Star Trek Review

Star Trek Review

Rorschach01's review of new JJ Abrams Star Trek movie...

Review Opinion
By MarkCassidy - May 07, 2009 05:05 PM EST
Filed Under: Star Trek

I have only ever been a casual Trek fan. I enjoyed the original show when i was a kid because of the dynamic between Kirk and Spock. I also enjoyed a few eps of the Next Generation and its many spin offs, but i also hated a few! The movies have been awful, decent and very good...In the case of Wrath Of Khan and First Contact excellent. But this new movie is really something special!

Its been hyped up so much that while i knew i would enjoy it, i was also afraid of leaving a bit disappointed..I didnt. It was better than i ever expected.

It begins with James T Kirks birth and his journey from angry young man to Starfleet cadet. This is contrasted with Spocks repressed childhood and his struggle to keep his emotions in check. But we all know where these 2 end up. I dont want to go into the plot too much because its very difficult not to give away spoilers if i do. But the crew of the Enterprise(for reasons i wont go into) find themselves in conflict with a vengeful Romulan called Nero (a brilliant Eric Bana) and Kirk and Spock must put their considerable differences aside and work with the fledgling crew to save Earth and come out in one piece.

The cast are pretty much perfect. I had issue with Chris Pine after seeing the trailers and thought him far too boyish looking and annoying but he actually makes a great Kirk once you see everything in context. (he is still just a tad annoying!). Zach "sylar" Quinto would have run away with the movie if it were not for Karl Urban as Dr Mcoy who screams for more screen time in the next movie. Zoe Saldanna is a sexy, assured Uhura. Jon Cho an ass kicking Sulu. My only problem cast wise was Anton Yelchin as Checkov. Hes not bad exactly but his accent is far too cartoonish and he really hasnt got that much to do. Simon Pegg suffers similarly with lack of screen time but is great comic relief when hes around.

The action scenes are awe inspiring. Space battles, sword fights, punch ups..theres never a dull moment. And even when it does slow the pace the cast ensure that the quieter moments of drama work just as well

All in all i cant recommend this enough, both to Trekkers(trekkies?) and even those of you who wouldnt be caught dead giving the Vulcan salute..see this movie, you wont be disappointed.

*****

Quentin Tarantino Finally Explains Why His R-Rated STAR TREK Movie Is Never Going To Happen
Related:

Quentin Tarantino Finally Explains Why His R-Rated STAR TREK Movie Is "Never Going To Happen"

STAR TREK: Colm Meaney On Possible Miles O'Brien Return And What He REALLY Thinks About Trekkies (Exclusive)
Recommended For You:

STAR TREK: Colm Meaney On Possible Miles O'Brien Return And What He REALLY Thinks About Trekkies (Exclusive)

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

DonkeyPuncher
DonkeyPuncher - 5/7/2009, 8:42 PM
sweet im going to see this movie for sure im not really a star trek fan and to be honest i had no intension to see this movie until i saw the trailer when i saw wolverine
Macksimus
Macksimus - 5/7/2009, 9:03 PM
Awesome review man; thanks for not including any spoilers.

I too am just a casual Trek fan, but I'm def going to go and see this flick.

Most of the reviews I've seen say that it was a great movie. So, I guess people are really enjoying it.

Spilox
Spilox - 5/8/2009, 12:51 AM
Dude, you are right on the spot. Bones ruled! Only had one minor detail that i didn't like. And that was that they skipped Kirks youth by 10 years. Would have liked to see a bit more of that. But that aside. A freaking great movie.
Did anyone else hear that strange ticking sound when spock was chocking kirk. I could have sworn i saw his finger go up :P
Shaman
Shaman - 5/8/2009, 1:13 PM
Well thanks for the great review buddy :)

I'd love to go see that eventually. I'll put it on the list!
Set2Fallfirst
Set2Fallfirst - 5/8/2009, 1:26 PM
I had a feeling i was gonna be really sick. Nice cant wait to go see it. haha Hey Ror when you went did you see anyone dress up? I am sure u did.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 5/8/2009, 1:55 PM
I like the cast especially SYLER as SPOCK!!! Sound like its gonna be a sweet movie!!! P.s Less talking, more fighting, yay!!! Yep im a STAR WARS fan! ; )
ironknight27
ironknight27 - 5/8/2009, 2:25 PM
Nice job Ror and like Macksimus said thank you for not using any spoilers.
shibazz
shibazz - 5/8/2009, 3:44 PM
Nicely done Ror-01 ol' buddy ol' pal! and great job on not giving away the movie. seeing it tongiht fo sho
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 5/8/2009, 3:48 PM
No probs guys, thanks for the feedback. I was gonna use spoilers and just warn people but naah, its too cool, gotta see for yourselves.

Lee this movie has done for Star Trek what the prequels SHOULD have done for Star Wars, as opposed to what they did do, which was actually turn off long time fans like myself! No Jar Jar bleedin Binks in this movie, and the cast can actually act, always a bonus!

Set2fall i actually didnt see anybody dressed up! One girl had Spock ears on and thats it, i was very disappointed:(
ironknight27
ironknight27 - 5/8/2009, 4:42 PM
Damn no girls painted up in green? Thats a disappointing.
adamant877
adamant877 - 5/8/2009, 5:42 PM
Thanks for the review, Ror! I'm especially grateful that you decided not to include any spoiler info, as I would have most likely read it, and then regretted it later. lol
Top notch, mate!
THEHAWK
THEHAWK - 5/8/2009, 6:49 PM
i never got into Star Trek, but if you say Bana is good, I'm in.
SPIDEY1985
SPIDEY1985 - 5/8/2009, 6:56 PM
hmmm.. I was actually on the fence about seeing this but I'll take your word for it and see it tomorrow.. Thanks
spideysweb
spideysweb - 5/8/2009, 7:05 PM
Nice review Ror. I just saw this today at 4:20pm and must say I loved it. By far the best Trek movie to date.
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 5/8/2009, 7:45 PM
Shit, i hope i didnt hype it up too much, theres a lot of people taking a chance on this now! Please keep in mind that although im not a Trekky, im a huge sci fi fan, so if your not you may not enjoy it as much as i did...

spideysweb i thought it was the 2nd best! It actually didnt surpass Khan for me, but thats prob because of the memories i have of seeing it as a kid and just balling my eyes out at the end! Technically it is a better movie, but nothing tops that scene with Kirk and Spock at the end of Khan
alcinde4
alcinde4 - 5/8/2009, 8:59 PM
Great review. I've never been a Star Trek fan, but I'll definitely be going to see this one.
Aiiwolf
Aiiwolf - 5/8/2009, 10:48 PM
THIS MOVIE GOT A 96% POSITIVE REVIEW RATIO WORLDWIDE. OF course this movie was good, and totally agree with the stuff you said in your review. I like Chris Pine, I felt that way too, when I first saw the trailers...but than I started thinkingm about SEQUELS for the new franchise of a DYING FRANCHISE. Dont they need YOUNG PEOPLE so they can AGE through-out the REBORN series?

Exactly. UNlike Wolverine Origins. THIS MOVIE IS WORTH TWO TRIPS if not more to the IMAX or your REGULAR THEATRES.
glenngwoz
glenngwoz - 5/9/2009, 1:39 AM
This movie kicked the everlovin crap out of star wars, and that's practically blasphemy for me to say. Go see it.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 5/9/2009, 5:34 AM
Cool RORSCH@ I know what you mean about the prequels of STAR WARS! Though SITH was good but ohhhh man DARTH VADER going= NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Still haunts me lol! Cool, gotta watch TREK then, its bout time we got good prequels!!! I gotta admit the cast looks fantastic! ; )
Spock
Spock - 5/9/2009, 7:46 AM
YOu didn't hype it up to much, but I left felling something was missing, I did like the film, but it was different even thou for a Prequel.

ironknight27 there is 1 Orion girl!!!
Spock
Spock - 5/9/2009, 9:56 AM
This want I've been saying all along lets get passed the old stuff & move forward. Same goes for Star Wars.
Thou Iam still a Trekkie... Over all I did like the movie.

Here we go, "Some reviews I have read imply that this was the only way to breath new life into a dead franchise. I couldn't disagree more. Trek fans who have read novels by Peter David or Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens can tell you that there are WAY better storylines out there and if Hollywood wanted to truly make good Trek movies they would hire better talent to write the scripts. Why not make a new ship with a new crew, set after Star Trek: Nemesis? Why go back to square one when so many more possibilities are available AFTER Nemesis? I'll tell you why. Because the names Kirk, Spock, McCoy, and Enterprise fills theater seats thanks to work done years ago by GOOD writers, directors, and actors that Hollywood is unable reproduce because they are more interested in selling recycled garbage." From No Substance
by lyonnryu On Yahoo

MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 5/9/2009, 10:03 AM
haha, yeah lee that Frankenstein walk that vader did made me cringe so much my face almost imploded! Lucas is a nob.

spock i kinda know what you mean, it may actually have been too action orientated, the other Trek movies were a bit more thoughtful. And i think there were too many attempts at humor, i mean have one comic relief character..or even two, but does every single member of the crew have to try their hand at being a comedian! lol, i guess i should have put all that in the review but i was just so blown away by it i only thought about the negative aspects a few days later.
TheGambitFreak
TheGambitFreak - 5/9/2009, 12:27 PM
as much as i want to kick star treks butt right now i have to say it was a better film than wolverine stupid 20th century fox you suck!
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 5/9/2009, 2:15 PM
gambitfreak @ I wish i could say i know what you mean, but i havn't seen TREK yet, looking forward to it! ; )

I know this isn't a TREK question, but has anyone heard anything of the Episodes 7 8 & 9 of STAR WARS??? Is it ever going to be made?? I keep hearing its on, its off, its on, its off lol?!? Damn you LUCAS lol! I'd love to see Luke as the aging Jedi an some of the original cast back!!! The prequels did nothing for me really at all! Too much CGI!!!

An another question,,, who liked CGI'd Clone Troopers??? What was wrong with just men in armor like Stormtroopers in original STAR WARS??? Alot of it looked too fake, or was it just me? : D

shibazz
shibazz - 5/9/2009, 5:21 PM
GawlDarnnit if you fella's anit right! That ol' Frankenstein walk was just, well it ws just too much to take. Damn good movie though, iffin yer askin me, which'ya might'n be, though yer probally not. Anyhoo you would think that Annikin ala Vader would use the Darkside and light that room up as him levitates er sumthing! Dang, what was they thinkin up in that there editin room, or what not? (scratches head) Guess i'll never know.
TucsonRican
TucsonRican - 5/9/2009, 7:46 PM
Me and the Mrs. paid to see this movie last night and then snuck in to Wolverine.....

I'm glad I paid for this movie.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 5/10/2009, 6:13 AM
LMFAO both of ya!!! : D
Phinehas
Phinehas - 5/10/2009, 9:17 AM
It was a fun romp, but not as good as I had anticipated. The deviations from TOS didn't ruin it for me the way it would for a Trekkie (Trekker? The debate continues I guess...), but I found that they were harmful in some ways. I think the way Nimoy's Spock struggled with emotion versus Quinto's was much more subtle. This provided a little more mystique that was lacking (IMO) in this interpretation. Kirk got his butt whooped too much. In fact, I don't think there was a fistacuff fight that he won in this. And Bana was the biggest disappointment. Too cliched. I know he's better than what he gave. I like villians that steal the show! The deliveries were great by everyone else! I would even say flawless, save Bana. I could tolerate this new direction, but I think some of the elements that they altered were what gave the original it's charm.

Oh well, I know I'm in the minority here judging by the other posts. So I'm gonna get grief for my critique. But I think my points are valid and I will stand by them unless I can be proven that they are not.
Talontd
Talontd - 5/10/2009, 4:36 PM
ROR-

Thanx man! I didn't wanna read any reviews until after I saw the movie, but i know you've seen a ton of films as well and i value your opinion.

I only read those last two mini paragraphs cuz i didn't wanna spoil it 20min before I leave for the IMAX! but you have me much more pumped than before!!!

View Recorder