Bryan Singer Looks Back on Superman Returns & One thing He'd Change

Bryan Singer Looks Back on Superman Returns & One thing He'd Change

Bryan Singer talks about one of the most polarizing performances in CBM history and what he may have done differently.

By TheGODDAMNSUPERGUY - Apr 16, 2011 05:04 AM EST
Filed Under: Superman
Source: Digitalspy.com

One of the most debated performances in CBMs has always been the performance of Brandon Routh in Bryan Singer's Superman Returns. Some people thought Routh did an amazing job as the titular character of Clark Kent/Superman, while others, myself included, thought he was sub-par at best. While doing a recent interview with Digitalspy.com, Bryan Singer seems to reiterate what many of the people against Routh have been saying...



"If I'm really honest, what I probably would have done is go back and retell the origin story with someone like Nicholas Hoult [playing Clark Kent/Superman]," he said.



A picture of Nicholas Hoult

"I would have done it differently from Richard Donner's original, which I love, but instead of doing a sequel I'd have started from the beginning - maybe I had that in the back of my mind and instead translated it to X-Men: First Class!"



To me, it reads as if Singer finally admits, even though he's done so on many occasions, that he only casted Routh based on his erie resemblance to Christopher Reeve.



While I think Hoult looks nothing like Superman, I'm glad that Mr. Singer is starting to see what he did wrong with his movie. Yes, it's always nice to pay homage to the past, but you can't live in it too much.
DISCUSSION: Which Movie Has The Best Superhero Costumes — SUPERMAN or THE FANTASTIC FOUR: FIRST STEPS?
Related:

DISCUSSION: Which Movie Has The Best Superhero Costumes — SUPERMAN or THE FANTASTIC FOUR: FIRST STEPS?

Marvel Studios Reluctant To Weigh In On Nicepool Legal Battle For Fear Of Revealing Future DEADPOOL Plans
Recommended For You:

Marvel Studios Reluctant To Weigh In On "Nicepool" Legal Battle For Fear Of Revealing Future DEADPOOL Plans

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Dynamo
Dynamo - 4/16/2011, 5:33 AM
Nicholas Hoult? [frick] me, don't let Bryan Singer direct a superhero movie ever again...
jazzman
jazzman - 4/16/2011, 5:37 AM
Nicholas Hoult as Superman is this guy on crack could someone just slap him
LP4
LP4 - 4/16/2011, 5:51 AM
Nice article Superguy. Again proving a point you and i have been saying for the past year on the subject of Routh.

Nice job my friend- oh and Singer blows.
LP4
LP4 - 4/16/2011, 6:00 AM
Oh and it's really lame how NOW all of a sudden, stupid-ass 'BrIan Stinker' is suddenly saying he'd do a film on the 'early years of Superman' gee i wonder where he got THAT idea from...lol

What an uncreative HACK.

He just doesn't understand Superman, never read a FU*KING comicbook in his life and doesn't give a crap about fans and only cares his own "VISION"

Hey mister Singer- FU*K YOU! And take that little boring, emo, whiney Superman to the gutter with you. Snyder will make a Superman film...for MEN. A concept I don't think you ever would have dreamed possible you unimaginative fu*king, devil-wears-prada-loving PRICK!

- I shall await the usual barrage of insults from the loyal bryan singer-blowup dolls. This should be fun. =D
Mason
Mason - 4/16/2011, 6:00 AM
Consider it a lucky escape.
BrianFXW
BrianFXW - 4/16/2011, 7:06 AM
Considering the material he was given to work with, which was nothing more than a fan film with a million dollar budget, I think Brandon Routh was a great Superman, Im dissapointed Singer screwed the franchise into a dead end the way he did. Totally psyched for Zach Snyder's Superman!
Ethic
Ethic - 4/16/2011, 7:09 AM
Nicholas Hoult?
Could you actually pick someone with a tinier jaw? lol

But besides that, you can't just pick random actors to play someone like Supes, they need to have certain acting strengths, and physical requirements, and Nic has none I can see besides height and hair colour.
YourMomNaked
YourMomNaked - 4/16/2011, 11:40 AM
Singer's greatest regret: he should've stayed in bed ;)

LP4
LP4 - 4/16/2011, 2:03 PM
@YourMomNaked- LMAO!!! Funny stuff dude!
JULEZ13
JULEZ13 - 4/16/2011, 2:11 PM
Wow really? Is he just trying to give his fellow gay men in Hollywood work?!? Like for real? Nicholas Hoult?!? And I thought Brandon Routh looked really gay in SR, but this guy... Oh Lord. NEWS FLASH BRYAN SINGER: SUPERMAN IS NOT GAY!!!!!!

No offense to homosexuals, I just don't like his vision of the greatest and one of the manliest Superheroes of all time.

Bryan Singer just needs to stay the f*ck away from CBM's! Ugghhh... This f*ckin guy. smh.
dudemanjac
dudemanjac - 4/16/2011, 3:39 PM
Wow. I've defended this guy so much, but I'm done.
mainstream05
mainstream05 - 4/16/2011, 5:39 PM
The only part I agree with is that, yeah, Singer really should've told the story from the beginning to line up with Batman Begins. But even so, the fact that Singer has stated he's never read the comics would've made me wary anyway.

As for Routh - no, he didn't shine, but he had some awful direction. Seeing him in interviews and in Scott Pilgrim, there's no doubt in my mind he could've been a terrific Superman.
JULEZ13
JULEZ13 - 4/16/2011, 6:53 PM
@BaneKill77: I'm not hating on Singer's sexuality. I honestly don't care that he's gay. I know a lot of gay people that I hang out with so I am obviously not a homophobe. Before you start judging you should read what I stated carefully. I clearly said that he made Superman look gay in SR. I didn't even know he was gay until a couple of years ago. When I found that out it made a lot of sense to me as to why Brandon Routh looked the way that he did. The style of the costume, his lack of muscle mass. I never mentioned anything about making every character in all his movies gay, just Superman. I never said anything about Beast being gay, just the actor. Specifically his vision of how Superman should look like definitely represents how an everyday gay guy looks. So get your facts straight before you start attacking people.
AITITOS
AITITOS - 4/17/2011, 11:52 AM
i believe he is taking some kind of pills lately. Mr Singer don't interefere again with super hero movies.
AITITOS
AITITOS - 4/17/2011, 11:59 AM
i believe he is taking some kind of pills lately. Mr Singer don't interefere again with super hero movies.
AITITOS
AITITOS - 4/17/2011, 12:08 PM
i believe he is taking some kind of pills lately. Mr Singer don't interefere again with super hero movies.
DarkTalbot13
DarkTalbot13 - 4/17/2011, 3:07 PM
Singer was damn good with X-MEN, and X2 in his defence. Nicolas Hoult looks like an ok young Clark to be honest as well. I think he will be a good Hank McCoy; this all coming from a fan who think First Class will suck. That being said though, Superman Returns shouldn't have been green lit. The whole passing the torch redo of Donner's series was not the right direction. Same with that dumb idea to give him a son XP. Singer should of stuck to the X-Men 3.
Ancar
Ancar - 4/18/2011, 8:50 AM
That was a joke?
tomwazhar23
tomwazhar23 - 4/18/2011, 9:36 AM
Is it just me or is Bryan Singer getting crazier? I thought Brandon Routh would have been great if they were doing a reboot rather than a continuation. And even for a continuation he did alright considering that he had to be a reincarnation of Christopher Reeve's Superman. All the times he was trying to do his own thing he was good. After the comment Singer just made I think we can take a lot more blame of Routh. Singer is obviously a lunatic when it comes to Superman. Routh was simply Singers puppet.
Dear Bryan, just stick with X-Men please... it's better for all of us.
fullmetal
fullmetal - 4/18/2011, 11:49 AM
man!!! i think singer wants to be hated! first the devil wears prada thing, now this! he really needs to just keep his mouth shut because he's giving all the haters great oppurtunities to tear him an new assho le...
fullmetal
fullmetal - 4/18/2011, 11:56 AM
i just want to say that in my opinion...x2 wasn't that good...i'll never forgive singer for abandoning cyclops and rogue's development...making iceman a total square bear..and putting rogue with iceman...and all those corny teen nick scenes...however, i love x1 and the usual sucpects...apt pupil was okay...valkeyrie was pointless..we all knew hitler got away, so what was the point?
BeeMo
BeeMo - 4/18/2011, 8:16 PM
I've read soooo many "regret" interviews from this hack and he STILL DOESN'T GET IT! The story for Superman Returns SUCKED, that's why it and Singer is HATED by almost 90% of the fans. Here are the regrets you should have MISTER Singer:
1) Copying Richard Donner
2) Having Superman return from Krypton???
3) LOIS LANE -- yaawwnnn!
4) A dark version of Gene Hackman-Lex Luthor ( Complete waste of Kevin Spacey )
5) SUPERBOY???? Were you HIGH on that one??
6) Superman lifting a freaking LANDMASS of kryptonite!! (Another high chronic moment)
7) YOU SHOULD HAVE SHOT THE SCREENWRITERS ON THE SPOT FOR THAT TURD STORY!

8)SERIOUSLY, Chronic is bad for the brain, Singer. Just say NO to drugs!
bkaado
bkaado - 4/19/2011, 7:21 PM
if i had my way, I would of kept Routh and gotten rid of Singer
doneill1027
doneill1027 - 4/19/2011, 7:32 PM
Nick Hoult looks like he sucks dick on the reg
LP4
LP4 - 4/20/2011, 8:31 PM
@bkaado- That is why I'm happy Snyder didn't listen to people like you, no offense.
View Recorder