Anil Rickly Review's: SUPERMAN/SHAZAM: The Return of Black Adam

Anil Rickly Review's: SUPERMAN/SHAZAM: The Return of Black Adam

Will the greatest superhero known as the Man of Steel be able to withstand the greatest magical threat at DC?...Or will the heart of one young man be the key to saving the day...

Review Opinion
By earzmundo - Nov 04, 2010 03:11 PM EST
Filed Under: Animated Features

Superman/ Shazam: The Return of Black Adam –



Now, DCU has been atop the animation movies for some time now. Marvel’s Ultimate Avengers films were average at best and while they do set a good tone as to what the movie may be portrayed, their other ventures such as Dr. Strange and Invincible Iron Man simply weren’t the best that they could have been. The HULK vs Wolverine/THOR series were fun and full of kickass scenes but at the end of the day…DCU has been the only entity to me who has delivered full-on animated glory. The Batfilms of old such as Mask of the Phantasm, Subzero, Return of the Joker etc were all glorious in their own way and kept us comic book bat-fans at bay, happy and content…but when the DCU took full-on challenges that may not be on the cinema screen anytime soon…I admit I was wary!

Superman: Doomsday and Justice League: The New Frontier weren’t up to my high standard but Batman: Gotham Knight proved a liking as the different fighting and art styles, coupled with the anime influence, made me as giddy as a comic fan on a Wednesday. Wonder Woman remains my favorite as the action sequences and decapitation scene were simply heaven. Green Lantern: First Flight also struck a good chord in my books but Superman/Batman: Public Enemies and JLA: Crisis on 2 Earths left a lot to be desired to me. I may not have been receptive of these particular comic arcs but again, Jeph Loeb on DC isn’t the sucky Loeb at Marvel, so while these films weren’t great, they were a ton better than what Marvel were delivering. However, as a huge fan of Judd Winick, I was amazed by the Under the Red Hood film, as this captivated the raw emotion and drama of the comic to a tee. Winick alone can write this Jason Todd, not even Grant Morrison comes close, and I hope more comic writers get into comic film scripts for real-live and animated features. These are the guys who can stick to the source and also allow deviated arcs on film that appease us to the bone. Would DC deliver with Superman/Batman: Apocalypse? Well I loved Mike Turner’s Marvel art, and this book was one of my DCU faves…and the film never disappointed. The ending was better than the comics, and this conclusion delivered ultimately cool results. DCU’s fight sequences remain an animation heaven. They have amazing writers and amazing voice-casts…Timm, Romano need to be praised in heaps. With All-Star Superman, Emerald Knights and Batman Year One in the future releases, I do hope that the likes of Flash, Aquaman and Green Arrow get full animated films soon. That is unless Geoff Johns, Dan Didio and Jim Lee get them to follow on the Superman and Batman films that will grace us soon, and have DCU pump out more movies to cinemas.

Well, DCU is about quality over quantity? Let’s argue that another time…Hot on the heels of reading JMS’ and Shane Davis’ Superman Earth-1, I was in glee as I loved this book, and lo and behold, I got to see this Superman/Shazam: Return of Black Adam short one week later…color me excited. The DCU SHOWCASE is a series of short films, where characters that don’t get full features, can be represented. There will be a full release of all shorts on November 9th 2010. The Spectre, Jonah Hex and Green Arrow shorts were all well done; but would the Black Adam newly revealed short be spectacular?

Answer –


Without delving too much into the backdrops of Black Adam, we get a simple fight scene between Black Adam and some heroes. The back-story between Adam and Shazam is kept minimal but concise, and the depth to the Billy Batson plot is well done and Zach Callison delivers the innocence needed by Billy. This tale of Billy discovering his destiny while trying to help Superman combat Adam is fun and filled with lovely fight sequences, as the action never flounders! Superman’s vulnerability to magic is well portrayed on-screen and Adam is shown as a huge force to be reckoned with. Geoff Johns and DCU made Adam a frightful entity since the days of 52 and World WAR 3, and this is translated well to the flick as Adam is kicking Superman’s ass. Billy’s exchange with Shazam is also short but straight to the point, and this along with Arnold Vosloo’s villainous foray from the Mummy is something that put a smile to my face as we got a 23 minute short of pure enjoyment. Any DCU comic fan would have loved a full feature without Superman, and delving more and more into the Marvel Family at DCU. But we got a short film, and it will have to suffice. The dialogue and plot are all well drawn out, the animation art style remains a steadfastly breath-talking view, and you never lose interest in this plot as the pace is fast and keeps you glued to the TV.



Jerry O’ Connell as Marvel reminds me of Tom Hanks’ Big and he compliments George Newbern’s Superman to a tee. Overall, I was sad to see a short film, as the quality was so high, I yearned for a full on feature. I hope DC hears this and delves into a Captain Marvel feature live action! I think DCU’s magic realm has a lot to offer…and while Dr. Fate doesn’t rear his head here, look out for a nice cameo at the end. It’s grrrrreat! Maybe Captain Marvel can follow a Smallville path on the CW as there is a lot of lore to hit this off, but I hope the cinemas are graced with this tale. I love this character, the family…and especially Black Adam! Osiris, Mary Marvel etc are all part of the lore to research, and since 52…this family has been quite interesting…and Adam is still a fave of mine at DC. Freddy Freeman anyone?...

I end with simply urging you to check this…I implore you…otherwise I wouldn’t give this a 9/10. It’s a great short indeed…and I leave you with one word…SHAZAM!!!

TOY STORY 5: Buzz & Woody Reunite, But Jessie Rides Into The Spotlight; Ernie Hudson To Voice Combat Carl
Related:

TOY STORY 5: Buzz & Woody Reunite, But Jessie Rides Into The Spotlight; Ernie Hudson To Voice Combat Carl

Andrew Garfield Would Love To Play SPIDER-MAN Again, But It Would Have To Be Very Weird
Recommended For You:

Andrew Garfield "Would Love" To Play SPIDER-MAN Again, But "It Would Have To Be Very Weird"

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Paulley
Paulley - 11/4/2010, 3:54 PM
Considering how little time they had to fit this story in.. and the fact these shorts wont get made anymore (unless they feature one of the big two).. im so glad that this turned out so great.

Im not a great fan of the Shazam stuff in general but start of the short with Billy Batson living in that state but still a happy go lucky child was done really well.

obviously the constraints held it back, but for what it was it was awesome.

---

On another note, Anil you may what to consider breaking up your paragraphs abit its a little hard to read in bulk.
Anthrax
Anthrax - 11/4/2010, 3:57 PM
Man great review he really should get a spinoff or even a tv one to replace smallville and they really should make a nightwing one I luv nightwing
Angelus
Angelus - 11/4/2010, 4:03 PM
Good review! I totally agree! I just loved how Superman inspired Marvel to think twice.

BMP!
StuckInPanels
StuckInPanels - 11/4/2010, 4:16 PM
not bad man. Think superkal will come here and bitch about this too.lol
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 11/4/2010, 4:32 PM
Anil @ Wicked review man!

Looking forward to this, kudos!

Maybe one day we'll get a live-action movie of SUPERMAN VS SHAZAM!

nuck82
nuck82 - 11/4/2010, 4:42 PM
leee777 has his head in the clouds lol superman vs shazam live action! in the year 2050 if u r lucky leee
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 11/4/2010, 4:57 PM
nuck @ I'm hoping for 2049!

Heh heh heh! ; p
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 11/4/2010, 5:03 PM
Tis a review, and a good un. i agree also, Marvel sucks ass at animation.
selinakyle
selinakyle - 11/4/2010, 5:29 PM
so where can i download this?
neuromonitor
neuromonitor - 11/4/2010, 5:58 PM
Intruder is absolutely correct, this is not even a decent film review.. he spends way too much time comparing studios... also, RorMachine, are you seriously gonna tell me that you think any DC animated films, besides GL first flight, are even able to compare the Planet Hulk???.... come on, dude!... I'm a huge DC fan myself, more so than Marvel, but i seriously gotta hand it to them for that one... If marvel actually gets off their ass and makes a Red Hulk movie, I seriously think it will probably set a new standard for all animated efforts....
Smallvilleisgood
Smallvilleisgood - 11/4/2010, 6:16 PM
Everytime I see this guys name I think Anal Rickly LOL.
darkblade
darkblade - 11/4/2010, 7:05 PM
Loooooooooooooooooved it!!!!
dahamma
dahamma - 11/4/2010, 8:05 PM
why all the marvel comparison even needed? anyway, i thought it was ok, and im not too much into Superman, but I thought he was no longer weakened by magic, and now he is? someone clarify plz.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 11/4/2010, 9:32 PM
Anil @ Dude, glad you loved it, I've got a feeling I'll love it too, cheers for a great review man!
ShibazzJenkins2
ShibazzJenkins2 - 11/5/2010, 12:12 AM
Oi Ror-Mach..... you talkin bout the Good kinda AZZ or the Bad Kinda Ass ?
ThunderCougarFalconBird
ThunderCougarFalconBird - 11/5/2010, 1:13 AM
Great review! What makes it great? The very thing some people are bitching about! You gave a little history on how this feature came about and the differences between Marvel and DC. The best reviews don't just tell us if you liked the feature or not, they help you understand feature. Great work!

I am itching for a Flash feature! Wally West hopefully. You may notice by my change in avatar!
EditNinja
EditNinja - 11/5/2010, 1:17 AM
Just watched it. Great review here. Story line and fight scenes were the highlights, and only 23 minutes!
Imagine a live-action version of this!
DCU are getting with every release.
ThunderCougarFalconBird
ThunderCougarFalconBird - 11/5/2010, 1:40 AM
Smallville - your not the only one! But for me it's just because his ass is so sweet!
Creature
Creature - 11/5/2010, 2:25 AM
The opening credits had me freaking jazzed, then there was decent character development. And then the dialogue let me down, then a cool fight and origin/mythology wrapped.
Not the best of the DCAU shorts, but it's pretty looking and entertaining. 7.8/10
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 11/5/2010, 4:43 AM
Guys, he does both. Yes he compares Marvel and DC animation, but then there is the review. Or didn't you get that far before nerd rage kicked in?

Neuro, yes, I'm seriously going to tell you that ALL of the DC animations so far compare to Planet Hulk, which I did enjoy. But I don't think it was a patch on a good lot of DC stuff. Anyway, besides both Hulk movies, nothing but garbage from Marvel.
MatchesMalone
MatchesMalone - 11/5/2010, 6:14 AM
Great review, Anil. I can't wait to see this. I'm a huge Shazam/Captain Marvel fan from way back since the animated series and live action show.

And, to all the Marvel Zombies, DC admittedly has some catching up to do in the live action department, but their animated movies have set a high bar that Marvel has yet to even come close to. I'm as much a Marvel fan as I am a DC fan, and I want to see both companies do well in everything they do, but you've got to just admit that Marvel's animated movies, except for the Hulk movies, are shit.
Shaman
Shaman - 11/5/2010, 6:18 AM
Wooooooooooooah Nelly! Waaaaaaaaaay too much hate on here. I seriously can't compute this! I for one, completely second Ron & Ror's comments. So this is an Editorial/SLASH/review, who cares? To say that this is not a review is absolute horseshit. A whole HALF of what's written here is a VERY in depth review of a 23 minute short. Let's not burn the guy at the stake for fleshing out his thoughts and comparisons, AND BRILLIANTLY AT THAT. This deserves to be on main for that very reason. It fulfills it's purpose AND THEN SOME. There is not one time that i don't cringe when i pop on to a review that consists of three lines saying "this is shit" or "this is good, go see it". This article should be a blueprint for not only reviews but editorials as well. Obviously you don't HAVE to like it, but to call the writer out on it and shoot him a bag of shit is a bit much, i find.
Smallvilleisgood
Smallvilleisgood - 11/5/2010, 6:35 AM
@Anal- No need for the personal insults, it was just a play on your name.
SpideyQuad
SpideyQuad - 11/5/2010, 8:26 AM
I disagree on Dr. Strange, Ironman animated movies were well done, As well as Planet Hulk. To me Hulk vs was lacking.

I agree the DC animated are good too. I really enjoyed doomsday.
SpideyQuad
SpideyQuad - 11/5/2010, 8:28 AM
I meant to say Dr. Strange and IM were very good movies, and I didn't agree that either was lacking.
niknik
niknik - 11/5/2010, 10:22 AM
No offense here but I stopped reading after the second paragraph. Reading through your list (review) of previous DC animated films, you hated all the films that I liked and liked all the films that I hated. Not much sense in my going any farther.

We'll just have to agree to disagree. Different strokes and all that.
niknik
niknik - 11/5/2010, 10:30 AM
Don't start throwing barbs now Anil. I didn't throw any at you. I just simply stated that we apparently have abosulte OPPOSITE tastes. Not reading how you review the newest film does NOT indicate I am "close minded". It indicates that based on the empirical data your opinion is different than mine.

Your calling me "close minded" and "jusdgemental" was uncalled for.

Should I now in turn call you "over emotional" or say perhaps you have a problem dealing with rejection? I wont seriously do that as I prefer not to stoop to that level or make unwarranted judgements on you.

I just don't believe your opinion will likely reflect mine. I intend to STILL buy the Blu-Ray regardless.
niknik
niknik - 11/5/2010, 10:48 AM
Wow. I just read the comments section now. I have to agree. You have no business being a CBM "reporter". Rokker10 got it right. You ARE unprofessional. Your last response proves it levels beyond your first. The name calling just keeps ramping up with you.

First of all, I never called you any names and never insinuated you were "ANYTHING" other than having taste in films the exact opposite of mine. That is not a demeaning attack. It just means we have different tastes. Now the fact that I do not agree with any of your opinions on the previous films pretty much means that your opinion on this one will have no value to me. Therefore my not giving it consideration and continueing on to read your opinion of THIS one is the logical course of action. I told you quite clearly in my initial post that I meant no offense and that we just disagree, mentioning different strokes. I never did or said anything that merited the responses I got from you. It has nothing to do with being "close minded", "judgemental", "immature", "bigotry", "disrespectful", or "ignorant".

You used all of those DISRESPECTUL INSULTS in reference to me. You sir are a real piece of work. I suggest you seek professional help and that CBM seriously reconsiders your next submittal as you obviously have some "people skills" that need work.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 11/5/2010, 11:06 AM
It is true... MARVEL do SUCK at animated movies, shame but true!

Like most of you guys I kinda like both HULKS but thats it... couldn't even manage to watch the IRON MAN animated movie all the way through it was so bad!

...Oh DR STRANGE had its moments but none touch most of the DC stuff!

Thank god we have DISNEY on their a$$e$ lol, might get quality toons now, worthy of buying!
ThunderCougarFalconBird
ThunderCougarFalconBird - 11/5/2010, 12:33 PM
Anil - if all those characters got their own feature you would be seeing my animated full length!
Vital
Vital - 11/5/2010, 1:56 PM
So far, this has been the 2nd best DC animated film I've seen. First one I'd have to give to Green Lantern First Flight cause it was just so good story wise. This one was nonstop, no slow parts at all, which is huge for me. It's a cartoon, you can't have slow parts in it. It's not a Clint Eastwood film lol, it's a superhero film, and this film did deliver on all counts. It was pretty much 90% action (which they never do) and I loved it. There were a few story elements in there that weren't action, but they didn't slow down the pace of the film at all, and that's the most important. I think this film is ridiculously better than the Superman/Darkseid one not long ago. It was just a good story, funny dialogue, and sweet action parts.

You guys need to relax, DC makes better animated films, and Marvel makes more and some better live action films. Give each company their due. Both are good at superheroes (since that's what they do). No need to attack each other over which side (company) gets you harder. I mean, in my eyes, they are all in the same, as in they are all equals, sharing the same hero universe. Talking shit isn't going to make either side do a better job at anything, and it just brings this site down (and a lot of newer users are trolling like crazy these days). I mean, why do you think half of the main regulars on here left? Because of trolling and hating and people that don't know their ass from their face lol. I don't know if those go together (they probably do lol) but that's why they left. All this shit talking is just going to make people upset and leave again. Then all you will have are troll members (which are starting to take over the site) and no old members who provide discussion and constructive feedback. It's a sad day when comic book fans turn on each other.
gandalf550
gandalf550 - 11/5/2010, 2:23 PM
Superb review! Can't wait to see the Shazam/Black Adam short this Tuesday, and I will definitely love getting all the shorts collected onto one DVD. Keep it up DC...and keep it up Rickly with the awesome reviews!!! :)
steelrocks
steelrocks - 11/5/2010, 10:38 PM

whoa people! The hate is freely flowing here. How about if we dont take it personal??
felixxx
felixxx - 11/6/2010, 1:36 AM
Its best to just let'em finish.
Vital
Vital - 11/6/2010, 12:27 PM
Scott Pilgrim vs the World was probably one of the best movies I've seen in a long time. I hope it gets tons of awards at a few award shows at least.
View Recorder