Fan Cast- Daredevil: The Man Without Fear

Fan Cast- Daredevil: The Man Without Fear

A simple Fan Cast of one of my favorite superheroes.

By jarydevan - Feb 07, 2012 04:02 PM EST
Filed Under: Fan Fic

I've held onto this project for a while now and have never been fully satisfied. I've jumped from actor to actor, trying to narrow it down to the select few that create a semi-original fan cast. Regardless, I've put a lot of work into it. I'm a fan of criticism, but don't be flat out disrespectful if you disagree with any choices. Please and thanks douchers.

My Daredevil origin story is split 70% adult Murdock and 30% young Murdock. The decent amount of young Murdock is meant to connect the audience to Daredevil. I want them to see the relationship he has with his father and the affect it really does have on his development as Daredevil. The relationship between Matt and Foggy will start within the young confines as well. The villain is Kingpin, obviously, and only Kingpin. He is a criminal mastermind, almost Joker like. Plotting multiple crimes throughout Hell's Kitchen, while Murdock must stop them all. This will develop the monarch of
Daredevil. Creating a rivalry between kingpin and The Daredevil.

Matthew Murdock/The Daredevil- Nikolaj Coster Waldau


I can honestly say I've never seen this gentlemen cast as Murdock and I'm not exactly sure why. His look is perfect and his acting chops suit the role. Nikolaj is more known for his role as Jamie Lannister in "Game Of Thrones", but I still remember him as John Amsterdam on the short lived FOX drama "New Amsterdam". Definitely disappointed that one was cancelled.

Young Matt Murdock- Callan McAuliffe

I've been working on a Spider-man fan cast outside of this one and initially had Callan as Peter Parker. But someone beat me to the punch... sadly. Regardless, I feel like this kid has some versatility. Thus, I choose him for a younger Matt Murdock. And by young, I mean during scenes of his father's death.

Foggy Nelson- Mark Addy

Again, someone I've never seen cast as Foggy and I never understood why. He's worked with Nikolaj before on "Game of Thrones" and he's a fantastic actor. I've always felt that the first Daredevil movie diminished Foggy's role a bit. So, I'd like to change that in this version.

Battlin' Jack Murdock- Joel Edgerton

Edgerton is one of the better up and coming actors in Hollywood. Warrior is by far one of my favorite movies EVER and I love Joel. But I don't like him as any one superhero. I've seen him cast as Batman and Daredevil himself. But he's to versatile, there's that word again, to pick just one superhero to play. He'd be quite the Jack Murdock though. A small yet powerful part.

Stick- Stephen McHattie

I'm a fan of McHattie's and I hate the idea of Stick being a fossil. I didn't put much thought into this role because he was my first and only choice.

Elektra Natchios- Olga Kurylenko

Not the most original pick. But a pick that makes the most sense. She's of the right age, the right look, and the right acting chops. Enough said.

Karen Page- Alice Eve

She is HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOT as hell. Not to mention charming. She was my first and only choice for this role.

Wilson Fisk/ The Kingpin- James Gandolfini

Again, it's not the most original choice. But he makes the most sense. I think us comic nerds must come to terms with the fact that there is no 500 lb white sea beast walking around to play Kingpin. Kane has the look, but NO acting ability. I hated Michael Clarke Duncan as Kingpin and I feel Gandolfini is the best choice.

Vanessa Fisk- Demi Moore

Demi is a tad washed up, but I think this role could give her a little more prominence in the acting world once again.

Richard Fisk- Tom Felton

I never really though ol' Malfoy could pull off an "American" accent. But he sure as hell did so in Rise of The Planet of The Apes. And I loved it. New found respect earned him a spot as another douche bag.

Ben Urich- Hugh Laurie

By far the best choice I've seen for Urich. I could not agree more with anyone else when choosing him.

Smaller Roles:

1.Roscoe Sweeney/The Fixer- Terry O'Quinn
2.Slade "Jack's killer"- Elias Koteas
3.Ambassador Natchios- Hector Elizondo
4.Young Foggy Nelson- Jacob Wysocki

Cameo:
Bullseye has a couple stories to his name. But I'm fond of a particular one. Mainly because of my baseball fandom. I like the idea of, at the end of the film, Foggy sitting in a crowded baseball stadium. Where, within one of Bulleye's origins, Ben "Lester" Poindexter looks to finish his perfect game. But grows bored and nails the batter in the head with a pitch, killing him instantly. While removing his hat to reveal a bullseye logo tattooed on his forehead, snickering and bursting into laughter as Foggy stands and the screen fades to black.

Benjamin "Lester" Poindexter- Joseph Fiennes


The Director- David Fincher

I LOVE his work. The Social Network and The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo are amazing and David really brings the realism out in stories. Which is what I want in my Daredevil.

Let me know what you think.
A.I. - Artificial Ironman: An all original WHAT IF...
Related:

A.I. - Artificial Ironman: An all original WHAT IF...

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created Infinite Crisis Video
Recommended For You:

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created "Infinite Crisis" Video

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Lewis25
Lewis25 - 2/7/2012, 5:35 PM
I love your pick for DareDevil, he was great in Game of Thrones and New Amsterdam, I liked that show too.

I don't see Addy as Foggy.

Edgerton would be great as Jack Murdoch.

I don't really like Olga Kurylenko. I would cast Stana Katic, she has the look and knows martial arts.

I don't see Alice Eve as Karen Page. I just think she would be better as Enchantress or something. for Karen Page I would cast Amy Smart.

James Gandolfini would be good as KingPin but I still like John Goodman for the role.

the rest are good.
Jolt17
Jolt17 - 2/8/2012, 12:14 AM
Nearly a perfect fan cast, I really like it! Always interested in Waldau as Murdock, however he's around his 40's already by now...but I think he can make a perfect fit, still. Not sure if he can do in reality, but I like that pick. The rest are great...nothing else to say. Terrific job! :)
MikeZ
MikeZ - 2/8/2012, 12:54 AM
- I'm not familiar with Nikolaj Coster Waldau that much. He could work, but like Jolt17 said, we should go younger. And maybe American at least, unless Nikolaj can actually speak like an American.
- Wow, Foggy is a little too old and fat. Foggy is fat, but not like that.
- I'm with Lewis25: Stana Katic as Elektra. At least have Elektra speak like she's half-exotic, not all exotic.
- I think I love your choice for Karen Page. Alice Eve is very unpredictable, so playing a straitlaced lawyer/drug addict wouldn't be too hard.
- It is hard to cast a super-huge actor to play Kingpin. Besides, Glenn Jacobs is better for Marauder mutant Blockbuster. Eh, screw it, I like James for Kingpin.
- Eh, Demi Moore is a great pick, but can she pick herself up from her Red Bull binge (who drinks Red Bull 3 times a day)? Plus it looks like she laid thick on the botox.
- Nice original pick for Richard Fisk. Yeah, Tom Felton pulled off a great American accent in Rise of the Apes.
- The smaller picks are also great choices.
- Nah, I don't see Joseph Fiennes as Bullseye. How about Jason Statham or Jude Law?

B-grade cast. Hey, be sure to check out my fancasts when you get the chance.

- Blade the Vampire Slayer
- Doctor Strange: Sorceror Supreme
- X-Men Reboot Preview
- Gears of War
superbatspiderman
superbatspiderman - 2/8/2012, 1:55 PM
THis cast is excellenmt and very original for the most part. I love your Daredevil and Bullseye picks.
ager
ager - 2/8/2012, 6:52 PM
I applaud you for using original (mostly) picks and, while all are spot on perfect look-wise (although I prefer a very old and weak looking Stick, mo matter though) the ages are so far off. Aside from Gandolfini typecast(I prefer D'Onafario) i was gonna mark out for this cast until I saw how far apart the ages were.
View Recorder