SPIDER-MAN: Why Marvel Studios Needs To Adapt This Controversial 1990s Storyline In The MCU

SPIDER-MAN: Why Marvel Studios Needs To Adapt This Controversial 1990s Storyline In The MCU

As we head into a new era for Spider-Man in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, there's one controversial story/era we believe should be adapted. Yes, we're talking about The Clone Saga and Ben Reilly...

Feature Opinion
By JoshWilding - Oct 06, 2025 02:10 PM EST
Filed Under: Spider-Man

The 1990s weren't a great time for the comic book industry, either creatively or in terms of sales. Marvel Comics very nearly went bankrupt, and in the pages of Amazing Spider-Man, attempted to give the web-slinger a fresh start. 

Through a highly convoluted series of events, Peter Parker discovered that he was a clone and that the real Peter, now going by Ben Reilly, had spent five years on the road, pursued by another twisted clone, Kaine. Peter retired to spend more time with his wife, Mary Jane, and the baby she was carrying, leaving Ben—who went by "Scarlet Spider" for a time—to resume being Spider-Man.

Fans rejected the change (unwilling to accept this new Spider-Man and that the past five years had been stories revolving around a clone), meaning we'd later learn that Peter was the real deal. 

If it sounds complicated, well, that's because it was. However, we believe that all the right ingredients are here to make "The Clone Saga" a compelling direction to take the MCU's Spider-Man in. Here's why...
 

6. At Its Core, The Clone Saga Is A Great Story

5tvefejz o

The Clone Saga features some dreadful moments. Those included the apparent kidnapping/death of baby May Parker, pretty much everything with Judas Traveller, and the many times the story became almost unbearably muddled as Marvel Comics attempted to figure out what the heck it was doing. 

Take all that aside, though, and the idea of a resurrected Green Goblin enacting his revenge on Peter by making him doubt his own existence through The Jackal's cloning experiments is an effective hook. As a whole, the premise was great; the execution, however, was often flawed. 

The horror of learning that he's a clone so soon after his Aunt May's death breaks Peter, and when Marvel Comics eventually course-corrected, his journey to establishing that he was the real Spider-Man made for thrilling reading. Of course, as all this was happening, we got to spend time with Ben Reilly...
 

5. Ben Reilly's Story Arc

1ba8plql o

As much as fans didn't want Ben to take Peter's place, it was a blast discovering how he'd spent his five years away from New York. Then, when he returned and became the Scarlet Spider, we got to spend time with a very different Spider-Man who had to rediscover his responsibility. 

Eventually becoming the official Spider-Man again, Ben took on all manner of threats and developed a bond with Peter that saw them consider each other brothers. He'd even make the ultimate sacrifice for his "clone," only to eventually be resurrected by The Jackal years later.

More than two dozen deaths and resurrections pushed Ben into madness, but he found redemption and became Spider-Man again...only to lose many of Peter's formative memories and become the villainous Chasm. Not everything here worked, but enough did to make Ben a fascinating character in his own right (and a hero whose story deserves to be told). 
 

4. Tom Holland Can Pull Double Duty

U8gwwu82 o

So, how can this storyline be brought into this MCU? It goes without saying that a lot of changes should be made, both to improve on the source material and to make it fit into this live-action franchise. 

The prospect of Tom Holland playing Peter Parker and Ben Reilly is hugely exciting to us, especially if the latter has the same baggage as his comic book counterpart. Ben isn't just Peter with blonde hair, and exploring the emotional complexities of these characters as they argue over who is "real" and the mental toll doubting their entire reality takes on them would allow Holland to excel. 

If the Multiverse somehow comes into play (that or time travel might be key in reimagining The Clone Saga), then Sony may even have the chance to launch its own, separate Spider-Man franchise that runs concurrently with the MCU. 
 

3. ...Or Make That Triple Duty

4hss7bwf o

Kaine is a failed Peter Parker clone who descends into madness and villainy after being left horribly scarred and in constant pain. He'd eventually see the error of his ways and, through a set of typically convoluted circumstances, became the hardened, badass Scarlet Spider. 

Given that Kaine is an imperfect clone, another actor could step in to lead a spin-off franchise, though we'd love to see what Holland could do as this villain. However, he's also far from the only threat that we'd like to see step into the wall-crawler's world from this era. 

There's the duplicitous Seward Trainer, his daughter, the new female Doctor Octopus, and obviously The Jackal himself. Obsessed with Peter Parker and Gwen Stacy, the college professor is a twisted psychopath who'd benefit from a present-day makeover without the '90s cheesiness.
 

2. It Expands The Franchise In More Ways Than One

Qtykqwda o

As we pointed out above, a Spider-Man clone could be key to giving Sony what it wants: more Spider-Man. Venom, Morbius, and Kraven the Hunter all suffered without the web-slinger, so Ben spending some time in another universe before being reunited with Peter could give the studio—and fans—the best of both worlds. 

There's also the matter of a new supporting cast to flesh out this corner of the MCU. Characters like Janine Godbe, the cast of The Daily Grind coffee shop, where Ben works (Shirley Lewis and Desiree Winthrop, for example), and the dogged Detective Jacob Raven. 

Holland has struggled to find success outside of Spidey, so why not headline Spider-Man and Scarlet Spider franchises? An adaptation of "The Lost Years," a story that saw Ben on the run from his past and a murderous Kaine, could even be an R-rated tale. Preferably told by Marvel Studios, of course. 
 

1. The Green Goblin's Return

5ah6e0zt o

In some ways, Marvel Studios has already laid the groundwork for The Clone Saga. Aunt May's death means Peter is going to fully embrace being Spidey, and the mystery of the hero's origin story surely opens the door to some sort of cloning reveal by way of retcon. 

Crucially, the MCU's Spider-Man has crossed paths with the Green Goblin. Whether Willem Dafoe's Variant did track down Earth 616's Norman Osborn to prepare him for his greatest foe or could somehow return to madness, eager to finish the job he started in Spider-Man: No Way Home, the impact of the Green Goblin being revealed as the mastermind behind this story would be significant.

In the comics, we learned that he wanted to destroy Peter in revenge for his son's death and orchestrated the entire Clone Saga to do so. Returning to New York, he engaged both Spider-Men in battle, leading to Ben throwing himself in front of the Goblin's glider to save Peter. He then crumbled to dust, confirming he was the clone all along...

Do you think The Clone Saga should be adapted for the MCU? As always, let us know your thoughts in the comments section. 
 

Kirsten Dunst On Potentially Returning As MJ In SPIDER-MAN 4: Me And Tobey Doing That Again... But With Kids
Related:

Kirsten Dunst On Potentially Returning As MJ In SPIDER-MAN 4: "Me And Tobey Doing That Again... But With Kids"

A KNIGHT OF THE SEVEN KINGDOMS: Spring Is Coming On First Poster For HBO's GAME OF THRONES Spin-Off Series
Recommended For You:

A KNIGHT OF THE SEVEN KINGDOMS: Spring Is Coming On First Poster For HBO's GAME OF THRONES Spin-Off Series

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

UltimaRex
UltimaRex - 10/6/2025, 2:54 PM
No thanks.
I remember the first time.
CrimsonComet40
CrimsonComet40 - 10/6/2025, 3:04 PM
User Comment Image
CrimsonComet40
CrimsonComet40 - 10/6/2025, 3:05 PM
I will say it would be hilarious if after years of butchering and disrespecting the classic Lee/Dikto/Romita comics, the MCU randomly decided to faithfully adapt the Clone Saga for some reason
grif
grif - 10/6/2025, 3:13 PM
wow green goblin again.......
KennKathleen
KennKathleen - 10/6/2025, 3:14 PM
User Comment Image

I want Tom to pull from this guy's hardened nature to play as Ben Reilly. I'd also like to see Sony make him Miguel O'Hara in a Spider-Man 2099 spinoff. I think he'd kill it.
JFerguson
JFerguson - 10/6/2025, 3:21 PM
User Comment Image
Fogs
Fogs - 10/6/2025, 3:29 PM
Hmmm

No thanks.
CreateNowSlpL8r
CreateNowSlpL8r - 10/6/2025, 3:58 PM
"At Its Core, The Clone Saga Is A Great Story"

No, it's not. It's a poster child for why people make fun of comics in the 90's.


Linux1172
Linux1172 - 10/6/2025, 3:59 PM
I would rather see Hobgoblin 1000% more than another installment with Green Goblin.
SummersEssex
SummersEssex - 10/6/2025, 4:00 PM
No.

But we could do Maximum Carnage. First got to get Venom in screen with Spider-Man though.
PC04
PC04 - 10/6/2025, 4:27 PM
@SummersEssex - I second that! would love to see Doppleganger, Shriek, and all the Symbiotes dont properly this time around.
WalletsClosed
WalletsClosed - 10/6/2025, 4:23 PM
The only thing Marvel needs to do is reboot.

Reboot the MCU and DCU
WiscoKid
WiscoKid - 10/6/2025, 4:36 PM
"Fans rejected the change (unwilling to accept this new Spider-Man and that the past five years had been stories revolving around a clone), meaning we'd later learn that Peter was the real deal."

Uh, no. That was 5 years in COMIC time.

In real time, that meant that the Spider-Man I had been reading for my entire life to that point (some 20 years) was actually the clone.

That's why people rejected it. I didn't think the concept itself was awful, but you can't look at a whole generation of comic readers and say "Pfft--joke's on you! That was never the real guy!"
DocSpock
DocSpock - 10/6/2025, 4:51 PM

You are wrong. The clone saga was total crap.

The big saga played out over 2-3 movies that needs to be done is Spiderman vs Eddie Brock/Venom. At the end of Secret Wars, have Spidey return with some of the black goo on him.

Do this. Do it right. Pure gold.

TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 10/6/2025, 4:51 PM
Honestly with the exception of seeing Holland pull double/triple duty as Peter , Ben and maybe Kaine , I don’t care much to see a take on the Clone Saga in the MCU tbh.

Also leading one franchise is hard enough , I don’t see Holland leading 2 as Scarlet Spider especially when he’s apparently only got another trilogy left.

Anyway , give me Hobgoblin instead of Green Goblin right now!!.

User Comment Image

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder