X-Men: DOFP - Should Hugh Quit While He's Ahead?

X-Men: DOFP - Should Hugh Quit While He's Ahead?

With negotiations being made about Wolverine's 3rd solo film (also counting that thing that happened in 2009), it raises the question, how long is Jack Hughman (joke) going to keep this up? Well lets look at a few points...

Editorial Opinion
By ClarkKent89 - Nov 17, 2013 10:11 AM EST
Filed Under: X-Men

(If any sentences, opinions are similar to other comments or articles posted, it was entirely unintentional as I went into this fresh-minded. Please Enjoy)

-Don't Call Me, I'll Call You



There's not a lot wrong with an actor being associated with a certain character, in some cases it can support that actor's position, but in others it can limit not their acting range, but reputation-al one. A good example of this is in Doctor Who, and for those of you who don't watch the show, the main character "The Doctor" is an alien called a Time Lord that can regenerate instead of dying so certain aspects of his character, personality are changed and an entirely different body and face is given before he is killed and this has kept the show going for what next Saturday, 23rd of November will be 50 years. The ninth actor to take on the role, Christopher Eccleston (Malekith, Thor: TDW) played the character in 2005 when it was being revived after 16 years of cancellation, and after one series of playing him, he hasn't quite been able to escape it. Even with blockbusters like G.I Joe, and Thor 2 under his belt; he's been quoted to not enjoying working on DW, and tries to escape questions and interviews whenever presented to him... I'm not saying that in ten years Hugh will try and avoid answering questions about Wolverine, but there comes a point where everyone gets tired.

-I'm Too Old For This S**t


Last month, Hugh Jackman turned 45 and still looks like he could juggle trucks; the guy's absolutely ripped whenever he's asked to be and as far as I know, in his everyday life. So what's with the title? We've seen in the DOFP trailer that he'll be donning some bad-ass grey sides and popping bullets out of his abs, and yet people will still bring his age into the equation because it might not necessarily be how old he is, but how long he's been in the series.. The first X-Men came out in 2000, so he filmed it in 1999 which means he's been playing the character along 14 years seven times. Although it's not year by year, that's a big commitment, the spaces between his knuckles must be killing; but in all seriousness I don't think Jackman's interested in a $500 million contract, because he's expressed multiple times what the character means to him and how much he loves him to the point where he pushes the studio to make an entire solo film, and when that flops, pushes them to do another. Would you mind seeing Hugh in 15 years time make a film about a pissed-off Old Man Logon moaning about his eyebrows sticking out and his claws getting wrinkly?

-Time For A Reboot


Lots of fans (or people) are still unimpressed by Fox's efforts at the X-Men saga talking about the comics being butchered, characters, stories, the list goes on.. I still see comments on the DOFP trailer saying how the film is just a cash-grab and Marvel should have the rights which makes me wonder what they think of Wolverine; and I watch a video of someone who dislikes the franchise and likes Hugh Jackman's portrayal. Do you remember when Taylor Lautner was rumoured to star as the mutant in a film showing off his (very) younger days, everyone either went ballistic or laughed like J.J. Jameson in Spider-Man 2. That makes me wonder if fans would find it easy to slip into an entirely different cast with Hugh Jackman still delivering f-bombs. But I'm sure that would be too big of a leap for Jacksey, in which case a new Wolverine must be found, but who could possibly dream of yelling like the legendary Aussie.

-"Hugh Jackman's Way Too Tall"


Comic-book fans have a tendency to have all the specifics with there characters, stories, settings when it's portrayed in film and this is why last year's "The Amazing Spider-Man" has such a mixed reception among movie goers. The most common quotes will be "Raimi did it much better" or "It was like that in the comics"; I personally disagree with both, but the second more because when a director and creative team are given the license, they can do what the hell they like with the material as long as a fat Spidey's not jumping around like an alcoholic. In the comics, Wolverine was 5'3" and Hugh Jackman is 6'2", so staright away you know what's going to happen. The Wolverine was based off of Frank Miller's comic arc of the same name, but only featured key characters along with the Japanese setting and some selected story elements, which brought to my attention something that's been going on long before comic-book movies, which is "it's not like the book" a statement that always gets on my nerves because the definition for "based" is to "use (whatever specified) as the foundation or starting point for something". It doesn't mean that when a comic-book villain appears, all of his wives, husbands, sons, daughters have to be present as well.

-My Conclusion


Although naturally, I have my concerns for the next Wolvie flick as Hugh was hinting that next year's performance would be his last, and jealousies of his diet; I have all confidence that whatever Hugh Jackman, James Mangold, (or whoever) will produce will be coming from the bottom of his heart (even if it flops)...

So there are my thoughts, write a comment down below to list what your thoughts are. I'd appreciate it...
THE KING'S MAN Star Harris Dickinson Has A Surprising Take On X-MEN/Cyclops Casting Rumors
Related:

THE KING'S MAN Star Harris Dickinson Has A Surprising Take On X-MEN/Cyclops Casting Rumors

X-MEN Star James Marsden On Returning As Cyclops For AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY: These Worlds Are Ready To Collide
Recommended For You:

X-MEN Star James Marsden On Returning As Cyclops For AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY: "These Worlds Are Ready To Collide"

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Moohika
Moohika - 11/17/2013, 10:50 AM
At this point Hugh is Wolverine, he is the RDJ of Fox's X-Men movies. The older he gets, the better he is at playing Wolverine, and people who bring up the height issue can shove an adimantium claw up their ass!
duncboy
duncboy - 11/17/2013, 11:15 AM
Hugh Jackman is actually 6'2. I met him in a Comic Shop once randomly when he was shooting Real Steel in Detroit, and while I'm 6'2, he was definitely a few inches taller (I have a photo for proof).
duncboy
duncboy - 11/17/2013, 11:15 AM
My vote for the next Wolverine is Tom Hardy - short, gruffy, and has proved he can get big if needed.
Moohika
Moohika - 11/17/2013, 11:20 AM
*adamantium
Before fanboys bitch me out for spelling it wrong.
Odin
Odin - 11/17/2013, 12:28 PM
Hugh is good at the role that I wouldn't risk ruining the character by changing the actor just for sake of change.
BANE5000
BANE5000 - 11/17/2013, 2:33 PM
In the first X-Men he was the perfect Wolverine, a loner with an attitude, cigar smoking, not giving a crap about anyone else but himself :]
BoredSorcerer
BoredSorcerer - 11/17/2013, 2:47 PM
He is an amazing Wolverine but if they did reboot I would go with Jon Bernthal.
staypuffed
staypuffed - 11/17/2013, 4:17 PM
He's one of the best characters in comic book movie history. Jackman has been amazing, regardless of the quality of the films. Keep him going til he drops dead.
Tainted87
Tainted87 - 11/17/2013, 4:43 PM
Doctor Who fangirls are the worst. There's a reason why Christopher Eccleston doesn't wanna talk about it.

I remember WAY back with Shallow Grave, a Danny Boyle movie with Ewan McGregor playing his usual douchey self. He was a creeper.

Hugh Jackman is one of the most good-natured actors in the business. Quote me an article or interview where he's legitimately annoyed about... well, any role he's played. This man is a professional dancer, singer, and actor. I'm positive that when he gets done with Wolverine, there will be something else equal to his X-Men work for him to be remembered by (besides Les Miserables, which is fantastic).
Tainted87
Tainted87 - 11/17/2013, 6:23 PM


I think we can forgive ya cipher.
Tainted87
Tainted87 - 11/17/2013, 6:43 PM
Yep, before X-Men, Hugh Jackman was Gaston.

And every inch of him's covered in hair...
Poolio
Poolio - 11/17/2013, 7:40 PM
@Tainted87
Could you imagine how people would react when they found out that guy would be playing Wolverine if the internet was as prominent back then as it is today
SimpleeComplex
SimpleeComplex - 11/18/2013, 4:29 AM
When the torch gets passed, Sam Worthington for Logan?? He seems to be an underdog stil but from seeing him in Avatar and Terminator Salvation he knocks it out the park.
Odin
Odin - 11/18/2013, 8:21 AM
@cipher I remember when I came home after seeing X-Men Origins: Wolverine, my mom was watching tv.
"Well how was your silly superhero-film, who was starring?" She asked.
I was about to answer, when I happened to look at tv-screen, my jaw dropped and I just pointed to the screen. "Those guys, they were playing mutant brothers, the film was about them." I said.
My mom looked at me with Sheldon Cooper-face. "Hugh Jackman and Liev Schreiber from Kate Leopold? Son, get out."
One of my teenage years funniest memories :)
Tainted87
Tainted87 - 11/18/2013, 9:58 AM
@Poolio
People would have rioted. Thankfully, I didn't have internet on my PC back then. I'm pretty sure fans still bitched and moaned.

@DurtyTalynt
I don't get you man. By getting decked with a log, that makes him NOT Wolverine? Clarify that for me, will ya?
MightyZeus
MightyZeus - 11/18/2013, 9:13 PM
No way. I actually enjoy Jackman's portrayal of Wolverine. He's really good in the role and yes he's tall but still he does a really good performance. Hugh Jackman is very talented.

RobGrizzly
RobGrizzly - 11/20/2013, 5:59 AM
I think people get way too defensive about things like this. Yes, Hugh Jackman has been a great Wolverine. But I agree he shouldn't do this forever. Get too attached, and it becomes harder for fans to embrace someone new in the role.

The author mentioned Dr. Who, but many comparisons, from James Bond, to all the people who have played Batman also apply. I did an article a few years ago called "Top 10 Perfect Castings in Comic Book Movies". I didn't put Hugh Jackman on the list for the same reason I didn't put Christopher Reeve. These are characters that can't be defined only by popularity of the actor. There is a chance someone better can come along, if given the opportunity
View Recorder