When did it become a CRIME to be a FANBOY ?

When did it become a CRIME to be a FANBOY ?

Editorial on the State of FANBOY culture

Editorial Opinion
By dageekundaground - Aug 14, 2010 03:08 PM EST
Filed Under: Other




I grew up during the very late seventies throughout the eighties and I for one consider myself lucky and a better fanboy for it. During those early times I was taken by my parents to see JAWS, STAR WARS, KING KONG, and ISLAND of DR.MOREAU (with Burt Lancaster & Peter York), SUSPIRIA and for me the POP CULTURE ICON, well for me anyway …. SUPERMAN the MOVIE.

Those were REALLY GREAT times to be a kid (I still remember my cousin having a door sized poster of Superman taped to his wall. With the advent of EMPIRE STRIKES BACK and SUPERMAN 2, the studios really began their big although plodding at the time; March towards making COMIC BOOK MOVIES a modus operates. These movies Big Cash Cows for Warner Bros. and 20th Century Fox changed the way things were done and SUMMER became the official time of the POPCORN MOVIE.

During the eighties there were more than a few missteps with FLASH GORDON, SUPERMAN 3 & 4 and probably most infamous of that era … “HOWARD the DUCK”. You know something funny; fanboys still went out and watched these films, still filled enough seats to give them some kind of profit (Who do you really think were filling the seats for Howard the Duck, soccer moms?). Case in point is that we have always done our part to support these films in one way or another (at the theatre or home rentals).

Well …

Somewhere along the line between the mid to late nineties and today… things have changed drastically. Most could probably look to AICN as the progenitor of FANBOY mainstream culture. Harry with his many behind the scenes scoops and internet leaks of script details drove the suits to distraction. My favorite all time post on Harry’s site regarded the upcoming X-Men movie at the time and was titled something to the effect of: “When it Rains, It Pours”.

Harry had what studios later claimed to be a pic of Hugh Jackman’s stunt double in a black, pleather looking costume was the epitome of bland bastardization. I really feel like that post was Harry’s finest moment. I credit that post with making industry standard statements made by actors/ actresses to the effect of “THIS IS TRUE TO THE SPIRIT OF THE MATERIAL” (even if it’s not).

Harry was so good at what he did, so good at being a human virus that he made the studios sit up and take notice. Some have even accused him of accepting so much swag that he has effectively become a studio shill, so to speak. Legions of fanboys and girls have been given license to voice their disgruntled nature in ill numerable comments sections across the world.

This also has opened a veritable PANDORAS BOX of CEASE and DESIST letters and an unknown number of GAG ORDERS regarding these CB movies. Currently the summer of 2010 has got to be one of the most miserable movie going summers I’ve experienced in a long time. There just wasn’t a lot to do in regards to the movies. IRON MAN II, I felt dropped the ball for being too full of itself (and not in a good way). I’ve read numerous retorts from actors, directors and producers at the rabid nature of the fanboys re: whichever property they’re adapting to the big screen. I’ve grown tired of reading comments from studio heads about changing the nature of comic book properties for the big screen.

I think most people are smart enough to realize that it’s generally a mixed bag when you are going into the CB movie business.

It’s just that HONESTLY…you REALLY get TIRED of hearing this spiel from studio heads that more likely than not have no CREATIVE IMAGINATION whatsoever. Some guy’s that is a Business an Economic major’s REALLY gonna TELL a DIEHARD FAN that it’s actually better if their FAVORITE comic book character wears a black leather jerkin?

Fanboys are just trying to say one BASIC THING… we now live in an age where it is literally possible to put anything up on the BIG SCREEN.

When you purchased the intellectual property for a lot of these films, did you really feel they needed to be fixed? Kind of like buying an Edsol huh?


People are passionate about things that they LOVE.

A lot of FANBOYS ... REALLY LOVE COMIC BOOK MOVIES DONE RIGHT!!

Before I go back into the shadows, I’d just like to leave all of you studio heads, actors, producers and suits one little tidbit.


“WHEN COMIC BOOK MOVIES ARE DONE RIGHT, THEN AND ONLY THEN DO THEY CROSS CULTURE AND APPEAL TO THE MAINSTREAM PUBLIC.”

…you want the dolla, dolla bill yall …. Follow this CAN’T LOSE mantra.

SHADOWGEEK10
August 14,2010
About The Author:
dageekundaground
Member Since 8/13/2010
COSMERE Author Brandon Sanderson Gives His Thoughts Why Book Adaptations Often Fail And How They Can Do Better
Related:

COSMERE Author Brandon Sanderson Gives His Thoughts Why Book Adaptations Often Fail And How They Can Do Better

Evil Dead Wrath Announced For 2028 Release; Evil Dead Burn First Look Revealed At CinemaCon
Recommended For You:

Evil Dead Wrath Announced For 2028 Release; Evil Dead Burn First Look Revealed At CinemaCon

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

LEEE777
LEEE777 - 8/14/2010, 3:25 PM
dageekundaground @ Agree with most of it, gr8 read dude!

Funny pic hahahhahaha! : D

Most movies are crap, and the fact HOLLYWOOD puts Millions in them, it makes it even sadder! : P

Why brake which ain't broken for a Hollywood lame watered down take?

I wont put my A$$ up in the air like some people haha!

FIRST CLASS should be made right or not at [frick]ing all lol!

(I'm not saying page for page lol, but the BASICS would be nice and not twisted crappy versions!)
marvel72
marvel72 - 8/14/2010, 4:29 PM
that was a cool read,i can relate to some of it.

my dad collected comics before i got into them,so i was brought up with them.
i started buying them when i was about thirteen.

being a young boy in the seventies,i had the star wars buzz the figures,posters & books.

some of the best movies ever made came out in the late 70s & the first half of the 80s.

i remember going to the cinema to see howard the duck,their was eight people in the cinema.

i would say i'm fan boy of all the cool shit comics & movies.

i wish comicbook movies were more like superman the movie,ironman,watchmen,300,sin city,kick ass,spider-man 2,the dark knight & x-men 2.

& less like x-men 3,the spirit,x-men origins wolverine & so on.

if that makes me a fanboy,then i'm one & proud of it.
FlashGordon2287
FlashGordon2287 - 8/14/2010, 4:50 PM
Im gonna have to disagree with nearly everything you said. If more studios listened to the fans we would have more spider-man 3s and less Dark Knights. Spider-man 3s failures were mainly becasue the studio listened to the fans who wanted venom and so on (the worst Spider-Man villain) Dark Knight Worked because Chris Nolan didnt listen to the fans. I say if a director really cares about these characters ala Raimi, Nolan, Vaughn, Singer, Favreau even to a degree Snyder then it will work. Most of the worst CBMs come from people who are in it for a check or dont know anything about the character ala Daredevil, Ghost Rider, Spirit and so on. I'm not saying its bad to want money but it would be nice if it was well done. Saying Hollywood doesnt care about these Characters is true to a degree but when the Directors care its good. Plus when a CBM is good its really good. I really want a Flash movie but when I think about it, the suit would be pretty ridiculous as well as the origin and the ring. I say if its not done right dont get angry read the source material and wait for the reboot. it can always be done better. Just my opinion. :)
Curmudgeon
Curmudgeon - 8/14/2010, 5:42 PM
The negative stigma of "fanboy's" comes from the trait that they really really love a franchise to the point that they hold it to extremely particular standards, and will attack and insult it for failing to meet those standards.

Now replace the word "franchise" with the word "spouse" and maybe (hopefully) you'll see why behaving like that isn't necessarily a good thing.
FlashGordon2287
FlashGordon2287 - 8/14/2010, 5:54 PM
@MaxJaybo Exactly
OdinsBeard
OdinsBeard - 8/14/2010, 6:47 PM
flashgordon@ I agree. There is a saying in sports that applies here as well - "listen to the fans and u'll be sitting with them"

Sometimes ppl online don't realize these films r made for a mainstream audience and not the niche that buys the books. Some things just won't translate to the screen. Like u said with flash.

It's definitley not a crime to be a fanboy, all of us here are. You just need to have perspective.

If u want exactly what was in the comic then go read it. But movies need an arc to follow in 2 hours. Not 500 issues and 70 years worth of continuity
FlashGordon2287
FlashGordon2287 - 8/14/2010, 7:02 PM
@Odin Thanks!
Matador
Matador - 8/14/2010, 11:59 PM
It's okay to be a fanboy just best of luck you don't turn into a fatass fanboy & can't see your own peepee.
GirlyGeek
GirlyGeek - 8/16/2010, 7:07 PM
Great article. I find myself living two lives...that of the mild-mannered business woman...and that of the geeked out fangirl. It's a pain sometimes. I get so many strange looks over my only non-business decor in my office: mighty mugg captain america. No one has yet to ask though.
TheLonelyComicBookNerd
TheLonelyComicBookNerd - 8/19/2010, 9:20 AM
It is true, But to the big movie franchise's its all about the money and even if it's horrible we'll still go out and see it, the only company that really cares is Marvel of course.
View Recorder