CBM Community Update: What's Up With The Comments?

CBM Community Update: What's Up With The Comments?

A quick update for the CBM community regarding the ability to leave comments on the articles on the site. What's happened to them, why has it happened, & what's next (if anything)? Find out after the jump.

By NateBest - Mar 16, 2018 03:03 PM EST
Filed Under: Community
!!!UPDATE!!!

Just  a quick update! I saw a few users mention that they would have liked some type of warning before the comments were disabled, even if it was temporary. I've re-enabled the comments for this reason. I would like this post to foster feedback and suggestions to combat the problem. In case you missed it in the original post below, the comments are my favorite part of the site.

Possible solutions I've seen suggested so far:
  • Some type of waiting period before a user is allowed to post comments
    Maybe add profile requirements as well, like requiring an avatar?
  • Additional community members that can serve as moderators
    Note that this ability is already built into the site. If you would like to be added, reach out to me in the comments or via email

ORIGINAL POST


You've probably found your way to this post due to comments being shutdown on the site. For some it may be a surprise that the feature has been disabled. Others may be wondering why they weren't removed sooner. In any case I thought the CBM community might want to know WHY this has happened. If you're one of these that do, please continue reading.

For those familiar with the site, and the other sites that cover similar topics, news, etc., you may have noticed that CBM is one of the last sites around that actually let you comment on a story directly through the site. CBM's community is one of the unique aspects that have kept the site thriving since we opened the virtual doors back in 2003. Users being able to voice the pleasure, or displeasure as the case may be, is one of the great things about hosting a site like this. There has been passionate debate, awesome discussions, and some REALLY great GIFs shared with the community over the years. It's honestly my favorite thing about CBM. Interacting with all of you is always a ton of fun.

Unfortunately with the anonymity of the web also comes some unpleasant things. Trolls. Flame wars. Personal attacks against other users. The list can be endless, and equally just as depressing. We've tried a lot of different things including adding additional moderators, reintroducing the "Hall of Shame" (where all reported comments get queued up for moderator review), adding the ability to "block" (i.e. not see comments from other users), but it seems to be a losing battle. For whatever reason, some users refuse to act their age, much less be respectful of other users and their opinions. Threads continue to be derailed with unrelated at best, purely idiotic at worst, comments.

For this reason, the comments for all articles on the site, with the exception of this post, have been disabled. Will they return? That's really up to you guys.

Feel free to share any suggestions or feedback below. Maybe I should reinstitute the auto account disabling for users who receive too many reports? That definitely made the job easier for moderators, but just like the Hall of Shame, it was abused and innocent users had their accounts disabled...
THE MINISTRY OF UNGENTLEMANLY WARFARE Now Available On Home Video And We're Celebrating With A Giveaway
Related:

THE MINISTRY OF UNGENTLEMANLY WARFARE Now Available On Home Video And We're Celebrating With A Giveaway

What's Going On With The CBM Community - Is There A New Sheriff In Town?
Recommended For You:

What's Going On With The CBM Community - Is There A New Sheriff In Town?

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ...
AT3374
AT3374 - 3/16/2018, 2:39 PM
I can behave
PBIRD
PBIRD - 3/16/2018, 4:56 PM
@natebest
I can't see who likes my post? Why?
NateBest
NateBest - 3/16/2018, 5:14 PM
@PBIRD - The information is there, and it's stored. I just haven't figured out a decent way of displaying it.
Saintsinnister
Saintsinnister - 3/16/2018, 5:54 PM
@NateBest - Without comments I see no difference between you and other click bait article sites. This used to be about a community and the prospect of getting your own article on main page. These days only four members are allowed on main page. Now we can't even comment?!? I have been coming here since before the MCU even existed! You are letting clicks and crybabies run the site into something it is not supposed to be. Sad. You said it yourself, the comments are 80% of the reason to even open these lame stories.
PeaceMaker1
PeaceMaker1 - 3/16/2018, 10:31 PM
@NateBest - I gotta say even though I don’t comment much I feel if you disable the option your site will suffer dramatically for it. As much as it seems a massive pain in the ass I bet it won’t seem that bad compared to not having it and the traffic dropping massively. Just my opinion but I bet it’s not wrong, just let off some steam every now and then by abusing us all and I’m sure that will make it easier and we will get over it!
NateBest
NateBest - 3/16/2018, 10:40 PM
@Saintsinnister - Have you missed the new people contributing? I have more than 30 Power Users (or above) who have ability to post directly to the home page. ANY user can contribute and I move things over regularly myself when I see them. Unfortunately, of the 30+ contributors, only a handful are contributing regularly, but there are some great new people posting.

You also may have missed that the comments were put back up several hours ago and I updated the post to reflect this and gather more feedback from the community.
NateBest
NateBest - 3/16/2018, 10:41 PM
@PeaceMaker1 - I like that (let off steam and abuse everyone). That seriously made me laugh :P
Luminus
Luminus - 3/17/2018, 2:57 AM
@NateBest - There's only one solution to this. Restructure this place similar to the TrekBBS. You have a category for each type of discussion and link articles to the categories they belong to. They even have a section specifically designed for trolls to play, so to speak, and to have off-topic discussions where the rules for getting a ban are a lot less strict. It's the Neutral Zone, I believe. The place has changed, since I frequented it, though. I think the Neutral Zone has been done away with, but you get the point.

I mean, really, if someone wants to troll, they're going to troll, regardless of the criteria or punishments you put forth. You ban them, and they'll just make another screen name. You block their IP, and they'll just sign up with an alternate computer. I've found that if given an outlet, they'll take it.
CaptainElrond
CaptainElrond - 3/17/2018, 3:41 AM
@Luminus - "You block their IP, and they'll just sign up with an alternate computer. I've found that if given an outlet, they'll take it. "

Actually think most of them just change there Ip (unless they do get another computor just to comment on this site) There are ways to ban them even then though.
Saintsinnister
Saintsinnister - 3/17/2018, 3:44 AM
@NateBest - excuse me for not being up to the minute on the way this site is ran. If I am not wrong this whole post is about comment deletion. I figured this was a more formal attempt at letting the community know comments were being taken off of the site. None of this was very clear. But I am the A-hole right? A loyal clicker of various bull shnit articles by Josh that are a total waste of time just because it's the only thing whoever you are deems is better than the average joe's editorial? Sometimes I see 16-24 hours before a new article is put on main. I know average users are coming up with content. I also know you are making way more money than when I first started coming to this site. Things have gotten lazy around here. Nobody even asked you to monitor the comments. Now they are too much of a burden? Get over yourself and let the community be what it is. As gross as it. Who really cares?
XelCorp
XelCorp - 3/16/2018, 2:39 PM
Wow. My god...
xinstituto
xinstituto - 3/16/2018, 2:40 PM
Shit. Censorship here too. Let the people express, even if it is offensive for some. I personally dont offend people, but please! That's censorship against free speech.
Himura
Himura - 3/16/2018, 2:42 PM
@xinstituto - Freedom of speech doesnt mean freedom to be a douchebag and say whatever it is you want. On top of that, this is a privately run website that isnt bound to the US Constitution or any democracy. You give up those rights when you "read" the ToS when signing up for your account.
Emeraldbeast62
Emeraldbeast62 - 3/16/2018, 4:00 PM
@Himura - It's really a shame dialogue between users often finds its way to abusive exchanges which is unwarranted. I, for one come here to keep myself informed on the updates from our favorite movies, etc. It is indeed a privately run site and they need to realize that civility should have a place here. The Terms are very clear on this and banning persons may very well be an unfortunate avenue to go down. Just sayin'
XelCorp
XelCorp - 3/16/2018, 2:40 PM
During infinity war hype... perfect timing.
Kumkani
Kumkani - 3/16/2018, 2:43 PM
@XelCorp - People don't want to admit it but it's Marvel hype that bring the trolls out
WakandaKing
WakandaKing - 3/16/2018, 2:40 PM
Interesting decision, but can we keep comments turned off until after infinity war (just for spoiler purposes)
Himura
Himura - 3/16/2018, 2:41 PM
Good! I'm tired of all the off topic comments and discussions in almost every article. For example, go into a DC article and someone comments "have you seen [such and such] Marvel trailer?" and the entire first 3 pages are filled with comments about it rather than the article itself. And thats one of the more minor derailments that occur on a regular basis.
Ha1frican
Ha1frican - 3/16/2018, 3:36 PM
@Himura - So your solution to off topic discussion is no discussion.... that’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard.
SisterSunday52
SisterSunday52 - 3/16/2018, 4:10 PM
@Ha1frican - When it's stuff like "Why the hell are we wasting time on this shit. DC is dead. Bury it. Let's talk about this Marvel movie trailer." It's annoying as Hell. If you want to shit on DC and praise Marvel, do it on a Marvel article. If you don't care about DC, why comment on a DC article to comment that you don't care? Just browse something else.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ...
View Recorder