MCU's Nerfing of Black Panther and the Civil War Disconnect

MCU's Nerfing of Black Panther and the Civil War Disconnect

The MCU is no stranger to continuity issues and nerfing of its heroes. BLACK PANTHER is out now, and while being a great movie it brings out a few problems in the MCU.

Editorial Opinion
By Armageddon26 - Feb 20, 2018 08:02 AM EST
Filed Under: Black Panther

A New Genius

      In the comics T’Challa is often seen as one of the smartest people on the planet, consistently ranking in the 7th-9th spots, or at least mentioned as being in the top 10. His intellect makes him feel like an even more worthy rival to the Tony Stark’s of the world.
     
      The MCU has seemed to change all that. 
In the cinematic universe we now have his younger sister, Shuri, taking the mantle of family genius. So where does that leave T’Challa in terms of intellect? The film never really gives us any sort of indication that he is anywhere near as smart as Shuri, or even if his intelligence is anything special at all (like, genius-level special at least).


T’Challa Isn’t a Great Fighter Anymore

      Civil War introduced T’Challa as a force to be reckoned with, holding his own against Bucky without the suit, and going toe-to-toe and even beating most of Cap’s team. His fighting style was unique, deadly yet still kind of cat-like in movement.
Black Panther seems to erase most of that. In the film Black Panther (SPOILERS, obviously) nearly loses to M’Baku early on without his powers, and loses pretty badly to Killmonger.
 
      Now, while both fights were interesting enough they don’t show the T’Challa from Civi War, the fierce hand to hang combatant going head to head with the MCU’s best fighters. His loss to Killmonger is especially hard as Killmonger is a good fighter, but someone who wouldn’t last long against any solo Avenger.

So why is it he beats T’Challa so easily?

The Civil War Disconnect

     The first thing that feels isolated relates back to Black Panther losing against Killmonger.

     When did T’Challa first get the powers from the Heart Shaped Erb?

      In the film he already has them, but in Civil War he states he is now the one with the Black Panther mantle because of his father’s passing, so was that T’Challa’s first time being the actual owner of the suit as it’s the King who has the mantle and the powers, or had both taken the Erb before the events of the movie?

      It’s not a huge issue, but either way, T’Challa seems to have been nerfed as fighter, hopefully something the Russo Brothers can fix.


The Wakanda of Civil War and the Identity of Black Panther

      Civil War never really makes Wakanda seem like the extremely poor, completely isolated nation it is in Black Panther.
In fact, the Wakandans killed at the start of the movie were killed on an outreach program, something that contradicts the new movie’s notion of Wakanda.

      Also, why is this incredibly poor nation powerful enough for T’Chaka and T’Challa to lead the Sokovia Accord/UN talks, and why do they care?

      As for the identity of Black Panther, Ross mentions to T’Challa that he owes him for not telling everyone he wears a cat suit or whatever, something along those lines. But Civil War establishes that the government would already know all this, including Secretary Ross. The issue of Panther ever signing the accords is completely different, but the identity is one already known throughout the government, so that line seemed a little odd.        The Civil War post-credit scene also feels odd now. The Wakanda we are shown and that is hinted at looks nothing of the Wakanda we have now seen. Even weirder than that: when does this scene even take place? Black Panther takes place immeditaley after T'Challa's return home, and yet Shuri makes a reference to Bucky being there. 



If there were any issues I missed, any issues you had, or you just wanna dispute my issues and prove me wrong, yano, please do.

About The Author:
Armageddon26
Member Since 11/10/2010
General fan of Marvel and DC properties.
BLACK PANTHER Star Lupita Nyong'o On Movie Offers Following Oscar Win: This Time You’re On A Slave Ship!
Related:

BLACK PANTHER Star Lupita Nyong'o On Movie Offers Following Oscar Win: "This Time You’re On A Slave Ship!"

GOD OF WAR: Frontrunners For Baldur And Thor In The Upcoming Prime Video Series Have Been Revealed
Recommended For You:

GOD OF WAR: Frontrunners For Baldur And Thor In The Upcoming Prime Video Series Have Been Revealed

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

View Recorder