PROMETHEUS Review: I Went Searching For Answers, But What I Got Was More Questions

PROMETHEUS Review: I Went Searching For Answers, But What I Got Was More Questions

Director Ridley Scott returns to science fiction, with his new film titled Prometheus, where we get to see a lot big ideas, starting from the creation of living organism to something so bizzare and crazy. SPOILERS ahead...

Review Opinion
By WolvieCBM - Jun 10, 2012 11:06 AM EST
Filed Under: Sci-Fi

Prometheus... A film almost everyone has been looking forward to ever since it was announced just as an Alien prequel. A film that might just answer all those questions you have about the Space Jockey, xenomorphs, etc... If you are going to see this film just for that, you will be disappointed. But, if you are looking for a interesting and complex story that will make you think hard, a story that deals with Gods, creation of race and death, then this is a film for you. More below... I'm a huge fan of Alien. I've watched it many, many times. So, when I heard that Ridley Scott is coming back to direct a new science fiction, and that it will be a prequel to Alien, I was very excited, but also very nervous. You see, Scott has been talking about the Space Jockeys for some time now. He wanted to make a film where they are the center of the story, because in all those Alien sequels, no one explored them. And as the time passed, studio and even Scott himself have said that it won't be a direct prequel, but it will share the same DNA. And let me tell you this... Prometheus is indeed a film that is set in that universe, but it's a whole different story. I've seen Prometheus twice so far, and it's a film that leaves you with a lot of unanswered questions, where you have to speculate... a lot. While we do get answers to some of the questions regarding Space Jockeys (the Engineers), it seems that many don't like this film because it's not what they wanted to see, in terms of getting as much details as possible. The script, which was written by Jon Spaihts and Damon Lindelof is quite bizzare, as it deals with truly big ideas, but it takes all that in a totally different direction than you are expecting. The film opens with a rather amazing sequence, and from that point on, it starts to get weird... in a good way. Now, I could go on and on about my theories, like what was that "creation scene," who exactly are the Engineers, etc... but I'm going to leave that for another time because all that would be just speculation, as we never really get a definitive answer about anything. And you know, that might actually be a good thing. I saw the film for the first time on Friday, and when it was over, I had a very long discussion with a friend about it, and then I realized that this was film's intention. To make everyone who has seen it talk about it, think about it and of course, speculate. While I really liked it the first time I saw it, there was something that made me want to see it again. So, I went yesterday and watched it one more time.

So what did I think of it? It's good, really, really good. The direction is perfect. Scott has an eye for a visual tone for his films, and that shows. Every frame is carefully planned, and this is one of the most great-looking films ever made. Just stunning. This is his third science fiction film in his career, and he already changed the genre with Blade Runner and Alien. I'm actually glad he went back to this universe, because there is MUCH more to this story, than what we have seen in Alien films. And I definitely want to see more of this story. As for the performances, Noomi Rapace is great as usual, and her character goes through a lot towards the end. There is a scene that justifies that R rating, involving a surgery table and a C-section. It's crazy. Michael Fassbender gives a brilliant performance as android David, he is just so good. He plays this character that doesn't have any emotions, and yet, there are moments where you see that David feels anger, and sometimes even embarrassment (when Weyland says how he doesn't have a soul for example). David is an interesting character for many reasons, and Fassbender absolutely steals the show. Logan Marshall-Green, who plays another scientist, was really good, and there is a very emotional/insane scene with his character that changes the course of the film. Idris Elba and Charlize Theron were good, I just wish they had some more to do in the film. Guy Pearce as Peter Weyland is rather interesting casting, mostly because Weyland is an old man in the film, so Pearce has a lot of make up. Pearce brought that little something to the character that I think Scott wanted to see. Other actors were all solid, including Rafe Spall and Sean Harris. The story deals with big ideas. The creation of life, destruction and death. When we first see that Engineer drinking the black goo, we know something went terribly wrong, but also something good happened. A new DNA was created, a living organism that will change the future. And while you may not get all of the answers that you were hoping for, the film explains just enough to keep the audience interested in possible sequels. And this is where a lot people won't like Prometheus. Like I mentioned above, it asks a lot questions, and yet it doesn't give any answers. It's all speculation, but I guess I liked it because of that. Think Inception, with a lot more stuff going on. One thing that I didn't like was how characters reacted to stuff that were happening around them. When 'Milburn' saw that snake-like creature, he tried to touch it more than once. I mean, he didn't know anything about it, and when it attacked him, he was all surprised about it. And before that, he and 'Fifield' saw a bunch of Engineers dead. I mean, it just doesn't make a lot of sense. Also, another moment that was weird for me was when Shaw (Rapace's character) told Janek (Idris Elba) that if they don't stop the Engineer leaving LV-223 in his
ship, there won't be any home to go back to, he and those two guys just decide to take down the Engineer's ship, and therefore killing themselves. I mean, it's a key moment of the film, but it's executed in a weird. I know they had to make the decision very fast, but I don't know... It didn't work for me. There is even a joke during that moment regarding the bet those two guys made before.

To move on, I'll finish this review by mentioning the Engineers, aka the Space Jockeys. In the film, it's said that we share the same DNA as them. Now, I know Scott said in one interview that the opening sequence of the film doesn't necessarily has to be Earth (it is never said where it takes place), but when you look at the whole film, Earth is the most logical place. Because when that Engineer dies, he falls into water, which is the important element here. So, why exactly do the Engineers want to kill us now? What happened? Those are the questions that never get answered, and Prometheus heavily relies on the sequel. And I want to see more of these films. But like I said, a lot of people won't share the same opinion on this matter, which is fine. Also, the final shot of the film is a great nod for the fans of this franchise. Overall, Prometheus is an ambitious film, with stunning production design, some great performances and a story that deals with a heavy subject matter, and it's just too big for one film. At times, it reminded me of 2001: A Space Odyssey, which is never a bad thing. In the end, Prometheus for me is a visually stunning, brutal and complicated space epic. And when the time comes, and it will, film will be remembered in good light.

RATING: 8.5/10

Starring Noomi Rapace, Michael Fassbender, Charlize Theron, Guy Pearce, Idris Elba and Logan Marshall-Green, Prometheus is now in theatres!



PACIFIC RIM Live-Action Prequel Series Officially Moving Forward At Prime Video With SHADOW & BONE Showrunner
Related:

PACIFIC RIM Live-Action Prequel Series Officially Moving Forward At Prime Video With SHADOW & BONE Showrunner

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY - 5 MCU Characters Who Should Be Paired Up With Tom Holland's Peter Parker
Recommended For You:

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY - 5 MCU Characters Who Should Be Paired Up With Tom Holland's Peter Parker

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2 3
Hudson3D
Hudson3D - 6/10/2012, 11:09 AM
I am on the beer.... I am not reading all that. Someone fill me in on the good bits.
magma123
magma123 - 6/10/2012, 11:10 AM
Great review. Liked the movie :)
myparentsaredead
myparentsaredead - 6/10/2012, 11:14 AM
My only real problems with the film come in when I try to think of it as a prequel to Alien. There are too many unanswered questions, as well as many generic characters. But when I see it as a stand-alone, I'll agree that it is quite a spectacular film.
TonyChu
TonyChu - 6/10/2012, 11:16 AM
@ myparentsaredead And that's why what you just said is exactly why Ridley Scott kept dogging the question if it was a prequel or not.
BFGLOOM
BFGLOOM - 6/10/2012, 11:19 AM
Pretty good review. You're right about the film leaving us ALL with more questions then ever before. They wanted people to talk about it after and wonder things so they'd see again until the 2nd one is released. It had holes and didn't explain characters motives or choices but I still liked it very much.
TonyChu
TonyChu - 6/10/2012, 11:20 AM
Yeah this movie is some sort of a prequel but not direct and that's where people get pretty upset with what they saw. Look at some of the interviews and it explains what Ridley was trying to do and explains why he wanted no Xenomorphs, its because he felt they have become too mainstream and no one really finds them intemidating.
TonyChu
TonyChu - 6/10/2012, 11:20 AM
I bet the sequel is going to be amazing.
WolvieCBM
WolvieCBM - 6/10/2012, 11:22 AM
Whodat: No, Isle of Skye in Scotland is when they show Charlie and Shaw in 2089, when they find that invitation. It never says where that opening sequence takes place.
Whoelsebutkevin
Whoelsebutkevin - 6/10/2012, 11:23 AM
I could not have said it better myself. I was actually telling my best friend during the movie, 'Ridley Scott is the MAN, this movie is sick' then the movie ended and I didn't have much to say. Like you said it was too much left unanswered which I would be ok with, if it continued on with a sequel to seek out the Engineers creation. Ridley created a film that with the oppose effect of snowballing. It just got more and more suspenseful but ended in a manner in which you already pre-expected from TV spots and Trailers. They gave away too much, Personally.
VinzClortho
VinzClortho - 6/10/2012, 11:27 AM
Score sucked!
AsianVersionOfET
AsianVersionOfET - 6/10/2012, 11:30 AM
I'd give it a 8.0 or 8.5 as well. Did I absolutely love it? No. But, I enjoyed it immensely and I love the way Ridley Scott directs, this film is way too fun to look at. Thought the writing coulda' been a little better. However I DID love the film from beginning to about 50% through. I loved the dynamic between Fifield and Millburn being trapped in the pyramid and then when shiz goes down (I won't spoil anything) it gets [frick]ing intense!
Groge511
Groge511 - 6/10/2012, 11:32 AM
Went to see this last night. Was really looking forward to it but left disappointed. As an Alien fan I loved the references and such and as a big sci-fi fan in general I enjoyed the visuals and action scenes. The problem I have with it is the plot. Now I do enjoy complex stories and films that make me think/discuss about them afterwards but not with this. It was far too thematic and was just weird. I understand what it was trying to do but it just didn't do it well. I say it's worth watching, especially for an Alien fan but its slow (far too slow. there's a difference between a films setup and an unexciting hour), there's not much action in comparison with Alien or others sci-fi blockbusters(although what there is is great, very tense!), it's confusing unless watched more than once or discussed in detail and other points were essentially pointless. I liked this film, I'd give it about a 7/10 but it just wasn't worth the hype. I'll certainly give it another shot knowing now what happens.
Groge511
Groge511 - 6/10/2012, 11:33 AM
oh, and I have to praise the acting. Especially Michael Fassbender. Loved him in First Class and think he's a great actor. Next Bond!?
SuperFrost
SuperFrost - 6/10/2012, 11:52 AM
CUE the History Channels Ancient Aliens Season Ridley Scott. Great Movie, I have to totally agree with the writer. The "ALien" Franchise over the years constantly dumbed down. This is a Scfi movie that will actually make you think and leave you wanting more. I am actually looking forward to a sequel or even a prequel to this. Scott should continue his vision. Maybe do a prequel between "Alien" and "Aliens."
AC1
AC1 - 6/10/2012, 12:02 PM
How can you rate this so highly and also say that it relies on a sequel? Unless a film is created as part of a bigger picture (e.g The Lord Of The Rings trilogy, Kill Bill Vol 1 and 2), it shouldn't depend on a sequel. Prometheus, by all of Ridley Scott's accounts, was meant to be a stand alone film with very few ties to Alien. If it is dependent on a sequel, then it fails as a film. And when I watched it, it just screamed 'SEQUEL!!!'
Remixxx
Remixxx - 6/10/2012, 12:21 PM
I thought the movie was good weird but good. Wasn't expecting it to be a direct prequel to Alien but I see this as maybe a trilogy in it's own right. One question I do have is how in the heck did that face hugger get so flippin huge??? I mean one minute it's the size of a squid then the next it's the size of a giant squid. Also do you think he will touch on how the creatures evolved? I mean the face hugger in the movie isn't the same as the one in Alien.
MitchConner
MitchConner - 6/10/2012, 12:24 PM
I don't know because I haven't seen it, but any movie that explores the ancient aliens theories is good for me, interrsting! Can't wait to just see it
ronnie42
ronnie42 - 6/10/2012, 12:31 PM
I'm not reading that either.

This is an article, this needs paragraphs. There is no breaking in the persons article.
Ortonito
Ortonito - 6/10/2012, 12:34 PM
To simplify, it's basically 'Alien' without the eponymous character and answers nothing.
gannicus
gannicus - 6/10/2012, 12:36 PM
it sucked nice scenery at the start man in rubber muscle suite falls down waterfall people look in caves for early man they find a ship they find funny looking containers some weird ass snake thing the guy turns into the guy from the thing the talk and talk on the ship guy has his drink spiked the find the space jockey he attacks them he trys to take off they crash it big guy trys to kill the woman big guy gets it from a big ass face hugger alien queen is born the end lol.
ShermanHakim
ShermanHakim - 6/10/2012, 12:40 PM
the only question that's important to me is: will paul ws anderson make PROMETHEUS GOES TO PANDORA 3D after seeing this movie? ha! because i hope not, prometheus is a visually stunning movie with complex ideas, it does really shows ridley scott's taste for science fiction genre : brutal,mysterious,bold and uncompromised.sir ridley scott...i salute you
edmundo
edmundo - 6/10/2012, 12:48 PM
I was really wanted to see this movie and was looking forward to it but was disappointed. Fassbender was great and the visuals were fantastic but over all a disappointing script with too many inconsistencies . I would give it a 6 or 7.
MisterBabadook
MisterBabadook - 6/10/2012, 12:48 PM
With the exception of the last 2 minutes, I 100% agree with your article, which is funny cuz I was saying to my co-workers last night that the last movie to force audiences to connect the dots lilt that was INCEPTION. Good review. A few spoilers, but absolutely nailed it. It won't please everyone, but to those it does please, it's great. Even down to the 8.5, I agree whole-heartedly.
bobafett300
bobafett300 - 6/10/2012, 12:59 PM
There's so much plot holes in this film like:
Where's the space jockey with hole in chest in the chair we saw in Alien?
Why are the space jockey so small compared to the one in Alien?
Was that the alien queen at the end? Cause how would there be alien eggs without the alien queen?
Where did those alien snake come from? Made by space jockeys?
Was that a painting of alien in the room with the head? If so, how would they know of that if no alien existed before that.

I still got more questions but those are the ones that I can't get answers for, dam you Damon Lindelof for making unanswered questions.
Tetsuo
Tetsuo - 6/10/2012, 1:00 PM
sacrifice engineer brought intelligence to earth..i guess.
like prometheus did it with the fire [ remember.. fire can keep or destroy life... like the black liquid does]

gods [engineers] deliberately wanted to keep humans down.
and prometheus [sacrifice engineer] has stolen the fire from them to help them evolve.

JV
JV - 6/10/2012, 1:00 PM
I think that they wanted to kill us because we started to worship and follow Jesus and not them. Before that we worshiped the Engineers. All in all I was disappointed in the movie. Too many plot holes and no explanation for major event in the movie.
JV
JV - 6/10/2012, 1:24 PM
I also think that they created us to test out their weapons...didnt want to use themselves or their people for their experiments
AmishGangster
AmishGangster - 6/10/2012, 1:30 PM
I want to like this movie, but just can't. Didn't explain enough. I read reviews that hinted at
a " big twist" at the end. I didn't see it. Seemed very predictable. The "engineers" would have
to be very intelligent beings to do what they do. The one survivor was made out to be a
screaming homicidal monster, just like in every other horror movie.
The theater was almost full and when the movie ended it was almost dead silent.
Some may like this movie, but I just don't. To each there own I guess.


thunderforce
thunderforce - 6/10/2012, 1:32 PM
You would think these advanced Engineer guys would find a way to spread their dna without killing themselves . Just a thought .
thunderforce
thunderforce - 6/10/2012, 1:34 PM
And what was she doing at the end going to nuke them for trying to nuke us?
AlexDeLarge87
AlexDeLarge87 - 6/10/2012, 1:39 PM
It was interesting. I got the answers i was looking for. Who the Space Jockey´s are and how the Xenos were born.

Overall enjoyable film.

It raised new questions which it didnt answer but i dont really see that as a bad thing. There is always going to be questions without answers. Who made who and why?
David´s and Charlie´s scene brings that up pretty good.
GUNSMITH
GUNSMITH - 6/10/2012, 1:41 PM
THEY RIPPED OF THE ANDROIDS HEAD, AND TRIED TO GO TO EARTH WITH A SHIP FULL OF CANNISTERS WITH VOLATILE ALIENS...OH YEAH LETS STILL...STILL GO TO FIND THEM AN ASK THEM QUESTIONS...REALLY?
GeekyCheekyChic
GeekyCheekyChic - 6/10/2012, 1:44 PM
It was complicated and thought provoking which I did like but it left SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much for a sequel that I felt a little like a test subject for watching it. Definitely the nod at the end that brings the entire thing together was thumbs up. Didn't see the need again for the 3D but whatever. I thought it was a solid 4 out of 5.
TheMyth
TheMyth - 6/10/2012, 1:49 PM
I skipped reading the review as I don't wanna be spoiled ;P but the title and description attracted me to address something. This whole issue that Prometheus doesn't answer the questions it poses, just more questions, has gotten under my skin. It's the fan reaction that has done so for me not the fact that the movie does this. I'm a man of science, any time I have a question about something, I spend hours on the internet learning about it. And one question always leads me to another... it never ends when you have a thirst for knowledge. That is the very nature of science, answering a question presents 3 more. So if this is a tactic Ridley has utilized, I must say I'm loving the sound of it. Also without seeing it, I'm getting the impression that this movie is too smart for the average person. The most common comments I see say something along the lines of not getting something or not understanding the significance of certain events. I'll be seeing it for myself this week to find out.
1 2 3
View Recorder