KEEPER Reviews Label Osgood Perkins' Latest His "Worst Movie Yet"; Rotten Tomatoes Score Revealed

Keeper is now in theaters, and the review embargo for Osgood Perkins (Longlegs, The Monkey, The Blackcoat's Daughter) latest horror film has lifted.

Though the movie has been praised for its creepy atmosphere, striking visuals and She-Hulk: Attorney at Law star Tatiana Maslany's lead performance, a lot of critics were disappointed, with some going so far as to label it Perkins' first misfire and "worst movie yet." Their main issues seem to be a confusing, "nonsensical" plot and an ending that doesn't deliver the answers audiences will be expecting.

The film hit Rotten Tomatoes with a "rotten" 40%, but has since risen to a slightly more respectable 51%.

Keeper stars Tatiana Maslany (She-Hulk: Attorney at Law, Orphan Black) and Rossif Sutherland (Possessor), and follows a couple as they "escape for a romantic anniversary weekend at a secluded cabin. When Malcolm (Sutherland) suddenly returns to the city, Liz (Maslany) finds herself isolated and in the presence of an unspeakable evil that unveils the cabin’s horrifying secrets."

KEEPER had me on the edge of my seat from first frame to last. Perkins’s mastery of tension and freaky imagery reach new heights, bolstered by a terrific Tatiana Maslany. The perfectly sick joke of the ending makes up for the lack of humor elsewhere. Go in as blind as possible. pic.twitter.com/NMt8pD5MSp

— Dancin' Dan in Halloweenland (@dancindanonfilm) November 14, 2025

If you vibe with that Osgood Perkins house style, you'll probably love KEEPER. I do. And I did. It's a fairy tale nightmare that effectively unnerves & completely satisfies in the end. Some real haunting imagery in there. Osgood doesn't miss. Go in blind; let it under your skin. pic.twitter.com/un3igdJ6ki

— John Squires 🎃 (@FreddyInSpace) November 13, 2025

Keeper is filled with the type of dark atmosphere, visuals and weirdness we’ve come to expect from Osgood Perkins. Unfortunately, Lepard’s screenplay doesn’t dig deep enough into the subject matter, and what you’re left with is a movie that fails to reach its full potential. pic.twitter.com/VCW7t2X6U6

— Epic Film Guys ® (@EpicFilmGuys) November 14, 2025

I really liked the new Osgood Perkins horror movie KEEPER -- smaller scale than his last couple, but a lot of great horror imagery. Reviewed it for The Guardian: https://t.co/zxsSJy3rsL

— Jesse Hassenger (@rockmarooned) November 13, 2025

#Keeper is one of the most confusing horror movies I've seen all year.

It's just throwing horror ideas at the wall and seeing what sticks. Undeveloped characters; everything is so vague. It fails as both a horror film and a commentary on romance. Unanswered questions! pic.twitter.com/7AOgProZ0l

— Jonathan Sim (@TheJonathanSim) November 13, 2025

‘Keeper’ Review: Not Even the Great Tatiana Maslany Can Save Oz Perkins from His Worst Movie Yet https://t.co/3PBwiKHqYb

— IndieWire (@IndieWire) November 13, 2025

'Keeper' Review: Osgood Perkins Directs an 'Impressonistic' Serial-Killer Movie — Lots of Creepy Atmosphere, Not Much Logic https://t.co/oSVPDrsc36

— Variety (@Variety) November 14, 2025

After months of cryptic marketing, Osgood Perkins' KEEPER is here, and Michael Gingold's review is here to tell you if it lives up to the hype. https://t.co/PkOzcxwFnL

— FANGORIA (@FANGORIA) November 13, 2025

Tatiana Maslany (The Monkey) embarks on a romantic weekend getaway in Osgood Perkins’ latest dark trip, KEEPER. An exclusive new clip turns romance into terror with the arrival of an unexpected visitor.

Hell awaits when Keeper opens in theaters on November 14 from Neon. pic.twitter.com/fFIh42EYbC

— Bloody Disgusting (@BDisgusting) November 7, 2025

New poster for Osgood Perkins’ #Keeper, starring Tatiana Maslany. pic.twitter.com/gHPak3oCAx

— Rotten Tomatoes 🍅 (@RottenTomatoes) October 15, 2025

Guillermo del Toro. James Wan. Damien Leone.

Osgood Perkins’ KEEPER has been unanimously hailed by the modern masters of horror. In theaters November 14. pic.twitter.com/0aFpuMrfnn

— NEON (@neonrated) October 15, 2025

A locked door. A dead phone. A creature in pursuit. There is no escape.

Watch a clip from Osgood Perkins's KEEPER, in theaters November 14. pic.twitter.com/Rx88VVkjBv

— Bloody Disgusting (@BDisgusting) October 15, 2025

“During an anniversary getaway at a remote cabin, a wife (Tatiana Maslany) is left alone after her husband (Rossif Sutherland) departs, only to confront a sinister presence that exposes the cabin’s chilling past,”

Keeper also stars Tess Degenstein, Claire Friesen, and Christin Park, and is set to release in theaters on November 14.