Defending Star Wars: The Phantom Menace

Defending Star Wars: The Phantom Menace

Does it really deserve all the hate?

Editorial Opinion
By sonofsamadams - Jun 15, 2015 12:06 PM EST
Filed Under: Star Wars

16 Years after the Phantom Menace came out, we must ask ourselves, does it really deserve all the hate? Now across most sites, like RT, Metacritic, Imdb, user scores rate the film about 6/10, which is mostly positive. Here we try to defend the Phantom Menace.: 

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A3aIQ-yQyfs



After all this time, do you still have a fanboy grudge against the Phantom Menace? Or were you like us and saw it as a fun popcorn adventure?

Comment and let us know! 

Hayden Christensen Reveals His STAR WARS Wishlist: A Live-Action THE CLONE WARS And A DARTH VADER Movie/Series
Related:

Hayden Christensen Reveals His STAR WARS Wishlist: A Live-Action THE CLONE WARS And A DARTH VADER Movie/Series

RUMOR: Lucasfilm Planning A Mandoverse-Style Slate Of STAR WARS Movie Set Post-THE RISE OF SKYWALKER
Recommended For You:

RUMOR: Lucasfilm Planning A Mandoverse-Style Slate Of STAR WARS Movie Set Post-THE RISE OF SKYWALKER

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

WYLEEJAY
WYLEEJAY - 6/15/2015, 1:24 PM
Let me put it this way. Me and my son are reaching all the films before Episode 7. Episode 1, I fast forwarded through the whole film and was able to easily explain the important plot points. We just watched the final scenes with Maul.

You shouldn't be able to do that and fully understand the film. He knows exactly what Palpatine plans are.
Dingbat
Dingbat - 6/15/2015, 2:34 PM
"Does it really deserve all the hate?"

Yes.

Attack of the Clones actually manages to be worse though, despite not having much Jar Jar or Kid Anakin. That's impressive.
pesmerga44
pesmerga44 - 6/15/2015, 5:32 PM
Yes the movie deserves all the hate it receives. The characters have no actual character to them because you can't describe the characters beyond a word or two and what they look like and their jobs. The movie has no real target audience it is going for because it is to kiddy and annoying most of the time for the adults i.e. Jar Jar and far too boring and monotonous for children i.e. all the Senate scenes and the Jedi Council scenes. Even George Lucas admitted so in the documentary that the ending to the movie is a complete mess with 4 major action end pieces going on at the same time. The Gungan battle, the space battle, the assault on the castle, and the Jedi fight that is far too many scenes to be happening all at once. There are exactly two cool scenes in the movie, the pod race and the battle with Darth Maul and they completely waste Darth Maul here.

Yet in the end Star Wars 1 is not the worst movie in the series Star Wars 2 is by far a much much worst movie. So much wrong with the movie. The dialogue is absolutely atrocious in the movie especially all of Anakin's dialogue. The characters do nothing but talk to one another the entire film completely missing the point of film with show don't tell. Everywhere is just CGI with giant empty CGI backgrounds that you can tell the characters are just standing in front of green screens, and finally the last battle that really kind of ruins Yoda as a character with that stupid end fight. Yoda was the mystical spiritual character that we did not really know in the original movies and much like the Emperor he was this powerful force user who did not use a lightsaber. The Emperor actually looked down on lightsabers calling them a Jedi weapon because he was so powerful with the force he did not need them and Yoda I feel was much that same way. Yet in that movie we had jumping back flipping Yoda with his ridiculous little lightsaber. That movie was the worst.
pesmerga44
pesmerga44 - 6/15/2015, 5:36 PM
@MrSotoMan

Well that really isn't much of a compliment now is it. That is like saying you would rather be handed a piece of sloppy shit to hold then get a steel toed kick to the balls. Sure the steel toed kick to the balls is worse but you are still holding a piece of sloppy shit.
pesmerga44
pesmerga44 - 6/15/2015, 5:38 PM


This is a long in depth review on how bad this movie is and easily shows why the prequels are bad. He does the other two prequels as well and they are all long and go through every single reason these movies are in fact bad.
pesmerga44
pesmerga44 - 6/15/2015, 5:44 PM
@Dingbat

Yes while it drops annoying as hell Jar Jar and kid Anakin it gets something I personally find much much worse. Annoying whiny and super creedpy teenage Anakin. Anakin in ep.2 did nothing but whine and complain about everything from his master to [frick]ing sand. While the rest of the time he was creepily hitting on Padme that made me super uncomfortable to watch.
pesmerga44
pesmerga44 - 6/15/2015, 5:50 PM
@sonofsamadams

Hey some helpful advice go edit this article and remove the s from the end of https because the video will not appear if the s is on there. All images and pictures can not be posted if they have the s there so just remove it and the video will show up.
01928401
01928401 - 6/16/2015, 5:16 PM
It's not that bad. You know why people hate it? The same reason so many people thought Jurassic World was disappointing. "Wahhh, my favorite franchise made another movie when they shouldn't have. It will never live up to the originals." Boo hoo.
acorsi11
acorsi11 - 6/17/2015, 4:36 PM
I've just rewatched all 6 films the past couple weeks, and I never saw the hate on the Phantom Menace, UNTIL NOW.

The Trade Federation is soooo boring, and the Naboo officials are super boring too.
Young Anikan is a terrible actor
Jar Jar Binks is terrible
I don't like the overuse of CGI

Only cool character is really Darth Maul, and they kill him off! (watching clone wars for the first time, so ready to see him back in action)
View Recorder