BATMAN: Paul Anthony Kelly Responds To Fan Support For Him To Play The DCU's Dark Knight

BATMAN: Paul Anthony Kelly Responds To Fan Support For Him To Play The DCU's Dark Knight

Love Story star Paul Anthony Kelly has emerged as a strong fan-favorite to play Batman in the DCU, and the actor has now responded to the growing support he's seen online...

By MarkCassidy - Feb 24, 2026 04:02 PM EST
Filed Under: Batman

Fans continue to throw their support behind certain actors they feel would be strong choices to don the cape and cowl as Batman in the burgeoning DC Comics movie and TV universe.

Reacher star Alan Ritchson and The Housemaid's Brandon Sklenar have already emerged as fan-favorites to play the iconic Gotham City vigilante, and more recently, model-turned-actor Paul Anthony Kelly gained a lot of attention following his performance as John F. Kennedy Jr. in Ryan Murphy's Love Story.

Kelly was asked about the fan campaign during an interview with GQ, and responded:

“If that’s what they say, then who am I to say no? I mean, that would be a dream come true.”

To be fair, we'd be more surprised if any actor said they weren't interested. Fan campaigns rarely result in the actor in question landing the role, but it has been known to happen.

We're probably still a while away from an official DCU Batman casting announcement, but DC Studios co-CEO James Gunn has previously revealed what fans tend to request most for the latest big-screen take on the hero, who is still expected to debut in The Brave and The Bold movie.

Gunn was asked if the "most requested thing" for the new Dark Knight was the white eyes (lenses to obscure the eyes when wearing the cowl) on social media, and responded that it's actually the blue and grey costume, then the "yellow around the bat," and then the white eyes.

"The most requested thing would be the blue and grey. Then the yellow around the bat. And THEN the white eyes. But all of those things I find less important than the character himself, the writing, and the person who plays him." 

Do you think Paul Anthony Kelly would be a good pick to play Batman? Drop us a comment down below.

"This is the introduction of the DCU's Batman," Gunn said of The Brave and the Bold when the Gods and Monsters slate was announced. "This is the story of Damian Wayne, who is Batman's actual son who we didn't know existed for the first eight to 10 years of his life. He was raised as a little murderer and assassin. He's a little son of a bitch. He's my favorite Robin. It's based on the Grant Morrison comic book's run, which is one of my favorite Batman runs, and we are putting that all together right now."

Peter Safran added, "And this is obviously a feature film, and it's going to feature other members of the extended 'Bat-family', just because we feel like they've been left out of the Batman stories in the theater for far too long."

We have heard conflicting reports about whether The Flash director Andy Muschietti is still attached to helm The Brave and The Bold, and Gunn has since admitted that the movie have "changed" fairly significantly since the above announcement.

There's been speculation that the new Batman could be introduced sooner, possibly even in 2027's Man of Tomorrow (we'd say this is highly unlikely).

About The Author:
MarkCassidy
Member Since 11/9/2008
Mark Cassidy is a writer, photographer, amateur filmmaker, and Rotten Tomatoes-approved critic from Dublin, Ireland.
TRANSFORMERS Star Megan Fox Seemingly Confirms Poison Ivy Interest After Viral Photo Dump
Related:

TRANSFORMERS Star Megan Fox Seemingly Confirms Poison Ivy Interest After Viral Photo Dump

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Shares New BTS Look At Wayne T. Carr As Green Lantern John Stewart
Recommended For You:

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Shares New BTS Look At Wayne T. Carr As Green Lantern John Stewart

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Nonameforme
Nonameforme - 2/24/2026, 4:27 PM
I dont see it
dragon316
dragon316 - 2/24/2026, 7:57 PM
@Nonameforme - don’t need see it need believe it looks are not everything not important thing look at actresss play super girl in flash did you see that stupid fan casting trash
GuardianAngel
GuardianAngel - 2/24/2026, 10:33 PM
@Nonameforme - User Comment Image
harryba11zack
harryba11zack - 2/24/2026, 4:31 PM
i'll think about it
Repian
Repian - 2/24/2026, 4:33 PM
I see it.
User Comment Image
ProfessorWhy
ProfessorWhy - 2/24/2026, 4:36 PM
We won't know for sure until the superfriends movie comes out and we see him doing the Batusi with Cornsweater
SummersEssex
SummersEssex - 2/24/2026, 4:40 PM
I still like Ritchson for it. But it seems that is as likely as Affleck coming back, so, whatever. They'll pick someone good that I will either not like or not care about initially and then make a movie that does not blow me away but I still enjoy and ultimately support even though it's still not quite what I think it could have been.

And my life will go on.
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/24/2026, 4:47 PM
@SummersEssex - weirdly enough unless they are want someone like Absolute Batman physically , I think he’s too big for the role.

I could see him being threatening and physically imposing as Batman but not entirely sure about him as Bruce Wayne.

Him as Captain Atom or Orion could be cool though!!.

User Comment Image

User Comment Image
ImNotaBot
ImNotaBot - 2/24/2026, 4:52 PM
@SummersEssex - I also like Ritchson after watching Reacher the problem with him is that i can only see him as Batman and not Bruce Wayne. He stands out too much and makes you feel like everyone would discover his secret identity lol. I think Ritchson is a better fit for Ted Grant.
EternalKnight
EternalKnight - 2/24/2026, 6:23 PM
@ImNotaBot - I would love for Richson to be Ted Grant/Wildcat! Perfect role for him IMO.
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/24/2026, 4:45 PM
I haven’t seen “Love Story” but the guy certainly has the look for Bruce imo so I wouldn’t mind if he was under consideration for the role at the least tbh…

User Comment Image

User Comment Image

Idk if he has acting chops but visually , I could see him as Bruce Wayne but I’m not sure about him as Batman as of yet.

Anyway , I really hope we get DCU Batman casting sooner than later!!.
ImNotaBot
ImNotaBot - 2/24/2026, 4:47 PM
He has the jaw line and he looks like some of Bruce Wayne versions from the comics mainly Neal Adams. But tbh a lot of actors out there can look like some version of Bruce Wayne from the comics, i don't think the looks are the most important element about the character. Keaton does not have the jaw line and they made him look great under the mask.

I like how almost all Batman castings we got so far were "controversial" because most of them didn't seem to fit visualy but each of them added something unique to the role just like all the Bond actors we get so far that also make each approach also unique.
MisterBones
MisterBones - 2/24/2026, 4:50 PM
Surprised. I can actually see it. He has the look
lazlodaytona
lazlodaytona - 2/24/2026, 4:55 PM
We all know it should be Jim Carrey.
micvalpro
micvalpro - 2/24/2026, 5:02 PM
The reason hes the new IT guy is really only because hes portraying JFK Jr. and JFK Jr. was basically our real life Bruce Wayne.
THEDARKKNIGHT1939
THEDARKKNIGHT1939 - 2/24/2026, 5:07 PM
All of the fan castings so far have been trash. This one though... not bad.
Slushythrone455
Slushythrone455 - 2/24/2026, 5:07 PM
I pray the DCU does not make it far enough to cast the Batman. What brother should just put the toys back in the box for a little while and wait until we actually want more superhero movies
JackDeth
JackDeth - 2/24/2026, 7:22 PM
@Slushythrone455 - What a WEIRD thing to pray for. Who is this 'we' you speak of?
DocSpock
DocSpock - 2/24/2026, 5:17 PM

A Canadian? Gross! That's worse than another brit.

TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/24/2026, 5:20 PM
Brandon Sklenar still is my choice honestly…

Still perhaps the only actor I have seen of the fancasted ones that could play both Bruce Wayne/Batman imo!!.

?si=_Yx561YpMalyXpwE

User Comment Image
HistoryofMatt
HistoryofMatt - 2/24/2026, 5:48 PM
User Comment Image
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 2/24/2026, 6:01 PM
Cast as Batman? Oh no thanks we already got one.
User Comment Image
TheNewYorkerr
TheNewYorkerr - 2/24/2026, 6:02 PM
Okay, JFK JR. Hold your utility belt.
TangerineAlfred
TangerineAlfred - 2/25/2026, 12:07 AM
Will anyone even care about who is cast as Batman by the time this project gets off the ground? We'll have had two more Pattinson movies before the DCU Batman is introduced, and numerous other in-universe projects. It doesn't make sense to wait so long to introduce a years-active Batman into this universe so late into it, unless they just plan on randomly having his silhouette make appearances in random things. I just don't get this.
UltimaRex
UltimaRex - 2/25/2026, 7:58 AM
@TangerineAlfred - you're working off debunked rumours. BatB will likely be between Batman pII and pIII.
Deadinside
Deadinside - 2/25/2026, 12:36 PM
Hey, as long as it's not "grounded", ala Nolan...Reeves...!
I want the fantastical, I want the crazy, I want the over the top...!
I want to see Batman jump off of a rooftop throwing his line, grabbing a gargoyle and swinging...!
I want to see him go up against Man-Bat...Clayface...Firefly...! ☮️😉
Nomis929
Nomis929 - 2/25/2026, 12:42 PM
He certainly got the Bruce Wayne look, no doubt there.

User Comment Image

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder