Between the official beginning of the Marvel Cinematic Universe in 2008 and 2010,
Marvel Studios managed to release three movies:
Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk and Iron Man 2. The studio decided to take a one-year break after the rushed into production
Iron Man 2 and instead released two movies in 2011, Kenneth Branagh’s
Thor and Joe Johnston’s
Captain America: The First Avenger.
Let’s take a look at the first movie, the beginning of the weirdest MCU trilogy, where every entry was made by a different director with his own sensibilities and vision of Asgard. It’s time to talk about the movie that opened the doors to the Marvel Cosmic Universe – Kenneth Branagh’s
Thor.
WHOSOEVER HOLDS THESE RIGHTS, IF HE BE WORTHY, SHALL POSSESS THE POWER OF THOR
The first talks about a potential movie adaptation of Thor took place in 1990. After shooting The Evil Dead in 1981, Sam Raimi (Army of Darkness) took a break to work as a counselor at Camp Tamakwa in Algonquin Park, Canada. The director was a huge Spider-Man fan and knew that he had to leave the camp to check the state of the film’s cut, so he obviously agreed to ask Stan Lee, who created the character with Steve Ditko, to sign posters for campers.
Raimi didn’t realize how complicated meeting with his comic book guru could be until a secretary turned him away. “That’s how I first met Stan Lee,” Raimi recalled, “by being rejected by him and not wanting to let those kids down. I became a forger of his autograph. Ya know, ‘All the best, Excelsior! To all the kids at Tamakwa — Stan Lee.’ ” It didn’t stop the aspiring director from attempting on meeting Lee and they finally had a chance to talk ten years later, in 1990.
At the time, Raimi finished directing Darkman and convinced Lee, who also had ambitious plans to bring Marvel characters on the big screen after many DC’s successes, especially Tim Burton’s Batman and four Superman movies, to pitch together a Thor movie to 20th Century Fox. “It was thrilling to be with Stan Lee and hysterical the way that we had to explain who Thor was to executives,” Raimi laughed, “walking out of there going, ‘We didn’t get it! They think it’s gonna be some Hercules movie or something”, Raimi said Variety in 2006. His vision of Thor ultimately didn’t come together, but a decade later he directed one of the biggest movies of all time and his passion project, Spider-Man.
Thor remained abandoned until April 1997. That year, Marvel Studios decided to shift gears and started developing (at least) fifteen movies at once, including X-Men, Namor: Sub-Mariner, Silver Surfer, Fantastic Four, Daredevil, Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk, Luke Cage, Venom, Blade: Vampire Hunter, Doctor Strange, Spider-Man, Black Panther, Ghost Rider and Captain America. Marvel was also looking for homes for Thor and The Punisher, but the company didn’t announce any movement in their development for a long time. Most of these movies have lost directors sooner or later.
After the box office and critical success of Bryan Singer’s
X-Men, Marvel Studios hit on an idea to adapt
Thor on a small screen. UPN was in talks for airing the potential series and approached Tyler Mane (
X-Men, Troy) to play the lead role. After years of unsuccessful development, Sony Pictures Entertainment purchased the film rights and asked David S. Goyer (
Batman Begins, Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance) to write and direct the movie in December 2004. Goyer ultimately left the project a year later.
Mark Protosevich (
I Am Legend, Old Boy), who was a big fan of the comic version of
Thor, agreed to write the screenplay for the movie that was sold to Paramount Pictures. On May 5, 2007 Marvel officially announced that
Iron Man, Ant-Man, The Incredible Hulk, Captain America and
Thor are on their way on the big screen, all made within Marvel Studios.
On June 2007, Los Angeles Times revealed that writer J. Michael Straczynski was working on a
Silver Surfer movie for Fox, and also that Protosevich has finished his
Thor screenplay. In the middle of the summer, Variety interviewed Matthew Vaughn (
X-Men: First Class, Kingsman: Secret Service) and here’s what the director had to say about his rumored involvement in
Thor: “
I've been discussing it with Marvel. I really like the Marvel guys, and it would be good to make”, the director explained.
“We're trying to find something to work on together. If Thor is going to happen, I don't know. I'm seeing them again next week. And, the other problem is the whole strike [of the Writers Guild of America, Directors Guild of America, and Screen Actors Guild] thing. It's, like, we'd like to make a movie before the strike, so whether Thor could be the one, I don't know”.
A month after that interview, IESB announced that “
industry circles” said that Kevin McKidd (
16 Years of Alcohol, Journeyman) was cast as Thor. During a conference call for
Journeyman, the actor said: "
It’s semi true, I didn't know about it either until I heard the rumors and I called my agent and he went, yeah, yeah, we've been talking to them about it. But the last I heard from my agent, they're talking that they want to go for somebody much younger, a 19/20-year-old, for that role. So they're re-conceptualizing it as we speak."
Vaughn has discussed what he could bring to the table as a director of Thor and how he would approach adapting a hero who’s solo movie has been in various stages of development for almost twenty years, "You've got Thor and Odin, and it's set in Asgard. It's not going to be like Lord of the Rings or even Narnia. I think it's important to keep it comic-book. We're not doing the Thor of Norse mythology. We're doing the Marvel Thor." One thing was certain: "They actually said to me, 'You are going to make Thor more macho? Right?' Well, don't worry: Thor's not going to be wearing a dress."
According to the Guardian, Vaughn approached Protosevich to rewrite his script together. The director revealed that “Marvel loves the script. The only problem is that it has been costed at $300 million and they ask how I am going to reduce it by $150m. I think I prefer being asked what it's like working with De Niro.”
With his Stardust being a moderate success in the US and a big hit in the UK, Vaughn has decided to bring the Thor production to his native land. The director told a Daily Mail reporter that "It obviously bought us luck filming at home and I'm relieved that the movie has performed so well in my own country.” Thor was initially slated for a 2009 release, but the 2007–2008 Writers Guild of America strike has successfully made creating the movie even more difficult.
Marvel Studios started 2008 with an announcement that they came to an agreement with the WGA, meaning that Captain America, Thor and Ant-Man could return to the normal developement again. After the unexpected success of Favreau’s Iron Man, Marvel Studios gave Thor a new release date of June 4, 2010, with Iron Man 2 being used to introduce the character (in a post-credits scene).
On May 5th, The Hollywood Reporter announced that “Matthew Vaughn no longer is attached to direct the project because his holding deal expired December." He adapted Millar’s Kick Ass instead.
Umberto Gonzalez and the Latino Review crew started all sorts of rumors about a potential casting decisions. Probably the most interesting (and absurd) one said that Marvel was looking for Brad Pitt (Twelve Monkeys, Big Short) to play Odinson.
After a year since the last announcement regarding Thor, Variety reported that actor and director Kenneth Branagh, who's best known to the general public as Harry Potter's narcissistic "defense against the dark arts" professor in The Chamber of Secrets, was negotiating to direct Thor. At the time, Branagh was drawing raves on the London stage in the title role of Ivanov. Chekhov’s drama had a big input on the creative process behind Thor, as Tom Hiddleston, who would be ultimately cast as Loki, was starring in the stage play alongside Branagh. They also worked together on Wallander.
IESB.net broke the odd news that James Bond himself, Daniel Craig (Layer Cake, Infamous) was approached to play Thor, but the actor decided to turn down the role because: “It would be too much of a power trip playing both James Bond and the mighty Thor."
After two months of speculation, Branagh officially confirmed that he would sit in the director’s chair of Thor. At Valkirie's press junket the actor told MTV that “I am directing “Thor” or “The Mighty Thor’ as you might like to call it. I think it will be ‘Thor’.” Branagh also kindly debunked the rumors that Kevin McKidd might be portraying Odinson “There’s been lots of talk [about casting] — I sound like a politician — but we are too early at this stage. We’re getting the story and the visual effects together and all of that is very exciting. Someone sensational is going to play the part but it is early days.”
Former Marvel Comics Editor-in-Chief Joe Quesada revealed at New York Comic Con 2009 that Branagh’s knowledge of the Marvel Universe impressed him: “You just thought, ‘Wow. This guy has immersed himself in the Marvel culture — not just in Thor — but in the Marvel universe in general,” Quesada said. “He knew a lot of stuff — some things that I didn’t even know. He was reciting Thor stuff from the past, continuity events, quotes from different books, little bits and pieces from stories that he really found fascinating — whether they were old [Jack] Kirby and [Stan] Lee stories or [Walter] Simonson stories or modern stuff that we’re doing. He really got it,” Quesada concluded.
According to IESB, Josh Hartnett (Pearl Harbor, 40 Days and 40 Nights) was gearing up to play Loki, Thor’s villainous brother. The actor apparently has met with Branagh and was on the short list to play the main villain in the film. However, Deadline Hollywood revealed a much more colorful and packed list of actors who were being considered for the role of Thor, Son of Odin.
The fascinating list includes Charlie Hunnam (Sons of Anarchy, The Lost City of Z), Tom Hiddleston (The Gathering Storm, Kong: Skull Island), Alexander Skarsgård (True Blood, The Legend of Tarzan), Liam Hemsworth (The Hunger Games, Independence Day: Resurgence) and Joel Kinnaman (RoboCop, Suicide Squad). Deadline also leaked an information that Natalie Portman (Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, Black Swan) was in the lead for an important female role, and the rumor turned out to be true.
Channing Tatum (22 Jump Street, Logan Lucky) told MTV News that he was in talks, and even had a chance to meet Branagh to play Thor but the studio was looking for someone more “Nordic-looking.”
Finally, after months of speculation and questions, Deadline was first again to announce that Marvel Studios has found their Mighty Thor, Chris Hemsworth (Rush, The Huntsman: Winter's War). At the time, the 25-year-old Australian actor was shooting Joss Whedon’s Cabin In The Woods. According to the website, Hemsworth has read for the part, but wasn’t given a test because a casting director had nixed his early on. His younger brother, Liam had a chance to test for the role, but Kevin Feige passed on him. Chris’ manager, Willam Ward managed to persuade the producer to give him another chance. Branagh saw the actor's performance and made the final casting decision.
The movie’s release date has also been changed and Thor was set to release on May 20, 2011.
Shortly after the first official casting announcement, Deadline announced that the part of Loki has gone to Tom Hiddleston. It was the third time the actor would work with Branagh. Hiddleston was on a six month diet to get lean for playing Loki, “'Ken[neth Branagh] wants Loki to have a lean and hungry look, like Cassius in Julius Caesar. Physically, he can't be posing as Thor”, the actor told MTV. "Loki's like a comic book version of Edmund in King Lear, but nastier," he added. "Loki's skilled in black magic and sorcery. He's a shape-shifter and has all sorts of super powers from the dark arts. He can turn clouds into dragons, things like that."
Branagh also had an opportunity to chat with MTV and revealed his inspirations for Thor, “I think that (the comics) go through golden patches and purple patches and everyone has personal favorites,” Branagh told MTV News. “The recent runs have been marvelous. The J. Michael Straczynski run has been a tremendous achievement. But I've also been reading way back, reading classic, vintage runs as well. There are many Thors and many accounts of the stories across nearly 50 years of the comics. We look to raid from the best.”
In another MTV interview, Guillermo Del Toro (Hellboy, The Shape of Water) has told that he was approached by Marvel to direct Thor’s big screen debut. “I’m a fan of Jack Kirby and the power he has, and I’m a fan of the original mythology," Del Toro explained. “So I thought we could go back to the original mythology a lot. I love Loki, I think he’s a great figure.” He ultimately abandoned the project to direct Hobbit, but that also didn’t work out for him.
Kevin Feige asked about how he felt about putting Hemsworth to play The God Of Thunder responded that "As new actors make their way into feature films, it is a rare thing to find someone who is not only immensely watchable and engaging, but can also represent a timeless and key character from the Marvel universe in such a compelling way. We have been watching Chris hone his craft over the last several months and due to his persistence and talent he rose above everyone else embodying the actor we were looking for."
Writer Brian Michael Bendis, who was also a part of Marvel’s creative committee with Alan Fine, Dan Buckley and Joe Quesada, said that Branagh’s presentation was “Shakespearean, with flourishes,” Bendis told Newsarama. “It was cool. It was a lot of fun. My wife goes, okay, that one I’m jealous of. She’s got a crush on him. And honestly, he’s not a let-down. I can see it. I can understand it. You’re spending enough time with someone that you know if they’re cool. And he’s cool.”
The end of 2009 was filled with casting announcements for Thor. Natalie Portman was officially cast as Dr. Jane Foster, the movie’s female lead. His son didn’t make the cut, but Stellan Skarsgård (Good Will Hunting, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo) was lucky enough to join the cast. Sir Anthony Hopkins (The Silence of the Lambs, Nixon) was confirmed to play of Odin, the King of Asgard and the father of Thor and Loki. The Warriors Three have been cast as well - Stuart Townsend, Ray Stevenson and Tadanobu Asano. Jaimie Alexander (The Last Stand, Blindspot) and Colm Feore (Storm of the Century, Chicago) also joined the crew as Lady Sif and King Laufey. Idris Elba (Beasts of No Nation, The Dark Tower) would play Heimdall, the guardian of Asgard. Rene Russo (Yours, Mine and Ours, Lethal Weapon 4) has been cast as Frigga, Thor's mother.
Zachary Levi (Heroes Reborn, Shazam) revealed that he turned down a role in Thor for Chuck. He was cast as Fandral the Dashing. The actor ultimately played the character in Thor: The Dark World.
At the press conference for Jim Sheridan's Brothers, Natalie Portman explained why she decided to play Jane Foster in the movie, "I just thought it sounded like a weird idea because Kenneth Branagh's directing it, so I was just like, 'Kenneth Branagh doing 'Thor' is super-weird. I've gotta do it.'"
Arguably one of the best news in the history of the Marvel Cinematic Universe was announced on November 26, 2009 when Jeremy Renner (The Hurt Locker, Wind River) revealed that he’s had talks with Marvel Studios about playing Hawkeye with a possible cameo in Thor, leading to a major role in The Avengers. "Hawkeye could be interesting”, Renner told Empire. “They're going to send me some stuff on it, see what it is." But I think they're pretty awesome, trying to make superhero movies almost plausible and not just some fantasy thing."
The actor also said that the movie version of the beloved character wouldn’t be similar to the comic books, "...it's going to be modernized, it's not going to be the guy with the big purple [mask], it's not going to be a guy in tights. It's going to be a guy in sunglasses and a vest. He's going to be more modernized and I'm gonna say, 'A cooler-looking version' and not the big weird costume he had on. I don't think they're going that route."
Paramount and Marvel Entertainment have pushed up the release of Thor by two weeks to May 6, 2011 to give Rob Marshall’s Pirates of the Caribbean 4: On Stranger Tides a room to breathe.
Finally, on January 11, 2010, Thor officially began filming under the direction of Kenneth Branagh.
Buf Compagnie, the VFX company that has worked on Andy and Larry Wachowski's Martix: Revolutions and James Cameron’s Avatar was pitched by Marvel to be the leading VFX company on Thor.
The New York Daily has reported that Hopkins has been vocally criticizing Chris Hemsworth's acting ability on the set. The rumor was debunked by Marvel, Hopkins’s wife, Stella and Jaimie Alexander. Finally, even Sir Anthony decided to express his feeling about the whole situation: “I am having the time of my life making Thor with Ken and Chris. They have made every day immensely fun and collaborative, and we're all puzzled that someone would fabricate a story suggesting otherwise. I'm proud to say that Thor has been one of the great experiences of my career.”
In an interview with LA Times, Branagh compared his efforts to what Jon Favreau achieved with Iron Man, “It’s a different story, and also, in that regard, Jon is a bit of a genius when it comes to that orchestration and getting the max out of another genius in Downey,” Branagh said. “It’s how you dance pretty close to the edge to get the sort of modernity and the edge that ‘Iron Man’ has and the real sharp comic sensibility of those two men. So it’s a different kind of dance," he concluded.
Chris Hemsworth has also spoken about his rumored conflict with Sir Hopkins, and said that “He [Hopkins] rang me afterwards and we had a good laugh about it. He said, 'Look, you can't take this stuff too seriously,' and told me a bunch of stories about ridiculous things that had been written about him over the years. You always assume there's some truth in it but on every point in that article they got it wrong...”
A month before the release of Branagh’s Thor, Box Office Pro updated their tracking to a $73 million opening and a $208 million domestic total score.
The biggest online movie websites have started to slowly release their reviews for Thor three weeks before the movie’s premiere in the US. Some websites called Branagh’s movie “The Best Marvel Movie Yet”, some gave it 3.5/5. With generally favorable reviews, Thor hit movie theaters on May 6, 2011.