STAR WARS: RETURN OF THE JEDI Revisited - 5 Things That Worked And 5 That Didn't

STAR WARS: RETURN OF THE JEDI Revisited - 5 Things That Worked And 5 That Didn't

We've now reached the end of our look back at the original Star Wars trilogy, but how did this finale stack up to the one George Lucas delivered with Revenge of the Sith years later? Find out here...

Feature Opinion
By JoshWilding - Jun 26, 2020 07:06 AM EST
Filed Under: Star Wars

The Star Wars franchise returned to the big screen in 2015 with The Force Awakens, and 2020 marks the first time since then we're not getting a movie set in a Galaxy Far, Far Away. The future of the franchise is also uncertain, with Rian Johnson reportedly still working on a trilogy and Taika Waititi recently announced as the director of an untitled adventure. 

However, neither of those have release dates, and it seems Lucasfilm is focusing on bringing this franchise to the small screen instead (courtesy of the recently launched Disney+ streaming service).

To fill that Star Wars shaped void in your lives, we're continuing to look back at the Skywalker Saga, and after delving into those divisive prequels, A New Hope, and The Empire Strikes Back, we've now reached the final chapter in George Lucas' master plan before he sold Lucasfilm to Disney, and they delivered their own take on his planned seventh, eighth, and ninth instalments. 

Return of the Jedi got a lot right, but made some crucial mistakes, and while it's nowhere near as divisive as The Rise of Skywalker, it certainly left Star Wars fans with an awful lot to talk about. 

So, to check this one out, all you guys need to do is click the "Next" button down below...
 

Did Work: The Jedi Knight

Knight

What a difference a year makes, eh? When Return of the Jedi begins, Luke has enacted a clever plan to rescue Han Solo from the clutches of Jabba the Hutt, and when we see him for the first time here, he’s become a fully fledged Jedi Knight.

Displaying some amazing lightsaber skills and a mastery of the Force, the one time farm boy couldn’t have been any different upon his return to Tatooine. With his black robes and a brand new green lightsaber (an interesting change), he looked every bit the part too.

It seemed a little convenient seeing as he trained with Yoda for such a short amount of time, but Marvel's Star Wars comics are now filling in the gap between The Empire Strikes Back and this film.
 

Didn't Work: A Second Death Star

Sta

Why?

That's the big question here, and the fact that another Death Star showed up so soon after the destruction of the first really cheapened the victory of the Rebels in A New Hope.

After all, Revenge of the Sith showed us that it’s something the Empire had been working on for decades, so the fact that they’d knocked together another – much bigger and more powerful than the last – so quickly seems a bit odd in hindsight, as does the fact that it once again had an easy to exploit fault to make it fairly easy to destroy.

As epic as the space battle may have been as Luke Skywalker and Darth Vader battled in front of the Emperor, this definitely felt like a retread of old ground in some ways, and we've yet to find out whether this was being built at the same time as the first one or whether it was just thrown together. 

With another weakness, of course!
 

Did Work: Endor Speeder Chase

Speeder

One of the most exciting and overlooked action sequences in the original Star Wars trilogy, Luke and Leia racing through the forests of Endor while being pursued by Stormtroopers stands as out as one of the franchise’s most kinetic and well put together set pieces.

Essentially flying motorbikes, the speeders made for a unique visual, especially as the previous movies had spent so much time in the air. Lucas would of course recapture this same excitement years later with the Podrace in the otherwise disappointing The Phantom Menace.

Alas, this one took an admittedly rather sour turn when it led to Luke and Leia meeting the Ewoks, something which proves once and for all that all good things do indeed come to an end.
 

Didn't Work: Boba Fett's Apparent Demise

Sarlacc

Despite the fact that The Empire Strikes Back had established Boba Fett as a firm fan-favourite, George Lucas still made the baffling decision to kill him off in perhaps the lamest way possible in Return of the Jedi. If the filmmaker really felt that there was no other way to end his story here, then there had to be a better way to have the bounty hunter meet his maker.

After all, his apparent demise boiled down to than Han Solo accidentally hitting his jetpack with a staff and sending him into the Sarlaac Pit for a slow and agonising death...we guess he deserved? 

While the Expanded Universe is no more, Disney has confirmed that Boba Fett managed to survive (much to the delight of fans), and he is now set to make his return in The Mandalorian on Disney+. 
 

Did Work: Slave Leia

Slave

A few years ago, it was confirmed that Disney had stopped producing any merchandise with Princess Leia in her slave costume, a decision which is understandable in many ways, but one that not even Carrie Fisher agreed with. That’s a shame, though, because regardless of how absolutely incredible the actress looked in this costume, she also got to kick some serious ass.

Bear in mind that Leia was responsible for killing Jabba the Hutt while chained up, giving her a role as pivotal as that of Luke and Han, and proving that she was no longer the vulnerable girl who had to be rescued in A New Hope. The fact she did it all while looking downright incredible was obviously a bonus, and the costume is of course now iconic. Sadly, it's just a tad dated!
 

Didn't Work: Leia Is Suddenly Luke's Sister

Luke-Leia

When Yoda (whose death happens far too quickly and feels wholly unnecessary) talked about there being "another." you’d think that it would have major ramifications for Return of the Jedi.

That wasn’t the case, and the reveal that Luke’s sister is Leia is actually handled very poorly, with it feeling like little more than a convenient way to squash the notion of any sort of romance between them because Lucas had decided that she was meant to be with Han.

While Vader briefly mentions her, you’d also think he would have had a bigger reaction to learning that the woman he kidnapped and had tortured was his daughter, and this is a reveal which feels too much like Lucas struggling to replicate The Empire Strikes Back’s big twist.
 

Did Work: Darth Vader Returns To The Light

Vad

Return of the Jedi may have featured an incredible space battle, but even more exciting was what was happening inside the Death Star. The highlight of the fight between Darth Vader and Luke Skywalker came when Anakin was forced to choose between his son and the Dark Side.

Regardless of their many faults, the prequels at least provided some insight into why Vader made this decision, as have Marvel's Star Wars comics (which revealed that he knows the Emperor had lied to him about the circumstances of Padme’s death).

All that aside though, and this was still a powerful moment, as well as one which didn’t necessarily fully redeem Vader, but did prove he was more than just a fearsome and entirely evil villain.
 

Didn't Work: The Ewoks

Ewoks

Look, you can be honest with us; when Star Wars: Battlefront was released, you totally spent all your time on the Endor map attempting to shoot these little bastards rather than other players, right?

The Battle of Endor would have been much better off without the infuriatingly stupid Ewoks, and the fact that these silly looking teddy bears played such a key role in proceedings were arguably a sign of the childish direction George Lucas would take the franchise in years later with The Phantom Menace.

The Ewoks added a lot of unneeded comedy to a final act where it really had no place, spoiling much of the action as a result. Making them blink just made them even weirder, and while they do have their fair share of fans, you can't really argue that they brought much to the movie. 
 

Did Work: "Let Me Look On You With My Own Eyes"

VaderD

With Darth Vader making up for his evil past by saving his son, Return of the Jedi did the right thing by giving him and Luke a very personal moment following his decision to bring the Emperor’s reign to an end. The unmasking is obviously a massive reveal, but more important than that is what’s said between these two.

Vader wanting to see Luke’s face with his own eyes and telling him to tell his sister that he was right about him still having some good within was definitely very powerful and memorable, and somewhat made up for his lack of reaction to learning he has a daughter as well as a son.

While Luke hoped he could save Vader, it was ultimately the right decision to kill him off. Whether it was the right move to have Hayden Christensen show up as a Force Ghost remains a big talking point.
 

Didn't Work: "Nooooooooooo!"

VaderD1

Added to George Lucas before he sold Lucasfilm to Disney, Return of the Jedi now gives Darth Vader a "Nooooo!" moment at the end of the movie which was one of the many tweaks George Lucas decided to make when the movies were all re-released on Blu-ray (it's still there on Disney+). 

Considering the fact that Vader’s borderline comical scream of anguish from Revenge of the Sith has been so widely criticised, why the filmmaker thought it would be a good idea to add that here (it’s not even a new recording; the dialogue has just been lifted from the prequel and placed over the scene) to the moment when the Sith Lord saves Luke from the Emperor is unclear.

It’s another unnecessary alteration, and while it’s one which doesn’t quite spoil that final fight, it definitely hurts it.
 

AHSOKA Season 2 Plans Reportedly Changed In Case Series Meets The Same Fate As THE ACOLYTE
Related:

AHSOKA Season 2 Plans Reportedly Changed In Case Series Meets The Same Fate As THE ACOLYTE

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW - Jude Law's Jod Na Nawood Claims To Be A Jedi In First Clips
Recommended For You:

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW - Jude Law's Jod Na Nawood Claims To Be A Jedi In First Clips

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
VileBlood
VileBlood - 6/26/2020, 7:16 AM
Lucas has ruined Return of the Jedi with all the stupid changes over the years. I can't even watch it anymore.
99OPTIMISTPRIME
99OPTIMISTPRIME - 6/26/2020, 7:17 AM
Nightwing1015
Nightwing1015 - 6/26/2020, 7:20 AM
ROTJ is my personal favourite but the 2nd Death Star concept is clumsy. Lucas said that in his original Star Wars plan, the story ended with the Death Star blowing up. But because he had to smash that 3 act structure into the first film, he had a problem. He had already destroyed the Death Star and that was meant to mark the end of the story.

So he just made another one, lol
GhostDog
GhostDog - 6/26/2020, 7:23 AM
“Did Work: Slave Leia"

knocturnalzen10
knocturnalzen10 - 6/26/2020, 7:43 AM
@BlackBeltJones - in this climate Josh maybe marked lol lol lol lmfao
GhostDog
GhostDog - 6/26/2020, 7:45 AM
@knocturnalzen10 - could be on a watch list and not even know haha
SgtSoggybottom
SgtSoggybottom - 6/26/2020, 7:39 AM
Did Work: Return of the Jedi
Didn't Work: This article and just about anything written by Josh Wilding
knocturnalzen10
knocturnalzen10 - 6/26/2020, 7:47 AM
as Josh types "slave Leia" this works right?.........

2 mins later .. oh well just go with my gut (feels right coach)
FleischerSupes
FleischerSupes - 6/26/2020, 8:00 AM
Need this Luke in Mandalorian. Especially if the Darksaber theories are true.

RevanIsMyMan
RevanIsMyMan - 6/26/2020, 8:02 AM
Ok I'm going to say this right now. Josh quit going with popular opinions especially when it involves the Ewoks. I can tell you right now that the Ewoks are scarier than shit, and tried to eat Han, Luke, Chewie, and somehow R2. I'm not [frick]ing with them.
rkshuttleworth
rkshuttleworth - 6/26/2020, 8:21 AM
@RevanIsMyMan - That's the thing lol. Every creature has the ability to be nasty lol
MasterMix
MasterMix - 6/26/2020, 8:17 AM
I despise the addition of "Nooooo!" That redemption is so perfect without having to say a word or show visible emotion.
RevanIsMyMan
RevanIsMyMan - 6/26/2020, 8:27 AM
@MasterMix - That I agree with. But it does seem he has never seen Star Wars until recently
WakandanQueen
WakandanQueen - 6/26/2020, 8:53 AM
OT: TLOU Part II sold a record breaking 4 million copies in its first weekend. Another win for the get woke, go broke crowd.
Nightwing1015
Nightwing1015 - 6/26/2020, 8:59 AM
@WakandanQueen - I'm not sure TLOU2 actually went "woke". I know there are many saying that it did because they want clicks on their videos and money.

But after playing it, there's nothing remotely "politically correct" about it. On the contrary. So I don't think anyone can actually say the game "went woke".
Nightwing1015
Nightwing1015 - 6/26/2020, 9:03 AM
@TheJustinHammer - Yeah exactly. Some people will literally say anything is "political correctness" for money. Doesn't make it true. A same sex relationship is obviously not forced political correctness.

So TLOU2 really has not bearing on the proposed relationship between "getting woke" and "going broke".
WakandanQueen
WakandanQueen - 6/26/2020, 9:13 AM
@Nightwing1015 - I know, but to that crowd of people just the existence of minorities anywhere is a woke politcal agenda shoved down their throats by the evil SJWs.
Nightwing1015
Nightwing1015 - 6/26/2020, 9:18 AM
@DutchCipher - Well some right wingers called the game woke. Only the ones intent on stirring up controversy. I doubt anyone who actually buys and plays the game can actually make a convincing argument that it's woke. Those who say it's woke tend not to have actually played it.
Nightwing1015
Nightwing1015 - 6/26/2020, 9:21 AM
@WakandanQueen - Yeah that is true those people are out there.

To be honest, I think it's pretty rare in media that you really get a product that goes out of its way to shove political correctness where it doesn't belong. I'm really struggling to think of more than a few instances of that. People make a fuss about that happening all the time but it's really very rare.
WakandanQueen
WakandanQueen - 6/26/2020, 9:27 AM
@TheJustinHammer - But I don't want politics in my games! I'm boycotting!
lawndart
lawndart - 6/26/2020, 9:39 AM
I never thought that a second Death Star was lazy nor clumsy. It was have been nice to see another new piece of hardware, it made sense to have another battle station.

The first major capability (regardless whether it is a ship, aircraft or ground vehicle ) that goes into production always takes more time because so often the processes and procedures are being developed during production to one degree or another. In addition, there are production milestones and limited use analysis and testing. Once the Empire reached a certain level of confidence in the manufacturing and item itself, they would naturally begin building another simultaneously.
1 2
View Recorder