The Elf who hid the Villain

The Elf who hid the Villain

What if Malekith was not the villain?

Editorial Opinion
By saintixe56 - Nov 11, 2013 12:11 AM EST
Filed Under: Thor

Read again Marvel's pitch regarding the Dark World:

Marvel’s “Thor: The Dark World” continues the big-screen adventures of Thor, the Mighty Avenger, as he battles to save Earth and all the Nine Realms from a shadowy enemy that predates the universe itself. In the aftermath of Marvel’s “Thor” and “Marvel’s The Avengers,” Thor fights to restore order across the cosmos…but an ancient race led by the vengeful Malekith returns to plunge the universe back into darkness. Faced with an enemy that even Odin and Asgard cannot withstand, Thor must embark on his most perilous and personal journey yet, one that will reunite him with Jane Foster and force him to sacrifice everything to save us all.

Right: who is this shadowy enemy? True, Malekith leads the Dark Elves and has vowed revenge... but does he really use this Aether or is the Aether using him?

Let's take a walk without priori claim of knowledge as who is the villain in TTDW. What do we see? Elves getting a thumping because Bor has captured the Aether. We also see that Bor does not go after the Elves: what we see is that he is very afraid of the Aether down to consigning it to some sort of prison. Just like in IM3 when we meet the 'nice' Killian humiliated for Stark. And we know this will come back to haunt IronMan. A good deed never goes unpunished...

From then on, what we see is a very active (shall we say bossy?) Aether driving Jane to him? Using the coming conjunction side-effects: the gravitation/realms/dimensional holes as to attract her attention?
Who then invades Jane: not Malekith.

Who triggers the awaking of Malekith but the Aether?
Who defends himself from the bobbies and Asgard's finest but the Aether?
Who because of Frigga's trick misses his appointment with Malekith but the Aether?

It is always the Aether who leads Malekith? Never the opposite. The Elven Lord is a follower, a superb henchman giving the Aether a physicality but always the boss is the Aether. Down to showing to Jane his plans despite being a very mute villain: just like any CMB villain has his cackling moment whilst disclosing his great plan to the hero...

Earth it is as the target and again Malekith follows his boss orders. And it is the Aether who rightly invades the realms like Loki led the Chitauri...
It is the Aether who takes over Malekith's body... and shows to Loki how to die and survive a deadly blow from Thor. Better he shows Loki how to take over as a disembodied being a physical body inhabited by the body's owmer spirit/mind. The power, the real villain who leads Malekith and Kurse to his nefarious tune is the Aether.

Down to the post-credit scene... Care to remember. We all fall for the revelation of the movie last scene... then the credits roll and who is prisoner and probably released in the wrong hands but the Aether... just like we could see that Loki was going to go after the Tesseract.

The cliff-hanger says it all: the villain has once again escaped and the realms are not safe.

The Aether has won: he is safe from Asgard and he is now able to carry on his plans. One down: five to go... Ragnarok is still on the equation.

As clearly, the Darkness wants to cancel the Light. Cancel the existence of Asgard...

Thanks for your thoughts.

THOR 5: Chris Hemsworth Addresses His MCU Future And Says That There's Nothing Official (Yet)
Related:

THOR 5: Chris Hemsworth Addresses His MCU Future And Says That There's "Nothing Official" (Yet)

RUMOR: THOR 5 Scheduled To Film Next Year; Writer And Director Currently Being Sought
Recommended For You:

RUMOR: THOR 5 Scheduled To Film Next Year; Writer And Director Currently Being Sought

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

BANE5000
BANE5000 - 11/11/2013, 12:21 AM
You make a good point that the Aether was in control all along and that no one was gonna be able to control it.

Now my big question is What happened to Odin?
saintixe56
saintixe56 - 11/11/2013, 6:27 AM
Well, this is a very interesting question which is led by this theory (admittedly a theory, though glaringly obvious from my point of view as the Aether being the real Deus Ex Machina of the movie).
Because it leads to the Odin's riddle as once again it is the Aether showing the way to Loki and not Malekith. Though Malekith is instrumental... yet just as instrumental as the pencil used by Einstein to write his equation (useful but not the brain behind the pencil)
In a way I should and I am at fault called this post: the elf who hid the villain, the king who was not and the Trickster who flunked the trick. Each event causing the next like a Russian doll.
The Aether pulls in front of Loki 2 new tricks:
1- how to come back from Death. because Thor's blows did indeed kill the Aether but it was able to recompose itself, to defy Death and live again.
As per Marvel's mantra: what is called science on Earth/Midgard is called magic in Asgard. In which case what we call here scientists/researchers like Tony Stark are called there wizards/sorcerers.
Who is Asgard most powerful warlock thus scientist? Loki. If there is something every scientist does in his/her life and something we know sorcerers do is observing/experimenting...
Loki watches as the Aether recomposes! Do not forget it: it was sitting front seat when the trick was pulled and he was utterly fascinated. so he watches it and being our Loki , well he has a brilliant intellect isn't it? he guesses how the trick is done and that is a new power added to his already quite full chest of magic tricks.
Better still, he watches as the Aether enters Malekith's body and takes over his mind (just like with Jane when the Aether shows her his big plan) Malekith's eyes turn red and we believe it is Malekith being the boss while he is just the medium, just the instrument. Loki once again witnesses the event and learns how to enter somebody's body and take over control. Why do I say that: when in the corridors and having fun at shape shifting Thor into Sif: we hear Thor's voice coming from the Sif Body. Maybe Loki has altered his brother's looks but the mind directing Sif's body is Thor: not Loki!
And now, Loki learns how to mentally take over a body and a mind. Relegating the body's owner spirit to sit in the shadow and wait till he can take control again...
He saves Jane, saves Thor ... in short ticking all the boxes of a brotherly approval ... but what did Thor promise? I'll grant you vengeance and then this cell. Loki may be the most heroic prince; his fate is to return into the dungeons and he does not want it!
So, he willingly let Kurse kill him... Heroic death scene... heart-broken Thor leave sthe scene with Jane because a tempest is raging. We all take it to be a physical symptom of the raging emotions and distress endured by the Thunderer . Which may well be.
It may well be that there is a physical event happening. Unrelated to Thor. When Loki projects the clones, what really happens is that Loki's body dissoves quickly, and recomposes nearby leaving just the air molecules to look like him. Dissolve/recompose.
As it is a death trick: the sequence would be : death while at the same time dissolving not his body but his astral projection! and then recomposing his body by the powers of his astral disembodied projection like the Aether is a disembodied being. Bit it does not work.
Or loki as in Loki's spirit is alive and well. Thank you but stuck in mid experiment. He is alive yes, but now even his astral projection is limited to a few pixie shining green particles dust but he is still powerful... except for having a body...
Then comes the rescue team sent by Odin? or possibly Loki able to morph into the Einherjar body because the trick says he cannot morph back into his body?? possibly because his body is too injured? Regardless either he is able to morph into the soldier or he 'invades' the soldier's body.
Why do I think he invades a body and does not invent a body? Loki shapeshifts into pre-existing body shapes: the soldier does exist. Another problem to consider is : what did Odin do after Heimdall played his own version of treason! If both my sons however disobedient one is while the other is on detention from misbehaviour were going to fight the big bad boy far away from my planet, I would be raising Hel to get them back alive. Odin sends the rescue team/paramedics or maybe only one as Heimdall does only see one alive? why one soldier to face Thor or Loki is a mystery, I grant you but we all know lately the ALLFATHER is not given to brilliant decision making.
Soldier comes, collects body but Loki invades his mind and we have now a body devoid on his spiritual component while we have a soldier with 2 masters...
Soldier comes to meet Odin who again is not feeling well: well he would not. In one day, he has lost his wife, almost lost his realm by poor decision making and lost one son while the other may die any time soon through the Aether. Odin is not a happy Asgardian bunny.
He does not notice the smirk on the soldier's face because he turns his back, lost in unplesant thoughts and Loki strikes. The soldier may die because of the experiment, may faint, may recover and wonders what happened whatis he doing in Asgard when last time he was on Svartalfheim planet... who knows but Loki knows. Loki has now taken over Odin's body and knowing Loki's grudge bearing my money is on Odin's mind stuck inside Loki's body!
Why do I think it is Odin's real body? because of the Heimdall factor. Heimdall sees everything: which means he sees a comatose Loki's body and would get suspicious at 2 Odin's bodies.
Sorry for the convolved explanation but it is like explaining a magical trick doing this and that...
sikwon
sikwon - 11/11/2013, 7:06 AM
Awesome.
JohnnyRoss
JohnnyRoss - 11/11/2013, 10:23 AM
Very interesting read.
Question:
In the comics, can Loki actually do what you think he did?
Can he take over people's bodies like that?
I don't know, I don't read them often.
NovaCorpsFan
NovaCorpsFan - 11/11/2013, 11:43 AM
He doesn't take people's bodies he just assumes their form.

I like the living shit out of this editorial. Interesting stuff.
CapitanAmerika2
CapitanAmerika2 - 11/11/2013, 12:02 PM
You make it seem like the Aether is a living organism that can think and act on its own. However, we know its not because Volstagg says it's an Infinity STONE just like the Tesseract. With your logic then the Tesseract was the real villain in Captain America: The First Avenger and the Avengers.
CharlesLord
CharlesLord - 11/11/2013, 1:23 PM
Wow this is a really interesting editorial. I like the idea that the Aether was the real villain behind the film.
saintixe56
saintixe56 - 11/11/2013, 3:26 PM
@vandinejd

Yes, the stones are 'alive' for lack of a better word and yes the Iesseract was using everybody...The stones want to be re-united to re-start a new cycle...
Ace101
Ace101 - 11/12/2013, 12:30 AM
That is an interesting concept, something i contemplated as well. When we see jane infused with the aether, she has these moments or visions where she is seeing the aether in some manner and that it looked liked it had a mind of its own.
However your point about lokis death and revival by witnessing the aether revive itself is a bit of stretch. I thought it was simple, he simply faked his death in front of thor, using his skills, then went to asgard, did something to odin, then took the form of odin and let thor go to earth, and since frigga aint there to see through his tricks hes free to do what he wants.
And that marvel mantra bit you stated in the comment above is inaccurate. Its "your ancestors called it magic, you call it science. I come from a place where they are one in the same thing"-thor
saintixe56
saintixe56 - 11/12/2013, 2:23 AM
@ace : if our ancestors called a thing magic and science and it is the same then sorcerers are scientists because it is the same...
Ace101
Ace101 - 11/12/2013, 3:30 AM
Oh yea i got that lol i thought you had misquoted is all
saintixe56
saintixe56 - 11/12/2013, 4:20 AM
By the way, I have come up with another theory... we know there was a rscue team sent for sure. Watched it again last night and the soldier says 'we found a body' so Odin had indeed sent soldiers to get his sons and JFoster back... hence Loki attacked the lone soldier who was the last to board back into their spaceviking ship in whatever above manner

He meets Odin who is sad, tired, stressed and in the perfect mood for ... convenient Odin Sleep : and Loki pulls it. Sends sleepy Odin spirit into his own weakened body and gets into daddy Odin's body.

The trick being to always keep the same number of bodies for Heimdall to check there is no trick... after that ... well Loki is clearly going to have some fun at being the King... but the Warriors 3 are going to find something is strange and Heimdall too...

Yet as long as Loki is apparently stuck into this wounded state/trance like they are unable to imagine the switch... possibly because never done before...

and when Odin awakes finally in the right place, my bet is he will look different. It would if you start messing around with molecules...plus it allows AHopkins to say elegantly good-bye.

He really was like a tired Lion in winter/Churchill-like Asgardian. Time to leave the stage...
dopemaster
dopemaster - 11/12/2013, 4:25 PM
I thought I remembered Odin turning back to Loki on the throne? If he turned back to the Loki form, wouldn't that mean that he only assumed the form and did not take control of the body?

Going to watch it again tomorrow...
wcwpoet
wcwpoet - 11/15/2013, 6:45 AM
The Aether wasn't the villain it's an Infinity Stone aka an Infinity Gem leading to the Infinity Gauntlet
View Recorder