Anil Rickly reviews "GI JOE: Renegades Pilot"

Anil Rickly reviews "GI JOE: Renegades Pilot"

...Can this new series see the GI JOE unit led by Duke...finally defeat the secret evil known as...COBRA...?

Review Opinion
By earzmundo - Nov 30, 2010 09:11 AM EST
Filed Under: Animated Features

GI JOE: Renegades –

Pilot Episodes - 01, 02



If you're a fan of the old school GI JOE comics, cartoons and old source material, then you may not like the changes to the lore in this series...and it comes abound...these changes!
Fans who found the movie lacking that Stephen Sommers made may also find that this is a repeat offender to some extent...and it's understandable.
'THE HUB' gives this series a chance to compliment its 'TRANSFORMERS: Prime' and I must admit that I did expect better from Jeff Kline's production team on this animation front!



Created by Whitney Chapman and Matt Meeks, many expected a hard hitting series along the lines of the recent GI JOE: Resolute!
'Resolute' did stray from old lore, but was an hour's worth of hard hitting action, killing and fighting that would appease those who thought the Sommers' film bombed...and on the heels of Resolute, and a wicked cool teaser shown at COMIC-CON, many expected a brilliant pilot.



Sad to say, this series, while not like TRANSFORMERS: Prime, who stuck too much to a film (s) but still managed to make its own storyline, gave us a GI JOE that again resembled the movie in that it just didn't utilize its change from lore to make an appealing effort to me. It has bits of potential...but that's it...just bits...



It's all about Duke (nicely voiced by James Marsden) and Scarlett, and their rogue team trying to bring COBRA to justice after the evil entity framed the heroes. It's nice to mention that COBRA is a corporate entity in the worldwide market of pharmaceuticals, secret experiments and weapons defense - that somehow managed to pull the wool over all military eyes...a nice spin...but one that isn't done too solidly here.



Scarlett's reasonings for assembling this team of JOES is muddled and the way in which they go about their extraction mission is such a fumbled step in the dark, it's not hard to believe the ramifications (although RISE OF COBRA film haters may feel justified by the continuous slashing of a certain beloved JOE, and may see this as an attempt to kill off residue from the aberrational Ripcord in RISE OF COBRA!).



As the team tries to prove COBRA as criminals, things take a turn for the worse and our heroes end up taking a huge fall at the hands of experiments done by a young, rash, annoying Mindbender! Fans may not take well to this guy at all.
While the JOES stick to a small unit of Duke, Scarlett, Roadblock, Tunnel Rat (who is very entertaining with his quippy disposition), it's nice to have a small roster to work with and expand upon...and this seems to be the mode for COBRA as well as we only meet Mindbender and Baroness in her usual slithery roles.
We are teased with DESTRO AND COMMANDER as well to come...and with Lady Jaye, Flint, and a somewhat trite version of Hawk, in the mix...I'm sure the introduction of some familiar faces over the next few episodes can inject a much needed fusion of life and old-school GI JOE to give this series the boost it badly needs.

The voice cast consists of Charlie Adler, Lee Majors, Clancy Brown, Khary Payton, Kevin Richardson and Johnny Messner...so it's decent, but sad to say, the plot needs some improving if this isn't to fall into the category of another GI JOE iteration that simply wasn't up to standard...or didn't meet our expectations. It's disappointing to say that this series is too akin to A-TEAM and yet still doesn't hit the poignant note that the producers and fans like myself thought it would...there's a lot of room for bettering this show if it's to strike us hard! After all...I was a huge fan of RESOLUTE and I strongly believe that Renegades is miles behind on the GI JOE Richter scale...After all, they can't expect the always-awesome Snake Eyes to keep saving their shows, can they...and with the poorly drawn Storm Shadow lurking, it seems that not even this awesome ninja Snake Eyes can salvage a potential wreck like this...Please God...let them improve this show for Christmas...




Rating = 5.5/10
About The Author:
earzmundo
Member Since 5/14/2009
SPIDER-VERSE Studio Releases First Trailer For Steph Curry's GOAT And It Looks Absolutely Phenomenal
Related:

SPIDER-VERSE Studio Releases First Trailer For Steph Curry's GOAT And It Looks Absolutely Phenomenal

Thomas Brodie-Sangster Talks GRAND PRIX OF EUROPE, LOVE ACTUALLY's Legacy, Possible MCU/DCU Roles (Exclusive)
Recommended For You:

Thomas Brodie-Sangster Talks GRAND PRIX OF EUROPE, LOVE ACTUALLY's Legacy, Possible MCU/DCU Roles (Exclusive)

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

skullboy
skullboy - 11/30/2010, 1:40 PM
Saw this show and really hate this direction they took. I wish they did a series based on the Resolute special. The new Transformers toon didn't do me justice either. As far as I'm concerned, it's an alternate GI Joe universe that just doesn't work.
StuckInPanels
StuckInPanels - 12/4/2010, 5:28 AM
why not just reair the classic series. Both GI Joe and Transformers, get kids on those shows first
kennywr22
kennywr22 - 12/5/2010, 6:25 PM
Sorry man but your review is way off. First problem is you believe resloute to be so great. That was an hour of over the top violence with crappy characterization and story. Give me a break, you think renegades is comparable to roc?? You have no right doing a review. This series borrows from A-team no doubt but other than that its fantastic. The characters are well written, they look more there part than roc, and the story is shaping up to awesome. Go watch episode 3 and you'll see what joe is supposed to be, not that over rated resolute crap.Yo Joe(renegades)!
Gutts81
Gutts81 - 12/12/2010, 7:36 PM
@KENNY I have no clue as to what it was you watched but resolute was the fantastic! It had everything a true fan joe fan could want. Renegades has a ok story idea with cobra being corporate terrorists and all. But the animation fails nd the story for the joe's is not all that well written.
kennywr22
kennywr22 - 12/27/2010, 1:26 PM
I stand by what i said. You are stuck in an eighties mind set. If you dont like it thats fine, but this whole thing about it should be cobra going all out againest gi joe!What part of "its a starting story to show us gi joe forming "did you not read? The story is leaps and bounds better than resolute or any other joe cartoon to date! Resolute was fun at best. It was not a great piece of gi joe. Everybody was an a-hole in resolute. The animation is right on par with just about any other weekly cartoon(not clone wars). This is not gonna be resolute quality animation( that was a one shot movie). Watch episodes 6 and 7 and tell me it sucks.No way. Gotta be open to new things.
Sindelle25
Sindelle25 - 1/19/2011, 8:12 AM
Personally, I really like Renegades. I enjoyed Resolute as well...the only thing I really didn't like was the movie. I like the direction Renegades is taking and I hope they continue it!
musicsuperhero1
musicsuperhero1 - 1/25/2011, 5:22 PM
@comicscritic87 ...they did. the Hub plays the original transformers, g.i. joe, transformers prime and g.i. joe renegades.


i think renegades is really good. they have a lot to work with re-envisioning these characters. ...its still too early to tell if it will be great but it has great potential...its a little ruff around the edges but..so far so good.
musicsuperhero1
musicsuperhero1 - 1/25/2011, 5:28 PM
@earzmundo ...its like 4 episodes into the first season..lol ...i'm sure eventually they will be the full out militant terrorist group...just as G.I. Joe will probably eventually be its own division of the military. its too early to tell...this is like an origin of the two groups.
View Recorder