Okay so I'am a massive fan of the Old Man Logan story it's one of my favourite stories of all time, The artwork is some of the best and the story telling holds me in and makes me want to know more.
One of the most powerful parts is right at the start with the dialogue:
"No one knows what happened on the night the heroes fell. All we know is that they disappeared and evil triumphed and the bad guys have been calling the shots ever since. What happened to Wolverine is the biggest mystery of them all. Some say they hurt him like no one ever hurt before. Others say he just grew tired of all the fighting and retired to a simpler life. Either way he hasn't raised his voice or popped his claws in fifty years. His old friends would barely recognize him now."
First of I'll talk about some of the questions left open and the things that I really wanted to know more about but at the same time was happy with how they were left due to the story being perfect how it was.
The heroes - We know they were mostly killed off but how? I mean we saw Captain America (Bucky) having the Red Skulls thumps stabbed into his eyes but I always wanted to see some epic flashes of Thor and Iron Man's death scenes. Were they scared? how hard a fight did they put up?.
Fantastic Four - Hawkeye mentions that "We know what happened to Ben and Johnny" and says from a third hand source (who heard it from the Shocker) that Reed Richards and Sue Storm were rumoured to have been beaten up and dumped in the timestream by Kang. It uncertain whether it was actually true so what happened to Johnny and Ben and where are Reed and Sue really?
While I'm on the topic of FF what happened with Loki being huge and having the Baxter building topple on top of him?
She-Hulk - We find out that Bruce Banner and Jennifer engaged in an incest relationship for years producing loads of hill billy Hulks, but what happened to her is never mentioned.
If Thor was killed and Loki was up to no good why didn't Odin allow Asgard to intervene?
Now what I want to see I'd love a graphic novel released containing lets say twelve chapters? eight of those being set before Old Man Logan.
The first is set the day before to show the villains coming together, then the next four chapters would be the event in which the villains take over but showing the point of view of Captain American (finally loosing to the Red Skull), Iron Man (witnessing his industry and life falling to the villains as well as the destruction of the Avengers), Thor (showing the mighty hero being one of the heroes putting up the best fight against the villain but loosing faith after witnessing so many heroes die)and Spider-man (Trying to protect his family as he races between helping his friends fight off the villains and save his family).
The next four Issues would be set after the heroes have fallen and the villains are fighting out who gets what showing things such as the Hulk take Abominations land and seeing Doom state his power to those who pose him.
The next two issues would show short stories such as Nick Fury having survived but having his tongue ripped out and crippled by a group of villains, What really happened to Reed and Sue, An elderly man (looking strangely familiar to Stand Lee) and his grandson taking a road trip and giving a civilians point of view to the new world, An old abandoned bar holding four aged men attending their annual poker game as they each share their account of what happened when the Villains took over (in the end we find out that Deadpool is the forth man when he is the last to leave after the game and take his old tattered mask from his coat pocket and reveal his scared face from he shadows) and the journey of the Symbiote going from weak host to weak host until witnessing Logan and Clint in the buggy and coming across a T-Rex.
And then the last two issues being a set after, A count of Baby Bruce Jr.'s life with Logan and then Logans tale of the Origin of his new Super Hero team.
So yeah give me your feed back would love to hear what you guys would like to see in it.