I know this is a little late but lets see what the fans say now that both have played the green lantern. Now this will be based on looks and how they played the character outside of the hybrid, think of him as a combo of there acting
First is Ryan Reynolds
This is Ryans first real comicbook role as a lead, he played the green lantern with a little bit of a comedic sense but he did have some seriousness to the character near the end of the film
Next is Nathan Fillion
Nathan Played the role as a completly serious character with no comedic sense whatsoever but some fans like that.
And finally the hybrid (p.s tell me how the hybrid looks in the comments)
Now think of more of a serios hal jordan only sprouting a joke once and a while but only joking when the fight seems easy and not when fighting someone like parralax or sinestro
alright leave your votes in the poll and in the comments alright thanks