The best and worst Retcons

Known for their infamy I will count down the 5 best and 5 worst.

Editorial Opinion
By StuckInPanels - Jul 12, 2010 12:07 PM EST
Filed Under: Other

Hey guys and gals. Well what can you say about retcons? Apparently a lot, they are known for taking a pre-establishing character, story, or concept and adding a new thing into the mix and can drastically affect the community we are a part of. Not only affecting us but also it can tarnish a once well respected character, story, or concept. Now while most Retcons are seen for their cheap cop-out feel, some have actually made some characters, stories, or concepts much better. So I'm gonna do two lists; 5 of the best known retcons and the 5 worse retcons.With that let me begin with the best.

Best Retcons

#5. Wanda and Pietro being Magneto's children: Now I sorta put this on the bottom because while its one of the better known. Wanda and Pietro Maximoff were both raised by gypsies, they grew up discovering that they themselves have meta-human abilities and thus used them in their own ways. They joined the Avengers for awhile even tho they were considered dangerous for being associated with Magneto as their children. Thanks to this simple retcon we got the infamous House of M story and now we are about to see the return of Wanda in Avengers: children's crusade.

#4. Static Shock joining the Teen Titans: now this an obscure retcon that actually crosses over from screen to page. In the Justice League and Static Shock team-up episode,Static asks Batman about Robin's whereabouts. Batman makes a tiny subtle mention that he's with the Titans and that Static would eventually see them. Wouldn't you know that he eventually did return in the comics and came into the titans as a member.

#3. Balder also being an Odin-son: Again this is another one of those subtle retcons but it is one of the more effective ones. In JMS's run of Thor, not only did he return one of the best characters in Marvel's lineup but also returning all the patron's of Asgard but he made Balder a much more interesting and well defined character. Balder in the beginning of this new run, was ambitious and wanted more out of his found existence. It's until Loki telling Balder that he too is a son of Odin, thus giving him the right to the throne. After he does gain the right to rule, he was for awhile Loki's lap dog, kinda like a Cheney/Bush thing, he ultimately steps up his game, grows a set, and actually does some awesome things during and post Siege.

#2. Superman no longer the LAST son of Krypton: this is sort of a Retcon of a Retcon. A long time back it was planned that all of Superman's excess kryptonian baggage was to destroyed or removed entirely thus leaving only our Superman to be the last and only survive of his home world. This plan was a major factor with Crisis on Infinite Earths. We saw Super-girl die at the hands of the Anti-monitor and having superboy prime and Earth II Superman lost in a time dimension. Until the events of Infinite Crisis, we got them all back and eventually a New Krypton, along with the evil general ZOD.

and the # 1 top retcon

#1. Namor the FIRST Mutant: Now this is something many are willing to fight over and all it is is a simple misuse of the term in context. Now many say that Namor is not the first mutant because there have been many accounts of Mutant activity long before his time, the best known is Apocalypse. Well this is in terms of APPEARANCE, so Namor is in fact the first seen mutant. Which in terms of the early days, he and the X-men term of Mutants were much different, he seemed to just be tacked in with them also

So those were the best that I could find, now here comes the worse offenders.

#5. Wolverine's Bone Claws: Now this is one that many consider to be okay with but it completely alters the awesome and mysterious nature that was Logan. They turned him from a shadowy loner who thrills to kill, into every other mutant out there, he hits puberty and he gets his power, end of story. Before his retcon his adamantium claws were mechanical based, until he had his metal ripped out of him by Magneto and showing that underneath the claws were in-fact BONE. However now that he's back to wearing his good old metal claws once again.

#4. Donna Troy and her many lives: Now this is one that I never read about, but I have heard that thanks to Superboy Prime and his infamous retcon punch caused a huge mess of retcons. Donna Troy's really seemed the most effective. She has be giving various amounts back stories, always changing and making it more difficult for the readers to follow.

#3. The Beyonder is an Inhuman: This to me is a huge slap in the face to such a mysterious and lets face it most interesting cosmic being alive. During the AWESOME Secret Wars event, the mysterious and powerful entity known as the Beyonder brought 12 heroes and 12 villains to a self constructed planet to do battle. He gets attacked by Dr. Doom and they both disappear, but Doom returns quicker. His true origin is tarnished during the comic New Avengers: Illuminati, where Tony Stark, Mr. Fantastic, Xavier, and Black Bolt find the Beyonder in a human form. Black Bolt then tells him via Xavier that the Beyonder is a mutant inhuman who gets infected with the terigen mist, thus causing him to posses such tremendous power. Way to go there Marvel, taking awesome and mysterious characters and pissing all over them.

#2. Hal Jordan's hair change: Now this is actually part of a reason. In the very earlier days of Hal Jordan he had brown hair and some small patches of white hair on the sides of his hair just above the ears. However it turns out that was actually part of him having part in becoming Parallax's host for some time. Now it was most likely due to poor sales as his character was dipping in interest and they wanted to revamp him, now thanks to Geoff Johns he's back to the status quo minus the gray.

and the #1 worse retcon of all TIME*dramatic drum roll*

#1. Norman Osborn as the Green Goblin: This was a retcon before it was even retconned. Lets turn back the clock, in the begin of Spider-man's early runs, Steve Ditko was a heavy believer in the Ayn Rand belief of objectivism in terms of heroism. He was planning on making on revealing the Green Goblin to be a person totally unrelated to the Spider-man universe, considering that all villains are someone you don't know. However the big wigs at the time thought it would confuse the readers so they told him to make it Norman Osborn, thus adding more tension to Harry and Peters friendship. Now to me, thats a huge slap in the face of the creator. Imagine how much history and continuity that would never be if Norman was NEVER the Green Goblin. Gwen Stacy, Thunderbolts, and Dark Avengers would be totally different. It's a retcon that will never be. I bet you were want to see OMD or BND but this to me is the biggest thing in Spider-mans history.

And there you have my list of best and worse retcons. Now I did miss a ton of better or worse retcons but I stuck with the ones I thought were the more interesting and well known. If you know of any others, I like to hear about them. Til my next article, Aki87 OUT!!!

New Academy Rules State Generative AI Use Will Not Impact Oscar Eligibility
Related:

New Academy Rules State Generative AI Use Will Not Impact Oscar Eligibility

THE DARK TOWER Gets A Promising Update From Mike Flanagan As He Vows Not To Let Stephen King Down
Recommended For You:

THE DARK TOWER Gets A Promising Update From Mike Flanagan As He Vows Not To Let Stephen King Down

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

BIGBMH
BIGBMH - 7/12/2010, 1:25 PM
I don't get why making Norman the Goblin was a bad thing. I think it's much better than him being some random guy. I also like the bon claws.
Nice article though. I didn't know that Pietro and Wanda weren't originally Magneto's kids.
StuckInPanels
StuckInPanels - 7/12/2010, 2:13 PM
@big...I don't hate Norman, he's a great villain, but as I said, imagine what would Spidey's life be had Norman NOT be GG.
Destroyer14
Destroyer14 - 7/12/2010, 2:22 PM
Good article. I don't agree with the Green Goblin, other than that, I agree with everything.
CorndogBurglar
CorndogBurglar - 7/12/2010, 3:31 PM
@ Aki87

this is a good article, but you're a little off with your Namor: First Mutant explanation.

It is known and recognized within characters in the Marvel Universe that Namor is in fact the first mutant. I can't remember for the life of me which story it is, but I have an issue of X-Men where one of them is teaching a class, and the teacher asks who the first mutant is, and one of the children answers Namor. The teacher (again, can't remember what character) said that he was right.

You're right, according to appearance, Namor is the first mutant, but they also stick to that in the actual comics too. I hate it, because, like you said, Apocalypse is a mutant and he was born in ancient Egypt. So technically, he would be the first mutant. its something that they never address in the comics themselves, and it irritates me to no end.
tazmaniak
tazmaniak - 7/12/2010, 3:43 PM
I also disagree about the Green Goblin thing.I don't see it as a retcon.My definition is directly contradicting established continuity in order to suit a current story.Anything else is just creating backstory.Alot of people get those confused.Now, I wasn't reading Spidey back then(wasn't born yet) but did making Norman the the Goblin contradict anything?Was Norman and the Goblin ever seen on panel together?Probably not.

On the Static front.It's not a retcon that he joined the Titans, as it happened in current continuity.It's not like they said he joined at some point in the past, and we just didn't know.I don't see what the cartoon has to do with anything.The actual retcon is the Dakotaverse now being apart of the DC Universe proper.But that's an in story retcon, so it doesn't count.

I had no clue we didn't always know Balder was Odin's son.I've been reading comics since 1994, and had always thought Balder was his son.I didn't read the story, but how was it explained?Did Odin and Frigga not raise him?Why didn't they tell him he was their son?
StuckInPanels
StuckInPanels - 7/12/2010, 4:32 PM
@TAZ...I agree with you that we weren't born then and the reasoning behind Norman being the Green Goblin is up for debate but from what Linkara said about Ditko and his Objectivism beliefs saying that GG should be someone unrelated to the character because not all villains are someone you know
tazmaniak
tazmaniak - 7/12/2010, 9:23 PM
Bucky surviving the plane explosion was a good retcon.Also, Jessica Jones was a good retcon character.
CorndogBurglar
CorndogBurglar - 7/13/2010, 7:43 AM
@ anil

JMS definately rocked the boat hard with that one, as well as the whole Spider-Totem story.
tazmaniak
tazmaniak - 7/14/2010, 8:28 AM
@Anil Rickly, while I agree the character doesn't really hold any real significance now, we still got Alias from her introduction.
View Recorder