STAR WARS: REVENGE OF THE SITH Revisited - 5 Things That Worked And 5 That Didn't

Star Wars fans recently celebrated the 15-year anniversary of Revenge of the Sith, and we're now taking a look back at George Lucas' final prequel to explore what did and didn't work in the movie...

By JoshWilding - Jun 22, 2020 08:06 AM EST

Filed Under: Star Wars

The Star Wars franchise returned to the big screen in 2015 with The Force Awakens, and 2020 marks the first time since then we're not getting a movie set in a Galaxy Far, Far Away. The future of the franchise is also uncertain, with Rian Johnson reportedly still working on a trilogy and Taika Waititi recently announced as the director of an untitled adventure.

However, neither of those have release dates, and it seems Lucasfilm is focusing on bringing this franchise to the small screen instead (courtesy of the recently launched Disney+ streaming service).

To fill that Star Wars shaped void in your lives, we're now taking a look back at the Skywalker Saga, and after delving into The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones, it's now time to conclude this revisit of the prequels by exploring what did and didn't work in Revenge of the Sith.

Was it the perfect finale? No, but it was arguably better than The Rise of Skywalker, and this exploration of the movie might just give you a new way of thinking about Darth Vader's origin story.

So, to check this one out, all you guys need to do is click the "Next" button down below...

Did Work: Count Dooku's Demise

The battle between Obi-Wan, Anakin, and Count Dooku was a great way to kick off Revenge of the Sith, and while it’s hard to escape the feeling that it probably should have been a bigger moment a little later in the movie, the villain being executed by the young Jedi was still well-handled.

With Palpatine sitting in that chair, this sequence was one Lucas clearly went out of his way to ensure would share some similarities with the final duel in Return of the Jedi, offering a look at how it might have looked had Luke given into the Dark Side and decided to kill father.

That kind of symmetry was ultimately just a bonus, though, and seeing Palpatine push Anakin into executing his minion was a great way to tease his later transformation into Darth Vader.

Didn't Work: Some, Ahem, FORCE-d Moments

Lucas wasted a lot of time in the prequels, so it should come as no surprise that when it came to wrapping everything up, a lot of plot threads were not handled in the most satisfying manner.

So many of them were rushed, they came across somewhat forced, as a result, and failed to be anywhere near as effective as they should have been. Senator Bail Organa’s rash decision to adopt Leia is a good example of that, while both Obi-Wan and Yoda’s sudden departures for Dagobah and Tatooine felt more random than meaningful.

If anything, this trilogy needed a fourth instalment to properly set up the original trilogy, or at least more than a quick five minutes which made these vital plot threads feel like an afterthought.

Did Work: General Grievous

With Dooku dealt with fairly early on, Lucas added a new bad guy to Revenge of the Sith in the form of General Grievous. While it was a little strange for the Star Wars franchise to make use of yet another villain with breathing difficulties, that wasn’t what made him memorable.

It was the fact that he had the ability to wield several lightsabers at once (something we hadn’t seen in the franchise before) and the reveal that those blades once belonged to Jedi Knights he had murdered took this movie to some dark places, especially for the mostly child friendly prequels.

After so much questionable CGI in the movies which preceded this one, Grievous looked amazing, and had a very memorable battle with Obi-Wan which surprisingly saw him taken out with a blaster.

Didn't Work: Padme's Death

Talking about her mother in the original trilogy, Leia says she has some fleeting memories of her, an impossibility considering the fact Padme died in childbirth (though there have been suggested explanations pointing to Leia’s connection with the Force being responsible for those visions).

Regardless, it would have made sense for her to have survived beyond the end of this film, but Lucas needed to explain why Vader didn’t know about his children and get them to where they needed to be as quickly as possible, so Padme’s death ended up both rushed and forced.

We were supposed to believe that she died from a broken heart, but that just came across as being an easy excuse for finding a way to kill her off, and this wasn't the ending the character deserved.

Did Work: Order 66

One of the biggest unanswered questions heading into Revenge of the Sith was how and why the Republic’s army of clones would end up as part of the Empire. Instead, it turned out that Palpatine had been planning the fall of the Jedi for a long time, with Order 66 resulting in them turning on their allies and mowing them down where they stood.

Sure, it could be argued that the Jedi should have been able to easily take out these disposable clones, but an effective montage detailing their fall ended up being one of the best parts of this movie, and perhaps the Star Wars franchise as a whole. The sight of Anakin leading them all into the Jedi temple was quite something, as was seeing the Jedi fall.

Oh, and those poor younglings…if that's a moment which failed to stick with you, we don't know what to say.

Didn't Work: Too. Many. Visions

Because Anakin’s visions in Attack of the Clones weren’t tedious enough, we were forced to endure them again in Revenge of the Sith. This time, he was seeing the future, but not clearly enough to witness his descent to the Dark Side or the fact that he was responsible for killing his own wife!

Regardless, while Lucas used them as a way of trying to explain why Anakin would ultimately become a Sith – Palpatine had after all promised that he could help him – it was a shame to learn that he ended up being a complete dullard essentially fooled into doing so via Palpatine's manipulations.

Lucas could have easily found a better way to explore and explain Anakin’s transformation into Vader without more of these visions, and this was ultimately far too simplistic.

Did Work: The Opening Space Battle

The Star Wars prequels had a long list of issues and Lucas got a lot of stuff wrong, but it’s hard to fault the space battles which were featured across, well, his entire trilogy of prequel movies.

By far the best of them and a real highlight of Revenge of the Sith was this opening sequence set above Coruscant as Anakin and Obi-Wan – now a better team than ever before after spending years fighting side by side in The Clone Wars – sprung into action to save Palpatine.

Utilising state of the art CGI, this battle was a sight to behold, and one of the most exciting and visually stunning battle sequences seen in any sci-fi film at the time. For a release with so much questionable dialogue, even the banter between Anakin and Obi-Wan’s worked here.

Didn't Work: Palpatine's Transformation

Palpatine was getting on in years when we met him in The Phantom Menace, so why Lucas found it necessary to show him being deformed by Mace Windu in their cringe-worthy duel is hard to say.

It’s a safe bet that pretty much everyone would have just assumed that in the decades that passed between the end of the Star Wars prequels and when we first saw The Emperor in The Empire Strikes Back, he had just aged. Alternatively, the villain fully embracing the Dark Side the moment his true colours were revealed could have led to his more monstrous appearance.

Instead, he spent the final act looking like he was wearing a cheap Halloween mask, and actually nothing like the Empire we saw in the original movies. This was just plain weird, and did not work.

Did Work: Obi-Wan Kenobi Vs. Anakin Skywalker

Putting aside the fact that this was one of the best lightsaber battles in the entire Star Wars Saga from an action standpoint, the emotion involved here really elevated this to the next level. This was the fight fans had been waiting for since the prequels were announced, and it lived up to the hype.

If there was one downside to this battle, it was that the ending felt somewhat anti-climatic, but there’s no denying that the sight of a tearful Obi-Wan leaving Anakin to burn (in a surprisingly graphic, but nonetheless extremely effective, moment) stands out to this day and explained Vader's hatred of his old Master.

Throw in John Williams’ incredible score, and no matter what came before or after this, you have to at least give Lucas credit for getting this right, and that's a big part of why many fans love the film.

Didn't Work: "Nooooo!"

Getting to witness the moment Anakin Skywalker is transformed into Darth Vader was always a must for Revenge of the Sith, and for the most part, the scenes of him being rebuilt and put into the iconic suit were handled well. It was a little strange hearing an almost vulnerable Vader as he asked The Emperor about Padme’s whereabouts, but that made sense here.

What didn’t was the hilariously bad "Noooooo!" which followed, a truly baffling addition made by Lucas.

Had Lucas handled Vader’s reaction to the news in a far more subtle manner (just imagine him standing there in silence, only for everything around him suddenly being destroyed), it could have worked, but this looked and sounded daft. Plus, it's pretty hard to forgive the filmmaker for later adding that to Return of the Jedi when the movies were re-released on Blu-ray.

STAR WARS: Darth Revan, Starkiller And More Finally Get Their Own Incredible Hot Toys Action Figures

Recommended For You:

STAR WARS: Lando Calrissian Actor Billy Dee Williams On Blackface - "Why Not? You Should Do It"

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

18 Comments

Marvelouspoorg - 6/22/2020, 8:10 AM

"Regardless, it would have made sense for her to have survived beyond the end of this film, but Lucas needed to explain why Vader didn’t know about his children and get them to where they needed to be as quickly as possible, so Padme’s death ended up both rushed and forced"

Despite the fact Padme is clearly said to have died in return of the jedi and never mentioned anywehere else in the EU or canon to have lived and torn apart the whole movie's plot? That's a ridiculous point.

bkmeijer2 - 6/22/2020, 8:22 AM

I only agree with how dumb the ''noooooooo'' was, but the rest is just including things that didn't work because of the chosen 5 things/5 things format

GhostDog - 6/22/2020, 8:22 AM

Didn't Work: This List

ShimmyShimmyYA - 6/22/2020, 8:23 AM

@BlackBeltJones - I see what you did there

GhostDog - 6/22/2020, 8:31 AM

@ShimmyShimmyYA -

Nightwing1015 - 6/22/2020, 8:28 AM

Somebody is saying bad things about ROTS?

Nerdman3000 - 6/22/2020, 8:37 AM

This is my favorite Star Wars movie. I seriously love it to death. Love live Revenge of the Sith!

Also on a side note, this list is awful.

Timerider84 - 6/22/2020, 8:49 AM

I wish the ending wasn't rushed, it was like this 4 minute montage and it's over. I wanted to hear Owen talk to Kenobi about Luke and what happened. I guess we might get a few minutes of dialogue with Owen in the Kenobi series at the end, I hope at least. No need to go to Tunisia anymore.

RevanIsMyMan - 6/22/2020, 9:13 AM

Jesus Josh how about let someone else do the list with actual points, and not whatever shit you pulled out of your ass.

sadham - 6/22/2020, 10:02 AM

I remember the entire theater burst out in laughter at Vader's "NOOOOOOOO!"

What should have been a memorable moment showing the birth of one of the most iconic characters in pop culture was reduced to a joke.

coderaven - 6/22/2020, 10:10 AM

I really only agree with Padme's death. Death from a broken heart with two new born in the world made zero sense. Been better if he just Anakin had truly just fatally injured her.

AnthonyVonGeek - 6/22/2020, 10:11 AM

Stop living in the past Josh. 🤣😜

Stinkor1 - 6/22/2020, 6:53 PM

Would it have been better if the robot said she died from blood loss due to multiple vaginal tears and hemorrhaging as a result of pushing two humans out of her?

Related Headlines

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Darth Revan, Starkiller And More Finally Get Their Own Incredible Hot Toys Action Figures

JoshWilding

2 days ago

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Lando Calrissian Actor Billy Dee Williams On Blackface - "Why Not? You Should Do It"

MarkCassidy

Apr 11, 2024 06:04 AM

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Is Latest "Star Tours" Update Teasing Dave Filoni's Plans For A HEIR TO THE EMPIRE Movie?

JoshWilding

Apr 10, 2024 04:04 AM

Related Headlines

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Darth Revan, Starkiller And More Finally Get Their Own Incredible Hot Toys Action Figures

JoshWilding

2 days ago

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Lando Calrissian Actor Billy Dee Williams On Blackface - "Why Not? You Should Do It"

MarkCassidy

Apr 11, 2024 06:04 AM

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Is Latest "Star Tours" Update Teasing Dave Filoni's Plans For A HEIR TO THE EMPIRE Movie?

JoshWilding

Apr 10, 2024 04:04 AM

Video Games

STAR WARS OUTLAWS Release Date Announced With Pre-Order Details And Special Editions

MattIsForReal

Apr 09, 2024 06:04 PM

Star Wars

STAR WARS: Daisy Ridley On Decision To Return For Rey-Focused Movie - "I Feel More Like I'm Owning It"

MarkCassidy

Apr 09, 2024 10:04 AM

Star Wars

Deadpool & Wolverine

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

MarkCassidy

1 hour ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

X-MEN Star Ray Park Responds To Rumors He'll Return As Toad In DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE

JoshWilding

2 hours ago

Latest Headlines

Marvel Comics

WOLVERINE #50: Marvel Shares First Look At Benjamin Percy's Final Issue As Logan Celebrates 50th Anniversary

JoshWilding

28 mins ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

MarkCassidy

1 hour ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

X-MEN Star Ray Park Responds To Rumors He'll Return As Toad In DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE

JoshWilding

2 hours ago

X-Men '97

Who Is [SPOILER]? Everything You Need To Know About X-MEN '97 Surprise New Villain

JoshWilding

4 hours ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

Does DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE's New Trailer Feature A Nod To 2002's SPIDER-MAN?

JoshWilding

5 hours ago

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

JoshWilding

7 hours ago

Hot Headlines

166 comments

MAN OF STEEL Director Zack Snyder Says Superman Would Be "Fake" If He Hadn't Killed General Zod

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

100 comments

Former X-MEN '97 Showrunner Beau DeMayo Says Show Will Address Mr. Sinister's Racism

MarkCassidy

1 day ago EST

72 comments

SHE-HULK: ATTORNEY AT LAW Guest-Star Megan Thee Stallion Sued For Workplace Harassment

MarkCassidy

15 hours ago EST

65 comments

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Official Trailer Features Ultimate Team-Up & Promises The Wildest MCU Movie Of All-Time!

RohanPatel

2 days ago EST

54 comments

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Director Zack Snyder Shares First Look At His Animated Norse Mythology Series

More Cartoons & Animated ►

New DESTINY 2: THE FINAL SHAPE Trailer Takes Us Into The Pale Heart Of The Traveler

More Anime & Manga ►

WEDNESDAY Season 2 Adds WESTWORLD Star Thandiwe Newton In Mysterious Role

More Horror ►

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Mask Designer Eddie Yang; Dev Patel Film Now Available On Digital HD

More Action Movies & TV ►

Jinder Mahal Reflects On Social Media Spat With AEW's Tony Khan And His WWE Day 1 Promo Alongside The Rock

More Pro Wrestling ►

STAR WARS: TALES OF THE EMPIRE Clip Sees General Grievous Attack Dathomir's Nightsisters

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

More Cartoons & Animated ►

More Anime & Manga ►

More Horror ►

More Action Movies & TV ►

More Pro Wrestling ►

STAR WARS: REVENGE OF THE SITH Revisited - 5 Things That Worked And 5 That Didn't

Star Wars fans recently celebrated the 15-year anniversary of Revenge of the Sith, and we're now taking a look back at George Lucas' final prequel to explore what did and didn't work in the movie...

Did Work: Count Dooku's Demise

Didn't Work: Some, Ahem, FORCE-d Moments

Did Work: General Grievous

Didn't Work: Padme's Death

Did Work: Order 66

Didn't Work: Too. Many. Visions

Did Work: The Opening Space Battle

Didn't Work: Palpatine's Transformation

Did Work: Obi-Wan Kenobi Vs. Anakin Skywalker

Didn't Work: "Nooooo!"

STAR WARS: Darth Revan, Starkiller And More Finally Get Their Own Incredible Hot Toys Action Figures

STAR WARS: Lando Calrissian Actor Billy Dee Williams On Blackface - "Why Not? You Should Do It"

STAR WARS: Darth Revan, Starkiller And More Finally Get Their Own Incredible Hot Toys Action Figures

STAR WARS: Lando Calrissian Actor Billy Dee Williams On Blackface - "Why Not? You Should Do It"

STAR WARS: Is Latest "Star Tours" Update Teasing Dave Filoni's Plans For A HEIR TO THE EMPIRE Movie?

STAR WARS: Darth Revan, Starkiller And More Finally Get Their Own Incredible Hot Toys Action Figures

STAR WARS: Lando Calrissian Actor Billy Dee Williams On Blackface - "Why Not? You Should Do It"

STAR WARS: Is Latest "Star Tours" Update Teasing Dave Filoni's Plans For A HEIR TO THE EMPIRE Movie?

STAR WARS OUTLAWS Release Date Announced With Pre-Order Details And Special Editions

STAR WARS: Daisy Ridley On Decision To Return For Rey-Focused Movie - "I Feel More Like I'm Owning It"

STAR WARS: DAWN OF THE JEDI Finds A Writer In ANDOR Scribe, But When Will James Mangold Direct SWAMP THING?

Popular Headlines

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Rumored New Details About [SPOILER], [SPOILER], And [SPOILER]'s Roles Revealed

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Rob Liefeld Responds To Trailer's Shot At His Apparent Inability To Draw Feet

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE Rumored To Feature An Appearance From [SPOILER] As [SPOILER]

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: New Statues And Standee Offer Another Look At Wade Wilson And Logan's Costumes

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

WOLVERINE #50: Marvel Shares First Look At Benjamin Percy's Final Issue As Logan Celebrates 50th Anniversary

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

X-MEN Star Ray Park Responds To Rumors He'll Return As Toad In DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE

WOLVERINE #50: Marvel Shares First Look At Benjamin Percy's Final Issue As Logan Celebrates 50th Anniversary

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

X-MEN Star Ray Park Responds To Rumors He'll Return As Toad In DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE

Who Is [SPOILER]? Everything You Need To Know About X-MEN '97 Surprise New Villain

Does DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE's New Trailer Feature A Nod To 2002's SPIDER-MAN?

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

Hot Headlines

MAN OF STEEL Director Zack Snyder Says Superman Would Be "Fake" If He Hadn't Killed General Zod

Former X-MEN '97 Showrunner Beau DeMayo Says Show Will Address Mr. Sinister's Racism

SHE-HULK: ATTORNEY AT LAW Guest-Star Megan Thee Stallion Sued For Workplace Harassment

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Official Trailer Features Ultimate Team-Up & Promises The Wildest MCU Movie Of All-Time!

SUPERMAN: Nathan Fillion On Why He's Perfectly Suited To Play GREEN LANTERN Guy Gardner

Sci-Fi & Fantasy

STAR WARS: TALES OF THE EMPIRE Clip Sees General Grievous Attack Dathomir's Nightsisters

DUNE: PART TWO Honest Trailer Isn't Afraid To Point Out The Flaws In Denis Villeneuve's Sci-Fi Masterpiece

FURIOSA: A MAD MAX SAGA Has Been Rated R For "Strong Violence And Grisly Images"

APPLE TV+'s NEUROMANCER Casts Callum Turner As Series Lead Case

DUNE: PART TWO Director Denis Villeneuve Breaks Down The Sequel's Ending And Teases MESSIAH Plans - SPOILERS

Jennifer Lopez Battle An A.I. Simu Liu In New Trailer For Netflix's ATLAS

Cartoons & Animated Features

TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Director Zack Snyder Shares First Look At His Animated Norse Mythology Series

THE LITTLE MERMAID: New Live-Action Movie Rated R For "Violence & Nudity" - Check Out The Trailer

X-MEN '97 Showrunner Breaks Down Cameos, Easter Eggs And More In "Bright Eyes" - SPOILERS

X-MEN '97 Finally Reveals Its True Villain In "Bright Eyes" As We Get A Few Shocking Returns - SPOILERS

X-MEN '97: "Bright Eyes" Unleashes Rogue And Features TWO Huge Marvel Universe Cameos - SPOILERS

X-MEN '97: Rogue Is Out For Revenge In First Clip From Tomorrow's New Episode, "Bright Eyes"

Gaming

New DESTINY 2: THE FINAL SHAPE Trailer Takes Us Into The Pale Heart Of The Traveler

GTA 5 Voice Actor Reveals Plans For "Agent Trevor" DLC Before Rockstar Apparently Scrapped It

TALES OF THE SHIRE: A LORD OF THE RINGS GAME Official Announcement Trailer Released

FALLOUT Series Showrunners Strongly Hint Season 2 Will Take Us To An Iconic Location From The Games

Billie Eilish Headlines FORTNITE FESTIVAL Season 3

LaKeith Stanfield To Star In Film Based On EL PASO, ELSEWHERE Vampire Video Game

Anime & Manga

UniVersus Reveals New MY HERO ACADEMIA: GIRL POWER Set

New Trailer For GAROUDEN: THE WAY OF THE LONE WOLF Released Ahead Of Netflix Debut

Netflix's ONE PIECE Finds New Showrunner In PERCY JACKSON AND THE OLYMPIANS' Joe Tracz

DRAGON BALL SUPER Interval Special Announced By Jump While Manga Remains On Indefinite Hiatus

New Teaser And Key Art For Live-Action TRILLION GAME Movie

Netflix's PARASYTE: THE GREY Is Now Streaming; Here's What The Critics Are Saying

Horror

WEDNESDAY Season 2 Adds WESTWORLD Star Thandiwe Newton In Mysterious Role

BLINK TWICE: Channing Tatum Invites You To "Pussy Island" In First Trailer For Zoë Kravitz's Directorial Debut

THE WATCHERS New Trailer Sees Dakota Fanning Terrorised In Ishana Night Shyamalan's Directorial Debut

EVIL DEAD RISE Director Lee Cronin Shares Gruesome New BTS Photos To Mark Movie's One-Year Anniversary

Happy 4/20! Check Out The Red Band Trailer For New Stoner Horror Movie TRIM SEASON

ABIGAIL Spoilers: Find Out What Happens - And Who Shows Up - In New Horror Comedy

Action Movies & TV