DUNE: PART TWO Makes A Big Change To The Novel To Set-Up Final Movie - SPOILERS

DUNE: PART TWO Makes A Big Change To The Novel To Set-Up Final Movie - SPOILERS

Dune: Part Two is now in theaters, and while Denis Villeneuve's sequel is a mostly faithful adaptation, it does make one fairly significant change that may impact the events of the final film...

By MarkCassidy - Mar 01, 2024 02:03 PM EST
Filed Under: Dune
Source: Via SFF Gazette

Dune: Part Two is now playing in theaters worldwide, and we're breaking down some of the biggest moments from Denis Villeneuve's critically-acclaimed sci-fi sequel, including the events of the final battle and one significant change to Frank Herbert's novel.

If you've read the book, this obviously won't apply to you, but everyone else should be aware of major spoilers from this point on.

Towards the end of Part Two, Paul Atreides drinks a substance known as the Water of Life (liquid from an infant sandworm), which greatly enhances his prescient abilities and gives him the "gift" of full foresight. "Muad'Dib" does this because he believes accepting his prophesized destiny as both the Fremen messiah and the Bene Gesserit's Kwisatz Haderach is the only path to victory - even though he knows it will also lead to a catastrophic holy war in his name.

Thanks to the Atreides nuclear warheads and some very big worms, the Fremen do indeed manage to prevail, and Paul kills the Baron Harkonnen - who is revealed to be Jessica's father, his grandfather - before facing Feyd-Rautha in a closely matched knife fight.

Paul is badly wounded, but ultimately dispatches his enemy and tells Emperor Shaddam Corrino IV that he will take the hand of his daughter, Princess Irulan, and rule alongside her as the new Emperor.

Paul then orders his people to attack the envoys of the universe's great houses who have assembled over Arrakis and refuse to acknowledge his ascendancy, thus beginning his holy Jihad.

The movie ends with a devastated Chani walking away from Paul and setting a thumper in the sand to call a worm. 

This is a major departure from Chani's character on the page, who follows/worships Paul and fully buys into his status as Mahdi along with Stilgar and the rest of the Fremen. The fact that she recognizes the danger of fundamentalism and seemingly opposes Paul at the end of the movie suggests that they may be enemies in the planned adaptation of Dune: Messiah.

Do you plan on seeing Dune: Part Two this weekend? Drop us a comment down below.

"Those hoping for blockbuster escapism might find themselves shook by this faithful, at times borderline depressing adaptation," we said in our review. "But Dune Part Two is Sci-fi spectacle at its finest and most audacious, as Villeneuve builds-upon and possibly surpasses (opinions will vary) his previous film with aplomb."

The saga continues as award-winning filmmaker Denis Villeneuve embarks on Dune: Part Two, the next chapter of Frank Herbert’s celebrated novel Dune, with an expanded all-star international ensemble cast. The film, from Warner Bros. Pictures and Legendary Pictures, is the highly anticipated follow-up to 2021’s six-time Academy Award-winning Dune. 

The big-screen epic continues the adaptation of Frank Herbert’s acclaimed bestseller Dune with returning and new stars, including Oscar nominee Timothée Chalamet (Wonka, Call Me by Your Name), Zendaya (Spider-Man: No Way Home, Malcolm & Marie, Euphoria), Rebecca Ferguson (Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning), Oscar nominee Josh Brolin (Avengers: Endgame, Milk), Oscar nominee Austin Butler (Elvis, Once Upon A Time…In Hollywood), Oscar nominee Florence Pugh (Black Widow, Little Women), Dave Bautista (Guardians of the Galaxy, Thor: Love and Thunder), Oscar winner Christopher Walken (The Deer Hunter,), Stephen McKinley Henderson (Fences), Léa Seydoux (James Bond, Crimes of the Future), with Stellan Skarsgård (Avengers: Age of Ultron), Oscar nominee Charlotte Rampling (45 Years, Assassin’s Creed), and Oscar winner Javier Bardem (No Country for Old Men, Being the Ricardos).

Dune: Part Two will explore the mythic journey of Paul Atreides as he unites with Chani and the Fremen while on a warpath of revenge against the conspirators who destroyed his family. Facing a choice between the love of his life and the fate of the known universe, he endeavors to prevent a terrible future only he can foresee.

DUNE: PROPHECY's Rotten Tomatoes Score Revealed As First Reviews Point To It Being A Far Cry From The Movies
Related:

DUNE: PROPHECY's Rotten Tomatoes Score Revealed As First Reviews Point To It Being A Far Cry From The Movies

DUNE: MESSIAH First Plot Details Revealed By Filmmaker Denis Villeneuve; Will Likely Begin Shooting In 2026
Recommended For You:

DUNE: MESSIAH First Plot Details Revealed By Filmmaker Denis Villeneuve; Will Likely Begin Shooting In 2026

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
supermanrex
supermanrex - 3/1/2024, 2:04 PM
didn't read the novels so i will be free of expectations and just enjoy it. i cant wait to see it.
dragon316
dragon316 - 3/1/2024, 2:55 PM
@supermanrex - same here didn’t read books don’t read much novels saw it today it was good fell sleep in some parts wasn’t boring
Mankzin2
Mankzin2 - 3/1/2024, 2:05 PM
Great Movie. The differences from the book are expected and make the movie smoother and setup Dune Part 3 nicely.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/1/2024, 2:57 PM
@Mankzin2 - I honestly felt some of the changes made t feel more empty. Particularly the lack of his son.
bobevanz
bobevanz - 3/1/2024, 5:14 PM
@ObserverIO - I think it's better without his son, there was a few changes that solely depended on the time skip
bkmeijer1
bkmeijer1 - 3/1/2024, 5:43 PM
@ObserverIO - I don't mind the lack of his son. But that's just because I don't like what he becomes way down the line
Apophis71
Apophis71 - 3/1/2024, 6:14 PM
@ObserverIO - They may still do Leto II the Elder but more as part of Chani's arc instead for the third film, pregnant with him at the end of the second and his death bring her back to Paul's side and fully loyal to the cause and on board with being a concubine then giving birth to the twins setting up the whole half in heaven/half reincarnated in Leto II Jr myth etc.
Antitrollpatrol
Antitrollpatrol - 3/1/2024, 2:12 PM
Haven't read Messiah but fully plan to after finishing the dune audiobook. I've seen the syfy adaptation of dune and the lunch version. Spoilers:


I loved this version of dune but the ending kind of made me feel sick to your stomach since I was rooting for him. Honestly I think it has to do with Zimmer's score but Denis was able to capture that cautionary tale for power within leadership better than Herbert was able to in the book. I'm excited to see what they do with Messiah.
Goldboink
Goldboink - 3/3/2024, 5:26 PM
@Antitrollpatrol -
Messiah is an interesting story and get's into some deep stuff. It's not an action adventure kind of thing though.
harryba11zack
harryba11zack - 3/1/2024, 2:21 PM

I liked the first movie but sure as sh1t doesn't sound like a Chani to me. Hopethe movie is good but damn that sucks.
WarMonkey
WarMonkey - 3/2/2024, 4:06 PM
@harryba11zack - The movie is good. And Chani is pretty great up till that 3rd act when they totally ruin her character and in the process it will ruin Paul, Jessica's, Princess Irulan, and Alia's arcs moving forward. I absolutely hate what they did here and it makes me less interested in the future of the franchise. Rest of movie was good though.
HashTagSwagg
HashTagSwagg - 3/1/2024, 2:41 PM
They just couldn't help themselves could they. At this rate Eowyn and Sam's lesbian wife Rosie Hobbit are gonna be the one's who tosses the ring into the fire when that inevitable remake comes along.
Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 3/1/2024, 2:49 PM
@HashTagSwagg - DESERT VAGINA POWER!

HashTagSwagg
HashTagSwagg - 3/1/2024, 2:52 PM
@Feralwookiee -
Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 3/1/2024, 2:53 PM
@HashTagSwagg - I see you know my ex wife.

Goldboink
Goldboink - 3/3/2024, 5:31 PM
@Feralwookiee -
Vagina Dentata!
Forthas
Forthas - 3/1/2024, 2:47 PM
I don't think that is a big change. I think it was presented for the dramatic elements. It makes sense from a narrative point of view that Chani would be upset that she has to share Paul even if it is not addressed in the book. Chani will certainly buy into Paul’s destiny even if reluctantly at first. Heck even Paul will express reservations so it is not something that I see will change much of the direction of the book.

For Dune Messiah, I have a secret wish that Denis Villenueve would invite the still living cast of Dune 1984 and the Dune Sci-fi miniseries to do various cameos. If they have members of the Lansdraad briefly featured in the film, these characterscould be populated by the previous cast members. I think it would be a nice handing of the torch and nod to the old versions. I doubt that would happen because it might feel way too gimmicky and the film is taken really seriously.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/1/2024, 3:07 PM
@Forthas - That would be cool. I noticed an easter egg in the first film for the Jodorowsky Harkonnen crest taht I haven't seen anywhere on the internet and the trailer and score feature nods to Pink Floyd (who were gonna do the music for the Jodorowsky version), so some references to Lynch's 1984 version and the TV series would be cool also.

The book actually does address the jealousy. It's the very end, the last page. Herbert actually ends the book on a moment of vague feminism.

The book ends thus:

“Do you know so little of my son?” Jessica whispered. “See that princess standing there, so haughty and confident. They say she has pretensions of a literary nature. Let us hope she finds solace in such things; she’ll have little else.” A bitter laugh escaped Jessica. “Think on it, Chani: that princess will have the name, yet she’ll live as less than a concubine — never to know a moment of tenderness from the man to whom she’s bound. While we, Chani, we who carry the name of concubine — history will call us wives.”
Forthas
Forthas - 3/1/2024, 3:16 PM
@ObserverIO - Good observations. One thing though, I thought that Irulan had Bene Gesserit training but was not a full Bene Gesserit. I have to look that up.
DalekCraigWasson
DalekCraigWasson - 3/2/2024, 12:27 AM
@Forthas - Yeah, it will never happen, but I did think during it that I could buy Kyle MacLachlan as Florence Pugh's older dad WAY better than Christopher Walken. Such a bizarre choice for that role, especially given how little he actually has.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/2/2024, 3:59 AM
@DalekCraigWasson - I totally agree! While I love all of the actors that were in both Dune 1 and 2, I think there are some that do not think were the best choices for the role. Instead of Oscar Isaac I would have cast Anson Mount. instead of Florence Pugh I would have cast Elle Fanning, Instead of Jaon Mamoa I would have cast Aaron Taylor-Johnson and instead of Christopher Walken I would have gone with Rhys Ifans.
WarMonkey
WarMonkey - 3/2/2024, 4:13 PM
@Forthas - Chani is supposed to be a strong Freman warrior who knew that Paul would need to marry Irulan so the other Houses would accept his ascendancy to the throne. I hate these changes. Chani is now like a child throwing a temper tantrum cause she couldn't get her way. Take Lady Jessia and her sacrifice for her Duke, she isn't a lesser character for that she is a stronger one. And now Paul is marrying Irulan for absolutely no reason, the only reason before was for the other Houses to accept his rule. Chani was great throughout the film till that last part and I agree with others it totally ruins her.

And I love your idea for Messiah! I think Susan Sarando retired but she might come back for this. She did the miniseries cause she was a huge fan of the books.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/2/2024, 4:20 PM
@WarMonkey - I would say to that that it is a narrative choice that does not make a difference in the end. All it does is show that the idea of sharing her man is upsetting. While it may be that way on the book, a more realistic response would be that she would be a bit angry about it. You can't compare it to Jessica because Duke Leto never married anyone else. At the end of the day Chani will likely begrudgingly accept it but will distrust Irulan just as it is in the book.
WarMonkey
WarMonkey - 3/2/2024, 5:10 PM
@Forthas - I like the other Chani's I guess more. They were the ones that declared they knew what it would mean if they were to be with Paul and sacrifice was part of it to Lady Jessica. They chose to sacrifice their wants and needs for love and did so without hesitation. This new Chani just seems so weak of mind and lacks willpower and is too emotional to me which completely goes against who she was throughout the rest of the movie and Part 1. BTW I really liked her in the other 95% of the movie as she was great and so was Zendaya's performance
GhostDog
GhostDog - 3/1/2024, 2:52 PM
Movie was visually spectacular. Though the colosseum sequence looked off

Paul’s shift felt a little too immediate at times but more I think about it, it worked. Wish they did more with the vision from water of life though
Arthorious
Arthorious - 3/1/2024, 4:49 PM
@GhostDog - Ok glad I wasn't the only one who felt that way with Paul's turn. The third act felt a bit rushed too.
GhostDog
GhostDog - 3/1/2024, 5:54 PM
@Arthorious - it was rushed and I get Denis feels like he had to squeeze it in but idk. I feel like he could’ve spent more time on it.

Show those possible futures
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/1/2024, 2:53 PM
They made a lot of important departures from the book.

First of all the Muad Dib moment isn't revelatory like it is in the book. In the book he is aware of his possible future as "Muad Dib" and when he is asked to choose a name he says that he wants to be named after the little mouse and asks for the word for it. He doesn't know the word for it, Chani's friend never says "Muad Dib can smell you" while playfully running her hand along his shoulder like a mouse, so when he hears the word "Muad Dib" it reveals to him that his dreams of who he becomes have just happened in a completely organic way and it's profound and scary.

Also, the biggest change is probably the fact that they completely cut the son. This is very important because it motivates him to become the Kwisatz Haderach and to get revenge on the Harkonnens. Taking the son out is like taking away Bruce Wayne's parents and just having him decide that he better become Batman some day, because what else is he gonna do, lol. It makes the film seem more driven by ego rather than emotion. Story and character arcs should inform one another and in the book they do.

I really couldn't believe that they skipped this. Two films and over 5 hours and they still didn't have time to do his son. They didn't even do his little sister. Remember Alicia Witt from the original movie? lol. We were denied her. We only saw a shot of her from the future. I don't know how she's ever gonna get to be that age if they won't even let her be born.

It's a trend of Hollywood theses days. They don't seem to like to make films that take place over a long period of time, unless they're biopics. Everything has to take place all at once.

Well novels aren't like that. Dune isn't like that. It takes place in two separate time periods, which is why I thought they were doing two separate movies so they could do the time leap, but they didn't.

Also, this isn't really a change but I noticed that this movie and the previous movie (Dune Part One) tended to skip over most of the trippy sequences. I would have thought that any artistically inclined director would have welcomed the chance to do something with these sequences, but Denise isn't inclined so, I guess. He's got his way, his style and that's where it ends I guess. No room for experimentation I suppose.

Other than all this though, I thought the movie was great. Both of them have been something extraordinary and I welcome and look forward to all the sequels.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/1/2024, 2:58 PM
@ObserverIO - I am absolutely over the moon glad they left out his and Chani's first son being killed. Movies that feature the death or suffering of children disturb me. It does not take away from the main point that he wants revenge. The fact they killed his father and tried to kill him to me is motivation enough. Movies don't need to perfectly adapt the source materials. They neither have the time nor does it much of it add to the broader story.
harryba11zack
harryba11zack - 3/1/2024, 3:06 PM
@ObserverIO - a baby that dies is a no go area if you want mass appeal, they did the same in the walking dead with Rick's cuck baby judith.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/1/2024, 3:12 PM
@Forthas - I guess his father was motivation enough and he was already set on the path of war before his kid died.

I just couldn't believe that they're doing a massive version that more faithfully adapts the book and in two whole movies comprising over 5 hours they couldn't find time for this plot or to introduce his baby sister. Even David Lynch found the time to feature his sister in one, relatively short, 2hr flick.

I mean, make it three movies if you have to.

But I can respect that you and many others would have found it disturbing and maybe that's what they were thinking.
Forthas
Forthas - 3/1/2024, 3:22 PM
@ObserverIO - In terms of having Alia be born. It was fine the way they did it but I do think there was a way to have her be born and it not look too silly. If I were the director, I would have had her sign as opposed to try to talk. They could have maybe also aged her up. But that would have screwed up the timeline.
WarMonkey
WarMonkey - 3/2/2024, 4:25 PM
@ObserverIO - You know what is really crazy, the miniseries was only 4 and a half hours long and included a TON more book stuff in it and the war lasted years not a few months. The story was shorter but so much richer. It's a real shame, but if they merged that miniseries with Villenueve's visual it would be epic.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/3/2024, 3:43 AM
@WarMonkey - Absolutely agree. Adaptations that are not only faithful to the source material (like the mini-series) but also do that material justice (like Villenueve's movies) are the best adaptations. The worst are those that do neither.
Goldboink
Goldboink - 3/3/2024, 5:35 PM
@ObserverIO -
I didn't miss Leto. Dennis had to make a creative decision not to let years pass after the end of the first movie and the penultimate scenes. He cut out several years and thus, no Alia as a child and no Leto. Loved it and I must see it again.

I did miss the vision with the water of Life transformation. That should have been some trippy special effects and he needed to explain that better, maybe to his mother, certainly to Chani.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/4/2024, 4:06 AM
@Goldboink - I wonder why he decided not to let years pass though. It's the sort of go-to decision of Hollywood these days. They don't let movies breathe like they used to.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 3/4/2024, 4:18 AM
It's also kind of the story that years pass. The story is that they become a part of this tribe to escape the Harkonnens, yet everybody thinks they're dead. Then years later they have become ingratiated. He has not only formed a relationship with Chani but has a child, Lady Jessica is the Reverend Mother, this is their life now. Then when they meet Gurney it's a real moment. Not just "Oh good you survived", but "Holy [frick]! WTF?!". There's even a really emotional scene where Gurney goes off at Paul for all the years lost. He doesn't know whether to even trust him or not. And he's angry and upset. He thought he was dead for all those years.

All of the enemies of House Atreides have been certain that Paul and Lady Jessica are dead for so long that it's now become a historical fact.

So much weight has been taken away because it all has to happen in a rush. Because they think that audiences can't accept that life and stories take place over long periods of time. Unless of course it's a biopic. And even those are starting to go the same way. I saw that Whitney biopic recently and even though it took place over the course of decades, her whole career felt like it happened in about a week or two.

Also, if they are going to introduce characters like Alia, then she has to be born at some point. Time will have to pass at some point.
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder