James Bond Used to Be Fun. Can Robert Pattinson Bring That Back?
When Robert Pattinson was announced as the next James Bond, it got me thinking about something that's bothered me for years.
When did James Bond stop being fun?
Sean Connery is still my favorite Bond, followed by Pierce Brosnan and Roger Moore. Three different interpretations, but they shared something I think the Daniel Craig era moved away from.
Bond was effortlessly cool. And he seemed to enjoy being Bond.
One of my favorite scenes from Goldfinger isn't a car chase, a gunfight, or an elaborate escape. It's a conversation with Moneypenny.
They're flirting, trading lines about marriage and dinner, and generally having a wonderful time until M interrupts over the intercom to remind Bond he has a job to do.
It's a small scene, but it captures so much of what made those movies entertaining.
Bond is charming without trying. Moneypenny gives as good as she gets. Neither actor treats the scene as a comedy routine. They're playing their characters completely straight, and that's what makes it work.
That's the Bond I miss.
I don't need Bond to be invincible. I want to root for him to be. Give me the clever dialogue, ridiculous gadgets, exotic locations, and villains with absurdly ambitious plans. Let him get into impossible situations and somehow find his way out.
And I want Bond to enjoy it.
It's the same appeal I find in Neal Caffrey from White Collar, Clooney and Pitt in the Ocean's movies, or Alan Ritchson's Reacher. Very different characters, but watching someone who's exceptionally good at what they do is part of the fun. They have confidence, even when things aren't going their way.
I'm not suggesting Daniel Craig was a bad Bond. I like Craig as an actor, particularly in Glass Onion and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. And Casino Royale was my favorite of his Bond movies, even if the absurd poker hands and Felix Leiter conveniently financing Bond's return to the table drove the poker player in me crazy.
But even Casino Royale was taking Bond in a direction I wasn't particularly enthusiastic about.
He became more grounded, vulnerable, and psychologically complicated. There were still funny moments, including some excellent exchanges with Vesper, but humor felt like a break from the seriousness rather than part of the movie's personality.
I enjoyed Skyfall and admired the filmmaking in Spectre. But the series became more interested in examining the emotional cost of being James Bond than in letting us enjoy watching him be James Bond.
I understand the appeal of that approach. There's an interesting character study to be made about a man who lives that kind of life.
I don't need that to be the whole franchise.
Sometimes I want to watch Bond pick up chicks and kick ass.
And I don't think that requires returning to every attitude from the 1960s. In fact, putting the traditional Bond, with his charm and arrogance, opposite intelligent, confident modern women could be a lot of fun. The Moneypenny scene works because she's playing the game right along with him. Why not give Bond more women who can match him, or even beat him, at his own game?
Which brings me back to Pattinson.
I was surprised by the casting, mostly because I hadn't given him much thought as Bond. I haven't seen The Batman, although I know he's working on the sequel. My impression comes largely from Tenet, where his character Neil is intelligent, charming, mysterious, and seemingly comfortable in the middle of chaos.
That sounds like a pretty good starting point for James Bond.
Pattinson has also worked with director Denis Villeneuve on Dune: Part Three, so there's already some familiarity between the two. And producers Amy Pascal and David Heyman specifically praised his self-deprecating wit in the casting announcement.
Of course they did. They cast him. But I hope that wit is part of what they intend to bring to Bond.
Steven Knight, the creator of Peaky Blinders, is writing the screenplay. I haven't watched the series, but I've seen enough clips to appreciate the way his characters can command a room without needing to announce their presence. That kind of cool confidence could work beautifully for Bond.
Still, Peaky Blinders isn't exactly known for lighthearted entertainment.
And then there's Villeneuve.
He's an extraordinary filmmaker. Dune, Arrival, and Blade Runner 2049 are impressive achievements. He knows how to create tension, spectacle, and genuine stakes.
But when was the last time you left a Villeneuve movie laughing?
That's what worries me about this new Bond. Pattinson can be charming, Knight can write a commanding character, and Villeneuve can make the whole thing look spectacular. But none of that guarantees a movie that's actually fun to watch.
Bond lives in a world of outrageous villains, impossible gadgets, and beautiful people doing ridiculous things. The actors don't need to acknowledge the absurdity. In fact, the whole thing works better when they don't.
The danger should be real. The stakes should matter. Let everyone take their characters seriously.
But let the movie have a sense of humor.
After all, The World Is Not Enough ended with Pierce Brosnan delivering the line, "I thought Christmas only comes once a year."
It's a terrible joke.
I laughed anyway.
And I'd like to do that again.