MCU: Breaking the Rules - The Use of Science-Fiction & Fantasy to Build Worlds

MCU: Breaking the Rules - The Use of Science-Fiction & Fantasy to Build Worlds

The MCU often appears to operate by a set up rules that shapes the universe, but just as quickly throw them out if it doesn't fit with the story being told. Read on and find out how.

Feature Opinion
By bkmeijer1 - Apr 01, 2023 11:04 PM EST
Filed Under: Marvel Studios

Since it's early days, the MCU has tried to follow rules to attempt to tell as grounded and realistic stories as possible. The MCU soon started moving into sci-fi more and more though, up to a point where aliens, the multiverse and eons old cosmic beings don't feel out of place anymore. And this also meant it started to play more loose with the rules.

However, moving into sci-fi does not mean realism is lost altogether. Science-fiction is fiction, but it could still be made to feel real or grounded if it follows certain certain rules. This is where soft and hard rules come it. The former means the rules are much less strict, something the MCU has come to rely on, whereas the latter means the rules are very strict, like in The Expanse.
 

Marvel Cinematic Universal rules

Soft rules are prevelant in movies like Thor and Guardians of the Galaxy. Especially Thor, which is almost fantasy with it's gods and magic. Thor might explain in his first movie they aren't gods and their magic is just really advanced science, while Ragnarok turns around on this later. Guardians of the Galaxy also has advanced science, but started to move into fantasy more with Ego's powers. And fantasy in the MCU has only been explored more, like with Gods having Avatars, as seen in Black Panther and Moon Knight.

Hard rules come in with the Pym Particles. While it is said space between atoms can be decreased and retains it's mass, Ant-Man throws this out in favor of the rule of cool anyway, as is seen with the tank keychain being light in it's shrunken form. The particles also allow for time-travel through the Quantum Realm in Avengers Endgame. Even though the realm is fictional, the rules of time travel aren't (as far as theory allows). However, the MCU is playing more loose with it within multiverse territory.
 

Science f(r)iction

A show that does try to follow hard sci-fi rules as much as possible, is The Expanse. Aside from a few fictional elements in the story, like the Epstein Drive, it abides to rules rooted in real-life physics. There is no sound in space, artifical gravity comes from acceleration or centrifugional force, conservation of energy is used to move in zero G, radio contact takes longer in relation to the distance it takes light to travel, etc. Even though it limits itself by following these hard rules, The Expanse is very scientifically accurate (1).

Using scientific concepts doesn't mean scientific accuracy though. In Avatar, humans are able to send multiple ships to a far away star system to mine an element that can counter the ongoing energy crisis. However, this trip itself costs massive amounts of energy, including the very-hard-to-obtain Dark Matter (2). In The Way of Water, humans return to harvest a liquid to counter aging while they already clearly mastered cloning and mindtransfer. This makes the trip for an anti-aging serum redundant as well.
 

Fantastical elements

A solution to play with rules more is fantasy. This doesn't mean all rules can be thrown out the window though. Fantasy still follows rules, as can be seen in the Critical Role web series. The series is based on the set of rules that come with Dungeons & Dragons 5e, although these rules are more focused on game mechanics. As for the worldbuilding though, Critical Role tries to stay within the confines of it's lore as much as possible (3). 

Fantasy and science-fiction aren't mutually exclusive though. The Destiny and Star Wars franchises both have common sci-fi elements and rules like space travel, faster-than-light communication, and aliens, but also very fantastical elements like magic (abilities and the force), dark lords (Savathun and Darth Vader) or even direct fantasy tropes (save the princess from the dark lord's tower in A New Hope). Like Thor, they are more science-fantasy. But whether it is sci-fi, fantasy, or both, the MCU still has rules to follow.

MCU Rumor Round-Up: HULK VS. WOLVERINE Movie, Steve Rogers Return, Emma Stone Casting, & More - SPOILERS
Related:

MCU Rumor Round-Up: HULK VS. WOLVERINE Movie, Steve Rogers Return, Emma Stone Casting, & More - SPOILERS

Former Marvel CEO Ike Perlmutter Has Sold All Of His Disney Stocks Citing A Lack Of Confidence In Management
Recommended For You:

Former Marvel CEO Ike Perlmutter Has Sold All Of His Disney Stocks Citing A Lack Of Confidence In Management

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

JFerguson
JFerguson - 4/2/2023, 2:45 PM
interesting read @bkmeijer1. I'd for sure like to see a successful cinematic universe based purely on grounded elements. At least for a comparison to the fantasy-heavy universes we already have.

I think The Batman universe is doing that as much as possible, but even then fantasy elements are bound to appear. John Wick and the planned spin-offs is also a good contender.

Nevertheless, I appreciate the MCU's slow build incorporating fantasy elements and it was such a natural progression. I think you have to be methodical in picking the first movie of a cinematic universe and MCU was smart or lucky or both to have began with Iron Man. Lightning in a bottle right there.

bkmeijer1
bkmeijer1 - 4/2/2023, 5:48 PM
@JFerguson - thanks. And I agree, Iron Man, but also Arrow, were definitely right places to start. Both were grounded, but now we're fully adjusted to it's sci-fi and fantasy elements.

As for The Batman, I think it will turn more supernatural eventually. It may not look now that it will fit in, but we thought the same when Iron Man and Arrow were first released.

A full grounded franchise though? Can't think of any right now, so would indeed be cool to see.
MyCoolYoung
MyCoolYoung - 5/6/2023, 3:51 PM
@bkmeijer1 - I didn't know you wrote articles. Could you tag me in the comments when you do. I'd love to read them
bkmeijer1
bkmeijer1 - 5/6/2023, 4:57 PM
@MyCoolYoung - I will! Been doing so for a while on every first and third's sundays of the month, so there'll be another one tomorrow. It's already finished, but I'm not sure if you can already see it
MyCoolYoung
MyCoolYoung - 5/6/2023, 6:33 PM
@bkmeijer1 - I had no clue. I don't usually go to the different pages,but I went looking for nates @. Cool stuff, man
View Recorder