POLL ROUNDUP: The character of Superman in "The Man of Steel"

POLL ROUNDUP: The character of Superman in "The Man of Steel"

As ComicBookMovies' resident "Superman Expert", I feel it is my duty to update you on the various POLLS you may have seen throughout the site recently and the results.

Feature Opinion
By Nicholsy - May 14, 2010 06:05 PM EST
Filed Under: Superman

The first poll was:

"Who SHOULD play Superman in The Man of Steel?"

For this Poll I included the actors most likely to be in the final running and the real fan favourites amongst fan forums and such. People like Brandon Routh, Henry Cavill, Jon Hamm, Tom Welling etc.



The Poll results was a resounding one to say the least. Brandon Routh and Tom Welling recieved just under 600 votes EACH! Shock considering there was around 12 candidates to choose. It is also interesting that niether of these actors will be portraying Kal-El/Clark Kent/Superman in "The Man of Steel" under the directorship of Christopher Nolan. It is clear that the "Routhboot" fanbase is still clearly there. I personally feel that IF he is given another shot, won't be too bothered because thought he was the only good thing that came from "Superman Returns (2006)" and under a new direction, would do the character even more justice.

The second poll was:

"Which actor is going to be the next Superman?"

This is more real world based and not fan fiction based like the previous poll and was an even bigger in terms of candidates on the list stretching it to 31 actors. I feel that the actor (Unless Unknown) that will portray Superman in "The Man of Steel" is on the list. For this list, I exluded Routh and Welling from the poll because they won't be portraying Superman. The results although still quite early, show that a very clear majority think that "HENRY CAVILL" is going to be the next man to grace the famous House of El symbol on his chest. I believe this is a fine choice by the voters, Cavill took my vote as he is almost perfect for the role. He also took 3rd in the Fan Fiction Poll previous behind Routh and Welling, but my suspiscion is that because Routh and Welling are already and have already portrayed Superman, that is why they are so high.



Given that Henry Cavill is British, the right age for a new movie trilogy, the right height, has the acting chops and has the right look for Superman given he missed out on the role before as well as James Bond all this sounds to me like what Christopher Nolan looks for in his actors. Most of the Batman Begins cast was British except the parts that REQUIRED an American or other actor. The same with The Dark Knight, most of the extras and smaller roles were all British.


So, would Henry Cavill suit you as the next Superman, possibly facing off against Billy Zane's Lex Luthor in The Man of Steel if rumors are proven to be true about his secret meeting with Chris Nolan? Comment and let the world know.
SUPERMAN: WB Moves To Dismiss Lawsuit That Could Block The Release Of James Gunn's Movie In Key Territories
Related:

SUPERMAN: WB Moves To Dismiss Lawsuit That Could Block The Release Of James Gunn's Movie In Key Territories

SUPERMAN Test-Screening Rumors Point To Surprise Villains And A Tone Similar To WONDER WOMAN
Recommended For You:

SUPERMAN Test-Screening Rumors Point To Surprise Villains And A Tone Similar To WONDER WOMAN

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

SHAZAM171
SHAZAM171 - 5/14/2010, 6:29 PM
This is the perfect SUPERMAN. I don't want a dumb sounding Superman like Josh Hartnet. He's got a annoying voice.
fanboiii
fanboiii - 5/14/2010, 7:25 PM
Hopefully by the time they're ready to cast, someone pops up that fits the bill. Kind of like how Chris Hemsworth appeared out of Star Trek to be cast as Thor.

I'm just glad they're making Man of Steel and Nolan of all people is watching over it.
SHAZAM171
SHAZAM171 - 5/14/2010, 7:50 PM
@Dave Nichols - Doesn't matter, Christopher Reeve and Brandon Routh were nobodies and they got the role. Victor Webster looks and sounds like Superman. He's 6'4 and built like the role. His acting is exceptional, all it takes is a director to show him the way. If not then let Tom Welling be Superman. If they're not going to permit him to wear the Superman outfit on Smallville, then put him on the silver screen and wear it already. Sheeeesh. None of the other people on that list above looks and sounds like Superman. Superman has to look like he has no race. He has to look like you have to guess his race if he had one. That way he can relate to all races all around the world. He's Kryptonian. Not blonde hair and blue eyes or brown hair and brown eyes. He has to have black hair and blue eyes and have the charm to make a straight man or lesbian drop their pants. LMAO!!!!
SHAZAM171
SHAZAM171 - 5/14/2010, 8:41 PM
I know, right?? You know Hawkman is going to save him. The Martian Manhunter did it once already. LOL
InTylerWeTrust
InTylerWeTrust - 5/14/2010, 10:30 PM
Nolan won't be directing. If anything, he'll be a producer.

I don't agree with Cavill. He just isn't the ideal Superman IMO. His look is wrong, I want Superman to look powerful and strong. I don't get that from Cavill. And I don't think that he has the screen presence for this role. He's a good actor, but Superman needs to command authority and respect from everyone and it's high time that we got an intimidating and imposing Superman. Cavill just doesn't fit that IMO. I am behind A. Skarsgard for the role, because he has a perfect height, decent build, masculine look, and tremendousbpresence to be imposing like on True Blood, but he can also excel at a leader-like role that demands strength and heroism as proven by Generation Kill.

Cavill is ideal for Batman IMO, because he's shown charm, intelligence, maturity, and a playboy-like quality on The Tudors. But I can't see him pulling off the all-powerful strength of Superman. Just my 2 cents.
Ranger14
Ranger14 - 5/15/2010, 1:19 AM
tyler@ Exactly! We need a masculine Supes! Cavill is too femmie. Sure, he can act masculine enough, I suppose, but do we really want people to go....Yeah...that femmie guy plays Superman! Nope...not me. Not the image I want for Superman. No more Reeves types playing Superman!

shazam@ That is one of the reasons I can't see Skaarsgard as Supes. Sorry Tyler. Blonde hair dyed black doesn't cut it for me, because his natural coloring doesn't go with black hair. They need a natural dark haired actor. Plus, I just don't think Skaarsgard looks like Supes.

David@ I am surprised you downplay Webster not being a big enough name, yet he has a lot more acting experience and exposure than Cavill does. As mentioned, he also has the physique down already. Even though he played a gay on Melrose Place, he is more masculine in that part than Cavill is in real life. ;-) Not to mention, he has already suited up and auditioned for the part before, so they have had interest in him in the past.
InTylerWeTrust
InTylerWeTrust - 5/15/2010, 8:37 AM
Ranger: Skarsgard looks fine with dark hair.

Photobucket
Ranger14
Ranger14 - 5/15/2010, 9:50 AM
Tyler@ that is not black hair. There's blonde highlights in it, for crying out loud! :P Look at the face though...he doesn't look remotely like Superman to me and his skin tone doesn't look right to me with the darker hair. It doesn't jive well for me. Funny how people see things differently. I guess I look at those things more critically being I used to color analyze and image consult in those areas of casting talent back in the day. Most casting directors don't want to mess around much with the natural palette of the actor, unless they have the right skin tone to pull off a drastic change of hair color and that is rare. It's all good. If we all agreed on everything, this place would be pretty boring.

Anil@ Bomer? Too short and his persona makes Cavill seem halfway masculine. Why are there so many that don't want to see an actual strong, masculine guy playing Superman? ...and I am talking strong, masculine guy prior to getting into the role. I feel it is a very important image thing.
SHAZAM171
SHAZAM171 - 5/15/2010, 1:41 PM
Hell no @Tyler... I mean look at him. He looks like Richie Cunningham from Happy Days. LOL Dark hair is Black... not dark brown with blonde highlights. His looks have to be from like another planet... God-Like, not from a high school locker room, Jock type.
InTylerWeTrust
InTylerWeTrust - 5/15/2010, 3:08 PM
SHAZAM: "Looks from another planet" Are you serious with that? There are a number of things wrong with that statement.

1. Superman doesn't look like he's from another planet. He looks like a normal human being. A human being that can lift planes and shoot lasers from his eyes, but he looks normal. Saying otherwise is just...ugh.

2. Show me an actor that "looks like he's from another planet" but still looks like Superman. Go on.

"Dark hair is Black... not dark brown with blonde highlights"

Not at all. Dark hair is hair...that's dark. Dark =/= black. Dark brown is dark hair, just like black hair is dark hair. And those aren't blonde highlights. It's the lighting. I thought that was pretty obvious. This entire topic of hair color is so incredibly trivial anyway.

"God-Like, not from a high school locker room, Jock type"

Are we even talking about Skarsgard anymore? If you say that he doesn't look masculine then I don't know what to tell you. Personally, I would say that you were high off your ass if you thought that about Skarsgard, but whatever.

I realize that Skarsgard doesn't have the most traditional "Superman look" out there, but I truly don't give a shit. The man is an excellent actor who is capable of portraying intimidating characters like Eric Northman on True Blood, but also leader-like, courageous, righteous, inspiring, tough-as-nails, compelling protagonists as in Generation Kill. So I want an actor that doesn't look like Superman jumped off the pages. Sue me. Or better yet, find me an actor who is the right age, height, build, look, and can also handle the role which requires him to command the respect of everyone he encounters and has a screen presence that makes you know that he is THE hero to beat. No living actor out there fits all that criteria. Skarsgard has more than enough acting ability, has the height, can attain the necessary build, is a decent age, but has a decent facial look. I don't know how you can deny that he looks fine with dark hair, but to each their own. Until I find an actor that is more talented than Skarsgard, has just as good a height, has a good build, the right age, and a better look, I'm sticking by him. I know this whole comment is going to come off as seeming angry, but I am just trying to get my point across, no angry vibe is intentional, and I do strongly support Skarsgard and will happily debate with anyone over why I think he should be Superman. Rant over.
Ranger14
Ranger14 - 5/15/2010, 9:42 PM
We all have our opinions and see things differently. That is what makes this site fun. For the most part we can disagree and still respect each other.

I could get into the whole details of color analyzing and how hair color, makeup and wardrobing makes a huge difference on how an actor looks, but I think most would fall asleep if I went into how it all works. Let's just say, Changing one's hair color can bring out the worst in their skin tone, flaws and defects. There are very few people that can pull off a drastic hair color change without looking completely odd and ridiculous. That is why Hollywood doesn't do it that often unless it still fits within the actor's natural color palette. It is much easier and better to work with the right natural look. Here's a photo with him with darker hair. The dark patches under his eyes are much more pronounced then most of the photos where he has blonde hair. I know it sounds weird, but coloring does have a lot to do with how one looks and how flaws and defects can become more pronounced




I know you believe he is a great actor...I am not that familiar with his work to be honest, but I still want someone who looks the part. His photos just don't look remotely close to Supes to me. With all the actors out there from knowns to unknowns there shouldn't need to be any compromising on looks or acting abilities.

I haven't put much thought into who I want to be Superman. Waiting for them to get closer to knowing if they are moving forward with it or not. I do know who I don't want though. I will say that Josh Duhamel is the closest thing to the overall package that I have seen thrown out there, but that doesn't mean he is my pick as of now. He has the height, better look, newer...but decent actor...
Akercocke
Akercocke - 5/18/2010, 4:17 PM
Routh should play Superman again. Honestly there's no one better right now. I wish they could just clone Christopher Reeve.
BluntForce
BluntForce - 5/20/2010, 4:57 PM
Routh Routh He's Our Man, If He Can't Do It Then They Shouldn't Make The Movie. And that's all i have to say about that!!!!
View Recorder