BATMAN: Ranking Every Actor Who Has Suited Up As The Caped Crusader From Worst To Best

BATMAN: Ranking Every Actor Who Has Suited Up As The Caped Crusader From Worst To Best

Only a handful of actors have played Batman in live-action, but how do they compare and which of them is ultimately the best Caped Crusader? We think you'll have something to about this ranking!

Feature Opinion
By JoshWilding - Mar 25, 2022 03:03 PM EST
Filed Under: The Batman

You shouldn't need us to tell you that Batman is one of the most beloved superheroes of all time, and only a relatively small number of actors have been given the opportunity to play the Dark Knight in live-action. We're not talking about throwaway appearances in the likes of Gotham and Titans here, but the performers who helped make this Caped Crusader a true cinematic icon.

Yesterday, Warner Bros. got us all talking about The Batman again by releasing a deleted scene from the movie featuring the Caped Crusader confronting The Joker. Between that franchise and Michael Keaton's planned DCEU debut, the future for Bruce Wayne on screen looks brighter than ever.

That got us thinking about a question that often comes up here: who is the best live-action Batman? If we were all taking all forms of media into account, Kevin Conroy would probably win, but in terms of those who have played this hero on the silver screen, we think you might be surprised by our ranking! 

To take a look through this Batman ranking, all you guys need to do is click the "Next" button below!
 

7. Val Kilmer

304930491223443

There are many fans who loved what Val Kilmer did after Michael Keaton passed on starring in Batman Forever. We get that, and wouldn't actually say the actor did a bad job with the material he had to work with. It's just unfortunate that he couldn't quite match the iconic work delivered by his predecessor, especially in a movie that embraced that cheesy '90s aesthetic in all the wrong ways.

Kilmer made for a dashing Bruce Wayne, and it was clear to see he enjoyed those scenes more than the ones he spent wearing the Caped Crusader's rubber Batsuit. That resentment bleeds into the actor's performance, and as a result, stops us from being truly won over by his take on this character. There was a lot to love about what he delivered here, but not enough for Kilmer to place any higher.
 

6. George Clooney

3049304912234433

Some of you might already be lighting your torches and sharpening your pitchforks, but yes, George Clooney has managed to escape being in last place here. Batman and Robin is a terrible movie that took the ridiculousness of Batman Forever and turned itself into a two-hour toy commercial, but Clooney - who doesn't look back fondly on this project - still seemed to be having fun.

As a Batman who was a weird combination of Adam West and Michael Keaton, what Clooney did here worked surprisingly well. This was far from a career-best performance (the actor is downright awful at times), but in the context of this movie for a Batman who was meant to be an action figure for kids, Clooney fit the bill. Maybe it's time to give Batman and Robin another chance? Maybe not. 
 

5. Adam West

30493049122344332

For many older DC Comics fans, Adam West will forever be their Batman. His costume may not have been as good as the rest of those featured here, and that '60s aesthetic obviously lent itself to a camp tone that isn't necessarily what comes to mind while thinking about Gotham City's Dark Knight. But is there anyone better at playing the Batman from those early adventures than West?

It's all too easy to forget those stories with Batman taking on silly costumed crooks now that he's been reimagined as a broody loner beating criminals to within an inch of their lives. Like Clooney, West was perfect for the Batman projects he was part of, and there's a reason this take on the hero has become iconic. We'd love to have placed him higher, but he can't quite compete with this lot...
 

4. Michael Keaton

304930491223443323

This is where this ranking starts getting competitive, and something tells us a lot of you will be unhappy with what comes next. That's understandable considering it's usually one of these four who are named the "best" Batman, but we're starting with Michael Keaton. The actor made this role his own alongside Tim Burton, and it's no wonder fans are now so excited to see him return (again).

Things did get a little too strange at times for our liking - such as Bruce Wayne sleeping upside down at night - and it's always hard to be fully on board with a Caped Crusader who kills. Despite that, we have Keaton to thank for putting this character on the map, and without Batman and Batman Returns, who knows what the superhero genre would look like. The actor truly made this role his own. 
 

3. Ben Affleck

3049304912234433233

With that, we've reached "Batfleck." One of the most divisive and controversial casting decisions of all time, we'd argue that Ben Affleck managed to prove the doubters wrong with his performance in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Proving himself the perfect choice for a jaded, broken Dark Knight, Affleck delivered a badass take on this hero that resulted in some truly incredible fight scenes. 

Again, we hate the fact that he killed (and used guns), but as a Batman based primarily on the version we saw in The Dark Knight Returns, everything here just worked. Justice League wasn't quite so kind of this iteration of the character, but the Snyder Cut went some way towards making up for that and left us more disappointed than ever that Affleck ultimately decided not to take the helm of The Batman
 

2. Christian Bale

30493049122344332333

Far too many fans become bogged down in the (admittedly) over the top voice Christian Bale used as Batman, but it still takes nothing away from his impressive work across The Dark Knight Trilogy. Given the chance to delve into Bruce Wayne's origin story, Bale gave this take on the hero some real depth and explored him across the course of three movies in ways previous adventures had not.

Whether it was that intense interrogation scene with The Joker (that recently released effort from The Batman doesn't even come close) or his final "sacrifice," we fell in love with this Caped Crusader and Bale deserves the lion's share of the credit. Three movies weren't enough in some ways, but as a story that told a beginning, middle, and end, we have nothing bad to say about this take on Batman.
 

1. Robert Pattinson

304930491223443323333

Are we jumping the gun here? Some of you might think so, but Robert Pattinson's work in The Batman was so impressive that we already feel confident in declaring him the best big screen Batman to date. There's still room for improvement when it comes to Bruce Wayne, but while he may not be a billionaire playboy right now, the actor still made him a richly fascinating presence here.

Pattinson's performance was off the charts, and along the way, he finally transformed Batman into the World's Greatest Detective and made this a character one we can truly believe in (whether it be as a symbol of fear or hope). Providing Matt Reeves keeps the momentum going with the sequel, we think "Batinson's" work will only continue to impress, cementing his spot here at the #1 Batman.
 

THE PENGUIN Episode 2 Hits 1.6 Million Viewers - A 17% Increase From Series Premiere
Related:

THE PENGUIN Episode 2 Hits 1.6 Million Viewers - A 17% Increase From Series Premiere

THE BATMAN: Robert Pattinson Could Become DCU's Dark Knight As David Zaslav Pushes For More Batman
Recommended For You:

THE BATMAN: Robert Pattinson Could Become DCU's Dark Knight As David Zaslav Pushes For More Batman

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2 3 4 5 6
dracula
dracula - 3/25/2022, 3:03 PM
1.Conroy
2.Pattinson
3.Keaton
4.Bale
5.West (take into account the time period)
6.Kilmer
7.Affleck
8.Clooney
TheEon
TheEon - 3/25/2022, 3:07 PM
@dracula -Completely agree. Keaton was amazing and brought the mainstream character to the big screen. However, Conroy defined and embodied the character.
FoiledCranium
FoiledCranium - 3/25/2022, 3:08 PM
Nice. Another list.
RolandD
RolandD - 3/25/2022, 3:22 PM
@FoiledCranium - Are you new here?😂🤣
FoiledCranium
FoiledCranium - 3/29/2022, 8:14 AM
@RolandD - Unfortunately, I've been here a while.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:09 PM
Bale has 4 academy award nominations, 1 Oscar win, led the Batman franchise to back to back billion dollar films, and has the highest critical ratings of any Batman movie.

Nuff said!
lordSTALE
lordSTALE - 3/25/2022, 3:17 PM
@Forthas - But none of those accomplishments mean that he played Batman the best

Just say you're salty that Pattinson is ranked higher here and move on 🤷🏽‍♂️
ComicBookPsycho
ComicBookPsycho - 3/25/2022, 3:20 PM
@Forthas - Yeah, but I never really liked his Batman. The voice and the stupid cowl ruined it
TheWalkingCuban
TheWalkingCuban - 3/25/2022, 3:21 PM
@Forthas - I’d like to disagree because that stuff doesn’t change his bay voice, HOWEVER his bat voice doesn’t change my general enjoyment of him as Bats/Bruces in 1 and even 2. In 3 I hated em
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:22 PM
@lordSTALE - See the poll I posted below
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:24 PM
@ComicBookPsycho - What was wrong with his voice?
PartyBoy
PartyBoy - 3/25/2022, 3:25 PM
@Forthas -

1. Baleman
2. Batfleck
3. Battinson
4. Keaton
5. West
6. Clooney
7. Kilmer

(But I have liked all of them. When the movies disappointed, for me it was never because of the Batman casting.)
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:25 PM
@TheWalkingCuban - what does his voice have to do with anything?
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:27 PM
@PartyBoy - Clooney over Kilmer? That is a hard one.
PartyBoy
PartyBoy - 3/25/2022, 3:31 PM
@Forthas - I thought Clooney was a completely convincing Bruce! I liked him.

And completely agree with you about Bale. GOAT. No contest.
Tpo81
Tpo81 - 3/25/2022, 3:35 PM
@Forthas - Bale is 1000% the best Bruce Wayne but I think his Batman voice was terrible and maybe takes him down a peg or two. I’d put Affleck & RPatts ahead of him personally
JesseCuster
JesseCuster - 3/25/2022, 3:36 PM
@Forthas - Because the voice matters? Why do you think people love Conroy as much? Because his voice is iconic. Bale's voice was just fine in Begins but he inexplicably changed it in TDK and TDKR to the laughable growling sound of a cancer patient. And I actually love Bale's Bruce Wayne, but his Batman? Always felt like a side character to his own cast mates.
TheWalkingCuban
TheWalkingCuban - 3/25/2022, 3:43 PM
@Forthas - it’s the main complaint of TDK, that’s what
MrKayDeeBee
MrKayDeeBee - 3/25/2022, 3:44 PM
@ComicBookPsycho - I'm glad I'm not the only one that thought this. I never liked ANY of his batsuits
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:45 PM
@Tpo81 - Pattinson whispers and the fact he does not change his voice means it would be easy to out him as Bruce Wayne. Bale's batman voice is mot meant to be soothing but menacing and at the same time disguise his identity.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:48 PM
@JesseCuster - If Conroy were really Batman anyone could figure out he was Bruce Wayne. It is unrealistic for a person trying to disguise themselves to use their same voice.
JesseCuster
JesseCuster - 3/25/2022, 3:49 PM
@Forthas - Unrealistic? It's a cartoon dumbass. Sometimes I wonder if you really smell the shit that you say.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/25/2022, 3:50 PM
@TheWalkingCuban - TDK is considered by many to be the best CBM ever. So it did not matter.
1 2 3 4 5 6
View Recorder