POLL:The Best Comic to Screen Joker MAKE-UP!

legionbecks@ Dude TDK Has The jokers mouth scarred from a cut to make his huge grin and his face is powdered in with makeup for the lips and stuff

The Joker in The comics has bleached white skin and ruby red lips from a vat of chemicals Although its is one of the best performances it's not how the real Joker looks

Id have to say City of scars or Batman 89

It does look good doesn't it? ...but Dead End is my favorite.

I hear ya about Mark Hamill ...he rules. If I do a Fancast for "The Dark Knight Returns" By Frank Miller, He will be my choice for Joker.

tdk joker looks more closer

City of scars or Batman 89

for what romack said, o wait nvm i read it wrong, i didnt read that it was the most faithfull to comics to screen adaptation. idk then, but if it was the most realistic while still portraying the character well, TDK, but thats not what this poll is about lol

For me it's a tie between Dead End and City of scars.

@ CorndogBurglar: Maybe I could explain, I think everyone's reasoning is that they loved The Dark Knight as a film, especially The Joker. They might be saying that he looks more like the comic book Joker, because they like Heath's Joker the most. It's possible that they're not necessarily considering the actual physical likeness of the two, or maybe they see something that others don't, I don't know.

I actually almost voted for TDK's Joker myself, but after looking at him and the other candidates, well I'm not really sure who to choose.

BUT

Just my theory on everyone choosing The Dark Knight's Joker above all the others.

cdb- WAT U MEAN MOST PPL R LIKE ME? CAN U EXPLAIN

@ flames

yeah, apparently they're blind. and people are such marks for Ledger because he gave us the best Joker, that they'll pick him for ANYTHING. He clearly looks nothing like the comics. its baffling that so many people would pick TDK Joker in this. i guess more people around here have never picked up a comic than i thought...

City of Scars Joker definitely looks the most like the comic version.
TDK has the best performance IMO.

@ CDB - LOL, I wouldn't take you up on that because I agree with you 100%. The question could be anything and as long as TDK "anything" is part of the question, people will default to that without fully understanding the question.

@ tea - yup. It's almost like most CBM fans are on automatic mode, in which the default setting is set to TDK.

And why are we making references to who's performance was best? Was that the question? Was this article edited and I missed it? If it was a question of performance, wouldn't ROMACK have mentioned it in his article. What he did instead is clearly the opposite. Here is a direct quote from the article in case it's not abundantly clear: "Ok everyone has their favorite actor when it comes to the Joker, but what we are looking for here today is "What movie provided the best Comic-to-Screen adaptation of Jokers look?" Acting performance is to have no influence here. It is simply a matter of "Which one do you think is most faithful to the comics?"

So pretty please, with sugar on top ... READ THE F.U.C.K.I.N.G ARTICLE!!!

Yeah, I havn't commented yet because I just don't want to say anything that might offend all the dumb$h!ts voting for TDK. Maybe they CAN'T read and just like looking at the pictures.

cdb- wow so ppl r blind cuz they pick tdk joker. and when i read a batman comic book i always seen the joker as tdk and that was be4 the movie came out.

I think Nicholson definitely matched the look perfectly. I mean look at his threads, it's practically straight from the comic, along with his makeup.

@ flames

and in the comics you read with the Joker, does he have scars on his face? is the white just paint? no? then how can say TDK looks more like the comics?

this isn't even a matter of opinion. it would be like someone telling you that the color red looks more blue to them. (unless they're colorblind, it would be crazy, no?) lol

Batman Dead End looks the most like the comics.
Heath Ledger was the best on screen potrayal of the Joker of our time.

Dead End Joker FTW.
If you havn't seen this short movie you are depriving yourself.

@ creature

Brian Azzarello's Joker comic came out AFTER TDK.