Anil Rickly's GREEN ARROW short-film Review

Anil Rickly's GREEN ARROW short-film Review

...Will Oliver Queen be able to withstand some of his biggest rivals to save the life of a young girl...or will he fall before he fulfills his true potential?...

Review Opinion
By earzmundo - Nov 09, 2010 12:11 PM EST
Filed Under: Animated Features

DC Showcase - Green Arrow



Background -
With Andy Diggle and Jock's 'Green Arrow: Year One' proving to be the most recently updated origins story of this hero, a thrill-seeker Oliver Queen, whose attack and subsequent victory over drug smugglers off the American coast, led to him donning the hood of the Green Archer, the build on the foundation of the likes of Judd Winick, Neal Adams, Dennis O'Neil, Kevin Smith, Parks, Mester, Brad Meltzer, as well as Mort Weisinger and George Papp, has seen this emerald archer rise to a prominent role in DCU's comic lore. He has been key in 'Cry for Justice', 'Blackest Night', 'Brightest Day' etc and has recently been in the spotlight for his vigilante actions in murdering the villain Prometheus.



His elevated popularity since DC revamped him, has seen him as a major player in the JLA, alongside his significant other, Dinah Lance aka 'Black Canary'.
His rogues include longtime archer and fiend, and a fierce rival in Merlyn, whose battles with Ollie are the stuff of archer legend in DCU. Not withstanding his prominence in DC's Justice League Unlimited and Batman cartoons, another rogue 'Count Vertigo' has been a hugely bitter rival of Queen. These 2 enemies are focused upon in this short which simply consists of a rendezvous with some blood-seeking thugs, and a fight which Ollie will struggle to overcome...as Vertigo and Merlyn both come a-knocking!




Feature -

Neal McDonough nails his role as Ollie with Malcolm McDowell proving to be a hit as usual as Merlyn. Steve Blum does well as Vertigo, with Grey DeLisle as Canary, and Ariel Winter as Princess Perdita, holding their own also. John DiMaggio gets a nod as a thug and that was pleasing as well.
As DC continues with their great voice castings, what wins here is the ever-evolving action sequences that DC showcases. Green Arrow's struggle to overcome thugs wielding guns and fists of fury, as well as his battles with his main villains, do well to depict that he is simply human...running around with a bow and arrow. His struggle to overcome the human thugs make this special. The fight scenes and chases make up for the prevalently cheesy dialogue...Ollie's quips do remind us of the modern wise-cracking Arrow, but stray along the lines of an annoying Spider-Man at times. This battle was too fierce and could have done with less quippy moments.

That said, the villains do well to hold Arrow out, and with an exciting array of fists and arrows, the Vertigo appearance and ensuing Deus ex Machina from a certain DC beauty, plays off well...despite being boldly predictable. This short, runs for 12 mins, and is ideally something that I swore came out a single issue of a Green Arrow comic...and as a Marvel comics freak, as well as DC lover...I don't find that a bad thing...not at all...
Overall, it could be longer and DCU could have done a full-hour length feature and give us more into Green Arrow. I don't know if they plan on a movie with him in the near future, but Green Arrow, as well as Flash and Aquaman deserve full lengths! Till then I'll be getting my fill of them in 'Brightest Day'...
and as a personal note, 'SUPERMAX' by David Goyer is something better left for comics and not for cinemas (much like his Blade 3 work!)...

That said and done...
El rating de Rickly = 7.5/10
Too short, much cheesiness...but cool as hell with the action!
New Trailers And Posters Released For DreamWorks Animation's THE BAD GUYS 2 And Pixar's ELIO
Related:

New Trailers And Posters Released For DreamWorks Animation's THE BAD GUYS 2 And Pixar's ELIO

New HOW TO TRAIN YOUR DRAGON Featurette Reveals First Look At Live-Action Astrid, Snotlout, And Fishlegs
Recommended For You:

New HOW TO TRAIN YOUR DRAGON Featurette Reveals First Look At Live-Action Astrid, Snotlout, And Fishlegs

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

lc
lc - 11/9/2010, 1:15 PM
green arrow will beat the hole lot
imo.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 11/9/2010, 6:00 PM
You an GREEN ARROW lol! ; P


Nice one @ ANIL... gonna be watching this tonight, haven't had the chance yet, thumbs up buddy!
Jimdlux
Jimdlux - 11/25/2010, 8:44 AM
Ok...I have never been a Green Arrow fan. The character in Smallville and the animated Justice League just made it worse. I always thought of him as a wanna be Batman...and I don't like Batman either. I just watched the short on Shazam & Superman BluRay. Ok...That Green Arrow I like! I'm officially a fan of any animated Arrow movie!
vermillion
vermillion - 11/28/2010, 7:13 PM
I think all the shorts have been amazing. I thought the action in this one was definitely the best. Green Arrow's hand to hand combat was excellent! Green Arrow is my favorite CB character.

Green Arrow: Year One should be the plotline if they ever decide to make a movie. If they ever do a sequel, they could use the Super-Max script. They could make GA film a little less comic-book-filmy in some areas and it'd work great.

-I love Smallville's take on GA. I think Justin Hartley has done a great job as Ollie. :D
View Recorder