Here's some more detailed scores for Roger Ebert's Comic Book Movie past - some surprises throughout - I suggest you check it out.
I know that I’m missing a few – maybe even some blatant ones. But there are just so many Comic Book Movies out there I couldn’t get em all off the top of my head. Feel free to find any I missed and post em.
Thanks everyone.
Some interesting notes –
- Ebert’s disdain for the old Batman movies.
- His props for The Phantom – WTF?
- Liking Ang Lee’s Hulk more
- Low score for X-Men 1
- High score for Spawn
300 – 2 Stars
30 Days of Night - 2.5 Stars
American Splendor - 4 Stars
Barb Wire - 2.5 Stars
Batman – 2 Stars
Batman Returns – 2 Stars
Batman Forever – 3 Stars
Batman & Robin – 2 Stars
Batman Begins – 4 Stars
The Dark Knight – 4 Stars
Blade – 3 Stars
Blade II – 3.5 Stars
Blade III – 1.5 Stars
Catwoman – 1 Star
Constantine – 1.5 Stars
The Crow - 3.5 Stars
Daredevil – 3 Stars
Dick Tracy - 4 Stars
Elektra – 1.5 Stars
Fantastic Four – 1 Star
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer – Not reviewed
Ghost Rider – Not reviewed
Ghost World – 4 Stars
GI Joe: Rise of Cobra - 1.5 Stars
Hellboy – 3.5 Stars
Hellboy II – 3.5 Stars
A History of Violence – 3.5 Stars
Hulk – 3 Stars
The Incredible Hulk – 2.5 Stars
Iron Man – 4 Stars
Judge Dredd - 2 Stars
KickAss - 1 Star
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen – 1 Star
The Mask - 3 Stars
Men in Black - 3 Stars
Men in Black II - 1.5 Stars
The Phantom – 3.5 Stars
The Punisher (2004) – 2 Stars
The Punisher: Warzone – 2 Stars
Road to Perdition – 3 Stars
Sin City - 4 Stars
Spawn – 3.5 Stars
The Spirit – 1 Star
Spiderman – 2.5 Stars
Spiderman II – 4 Stars
Spiderman III – 2 Stars
Steel – Not reviewed
Superman – 4 Stars
Superman II – 4 Stars
Superman III – 2.5 Stars
Superman Returns – 2 Stars
Surrogates - 2.5 Stars
Tank Girl - 2 Stars
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – 2.5 Stars
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II – 1 Star
Transformers - 3 Stars
Transformers II - 1 Star
V for Vendetta – 3 Stars
Wanted – 3 Stars
Watchmen – 4 Stars
Whiteout - Not reviewed
Wolverine – 2 Stars
X-Men – 2.5 Stars
X-Men 2 – 3 Stars
X-Men 3 – 3 Stars