More Early Reviews In For X-Men: First Class

More Early Reviews In For X-Men: First Class

Or perhaps, not early exactly as it's after midnight here in the UK and Ireland! Anyway, check some review highlights from several other websites ...

By MarkCassidy - May 24, 2011 04:05 PM EST
Filed Under: X-Men
Source: Various

Much or the reviews are slightly spoilery so if you want to read the whole thing, click on the links back to the sites. Here are some highlights from the final paragraph summations..



From HeyUguys..

Like The Dark Knight before it, the film has far-reaching ambitions outside of the normal comic book world, and by Vaughn insisting on making sure the very human and entirely relatable interplay between characters is allowed to breathe, and more importantly, develop in amongst some impressive action beats, the audience is fully engaged right through to the huge (yet somehow intimate) ending, which delivers a devastating and emotional punch seldom seen in films of this nature.

Easily up there with the second feature, X-Men: First Class should hopefully eliminate the nasty, lingering aftertaste of the thoroughly underwhelming third installment (incidentally, a film which Vaughn was mooted to direct at one point) and the anemic Wolverine spin-off. Fox are now in the enviable position (like the aforementioned Star Trek) to essentially start afresh and embark on another series. Let’s hope they stick to this template in the future, whether it’s for another X-Men film or any comic book adaptation for that matter.
If the rest of this season’s high-profile superhero features get anywhere close to matching what Vaughn has done here, we could be in for a thoroughly satisfying summer of escapism.


They give the movie 4 and a half stars out of 5.

From Obsessed With Film

Vaughn has often expressed his desire to make a Bond film, but here he’s gone one better, crafting a superior, exciting, and intelligent comic book movie around an anti-Bond, who’s just as cool, just as calculating and necessarily cruel, but existing in a parallel universe where the fantastic is born from genetic mutation and not Q’s laboratory.

But perhaps Vaughn’s best trick is infusing a real emotional core within X-Men: First Class’s expected stylish action and special effects. Leaving us on a tropical beach with the last vestiges of Erik’s humanity disappearing, like blood running into the sand.


They give it 4 out of 5 stars.

From Total Film

There's a lot of ground to cover to give the gang a chance to stretch their legs (wings, feet, etc), but fortunately Jane Goldman's tight script and Vaughn's zip and pacing (abundantly in his brilliant anti-superhero Kick-Ass, where he also teamed with Goldman) mean the balance between big set-pieces and character business is deftly held.

If First Class doesn't quite achieve the anarchy and irreverence of Kick-Ass it's partly because this is a different beast - not lacking in charm and wit, but occasionally in danger of veering towards broader laughs.

This isn't one for tots, though - carrying the same 12A rating as The Dark Knight, it mirrors Christopher Nolan's unwillingness to shy away from scenes of cruelty too bleak for infants.

"Mutant and proud!" asserts a naked, blue Jennifer Lawrence, in the closest X-Men: First Class gets to a catchphrase. She could be talking about Vaughn's film, which takes DNA from Singer (back in the fold as producer) and Marvel and mixes it with Bond and Batman, bromance and coming-of-age angst to create a cool, character-driven actioner with a social conscience that's something to be proud of. Top class.


They also award the movie 4 out of 5 stars. All the reviews seem to universally praise the cast, particularly Fassbender and McAvoy but also Kevin Bacon and Jennifer Lawrence. There is also the feeling that some of the second tier characters(Azazel, Emma Frost etc) are a bit neglected. Anyway, seems to be a resoundingly positive reaction, and I can't wait to see it!

X-MEN: 10 Biggest Mistakes 20th Century Fox Made With The Franchise That Marvel Studios Must Avoid
Related:

X-MEN: 10 Biggest Mistakes 20th Century Fox Made With The Franchise That Marvel Studios Must Avoid

X-MEN Reboot Production Company Name May Point To A Fresh Start For The MCU
Recommended For You:

X-MEN Reboot Production Company Name May Point To A Fresh Start For The MCU

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
SuperSpiderMan5778
SuperSpiderMan5778 - 5/24/2011, 4:50 PM
FIRST!!!!

FIRST CLASS IS GOING TO BE EPIC!!!!
patriautism
patriautism - 5/24/2011, 4:58 PM
I bet Fox held these reviewers families for ransom, kidding..
..Why can't people just accept that this movie is actually good, and that they were wrong about it?

billthebutcher
billthebutcher - 5/24/2011, 5:20 PM
Where the haters at!
SonOfStarKiller
SonOfStarKiller - 5/24/2011, 5:23 PM
@Patriautism- Because (some) hardcore fanboys are a stubborn lot. Once they see it one way, that's it. If a movie isn't torn page by page from the comic book, then it's a sh*t movie. Even if they're clearly wrong in their prejudging, they still wont budge. If it's not their vision then it's wrong. PERIOD. Me? June 3rd can't get here fast enough!
Tallglass54
Tallglass54 - 5/24/2011, 5:24 PM
They didn't start promoting the movie very well until lately. The first few pics and posters didn't make the movie look all that great. But man lately it has started to look great!
Nemeres
Nemeres - 5/24/2011, 5:26 PM
I think it kind of sucks that we live in an age when reviews - other people's oinions - make or break a film instead of giving the viewer a chance to decide for him/herself. Simply put, if Shakespeare were to exist today, he would fade into obscurity in a jiffy. Or better yet, if today's critics had been active back then, we would have never even heard of Shakespeare.

... you don't care, you say? Well, that being said, I'm really glad this gets people excited for this movie.

GrimeKid
GrimeKid - 5/24/2011, 5:29 PM
I'm really glad this is as good as I knew it could be.
There's been nothing negative said about this. Can't wait to see what it's RottenTomatoes rating will be
YeaOkYea
YeaOkYea - 5/24/2011, 5:42 PM
I knew from the minute I heard Matthew Vaughn & Bryan Singer were on board that this would be great. Kinda upset that Mr. Sinister isn't the villain being he's the one who performs experiments on mutants. PLUS how can you have the Hellfire Club but no Jean/Phoenix story involved???
asherman93
asherman93 - 5/24/2011, 5:45 PM
And to think, everyone thought it was gonna suck.

Haters... EAT YOUR WORDS!

still wish we got X4 with Apocalypse though...
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 5/24/2011, 5:45 PM
Azazel1 @ I'm here and I don't give a crap what Hollywood reviewers say, they know nothing lol.

Wait till actual comic book fans watch and review it.


Should of gone with X4.


Talking Marvel tho, can't wait for CAPTAIN AMERICA!
Hellsing
Hellsing - 5/24/2011, 5:52 PM
@Nemeres not really reviewers barely effect peoples opinion the new POTC movie is getting murdered by reviwers and its nearly made 400 million with in days. Same thing can be said about revenge of the fallen too. Yes in some cases it does change people's opinion but majority of them time it doesn't do shit.
113
113 - 5/24/2011, 5:53 PM
Still not excited for this, I'll see it now just because the reviews have been good but it's more just filler while I wait for GREEN LANTERN and to a lesser degree Captain America and Transformers 3
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 5/24/2011, 5:53 PM
They are English reviewers Lee, and some are run by comic fans just like us.
ClosetNerd
ClosetNerd - 5/24/2011, 6:05 PM
I'm actually kicking myself for watching all the clips/previews....as I assumed the movie would suck donkey balls. It looks like it'll be pretty good...not looking forward to seeing Professor X lose his legs though.
patriautism
patriautism - 5/24/2011, 6:12 PM
Here is another one.. 5 out of 5 stars..
http://www.digitalspy.com/movies/review/a321200/x-men-first-class-review.html


"X-Men: First Class has noble intentions beneath its glossy sheen, as its impressive subtext confronts what it means to be different in a society in which conformism prevails. This loosely mirrors its own identity as a movie, being an all too rare beast - an action blockbuster with rollercoaster thrills and laughs that has a fundamentally intelligent core. Fine acting, perfect direction and a couple of audacious cameos work wonders too."
EditNinja
EditNinja - 5/24/2011, 6:18 PM
Haters gonna ...change their minds?

This is good news.
blueorangeny
blueorangeny - 5/24/2011, 6:19 PM
Ok question fellas and ladies....

I'm not a marvel cat, I bleed DC

So I need a clarification...as far as First Class, is the film pinpoint with the actual First Class and it's comics? and is this movie an actual prelude to the past 3 films that FOX filmed?

BigK1337
BigK1337 - 5/24/2011, 6:31 PM
@blueorangeny
Now I basically hate everything about this movie, but unfortunately I know alot about it.

X-Men First Class isn't really based entirely on the comic of the same name. It really (supposedly) preludes the last 3 movies and Wolverine (apparently).

Honestly, my feelings for this movie is pretty much the same as that Karate Kid remake; its a good movie, but doesn't really deserve the title it was given (seriously, does how the hell is it the Karate Kid when he practice Kung Fu).
Reasonnnn
Reasonnnn - 5/24/2011, 6:46 PM
Fanboys will always be ignorant and will say let's see what "comic book fans" like/dislike it.

Hello! A lot of film critics have read and enjoyed comic books when they were kids. A lot of the popular comic books came out before the 1990s.
JoshWilding
JoshWilding - 5/24/2011, 6:46 PM
LEE: You're an idiot.
Seamusowns
Seamusowns - 5/24/2011, 7:14 PM
This movie looks [frick]ing stupid.
It looks like nothing but action.
The trailer with Mystique and Professor X as little kids is laughable.
Fox is a terrible company, I do not trust these reviews at all.
axiouz
axiouz - 5/24/2011, 7:14 PM
See, haters will keep hating and hating and hating, doesn't really matter anyways since the Movie looks damn awesome right now, and with the reviews coming in, it doesn't look like trailer good full thing bad type movie. So let them keep hating, the movie just keeps getting better day by day :p
Ryguy88
Ryguy88 - 5/24/2011, 7:18 PM
I was a worried that this movie being hailed a gem was a bit premature with the first review, but 3 more here is definitely promising! Can't wait.....Just hope this thing holds up through the 200 or so more reviews coming in the next week and a half.
blueorangeny
blueorangeny - 5/24/2011, 7:27 PM
@ BigK1337 - So this film is a stand-alone type. Just relates to the 3 x's films and wolverine. No relations to the actual comics?

Ok np. I was wondering why Prof X was talking to Mystique at a young. Shit if you look at the previous 3, she kept herself in excellent condition. Fine and never aged lol while X and Mag grew white hair...

Now how does that ad up? my math doesn't lol

Plus who's the red demon cat, isn't it suppose to be Nightcrawler?

theangrytroll
theangrytroll - 5/24/2011, 7:36 PM
I'll echo what someone earlier said: Who cares about what reviewers think? (I paraphrased.)

Gotta strongly disagree with the, "wait til comic book fans review it," idea. This is a group who spends dozens, (or more,) posts bitching about the length of a character's HAIR being SLIGHTLY shorter than in the comics, but is okay with Chris Nolan's "Batman" movies having nothing more in common with the source material than the NAMES. THOSE are the people who's judgement we should trust? No one who has two IQ points to rub together should pay any attention to that group.
BigK1337
BigK1337 - 5/24/2011, 8:08 PM
@blueorangeny
The X-Men movies never relate to the comic book X-Men at all (which caused alot of backlash amoung the comic book community). Though for the film, I am not sure what it is anymore. At first, it started out as a prequel; than, all of the sudden, it is being called a reboot which has nothing to do with the previous films. So pretty much, the movie's overall plot is pretty messed up right about now.

As for Mystique, she pretty much have like some sort of inability to age; much like in the comics (even though she lived alot longer than that, pretty much as long as Wolverine and Sabretooth).

And that red demon guy is Azazel, who is Nightcrawler's father.

@theangrytroll The only thing Nolan does is basically make the Batman world realistic. Other than that, compare to this X-Men movie as far as the story and characters, Nolan Batman seems alot more closer to the comics than First Class. So yeah, let the fans decide whether its good or not when the movie comes out; specifically one who is optimistic about the movie and is a die hard X-Men fan.
sonofsamadams
sonofsamadams - 5/24/2011, 8:23 PM
No doubt, that this flick will be a far improvement over X-men Wolverine. i'm glad they're doing this. They need to move away from Hugh Jackman. That was the big flaw in those movies, it was too Wolverine centered. I hope they don't center the Justice League movie on ONE super hero.

First Class will be awesome. But somethin' tells me that it'll get bashed by the critics that matter. these guys are the low and not to well known ones. But if EBERT hates it, and so does Armond White, THEN ITS GOOD! :)
BIGBMH
BIGBMH - 5/24/2011, 8:27 PM
So many haters. Just watch the freakin movie. Then, if you don't like it, talk about it (but not excessively)

Scenario 1: It gets bad early reviews
Haters- "See! I knew it was gonna suck!"

Scenario 2: It gets good early reviews
Haters- "Psh. I don't care about what reviewers say. I'm a fan so my opinion is th only one that matters. I say it's gonna suck so it's gonna suck."
thewolfx
thewolfx - 5/24/2011, 9:01 PM
how about they get some actual xmen fans to review it ?


ill be the judge when the movie comes out , im still sure gl and cap will blows this shit out of the water
GoddamnBatman
GoddamnBatman - 5/24/2011, 9:07 PM
@YeaOkYea when Vaugh was directing, Hellfire Club was in x3. @BigK1337 Bryan Synger said it's a prequel to his movies
1 2
View Recorder