What is Wrong with GI JOE?

Hard to believe such talent can be put to such waste.
I just finished watching GI JOE: Rise of Cobra not 45 minutes ago. And I must say that this movie just doesn't have the chops.
I walked into the theater with the reviews of a hundred angry nerds festering in my mind. And I have learned not to take all of them seriously. I can say that some of the opinions posted on this site were a little overzealous in their descriptions. Not to mention that I just finished reading the novel of the film mere minutes before I walked into the theater.
I didn't have high hopes for this movie because just this morning, a friend of mine, whose opinion I trust, warned me with extreme prejudice not to see this film.
Am I calling this a horrible movie? Certainly not! There are worse movies out there. Cough! Dragonball! Cough! But I am saying that this was a wasted opportunity. I never grew up on the TV shows nor did I ever read the comics but I did look it up online weeks prior to Cobra's release.
As an adaptation, the filmmakers skewered some of the mythology. Like when did Ripcord and Scarlett ever get together? But of course, a bad adaptation doesn't always mean a bad movie. Look at the Harry Potters.
But as a movie, this film generally doesn't deliver. This is because of a few reasons: (1) Acting, (2) story, and (3) effects. These parts are essentially crucial in a film about a covert paramilitary operation.
(1) Acting:
Whenever a filmmaker casts a movie, they usually scout for chemistry. Unfortunately, these actors seem to have NONE! Look at Duke and the Baroness. There are all of these chances to make the scene tense or OTT emotional, but instead Tatum deadpans while Miller shifts her glasses and smiles.
And the one thing people are complaining about the most was what kept my attention throughout the movie: the comedy of Marlon Wayans. He is in his element when he can crack wise and flirt with a girl who isn't interested. Some of his moments, and there were a few, kept me entertained while enduring Tatum's wooden performance. Tatum seriously reminds me of Hayden Christensen as Anakin Skywalker.
(2) Story
The story was a simple one: keep the bad guys from using nano-mite warheads to rule the world. But the story became convoluted when the writers deemed it necessary to add as many back stories as they could into a movie that is less than two hours long.
Another problem I had was the pacing. Fight sequences were as fast as they come and awesome to boot. But when it got to the personal emotional part, time slowed down to a crawl. I honest to God thought I saw a snail whisper "Is it almost over?" These scenes lead back to my argument about the lack of chemistry.
(3) Effects
The effects of this movie ranged from "Holy Crap! That Looks So REAL!!!!" to "Good lord! The Mortal Kombat Movies looked better!" You see, I like consistency in the movies I see. This film didn't have any. The Paris chase scene was freakin' awesome, the water assault mission, was mediocre, but what really steamed my cortex was Destro's mask! The second King Kong Movie looked more real than that piece of crap!
Don't get me wrong, there were some shining moments. Any scene with Snake Eyes was a jewel. Dennis Quaid was not half bad as Hawk and Zartan was cool minus the lack of screen time.
This movie was the most disappointing film this year. I am hoping that if they make a sequel, that they fix the pacing, edit the effects better, and get some actual acting going on or this franchise won't ever make a dime.

Acting: 4/10
Story: 5.5/10
Effects: 5/10


Overall Score: 4.83 out of 10
4 Yes
7 No
Wadey09
8/9/2009

59 Comments

8( chemistry, that must be it!
Spilox - 8/9/2009, 2:58 PM
I tend to agree with most of what you said except one thing. Dennis quad. I thought he was horrible. When he delievered that line toward the end "alright calm down everyone we've got more joes to save" someone next to me actually laughed. He was horrible.
superdog - 8/9/2009, 3:18 PM
well, i thought he pulled off that protective wise flirtacious uncle general really well. Not to mention he was one of the few actors to ever really crack a genuine smile in the movie. Everyone else was stony faced and that drove me crazy. I thought the vipers were supposed to be the drones. Not the Heroes!!!!
Wadey09 - 8/9/2009, 3:34 PM
Very good review Wadey ...thumbs up :)
teabag - 8/9/2009, 3:42 PM
Nice. Although i actually liked the flashbacks! Well, Snake Eyes and Storm Shadows. And i thought Sienna Miller did a good job..while she was evil! Otherwise, 4 out of 10 sounds about right.
Rorschach01 - 8/9/2009, 3:59 PM
This movie sucked d**k.
Ozymandias - 8/9/2009, 4:12 PM
I wish. If it did that it would have at least been worth the money.
superdog - 8/9/2009, 4:14 PM
Well it is the RISE of COBRA!!!

Cool review! An lets hope we get a better GI JOE 2, well X-MEN did it, here's hoping! ; )
LEEE777 - 8/9/2009, 4:16 PM
Ahhhhh crap 3RD! : D

It still had one up on BORIGINS!


LEEE777 - 8/9/2009, 4:17 PM
LEEE i think most people are hoping the first one never happened let alone a sequel.....you forget that X-Men was a solid first film :)
teabag - 8/9/2009, 4:17 PM
; D
LEEE777 - 8/9/2009, 4:19 PM
Leee X Men did it coming off X1, which was about 7000,000(yes, i did precise calculations!) times better than Joe. I really would,t hold out much hope for a better sequel. Sommers does not have a good track record! The Mummy movies only got worse!
Rorschach01 - 8/9/2009, 4:20 PM
Man, i'm going to see this on Tuesday with a buddy who is dying to see it. If it is as bad as everyone says it is (except Leee of course lol) I might actually fall asleep and that would be a first.
spideysweb - 8/9/2009, 4:26 PM
I went with a buddy who was dying to see it as well. When it was over he said "so basically it's team America world police.....but funnier". He was so frigen upset but I tried to warn him.
superdog - 8/9/2009, 4:32 PM
Reboot G.I. Joe.
SirPrize - 8/9/2009, 4:41 PM
REBOOT X-MEN!!!

ROR @ ; )
LEEE777 - 8/9/2009, 4:42 PM
I can't argue there. I haven't seen GI Joe so I cannot add anymore. Sounds like I'm gonna use that money to buy beer and get a pizza delivered. =P
SirPrize - 8/9/2009, 5:01 PM
Reboot this thread
superdog - 8/9/2009, 5:01 PM
All I have to say is...the best fight scene in the whole entire movie was between young Snake Eyes and young Storm Shadow when they first meet in the kitchen. That's pretty damn bad when a kid fight is the most entertaining fight in a G.I. JOE movie. The movie was just as I expected it to be. Only thing Mr. Tatum did right in this movie was his headbutt scene.
icebergslick - 8/9/2009, 5:23 PM
All the advanced technology they had and cobra couldn't tell that duke activated a tracking device when head butted destro? More ridiculousness
superdog - 8/9/2009, 5:54 PM
I have seen it and liked it... I did say though that there were parts. I agree that Ripcord and Scarlett never got together. I am really tired of the POLITICALLY CORRECT crap. In the cartoon it was her and Duke. He never knew the Baroness. I guess that is why they couldn't cure her... She will be made bad again in the next one. Therefor we have a scott and jean or clark and lana... Ripcord could have had a touch less jokes even though G.I. Joe cartoons had jokes. He also needs to stop so many "woos". I also agree with LEE that Scarlet was much hotter than the Baroness and needed more sexy air time. Cobra Commander's and Destro's masks were were weak. Don't get me wrong, I liked it and even caught it on line... But my biggest complaint was that Snake Eyes should have done a bit better in fights but the camera angles during the fights were bad. You know that these two were what everyone wanted to really see and I thought the camera angles were bad. Needed more hand to hand for me. The last fight seemed to be that camera moving while fighting (you know when someone runs and the camera runs). Ray Parks did his trademark move with the body roll and they didn't film it dead on. They need work with the next bacuse we all know that freezing cold water can slow someone's body functions down. Which means or a good excuse for Storm Shadows return. In a nut shell I can deal with it all but the fights needed better filming or angles.
animeex - 8/9/2009, 6:09 PM
i thought DBE was better than this crap
ALmighty1080 - 8/9/2009, 6:26 PM
This movie gets 5 and half stars, 2 for the barroness' hotness, 2 for scarlett's hotness, 2 for snake eyes/shadow storm fights, minus half for snake eyes' mouth
droopy1317 - 8/9/2009, 7:20 PM
Almighty@ not quite as bad as DBE. But pretty damn close :)
superdog - 8/9/2009, 7:22 PM
ROC was fun for most people that saw it and if you are a fan of the old comics and cartoons there are many subtle references throughout the film that you will appreciate.
Xfactorz - 8/9/2009, 7:33 PM
It's not really that bad.. I enjoyed the movie because I accepted it for what it is. I grew up watching Joes, and I could honestly say that this is something like an episode of G.I. Joe, over the top fun. If you are coming in with different expectations then you would really be disappointed. I must admit acting is a bit wooden, maybe they got their cue from the toys, and the animation is a bit clunky, storywise is not convulated, simple but not simplistic, something from a child's mind's eye which is really what the G.I. Joes are about. I like the movie maybe because I am more forgiving, and I believe they respected the source material.
access - 8/9/2009, 7:40 PM
My only expectation that I ever go into a movie with is that it be good. And I refuse to lower that expectation regardless of the source material. Putting your brain at the door is different than putting your taste at the door.
superdog - 8/9/2009, 8:09 PM
I m sorry guys... DBE was really bad. I think G.I. Joe has it beat... The box office receipts will show that. I don't want to be mean, but DBE was 8th place on opening weekend. Good call eliwingz.
animeex - 8/9/2009, 9:12 PM
Just saw the movie today and I actually liked it. Not sure what all the complaining is about I thought it was a fairly decent movie.
Kratos6 - 8/9/2009, 9:15 PM
Most movies nowadays will only rate a three with me because my standard is a little high. I did not call GI JOE a horrible movie, it just could have been way better. It's potential for a true blockbuster to end the summer with a significant BANG!!!! The movie had bangs, but with no substance, it hardly meant a thing!
I respect the attempt and hope they get the formula right for GI JOE 2.
I am just venting my particluar opinion on this film and feel if you want to think that this movie is a piece of crap, then go watch it so that you can back it up.

Wadey09 - 8/9/2009, 9:29 PM
whaaaat!? G.I. Joe wasn't that bad, but it wasn't that good either. it's really more of a sit back relax, turn off your thinking cap type of movie. enjoyed it more than Transformers 2(stupid movie). i just hope, they get a different director for the sequel. i don't like that mummy dude. x-men?? first x-men movie was an epic fail for me...but the did a good job with the second one...the 3rd one should've gone straight to DVD if you asked me. i'm just thankful that Marvel movies are improving. G.I. Joe still have 2 or 3 chances to redeem itself.
redskullrevenge - 8/9/2009, 9:40 PM
@Kratos6 - what is your favorite comic book or particular animated hero(es) that you grew up on?
KidFReSHofKrypt0n - 8/9/2009, 9:40 PM
@luffycapri@ dude! sweet fan trailer!
prototype 3D - 8/10/2009, 3:20 AM
REDSKULL @ Exactly man!!!! ; )


Oh and......


VOTE =



PERFECT
LEEE777 - 8/10/2009, 5:59 AM
Spideysweb @ Read my ARTICLE! More ppl like GI JOE than h8 it man!!! ; D
LEEE777 - 8/10/2009, 6:05 AM
i went in with no expectations. most of what was said on this site is the same type of thing people said about transformers 2, and i enjoyed transformers 2. it wasn't the greatest, but it was enjoyable.

having said that, this is the worst movie i've seen in a very long time!!!! i did not like ANYTHING about it. not even the snake eyes/storm shadow fights everyone talks about. they were just as bad. they might stand out as the best part of the movie, but they were still far from good. ray park and Bung-Hung Lee (lol) are such amazing martial artists, yet they were wasted in this movie. their fight scenes consisted of 3 or 4 punches being thrown, and then a quick scene change. they were just way too broken up. through no fault of their own this ruined their fight scenes, and that can be blamed on directing all the way. and i seriously laughed my ass off when storm shadow was flying around on that jet pack...also, like ROR said, when the doctor made his transformation into cobra commander...that really is just comedy gold. even better than darth vader stepping off the chair thing in episode 3..."NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO..." LOL. and the special effects?? heh, yeah, terrible. they CGI'd EVERYTHING. there was even a scene that was a birds eye view of a car pulling up to a mansion, and the freakin' CAR was CGI. really?? anyway, this is the first movie to come out in a long time that i don't have a SINGLE good thing to say about it...and i was very excited to see it, AND wanted it to be good.
CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 6:59 AM
Amen. For me its very simple. If im laughing my ass off at a movie in the bits that are not supposed to be funny and rolling my eyes at the bits that are, it FAILED.
Rorschach01 - 8/10/2009, 7:43 AM
@swag I grew up with GI Joe, Transformers, I also like Spiderman, Superman, Batman, Captain America, Justice League, Avengers, Hulk, just to name a few. Why?
Kratos6 - 8/10/2009, 8:07 AM
So when can all of us that liked ROC start using the same toolbox excuse as those who defended TF2, "it has to be good...look at how much money it has made, already over a 100 million internationally!"?

(I am not actually justifying my opinion of ROC, just trying to point out how lame that excuse was in defense of that craptastic sequel ROTF)

For me, ROC was so much better than ROTF it wasn't even close(except for the CGI, which was great in ROTF and terrible in ROC)!
Xfactorz - 8/10/2009, 8:12 AM
@ xfactorz

you don't need to use any "excuse" for anything. if you liked it, you liked it, bottom line. its not like anyone will think any less of you, at least they shouldn't. its just that, to me, gi joe was WAY more over the top than ROTF. and the special effects are no contest. but that doesn't make you any less a fan or anything, man!
CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 8:20 AM
LEEE...i read your post and count more people not liking it...the only real problem with GiJoe was it was made in the first place ;O
teabag - 8/10/2009, 8:48 AM
cordong@ your right. i said the same thing about transformers if you liked it you liked it. people should feel free to come on here and express theier opinions without getting called names or being yelled at.
superdog - 8/10/2009, 8:55 AM
@ superdog

lol, did you just call me cordong?? lol
CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 9:28 AM
yeah i did. sorry. i kinda like it though so i think ill keep doing it :)
superdog - 8/10/2009, 9:48 AM
lmao, no problem
CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 9:50 AM
oh yeah go by this ass hole! he never saw the cartoon or comic he knows nothing. And has know say in anything. I love the fact that people who never saw the cartoon are criteaking it. U people no SHIT! >:0 and @(roschach01) dosent know his ass from his elbow much like all of U!!!!!! >:0
Logan-X - 8/10/2009, 10:23 AM
@CDB- thanks bro, but I must have not expressed my point clearly. I was actually meaning that I was not attempting to make an excuse for my opinion but simply point out how lame that argument was when I started hearing it in regards to ROTF and to point it out before someone tried using it again.
Xfactorz - 8/10/2009, 10:23 AM
@ xfactorz

no, it definately is a lame excuse, the money a movie makes has nothing to do with the quality of the movie, just means more people saw it, not more people liked it.

@ Logan

so i take it you liked it?
CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 10:37 AM
Logan X is what happens when cousins marry. By the way you used "know" and "no" in the wrong places there genius.

CDB...you realize "dong" might stick as a nicname!
Rorschach01 - 8/10/2009, 10:48 AM
@ ror

his whole post was a grammar nightmare. he's probably supermike's cousin, lol. and no problem with the nickname, lol, i guess. at least it isn't supermike's nickname!

@ logan

so if someone didn't watch the cartoon, they aren't allowed to have an opinion about the crapfest movie??


CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 11:10 AM
Dong@ lol

Logan@ so if someone watched the cartoon but still didnt like it i guess they just never played with the toys enough to give a verdict.!! :(
teabag - 8/10/2009, 11:56 AM
@Kratos6 - well lets just say for example (if they put these scenarios in a movie and Hollywood expected you to just take it, you would be furious that they(Hollywood) have once again raped your favorite heroes, right?!?):

-Spiderman: A human sized Spider rapes Aunt May and boom...Spiderman is born. lol

-Superman: Superman started out as a hemorphadite and he was known as SuperPerson (Thanks Bryan Singer).

-Batman: Alfred started out as the Bat and inspired Bruce Wayne to become him later on in life.

-Captain America: Bucky is frozen with Cap and the Red skull unthaws Cap and not Bucky, just so he could watch him smash Bucky to pieces, lol.

-Justice League: Booster Gold starts the Justice League.

-Avengers: The Wasp is the leader of the Avengers.

-Hulk: The Hulk was sky blue for the first 3/4 of a movie.

See where I am going with this...origins all f'd up, relationships not what they should be. G.I. Joke is just that f'd up and more. They BarakaPool'd G.I. Joe. lol
KidFReSHofKrypt0n - 8/10/2009, 12:55 PM
the only thing i did not like is the baroness being good,the rest rocked!!!!
NightAvenger4 - 8/10/2009, 2:35 PM
r u shitting me biggest disapointment this year my ass Transformers was the biggest disapointment this year. Because in order to be disapointed u have to be really hyped about the movie, and from the looks of it everyone one here was really hyped for transformers I really wasn't because Transformers one didn't even blow me away. The story was mediocre at best. But everyone here thought it was [frick]ing great. When I went into GI joe I wasn't really hyped to see it (the only movie I was really hyped for was Terminator, It disapointed me a little) but when I came out of it I was pleased. The story was fine, And who cares if they [frick]ed up the comic book, at least the story made sense. It kind of pissed me off when the baroness turned good, but I think there's something else behind that. They could have made the Commander's mask look like what it was on GI Joe Resolute, but it wasn't all that bad. Destro did look a little fake but I liked his origin. I like how the back story's all linked up and brought more depths to the characters. The flash back's did remind me kind of an anime. But they weren't unecessary. All and all GI Joe wasn't bad nor was it great, but it was good.
GunRyder - 8/10/2009, 4:05 PM
@ teabag, lol, and so it begins
CorndogBurglar - 8/10/2009, 7:00 PM
I'm glad you were disappointed, and I hope you had to pay for a ticket also....cause that's what YOU get. Lighten up for God's sake. I wont even comment on the idiotic things you wrote.... I am just happy that YOU were disappointed.
chuckops - 8/11/2009, 4:01 AM
@ chuckops

lol, who are YOU talking to??? lol
CorndogBurglar - 8/11/2009, 7:40 AM
The only thing wrong with this movie is Baroness is softer than she was before and Cobra Commander's mask. Everything else is great. All the back stories of the characters were fleshed out a lot more. The only one that changed the most was Cobra Commander's, but it fit the good story.

As great as the cartoon was, it was very campy and unrealistic. This movie puts it in the real world and doesn't put everyone in unmatiching multicolored uniforms. There is an enormous amount of attention to detail here in this movie and it should be realized.

This movie was nearly as good as possible for a first run. 7 out of 10 atleast. I don't know why people are expecting so much, especially when they stayed so faithful to details.
venkman9993592 - 8/11/2009, 11:37 AM
@ corndog burgler

I was talking the jacka$$ who wrote the comments at the top.

Oh, and to Ozymandias: You suck d**k.



chuckops - 8/13/2009, 1:34 AM

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

Horror SciFi SciFi Video Game Movies Animated Features Anime & Manga
Earths Mightiest Fansites
Earths Mightiest Fansites


Join our Forum
Join the discussion in our Community Forum!

www.MightyHotties.com

CBM Calendar
2009
  • September 11 - Whiteout
  • September 25 - Surrogates
  • October 23 - Astro Boy
  • TBD - Kick Ass
2010
  • May 7th - Iron Man 2
  • Jun.25th - The Green Hornet
2011
  • May 6 - Spider-Man 4
  • June 17 - Thor
  • July 22 - The First Avenger: Captain America
2012
  • May 4 - The Avengers