Jim Starlin Sits Down to Discuss Comic Book Movie World Building

Jim Starlin Sits Down to Discuss Comic Book Movie World Building

I sat down with Jim Starlin to discuss his views of comic books, universe building for movies, and the duty of writers and corporations owe the fans.

By JosephOveraitis - Nov 21, 2026 11:11 PM EST
Filed Under: Marvel Studios

Send in the Experts

In law school I was taught that in order to win cases your evidence matters. Judges apply the laws but the jury is swayed by facts and testimony. Trial attorneys use expert witnesses to take what was introduced as evidence at trial and try to persuade the jury to view it in the light most favorable to your argument. A great expert is very useful when trying to determine how the evidence shall be interpreted, but first they must be qualified as an expert. This requires them to be deemed to be an authority on the topic they wish to serve as an expert. Very few meet that criteria because the standard to achieve that status is quite high.  Still, the use of an expert is essential in most cases. 

You have no Idea Counselor

Many times, journalists are accused of exceeding their level of expertise. In order to be able to write about actors I actually put myself in their shoes in by working as an actor and member of precision drive teams for both television and major film projects. What looks easy on the screen is rather difficult in real life. I have also written stories on various pop culture topics but never have I been allowed to use someone else’s intellectual property to create a story, much less a universe. That level of analysis is above this journalist’s pay grade so I did what any good play by play guy requests when working on a project…I sought out a good analyst to make me look better. If you are writing about building a universe who is more qualified  to talk to then someone who set the groundwork for what was used to create some  corners of the MCU.

Motor City Cruising

Many of the concepts and plotlines in the MCU can be traced back to ideas that sprung from the mind of Jim Starlin. He created Thanos, Drax the Destroyer, Gamora, Starfox and many others and combined them with other mainstay characters in his cosmic tales. Kevin Feige and rest of the MCU creative team thought Starlin was so important to the legacy of those characters that it garnered him a cameo in Avengers: Endgame. Besides his writing and artist work in comics he also has become a publisher that owns his own line of comic characters.  That means he comprehends how the corporate side and value of his characters are impacted by the artistic actions. Who better then to provide in depth analyst of how we, the pop culture fandom jury, should view the actions of James Gunn, Zack Snyder, Kevin Feige, and any other person in charge of a creating a universe and their obligation to stewarding the comic characters.

Jing Starlin and Jim Starlin at Motor City Comic Con 2026

 (Photo Joseph Overaitis)

Back to the Captain

I was granted the honor of being able to sit down with Jim Starlin at Motor City Comic Con(“MC3”) in a one-on-one interview.  Jim is always a great interview who provides insight into the world of pop culture.  Years ago, after conducting an in-depth interview with Adam Scherr, aka WWE’s Braun Strowman, the wrestler mentioned a line in the movie from Thanos as his inspiration to do good in life to this journalist. A follow up side interview with Jim Starlin revealed his surprise at Strowman’s take because in his eyes Thanos was only bad, but he loved conversing on how comics could impact real world situations.   As a result, when needed to judge real world ramifications of character development and universe building from comics, we called on Jim Starlin.  This is the man who let fans decide the fate of one DC character; killed a hero he built up not in battle but from a real life disease; created an Asian character to be more than a mere stereotype; stood up for artist’s rights, and then established a company where he was the owner of his own characters. He has done it all!


In His Own Words

On how artists, writers, and directors should treat characters they utilize

“Well, the main rule should be if you’re gonna play with the character you got to put it back in the box unbroken. I’ve been on all different sides of this and my normal rule is if somebody is taken over character I have written like Thanos… I haven’t read any of the new stuff at all because I do not want my sphincter to get tight.  I’ve been on the other side where I’m taking somebody’s character like Robin and did things with it and this particular case killed him but it was not the Bob Kane Robin and he came long later and he was not popular and the publishers asked me to do it, so I felt breaking that one before putting it back in the box was ok.”

Views on other artists and writers following his work and what he does in that situation

“Marvel gave Warlock to somebody else to write and in the first 3 pages it was mocking the Warlock I created in the 70s which I thought was kind of a cheap shot but it is their property and they get to do what they want…Basically if it’s going to be something like Captain Marvel, I try to enhance it and make it more interesting…”

Views on Characters and Stories

“Certain characters you do not have to do that with, you just have to do a good story like with DC Presents, Superman didn’t need any improvement…Just do a good story and try to be faithful to what he is and same with Batman and make a different story that was not seen before and respect what you got.”

On how companies need to be concerned about their characters

“That is a tricky one. I tried to get a tv series going with Dreadstar a number of times and it goes into the hands of the producer and then a show runner is brought in and it is at the mercy of the show runner. We had one unsuccessful attempt at getting the show going because the show runner basically turned it into the Guardians of the Galaxy…. Unfortunately, no one wanted to buy it. Once it becomes something other than a comic book you sort of are at the mercy of whoever is working on it…. You have to have a good idea what is going on and in this particular case I didn’t set my foot down hard enough.”

Would You Rather Turn Down Profits than Allow Dreadstar be portrayed poorly

“Yes.” (he stated that emphatically)

A Toy Story

Attorneys know every word used in a court’s opinion or statute is important. “Shall” and “may” have different degrees of power. Starlin is an accomplished writer and he too chose all his words with great care.  He compared a writer, artist, or director using characters as if they were toys.  Toys are meant to be used and even though it may have caused him angst, he understood that the company could allow others to play with those same toys and that this could mean his input was no longer recognizable. The issue for Starlin was if writers treat it poorly the character loses it’s value for those that want to play with them later. These subsequent writers could use the characters too but they should not selfishly break them to fit their own narrative goals.  In this way it made me realize that these characters could not be looked on as just toys by Gunn, Snyder, Feige and others when they were in charge of a universe.  These “toys” were to be shared with comic book writers, cartoonists, tv and movie producers/directors, poster companies, and many more. If a character is broken by a director, then that character is damaged so that a comic book artist, writer and a toy manufacturer may not be able to use them anymore. Universe builders are thus more than artists; they are gatekeepers for a business’ assets as well because  everyone wants to play in the sandbox with those valuable toys. 

Kids in the Sandbox

Jim’s tale about protecting Dreadstar was interesting because one would think as a business owner with a viable intellectual property he would want to make money than let a character sit in the box in mint condition.  Jim said he would rather turn down bad projects and poor fits for his creations than risk damaging them.  He thought of this not from an artist but as a businessman.  He understands in the future someone else will be required to carry on the legacy of his characters but one poor choice could ruin that potential. Media divisions may be a small segment when it comes to earning profits for corporations.  Corporations also need apparel, gaming, houseware, toy, comic writers and other businesses that may have licensed those characters to bring in the major revenue. They all have vested interests in those characters not being broken. Not many fans would want to wear a shirt of a character that is a racist or dress their daughter in an outfit featuring a murderer. Companies have many people who are dependent on those characters and if they are broken, they might be so damaged as to never be able to be pulled from the box and be used again. This will not only damage the toys but put crap in the sandbox so no one wants to play or watch people play in it. Starlin understood both artistic goals and corporation's need for profits and how the person in charge had to balance both to maximize the value of his characters. This vision should be the goal of world builders, but some may be willing to sacrifice one for the other.  That  could have unintended consequences for many interesed parties. 

Play Nice with Others

Gunn may be able to overcome his firing from the DCU.  Others who were playing with those same toys may not be so lucky. A small vendor in the USA who spent their  last dime  purchasing a license to manufacture Hal Jordan shirts may not have had prior knowledge of how Gunn planned on using that character.  At Motor City Comic Con Stylin Onlinemanager Jeff Bennett indicated that fans were interested in the Green Lantern merchandise, but hardly any wanted the Hal Jordan branded items. I guess most parents did not want their children appear to identify with a proposed racist at school. These items then could sit on the shelves.  The store still supports DC Comics but inventory that is not easily sellable probably hurts their bottom line. Vendors with toys and household goods also seen their items sit on the shelf. Production assistants, craft services workers, and grips all could face hardships caused because of one's artistic views.  World builders cannot afford to make that mistake. 

Readers Demand the Truth

In many columns that appear on the Internet the success of these comic book universes is reduced to critical success and return on investment. When things go wrong people want to know who to blame.  At the Motor City Comic Con almost half of the 30 people surveyed supported James Gunn’s universe and blamed Skydance from killing it before it could fully be fleshed out while a little more than half said he had enough time and that Skydance was only protecting their assets.  After talking with Jim Starlin this journalist believes the answer lies somewhere in the middle. James Gunn is an artist who really did not want to deal with the corporate side of the movie division because he only wanted to be the artist.  Universe builders have to be so much more than artists because so many people’s financial success rides on these films and television shows. Skydance had to step in and stop Gunn from breaking their toys if that is what they were seeing. No one ever cheers the plight of mega corporations. Unfortunately, their job is difficult because they have to see the micro and macro impacts of their universe building artists. The most difficult decision is when companies should take their toys away from these artists.  Too soon and they may miss out on real money makers while too late the brand is broken beyond repair. The owners of these properties must also be worried that they dilute and confuse the audience so no one cares anymore and just goes home. Even the hottest toy could end up not broken but still unwanted by the target group that once clamored for it. 

Broken Toys and Abandoned Sandboxes

  What Kevin Feige has achieved truly remarkable. His MCU has made money for the company and licensees, but it also has produced quality products  that have achieved critical success for the most part. He is the gold standard that all other universe builders should hope to replicate. They can tell their own stories but remember that they are only playing with those toys a short time. Soon they will be returned back into the box so that others can play with them in the future. The comic book industry has lasted for years playing with those toys, so too must Disney’s and Skydance’s film divisions for the good of their bottom lines and for the satisfaction of the fans.

Thanks and More

I want to thank Jing Starlin and Jim Starlin for the time they gave for this interview.  JIng Starlin was patient and a great part of the interview process. In addition, Jim always provides great takes and insights on topics that go beyond quick quotes. Much more was discussed on different topics and I plan on those subjects appearing in future articles. I also wish to thank the staff of Motor City Comic Con  for both this interview and others with celebrities that will appear in future articles. Finally I want to thank Dawn Kelley, Katrina Luts and the rest of the team at Expand Marketing Group. They always provide this journalist unique  access to celebrities that give the fans insights that they may not have been able to get on their own.  You deserve the best and that is what I plan for readers in the future. 

About The Author:
JosephOveraitis
Member Since 10/6/2026
I have served as an attorney who has handled comic book collection cases worth up to a half million dollars and as a buyers agent for collectors of pop culture items in the state of Michigan. I have also interviewed tv and movie actors for GoCollect.

In my spare time I have been a background actor and member of the precision driver team in feature films and television shows. Best advice I got from Zack Snyder and the stunt coordinator was don't stand to close to the fire and do not trip Affeck. My list of interview subjects have included actors, actresses, WWE superstars and HOFers.
UPDATE: Man Of Tomorrow Rumored Footage Description Reveals New Supergirl Suit, Injured Superman, And More
Related:

UPDATE: Man Of Tomorrow Rumored Footage Description Reveals New Supergirl Suit, Injured Superman, And More

Former DC Studios Co-CEO James Gunn Makes Big Change To His Social Media Presence
Recommended For You:

Former DC Studios Co-CEO James Gunn Makes Big Change To His Social Media Presence

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Be the first to comment and get the conversation going!

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder