Anne Hathaway's Scrapped Spider-Man: Brand New Day Villain Revealed; Drew Starkey Eyed For X-Men's Cyclops?

Anne Hathaway's Scrapped Spider-Man: Brand New Day Villain Revealed; Drew Starkey Eyed For X-Men's Cyclops?

We finally know which X-Men villain Anne Hathaway decided against playing in Spider-Man: Brand New Day, while the latest X-Men reboot casting rumour points to Drew Starkey playing Cyclops.

By JoshWilding - Aug 01, 2026 04:08 AM EST

Spider-Man: Brand New Day is now playing in theaters, and for the most part, the rumours heading into the movie were largely accurate. However, we didn't get the older female villain who was said to be a lock for the project, and new details about that character have been revealed on The Hot Mic.

According to John Rocha, The Odyssey star Anne Hathaway was approached to play the MCU's Leper Queen in Spider-Man: Brand New Day. Ultimately, she decided the role was too small, and the character was changed, becoming Tramell Tillman's Bill Metzger. 

In the comics, the Leper Queen was a normal woman whose unborn child was "infected" by a passing mutant. At the age of two, the child manifested pyrokinetic mutant abilities and burned down her house, killing herself and scarring her mother. With that, the woman—known only as "Page"—swears revenge against all mutants.

The idea was likely to reimagine her as the head of the Department of Damage Control, and similar to Metzger, leave the door open to Hathaway's villain returning in the upcoming X-Men reboot. 

Elsewhere in the podcast, Rocha said he's heard that Cooper Hoffman is playing Cyclops, with Adam Driver cast as X-Men's main villain, Charles Melton as Beast, Cailee Spaeny as Rogue, and either Bill Skarsgård or Tom Pelphrey as Professor X.

However, his co-host, Jeff Sneider, disputed Hoffman playing Scott Summers by revealing that he's heard Drew Starkey is in the mix for Cyclops. The actor, best known for his roles in Love, Simon, The Hate U Give, Outer Banks, and Queer, certainly looks the part, though he'd arguably make a good Warren Worthington III/Angel, too. 

With D23 fast approaching, chances are we'll learn who will lead the X-Men cast in Anaheim between August 14 and 16. However, based on yesterday's Emma Frost news, the trade could share some news before the event takes place. 

Last year, we asked Schreier how Thunderbolts* had prepared him for the X-Men reboot. "I loved working on it," he told us. "And I loved working with everyone at Marvel. I think that the lesson of the movie is also the lesson in making the movie, which is that you cannot, and I mean, it's kind of obvious making it, that you cannot do it alone. I think that Thunderbolts* is the product of just a massive amount of work."

"Jon Watts was my roommate in college, and I used to go see the Spider-Man movies and be like, 'God. That just seems like so much work. There must be some way where it doesn't feel that way,' and it's like, 'No, it's just a massive amount of work by a ton of people who care deeply,' and I think that I would not have gotten through this without so many [of them]."

"If you can learn to work within that environment and really harness the kind of energy that those people bring, then there's an opportunity to really tell interesting stories and take things to places that are unexpected, and try to make something special," Schreier concluded. 

Marvel Studios' X-Men reboot is expected to be released in 2028.

About The Author:
JoshWilding
Member Since 3/13/2009
A lifelong comic book fan who grew up on Spider-Man: The Animated Series in the '90s, Josh Wilding has been contributing to ComicBookMovie.com since 2009.

While he's also written for websites like Batman-News, HeyUGuys, and WhatCulture, Josh is CBM's Rotten Tomatoes-approved critic and the site's #1 contributor with nearly two decades of experience covering film and TV news (including interviews with Tom Holland, Chris Pratt, Gary Oldman, Halle Berry, Jon Bernthal, Tom Welling, and hundreds more).

Based in the UK with his wife, Josh is also an avid WWE and Formula 1 fan and writes about those passions on CBM's sister sites, TheRingReport.com and FullThrottleHQ.com. Favourite superhero? Spider-Man. Favourite pro wrestler? CM Punk. Favourite F1 driver? Max Verstappen.
X-Men Rumor: Cailee Spaeny May Still Be In Talks With Marvel Studios For An Insane Role
Related:

X-Men Rumor: Cailee Spaeny May Still Be In Talks With Marvel Studios For An "Insane" Role

Spider-Man: Brand New Day Under Fire For Alleged AI Usage In Concept Art For $2 Billion Hit
Recommended For You:

Spider-Man: Brand New Day Under Fire For Alleged AI Usage In Concept Art For $2 Billion Hit

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
harryba11zack
harryba11zack - 8/1/2026, 6:15 AM
.

User Comment Image
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 8/1/2026, 8:46 AM
@harryba11zack - Very.
hue66
hue66 - 8/1/2026, 7:52 AM
In your opinion Starkey looks the part? Neither of the 2 guys mentioned look the part. I hope Neither of these guys are up for Cyclops because Cyclops has a certain look as well as personality and is a very important role. Marvel cannot mess this up. At least they got Marsden right in the original series. These guys look nothing like him.
dragon316
dragon316 - 8/1/2026, 9:32 AM
@hue66 - here we go again racist fan cast based on looks not experience this is not Hollywood does things thank gooodness fans are not will never be in charge.,

You want go by looks look at kang in books he’s white movie he’s black , elsa bloodstone red hair in movie brown burnette hair , josh brolin 5 foot in books cable is 6 foot , wesly snipes 5 foot tall in books blade 6 foot tall , don cheadle 5 foot tall 200 pound less muscle to Jim Rohde to in books any cry about that change nope never
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 8:00 AM
Needs an actor with real dramatic chops to play Cyclops, not just a pretty face. A leader. Put him front and center of The X-Men. Push Wolverine to the side-lines.

Less Wolverine is better Wolverine.
lazlodaytona
lazlodaytona - 8/1/2026, 8:09 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - give it to Bale....
Or a black actor like Jordan
dragon316
dragon316 - 8/1/2026, 9:34 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - how we know he can’t do it many these type comments say samething about the Batman he played vampire he can’t be Batman after racist fan cast go looks not experience they proved wrong they Patterson Batman after they saw movie
gonzor
gonzor - 8/1/2026, 9:46 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - Throwing it out there butI really think Jamie Campbell Bower should be in the X-Men. And given we know he can act... maybe Cyclops would be a great fit?
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 12:37 PM
@dragon316 - Yes. It's really about the energy/intensity an actor can bring to any role. Other factors have never been on my check-list.
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 12:39 PM
@gonzor - At this point, I'm just hoping for a Cylops-centric team. A strong actor in that role would lift the entire movie.
lazlodaytona
lazlodaytona - 8/1/2026, 8:07 AM
Saw BND yesterday.
All I can say is it was .... Eh.

It was pretty good but not worth the billion dollar makings due to the fact the Jean Grey story was just odd and weird to put in there, plus, outside of Hulk I guess, all the character's stories really didn't progress that much.

I mean, we've had a lot of Jean already. This was the way to introduce her? Just not a great story and a used trope for decades now.


I did enjoy Spidey sitting in a bean-bag chair having fun with Ned while MJ hung out. That's the little things that fans always imagine and want to see and the film gave it to them.

Otherwise.....

Best I can give it is a 6/10.
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 8:35 AM
@lazlodaytona - I haven't seen it yet, but I felt the same about America Chavez / Scarlet Witch in the Dr Strange sequel. The whole movie is structured around them and Strange is a subordinate character playing catch-up. Does it at least 'feel' like a Spider-man film and not just a set-up for Jean Grey?
Lucasberg
Lucasberg - 8/1/2026, 9:10 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - for the record this is way the frick better than Dr Strange 2. Just saying
SurfinSuperman
SurfinSuperman - 8/1/2026, 9:25 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - It's mostly a Spider-man movie with only about 10-15 minutes that's setting up Jean Grey.
lazlodaytona
lazlodaytona - 8/1/2026, 10:58 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - it does feel like a Spidey film. His progression starts awesome but then he neuters himself and it's back to the same Ol'
I mean, I enjoyed it, but I'll probably never watch it again. Definitely not on the level of Spiderman 2.
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 12:30 PM
@lazlodaytona - That's not good to hear. Re-watchability is really important. Of course, Spider-man 2 was blue-chip.
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 12:31 PM
@SurfinSuperman - Thanks man.
BillyBatson1000
BillyBatson1000 - 8/1/2026, 12:32 PM
@Lucasberg - thank god for that.
lazlodaytona
lazlodaytona - 8/2/2026, 8:34 AM
@BillyBatson1000 - I think more people will love it than the way I feel for sure.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 8/1/2026, 8:45 AM
Cooper Hoffman as Cyclops
Sadie Sink as Jean Grey
Charles Melton as Beast
Timothee Chalamet as Angel
Iceman?
gonzor
gonzor - 8/1/2026, 9:38 AM
@ObserverIO - Chalamet has too big an ego. No thanks. I would like Leo Woodall as Angel.

And Jamie Campbell Bower would be a great Iceman.

ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 8/1/2026, 11:12 AM
@gonzor - Leo Woodall would be a great Angel. Not sure about Vecna as Iceman though. Dude creeps me out lol.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/1/2026, 3:47 PM
@ObserverIO - I mean the entire cast are miscasts if this is accurate
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 8/1/2026, 8:48 AM
Rogue is my favorite character, but they shouldn't have Rogue in the first film. Unless she's Mystique's young daughter and a villain.
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 8/1/2026, 8:58 AM
Interesting if true…

I’m guessing the rumors of “The Queen” being the villain might have been accurate but someone got their wires crossed with Adriana Soria aka The Spider-Queen being the antagonist when it was perhaps a version of the Leper Queen that Anne and Sarah Snook were rumored to be up for that ultimately didn’t happen.

User Comment Image

User Comment Image

User Comment Image

In regards to Drew Starkey , I haven’t seen much of his work but while he looks the part of Cyclops , I feel he would be a better Angel tbh!!.

User Comment Image
gonzor
gonzor - 8/1/2026, 9:30 AM
Please no Skarsgaard for Professor X.
dragon316
dragon316 - 8/1/2026, 9:35 AM
@gonzor - marvel did race swap kang , it could be possible
dragon316
dragon316 - 8/1/2026, 9:35 AM
@dragon316 - look at choices for fantadtic four who played who
gonzor
gonzor - 8/1/2026, 9:41 AM
@dragon316 - Hmm? What race swap? Skarsgaard?
deamon
deamon - 8/1/2026, 9:36 AM
Cooper Hoffman looks nothing like Scott Summers.
Starkey has ideal height and is slim. Dickinson is other choice.
gonzor
gonzor - 8/1/2026, 9:41 AM
@deamon - Jamie Campbell Bower could play Angel, Iceman but maybe... an actor of his callibre should play Cyclops? To show intent of him being a key player.
Bucky74
Bucky74 - 8/1/2026, 9:59 AM
@gonzor - Whoever plays Scott has to have great chemistry with Sink now. A good director will audition actors together to see how it works first
Forthas
Forthas - 8/1/2026, 1:00 PM
That is curious...Tom Pelphrey is only 3 years younger than James Mcavoy. Why not just continue on with him...especially if they can keep Jackman as Wolverine?
Rosraf
Rosraf - 8/1/2026, 1:35 PM
@Forthas - MCU probably wants a fresh start for X-Men after Doomsday and Secret Wars. Maybe Jackman survives, but I doubt it.
String
String - 8/1/2026, 1:01 PM
I much rather have Drew Starkey as Scott Summers than Cooper Hoffman. At least Starkey looks the part. Cooper is like 5'6". That's shorter than Holland. If Marvel Studios has to tell a male actor to diet to get in shape, put lifts into their shoes to appear taller, put wigs on to hide thinning hair, then Cooper is not the person to play Scott Summers for the next decade. Cooper probably will be bald by 30 years old. The ONLY argument against Starkey, I've seen is he's some sort of MAGA. I don't buy that argument as a good reason to hate on him. There are levels of MAGA, are you like Zackary Levi level, who broadcasts his political ideology and blames others for losing jobs or a person who can keep their ideology separate from work. I would never have known Starkey was some sort of MAGA until others started using that as an excuse to hate on him. To me, if folks have got over Leticia Wright being an anti-vaxer and still support her as Shuri, then others can get over Starkey. MAGA is a dying ideology. It never had more than 20% support of the American populace. In 5 years, I believe those who support MAGA will either crawl back under the rock they came from or will deny they were the ones conned by Trump in believing his policies were ever 'America First'. So, to me, Starkey being MAGA or something similar, is not a big enough reason to hate on him. This guy was brave enough to play a gay role in 'Queer'. He fits the role of Scott Summers; he's roughly as tall as Chris Evans, he isn't losing his hair or needs much to get into shape. I see more positives with Starkey; despite any ideology he may support. We are talking about superhero films, you need to have a physical aesthetic to go along with the role, Cooper doesn't have it, not for a leading man like Scott. Starkey does have it. So, I'll always go for the actor that can believably play the role than an actor that has to totally cosmetically change themselves to fit the role.
String
String - 8/1/2026, 1:41 PM
@String - But with all that said, Jeff Sneider has been high on Drew Starkey for quite a while as potentially breaking out with the right franchise. This isn't the first time Sneider has been an advocate for Starkey. So, there is a huge part of me believing Sneider is just being a supporter rather than there being solid information behind his scoop. My preference was always Harris Dickenson, who is slightly younger. If Marvel Studios is looking for that type of actor that Drew is probably as close as you can get. If Cooper gets chosen, it's because he's a far cheaper option and I fear that is going to be the mindset with Marvel/Disney when it comes to large casts. Cooper's acting chops are secondary to how much he will ultimately cost.
Forthas
Forthas - 8/1/2026, 1:03 PM
Why have none of the two other versions of the Fantastic four been referenced other than a cameo by Chris Evans Johnny Storm.
Rosraf
Rosraf - 8/1/2026, 1:17 PM
I doubt it's true, but Pelphrey as Prof. X is pretty interesting. He is a great actor who could bring something new to the character.
abd00bie
abd00bie - 8/1/2026, 3:17 PM
Scott Summers is like 6'3", maybe Skarsgard is Scott
String
String - 8/1/2026, 4:52 PM
@abd00bie - Drew Starkey is 6'1". Cooper Hoffman is 5'6". To me, that is short. I mean, not Michael J. Fox short from Back to the Future, but short for a leading superhero male character. Cooper is 3 inches taller than Sadie Sink who is 5'3", but although I think that's short too, for an American, Sadie is normal height for a woman her age. Scarlett Johannson is 5'3" as well. I remember Tom Holland was hired for Peter Parker; his height was the big argument with some fans, but at least Tom has the physical expertise & build to play Spider-Man. Cooper has none of that & a Chris Pratt glow-up isn't going to change it. By Infinity War, jokes were being made of Peter Quill's weight issue, by Guardians 3, James Gunn wasn't even trying to hide the fact Pratt had gained a lot of weight back. Genetics eventually finds its way back no matter how hard actor works to slow nature down.
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder