Recent film history has shown that films about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan tend to not do very well at the box office, some will even say that it's a taboo subject to portray. No matter what side of that argument you fall on, you have to agree that it brings up a lot of feelings. I think this film does a fantastic job of portraying some of what happens after someone has returned home. Having said that, I do not personally know someone who has been through this situation and my heart goes out to those who have.
Now, on to the film. This is easily one of the best films I have seen this year. Every aspect of this film just stands out to me: the acting, filming, the story. While these actors have been around for quite some time and they have all played a variety of character, this film is a best for all of them.
The story follows the family of a marine (Maguire) who is sent back to Afghanastan. Just before that happens, his brother (Gyllenhaal) is released from prison. After the marine's helicopter is shot down, his family tries to move on, having been told that he is dead. Brother steps in to help the family to cope with his and their loss. The story is actually a remake of a Danish film of the same name. The story seems quite simple, but it also has a depth that is rare these days. I hate to use such a cliche word to describe a film, but the film is really quite moving, in many ways.
As I stated earlier, this film is acted incredibly well. Tobey Maguire seems to have tapped into a dark corner of his being; his portrayal of Sam is disturbing and emotional. For those that are used to seeing him as the dorky Peter Parker and Spiderman, this is a whole new person. It really shows his abilities that he has been hiding away from us apparently. I've always known that Jake Gyllenhaal was talented, but this role allows him to show it off. His transition from the hard prisoner to loving family member is incredible and seamless. Natalie Portman has cemented her position as one of the top female actors of our time. She is stellar in her role. I can't leave out the two little girls, as they held their own in this group of actors, especially Bailee Madison. She has a scene that is one of the most moving scenes in the film.
Technically speaking, the movie is rather simple, which is perfect for this situation. The simplicity keeps the story in the fore front and doesn't distract you at all and allows the realism to take place. I have a tendency to notice music in films (not sure why, it just stands out to me) and the music that was selected here was a perfect fit for the story and the characters.
I love this time of year, as it is a time when some of the best movies are released and this is no exception. All the pieces come together in unique fashion to give us glimpse into the scattered world of war veterans and their families. I can't stress enough the gratitude I have for the men and women of the armed forces and their sacrifice. This film is simply amazing and I'd suggest that you check this one out.
Grade: A-