Rose McGowan as Red Sonja yes or no?

Well if that's how you feel SaintC, please kidnapp her and chain her in your parent's basement!!! I hate her with a passion, she's so ugly she's not even handsome and has no talent what so ever as an actress and the only reason we see her everywhere is because she's screwing her way around the business! Sic her boy, SIC HER!!!

Dude you have to stop boosin'up like that, your judgement gets so clouded that even the shadow himself can't make heads or tails of it!!!

i think rose is a great actress ive seen alot of things she in and i think she is a great choice for red sonja body wise she working out heaps of hours a day for the role and with her hight they can us movie magic to cover that up with camera angles

if you do think she could play the role you should wactch her in Planet Terror i think after seeing that you will agree shes a good actress she got great reviews from that

yes she did she got great reviews from that film


Critics on Rose McGowan's Performance

From Richard Roeper, Ebert & Roeper
"In the performance of her life, McGowan throws herself into the juicy, sexy, funny, comic book hero role of Cherry Darling."

From Paul Travers, Rolling Stone
"McGowan is dynamite as Cherry Darling."

From Mick LaSelle, San Fransico Chronicle
"And, of course, there's the go-go dancer with a dream - played by Rose McGowan, in the best showcase of her career so far."

From Tim Goernert, JoBlo
"In Planet Terror Rose McGowan, who plays Cherry, was ridiculously hot and spectacular in the opening credits! CRACK-BOOM! For a chick who has a machine gun for a leg, she re-defines what a hot badass woman is! Move over Sarah Connor and Ripley 'cause Cherry is the new action girl on the scene!"

From The Arrow, Arrow in the Head
"The incredible cast in this madhouse thankfully ran with that sweet joo-joo all the way! Rose McGowan was all around class, sass, confidence and sexiness! Cherry was a fantastic character and McGowan wrangled it effortlessly! Think Ripley from Alien but hotter than hell and sporting a dangerous yet arousing attitude! I'd kill to see Cherry in her own movie! KILLL!"

From The Arrow, Arrow in the Head
"Rose McGowan (Cherry) exuded powerful confidence, charm and sensuality. She led Planet Terror like the acting trooper that she is. Impressive performance!"

what do you mean are you gainst comic movie or just this one? but they made conan movie desent and with robert in it i feel itwill be just as great as planet terror i just hope it will get a bigger box office hpefully theyll cast more big names along with her because electra failed in box office not that there the same thing i think red sonja will be better then that

i love rose, she is a great actress most of the time....not in the 5th season of charmed though!but she looks like red sonja and she is soooooooooooo sexy