Unlike the robin's Dick Grayson and TIm Drake, the Robin known as Jason Todd, is impulsive, reckless, and full of rage. Even on missions in which Batman orders him to conduct surveillance, Jason attacks, ruining months of planning. In one adventure, asked to "hold off" villains, Jason instantly takes to firing at them with a gun, despite Batman's abhorrence for firearms. For the murder of his father, Jason also attempts to choke Two-Face to death in one story. Todd is of the belief that lethal force is acceptable when dealing with criminals. Another adventure implies that Jason actually allows (or causes) the death of a rapist who evades criminal charges due to his father's status as a diplomat. What really happened is never revealed, though Jason later denies any wrong doing, claiming that the man fell off a roof rather than having been pushed.
Jason finally met his end at the hands of the Joker, but surprisingly returns as the Red Hood later on to haunt his old mentor.
Bucky Barnes was the side kick and friend to Captain America, Steve Rogers.
He fought with him through many battles of WW2, and ultimatly gave his life to to stop bomb exploding in a plane, or so it is thought.
Years later, eneral Vasily Karpov and the crew of a Russian patrol submarine find Bucky's cold-preserved body (minus an arm). Bucky is revived in Moscow, though, as a result of the explosion, he suffers brain damage with amnesia. Scientists attach a bionic arm.
Programmed to be a Soviet assassin under the code name the Winter Soldier, he is sent on covert wetworks missions, becoming increasingly ruthless and efficient as he kills in the name of the state. While a Soviet agent, he also has a brief relationship with The Black Widow. The Winter Soldier is kept in stasis when not on missions, and as a result has aged only a few years since the closing days of World War II.
Both are rogue, and both have learned from the BEST.
Scenario:
Red Hood is on the trail of agents belonging to the orginization of HYDRA who have abducted Crime Family princess Talia Al Ghul. There is a Leak in the League of Shadows(Which is how she was captured) so knowing Todd's affection for Talia, Rhas Al Ghul inlists the services of vigalante/Assassin the RED HOOD.
Meanwhile the Soviet government has assigned Buckey Barnes as a liaison between themselves Hydra to see to the capture and hiding aways of Taila Al Ghul, the end result is to exchange her for the lazerous pits which her father possess.
Winter Soldier and Red Hood learn of each other and now are going head to head in witt and in strength.
Who will victor?