic relief and shoving them down your throat is just not effective, and the moments which were clearly meant to gain laughs drew only a few quiet chuckles in the packed cinema I was in. The pacing was a little off in places, with the second act in particular getting a little slow, but there’s luckily plenty of action to keep things going.

It’s hard to complain about what Michael Bay did with this movie in terms of direction. I’m no Transformers expert, and could probably name only a handful of the Autobots and Decepticons even now after only having seen the movie a few hours ago, but was pleased to find it much easier to keep up with the action and various altercations between the two this time. The action sequences feel a lot less cluttered and frantic, and Bay once again does an outstanding job of delivering some truly breath-taking and awe-inspiring moments. Perhaps his biggest asset is the addition of 3D. There are a couple of set pieces in particular that benefit a great deal from the format, and it’s clear that the director used these specifically to show off what he could do by using it, with these scenes literally leaving me sat back in my seat with bated breath. That’s right, it really does live up to the hype and looks as good as Avatar on many occasions. There are some scenes which lack as much depth (I’m guessing those are the ones converted to 3D rather than actually shot in it) but this was a very rare occurrence. For the most part, it work beautifully, and blows both Thor and Green Lantern right out of the water. While I’m sure Dark of the Moon would be just as good in 2D, I strongly recommend seeing it in 3D, as it actually made the movie BETTER. A seemingly rare occurrence in this world of conversions we currently live in. When it comes to everything else, Bay does a perfectly adequate job with the quitter moments as well as blending practical and CGI effects seamlessly. I find it very hard to complain about anything he did this time out, and would go so far as to say it’s his best movie yet. Oh, and any of you hoping for plenty of lingering shots of the lovely Rosie Huntington-Whitely will be very happy indeed.

By this point, I hardly think it comes as a shock to say that ILM nail the special effects. Whether it’s the opening few minutes set on the moon, the title sequence, or the many magnificent and downright stunning action sequences, there’s literally not a single weak moment. The final battle in Chicago in particular contains thrill after thrill, and the arrival of the Decepticons over the city easily outdoes any of the other recent alien invasions seen in movies like Battle: Los Angeles or Skyline. In fact, they should also surely be commended for making the whole thing look so damned good in 3D. The score is suitably impressive, and fits well alongside the epic action. While it all goes a little Inception in the final battle (you’ll see what I mean when you actually watch the movie) this actually works really well and in a movie full of so many HUGE moments, it’s always good to have music which backs this up and ends up enhancing and improving the overall experience.

In terms of acting, it's Shia LeBeouf who once again sets the standard for everyone else. I'm sure some of you might think I'm being sarcastic, but I happen to actually quite like the guy, and he helps to keep things grounded as the likeable and easy to relate to Sam Witwicky. He only has a handful of scenes which require a great deal of emotion, but he does a fine job and his witty sense of humour is a blessing when compared to the other "comedic" actors I've mentioned above. Of course, one of the most noteworthy additions to the cast is Rosie Huntington-Whitely as Carly, otherwise known as Megan Fox's replacement. She's not really given a lot of material to work with, but does a surprisingly decent job, and I'm tempted to say that she ultimately does better than Fox in some respects. However, that could simply be down to the fact her character is far less unpleasant and bitchy! Overall, she might have a future in acting, and while her performance is ultimately a little forgettable, her looks most certainly are not! Don't be too surprised if you find yourself somewhat unimpressed when Patrick Dempsey first shows up as Dylan, but stick with him as things get a lot better, and he ends up delivering something of a show stealing performance. His character also happens to be the most interesting, but rather than break my no spoilers rule, I'll let you discover why that is for yourselves! Needless to say, I'm now convinced he could pull off Doctor Strange, a role he's recently been campaigning for. Josh Duhamel and Tyrese Gibson are back as Lennox and Epps respectively and each do a decent enough job, as does new cast member Frances McDormand. Overall, it’s a pretty decent cast. Of course, Transformers: Dark of the Moon also has a reasonably impressive voice cast for the various Autobots and Decepticons. The supporting robots don’t really stand out, but there’s once again no faulting Peter Cullen as Optimus Prime or Hugo Weaving as Megatron. The biggest addition of course is Leonard Nemoy as Sentinel Prime. He was very, very good as the voice of this particular character and he lends some real power and authority to Optimus’ mentor. When I first heard that he’d been asked to join the voice cast of this movie, I couldn’t quite imagine him being a good fit, but am happy to have been proved wrong.


If you didn't like the first two movies in the franchise, don't bother going to see this one, as I doubt even the impressive 3D effects will change your mind. If this truly is Michael Bay's last Transformers movie, it's a fantastic send off. While it’s not perfect, Transformers: Dark of the Moon is easily the best movie in the franchise, and while it will struggle to change the mind of those who have already decided they won’t enjoy it, the rest of you will surely have one hell of a good time!






Image and video hosting by TinyPic



BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE Remains At The Top Of Domestic Box Office As TRANSFORMERS ONE Underperforms
Related:

BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE Remains At The Top Of Domestic Box Office As TRANSFORMERS ONE Underperforms

TRANSFORMERS ONE Ending And Post-Credits Scenes Explained (Including How They Set Up A Sequel) - SPOILERS
Recommended For You:

TRANSFORMERS ONE Ending And Post-Credits Scenes Explained (Including How They Set Up A Sequel) - SPOILERS

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
PaulRom
PaulRom - 6/29/2011, 12:46 PM
Good review dude, looking forward to seeing it myself soon.
mrjones
mrjones - 6/29/2011, 12:53 PM
With special fx being so advanced you'd think that Bay and co. would put other transformers in the spotlight, but no, we get to see the same bots & cons for 3 films. I was dissapointed.
StrangerX
StrangerX - 6/29/2011, 12:56 PM
Yea Def a great review Josh. IDK how you do it when I get out the theater I'm still way too baked to do any reviews
KALel3412
KALel3412 - 6/29/2011, 1:02 PM
its not that good. maybe 3 stars. people are giving way to much credit imo.
ArtisticErotic
ArtisticErotic - 6/29/2011, 1:03 PM
@jimyjam1991

Yeah it's two hours long and yet the robots are on screen for a minimal amount of time. Whats worse the crappy jokes are still there, sure the fights are better but that's not saying much. I think our standards are really lowering for movies these days, what happened to good characters, good story?

Well at least I have Transformers Prime which is good and provides everything I want from a Transformers franchise.
ScarltSpeedster
ScarltSpeedster - 6/29/2011, 1:03 PM
Saw it last night. It was better than TF2 but it was far from great. 3D was awesome but the rest left me feeling unfulfilled even though I went in with low expectations.
Tin
Tin - 6/29/2011, 1:08 PM
TayDee
TayDee - 6/29/2011, 1:12 PM
Did they explain why Megan Fox's character wasn't in the film
plasticman
plasticman - 6/29/2011, 1:12 PM
I see a pattern starting. B, 4/5 stars...I can agree with this. It leaves room for improvement but overall is entertaining and far superior to Revenge of the Fallen.
marvel72
marvel72 - 6/29/2011, 1:13 PM
i'm going to see it next week,can't wait.
Destroyer14
Destroyer14 - 6/29/2011, 1:13 PM
Wow, I really want to see this, good review, looking forward to seeing Shockwave and my main bot Soundwave.
Fantine
Fantine - 6/29/2011, 1:19 PM
@TeyDee, they did. A couple of autobots living with Sam and Carly just said that they hope Carly doesn't dump Sam "like that last girl..we didn't like her, she was mean"

The movie was OK, it was super boring at times, and Rosie Huntington - Whitley was awful, she seriously makes Megan Fox look like Katherine Hepburn. The 3D was very good though.
Fantine
Fantine - 6/29/2011, 1:19 PM
Plus..I would give it 2 1/2 stars, it wasnt great.
StingrayX
StingrayX - 6/29/2011, 1:20 PM
I thought Shockwave was going to have a bigger role...but all he did was stand there.
StingrayX
StingrayX - 6/29/2011, 1:20 PM
I would give it 5/5 stars...it was an epic movie...I don't know how people could say it wasn't good.
StingrayX
StingrayX - 6/29/2011, 1:20 PM
I would give it 5/5 stars...it was an epic movie...I don't know how people could say it wasn't good.
StingrayX
StingrayX - 6/29/2011, 1:28 PM
There should have been more 1 vs 1 fights...the only good one was Optimus vs Sentinal...but that was only for about 1 minute.
militantcharles
militantcharles - 6/29/2011, 1:40 PM
I like it, I especially liked seen my home town get messed up for 45min. I was sick of seenin New York get all the chaos
ThaMessenger07
ThaMessenger07 - 6/29/2011, 1:45 PM
@ Videogameboy362? What would be a proper Transformers movie?

Anyone please tell me!

WTF is a movie based on F*cking Acton Figures from the 80's Supposed to be like?!?!?

I can't stand the Pompous Ignorance and Jaded Douchebaginess of the Transformer hater!
thesymbiote
thesymbiote - 6/29/2011, 1:49 PM
This movie definitely has some of the best 3D and CGI I've seen. A really fun action movie to watch. Liked it.
ThaMessenger07
ThaMessenger07 - 6/29/2011, 2:14 PM
@ CloneKev: I did read them, they were still cheesy and awful! My Brother is a fan of Transformers through and Through.

@ VideoGameBoy: It's not a cop out. They had shit material to work with. X-Men is actually a brilliant comic that takes it's story from very serious Real life situations. Prejudice and Equal Rights is the Theme. Hate for another Ethnicity or type of people is the theme. Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm-X and the Civil Rights Movement Inspired the X-Men story. Individuals that will be referenced in movies and books for all eternity.

Transformers is about giant Robot/Aliens that turn into Vehicles that originated as a cool toy idea.

"There are Bad guy ones and good guy ones. The Bad guy ones are essentially just Dickheads. The Good guy ones are heroes. There you go, now we have about 8 different comic series that have nothing to do with one another that you can refer to. We also have 5 outdated cartoons that again do not continue from one another. Okay......Lets make a Movie!"

I'm sorry were you expecting Shakespeare?

Transformers Fans that do not like the Transformers franchise remind me of NASCAR Fans that don't like "Talladega Nights".

They Complain "where is the heart and substance!?!"

"Umm sorry, we couldn't logically find any in the source material, so we just made the shit fun....."
CapFan79
CapFan79 - 6/29/2011, 2:18 PM
Actually, the plots of these films resemble those on the G1 cartoon. The DOTM plot with transporting Cybertron was part of a season 1 three part story called "The Ultimate Doom".

Everything is black or white, like a childs story. There is no nuance. They're either Decepticons or Autobots. I mean, are there Libertarian bots? Or centrists? It's simple action.

These are big live action cartoons. Nothing more. If anything I'd like more cartoony robots (not the humor) and more interaction between the bots.

Oh and Videogameboy362, I thought Devastator's wrecking "balls" was humorous. "That's funny right there! Shoot!"
danwgriff
danwgriff - 6/29/2011, 2:23 PM
@ThaMessenger07- I get on here and laugh at these tools that are so critical.

I think the hardest thing the movie hater has to get over is the wait for it to come out on dvd so they can pleasure themselves to it. When it was a saturday morning cartoon it was instantly at their grasp.

Seriously though, every hack on here that has bad stuff to say about these movies sees them and then buys every f#*kin edition that comes out.


To the people that say put some effort into it, are you kidding me, have you seen any of the footage of filming or read any of the articles on how technical this movie was and how hard it was to make. This wasn't some jack off sitting behind his MacBook with CS5. THIS WAS INDUSTRIAL LIGHT & MAGIC! The best of the best! They are known for EFFORT!!!! Are you kidding? If you are so disheartened by this film I will send you a copy of the cartoon movie and then I want your take on effort.....
thewolfx
thewolfx - 6/29/2011, 2:29 PM
i saw this movie on opening night and all i have to say is

IT WAS FCKIN AWESOME

i wacthed it in 3d with my jaw droped for the most part or the movie.

i dint go in there expecting country for old men

i expected a fun movie and i was blown away unlike some of you basement trolls .
danwgriff
danwgriff - 6/29/2011, 2:32 PM
@videogameboy- What in the world are you talking about? You cannot be serious. Is Optimus supposed to have a love interest or does BumbleBee need to come out of the closet in order for there to be "good" source material?

Give me one good example on how YOU would have made the story better? You are not making any sense.
danwgriff
danwgriff - 6/29/2011, 2:34 PM
Chirp.... Chirp.....
danwgriff
danwgriff - 6/29/2011, 2:35 PM
If Micheal Bay would have left out the dog humping it would have made the movie that much better huh? Thats it? Then it would have been Best Picture?
1 2
View Recorder