Due to my becoming tired of seeing the same faces in every fancast(seriously, Fassbender, Olivia Wilde and Zoe Saldana can't be in everything) I have decided to do my best to create a cast featuring actors and actresses with no ties to any prior comic book movies as well as people who had starring roles in television based superhero series. Also, to make this more interesting, no one with direct ties to Nolan or Whedon will be put into my cast.
If this is well received I will move forward with my idea to cast people under the same criteria in other casts as they come to me.
For the most part I am not looking for superstars for the parts. I want anonymity to a degree so that you become submersed in the movie, not who is in it. i feel background and secondary characters can be filled with bigger stars.
Superman
Kellan Lutz
You can hate on this dude for his involvement in the Twilight movies, but you can't disregard that the dude has the physical makeup to easily don the suit. He is a fairly decent actor that can play the role of a leader like Superman
BATMAN
Jake Gyllenhaal
Love or hate this guy, he is due for a comic role. He is one of the few actors of appropriate age that has the good looks to be the billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne and also the physicality to be a great Batman. He is a good actor that can play charming and sophisticated and then flip and be tough and focused and kick ass.
Wonder Woman
Meghan Ory
Dark hair, blue eyes, good height and beautiful. The fan favorite seems to be Gina Carano with good reason. She has the look, but lacks the acting chops. Ory on the other hand has the acting ability, and the look, but just needs a little work with a trainer to tone up and look the part of a fighter and be more than just a pretty face.
Green Lantern(Hal Jordan)
Mike Vogel
Good looking guy who has been among finalists for the parts of Captain Kirk, Captain America, and Angel in X-Men Last Stand. He is a good actor who can play Hal Jordan with ease. Can do sarcasm, can do serious and be a great person for the part
Aquaman
Charlie Hunnam
Great actor who is soon to become a household name with the release of Del Toro's Pacific Rim this year. He has been a favorite to play Green Arrow, but i believe he has the ability and presence to take Aquaman from overlooked member of the Justice League and the joke of the team to a focal point and make the character hugely relevant to the masses.