FAN CAST POLL: Who Should Play Captain America?

FAN CAST POLL: Who Should Play Captain America?

So many choices abound for this role. Do any of these actors have what it takes to play Captain America?

Fan Fic

By 6of13 - Oct 07, 2009 12:10 PM EST

Filed Under: Fan Fic

I have created this poll based upon research of potential candidates from the world wide web and the CBM community. Overall, I came across more than 40 names for this role. In order to eliminate any bias, some candidates have been omitted from this poll. Can any of these actors truly embody Captain America?

Alexander Skarsgard

Ben Browder

Casper Van Dien

Chris Pine

Cole Hauser

Eric Dane

John Barrowman

Jon Hamm

Josh Duhummel

Josh Lucas

Leonardo Dicaprio

Mark Valley

Michael Shanks

Matt Damon

Nathan Fillion

Patrick Wilson

Ryan McPartlin

Ryan Philippe

Tahmoh Penikett

Thomas Jane

About The Author:

6of13
Member Since 9/3/2009

A.I. - Artificial Ironman: An all original WHAT IF...

Related:

A.I. - Artificial Ironman: An all original WHAT IF...

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created Infinite Crisis Video

Recommended For You:

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created "Infinite Crisis" Video

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Show Comments

30 Comments

Related Headlines

PROJECT GAMMA: Disturbing HULK Short Film From 20 Years Ago Resurfaces, And It’s Just Too Awesome

Hulk

PROJECT GAMMA: Disturbing HULK Short Film From 20 Years Ago Resurfaces, And It’s Just Too Awesome

DanielKlissmman

Dec 03, 2025 11:12 AM

Incredible BATMAN: YEAR ONE Live-Action Costume Shows How Well A Comic-Accurate Batsuit Can Work On Screen

Batman

Incredible BATMAN: YEAR ONE Live-Action Costume Shows How Well A Comic-Accurate Batsuit Can Work On Screen

DanielKlissmman

Nov 30, 2025 05:11 PM

Incredible AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Fan Art Pits Captain America, Mister Fantastic, And Cyclops Against Doctor Doom

Avengers: Doomsday

Incredible AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Fan Art Pits Captain America, Mister Fantastic, And Cyclops Against Doctor Doom

JoshWilding

Nov 28, 2025 10:11 AM

Tom Holland's SPIDER-MAN Meets David Corenswet's SUPERMAN In Awesome Crossover Fan Art

Superman

Tom Holland's SPIDER-MAN Meets David Corenswet's SUPERMAN In Awesome Crossover Fan Art

JoshWilding

Oct 07, 2025 10:10 AM

Batman 3: For the right price, I will help the GCPD. Unless they are going to ask the Bat-Man for help.

Fan Fic

Batman 3: For the right price, I will help the GCPD. Unless they are going to ask the Bat-Man for help.

ager

Jul 13, 2025 07:07 AM

ANDOR Star Adria Arjona Suits Up As The DCU's WONDER WOMAN In Awesome New Fan Art

Wonder Woman

ANDOR Star Adria Arjona Suits Up As The DCU's WONDER WOMAN In Awesome New Fan Art

JoshWilding

Jul 07, 2025 06:07 AM

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Officially Announces Who Will Play Brainiac (And You Probably Don't Know Him)

THE ODYSSEY Leaked Trailer Teases Odysseus' Epic Journey And The Movie's Mythological Creatures

SPIDER-MAN Just Killed [SPOILER] In One Of The Most Heartbreaking Moments In Marvel Comics History

RUMOR: Seth Rogen's Mystery Role In DC Studios' SUPERGIRL Has Been Revealed - Possible SPOILERS

RUMOR: Deadpool's Role In AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Has Been Revealed - Possible SPOILERS

Latest Headlines

AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY's Second Teaser Trailer Has Arrived In Theaters - Will It Leak Online Before Next Weekend?

Avengers: Doomsday

AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY's Second Teaser Trailer Has Arrived In Theaters - Will It Leak Online Before Next Weekend?

JoshWilding

49 mins ago

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Reveals Comic Book Inspiration For Brainiac And Why He Didn't Cast An A-Lister

Man of Tomorrow

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Reveals Comic Book Inspiration For Brainiac And Why He Didn't Cast An A-Lister

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

LUKE CAGE Actor Mike Colter Sparks Speculation About Power Man’s MCU Return With Cryptic Social Media Comment

Luke Cage

LUKE CAGE Actor Mike Colter Sparks Speculation About Power Man’s MCU Return With Cryptic Social Media Comment

DanielKlissmman

15 hours ago

Avatar

AVATAR: FIRE AND ASH's CinemaScore Revealed As Threequel Gets Off To A Slow Start At The U.S. Box Office

JoshWilding

17 hours ago

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Officially Announces Who Will Play Brainiac (And You Probably Don't Know Him)

Man of Tomorrow

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Officially Announces Who Will Play Brainiac (And You Probably Don't Know Him)

JoshWilding

19 hours ago

THE ODYSSEY Leaked Trailer Teases Odysseus' Epic Journey And The Movie's Mythological Creatures

Fantasy

THE ODYSSEY Leaked Trailer Teases Odysseus' Epic Journey And The Movie's Mythological Creatures

JoshWilding

19 hours ago

Hot Headlines

96 comments

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Officially Announces Who Will Play Brainiac (And You Probably Don't Know Him)

JoshWilding

19 hours ago EST

83 comments

James Gunn And Peter Safran Confirmed To Be Staying On As DC Studios CEOs Following Netflix-WBD Merger

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago EST

56 comments

AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Trailer: Video Shows Fans Screaming And Cheering While Watching First Teaser In Theaters

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

47 comments

RUMOR: Seth Rogen's Mystery Role In DC Studios' SUPERGIRL Has Been Revealed - Possible SPOILERS

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

43 comments

YouTube Finally Shuts Down Established Deceptive Fake Trailer Makers

GabeReisinger

1 day ago EST

James Cameron Hits Back At Matt Damon's Claim He Lost Over $100 Million By Turning Down AVATAR

JoshWilding

6 mins ago

AVATAR: FIRE AND ASH's CinemaScore Revealed Ahead Of A Good, Not Great, Opening Weekend In The U.S.

JoshWilding

21 hours ago

THE ODYSSEY New Trailer Leaks Online And Offers A First Glimpse At The Movie's Mythological Creatures

THE ODYSSEY New Trailer Leaks Online And Offers A First Glimpse At The Movie's Mythological Creatures

JoshWilding

22 hours ago

AVATAR: FIRE AND ASH Takes In $12 Million From Thursday Previews As Rotten Tomatoes Score Drops

MarkCassidy

1 day ago

THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU Trailer Leaks Online After Debuting In Theaters With AVATAR: FIRE AND ASH

JoshWilding

2 days ago

STAR WARS: Shawn Levy Announces That STARFIGHTER Has Officially Wrapped Production

STAR WARS: Shawn Levy Announces That STARFIGHTER Has Officially Wrapped Production

MarkCassidy

2 days ago

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

STEEL BALL RUN: JOJO'S BIZARRE ADVENTURE Confirms March 2026 Release With New Trailer And Cast Details

STEEL BALL RUN: JOJO'S BIZARRE ADVENTURE Confirms March 2026 Release With New Trailer And Cast Details

MattThomas

16 hours ago

SAKAMOTO DAYS Season 2 In Production; First Trailer Teases Legendary Hitman’s Past

SAKAMOTO DAYS Season 2 In Production; First Trailer Teases Legendary Hitman’s Past

MattThomas

20 hours ago

KAIJU NO. 8 FINAL CHAPTER Announced With First Teaser Trailer

KAIJU NO. 8 FINAL CHAPTER Announced With First Teaser Trailer

MattThomas

21 hours ago

MY HERO ACADEMIA Anime Announces Special Episode Adapting Chapter 431

MY HERO ACADEMIA Anime Announces Special Episode Adapting Chapter 431

MattThomas

22 hours ago

WORLD TRIGGER REBOOT Anime Project Unleashes First Teaser Trailer And Details

WORLD TRIGGER REBOOT Anime Project Unleashes First Teaser Trailer And Details

MattThomas

22 hours ago

BLACK CLOVER SECOND SEASON Rumored 2026 Release Could Be Confirmed This Weekend At Jump Festa 2026

BLACK CLOVER SECOND SEASON Rumored 2026 Release Could Be Confirmed This Weekend At Jump Festa 2026

MattThomas

1 day ago

More Anime & Manga ►

INTERGALACTIC Missed Several Deadlines Causing Naughty Dog To REQUIRE Overtime

INTERGALACTIC "Missed Several Deadlines" Causing Naughty Dog To REQUIRE Overtime

GabeReisinger

1 day ago

CALL OF DUTY: BLACK OPS 7 Drops To Record-Low Price After Sales Slump

CALL OF DUTY: BLACK OPS 7 Drops To Record-Low Price After Sales Slump

MattThomas

3 days ago

ROBLOX's Ongoing Child Safety Concerns Is Driving Away Disney

ROBLOX's Ongoing Child Safety Concerns Is Driving Away Disney

GabeReisinger

3 days ago

TERMINATOR: SURVIVORS Delayed Indefinitely As Game Shifts To Full Single-Player

TERMINATOR: SURVIVORS Delayed Indefinitely As Game Shifts To Full Single-Player

MattThomas

3 days ago

FALLOUT Season 2 First Reviews Promises A Worthy NEW VEGAS Adaptation As Rotten Tomatoes Score Is Revealed

FALLOUT Season 2 First Reviews Promises A Worthy NEW VEGAS Adaptation As Rotten Tomatoes Score Is Revealed

JoshWilding

4 days ago

Wastelanders Rejoice! FALLOUT Season 2 Is Now Premiering Today

Wastelanders Rejoice! FALLOUT Season 2 Is Now Premiering Today

MarkJulian

5 days ago

More Video Games ►

ANACONDA Called The Most Pleasant Surprise Of The Year In First Social Media Reactions

ANACONDA Called The Most "Pleasant Surprise Of The Year" In First Social Media Reactions

MarkCassidy

3 days ago

M3GAN Spinoff SOULM8TE Has Been Taken Off Universal’s Release Calendar Following M3GAN 2.0 Flop

M3GAN Spinoff SOULM8TE Has Been Taken Off Universal’s Release Calendar Following M3GAN 2.0 Flop

DanielKlissmman

3 days ago

STRANGER THINGS: Netflix Releases Emotional First Teaser For The Series Finale - SPOILERS

STRANGER THINGS: Netflix Releases Emotional First Teaser For The Series Finale - SPOILERS

MarkCassidy

3 days ago

Famed YouTuber Jacksepticeye Is Producing Indie Horror Film GODMOTHER

Famed YouTuber Jacksepticeye Is Producing Indie Horror Film GODMOTHER

GabeReisinger

3 days ago

THE HOUSEMAID First Reviews Promise Good, Trashy Fun As The Movie's Rotten Tomatoes Score Is Revealed

THE HOUSEMAID First Reviews Promise "Good, Trashy Fun" As The Movie's Rotten Tomatoes Score Is Revealed

JoshWilding

4 days ago

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Creative Team Breaks Down Huge Pennywise Twist And Teases Future Seasons

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Creative Team Breaks Down Huge Pennywise Twist And Teases Future Seasons

JoshWilding

4 days ago

More Horror ►

TANGLED: The Actors Testing For Rapunzel And Flynn Rider In Disney Movie Have Finally Been Revealed

TANGLED: The Actors Testing For Rapunzel And Flynn Rider In Disney Movie Have Finally Been Revealed

JoshWilding

1 day ago

Live-Action GASTON Movie In Development At Disney From ACROSS THE SPIDER-VERSE Writer

Live-Action GASTON Movie In Development At Disney From ACROSS THE SPIDER-VERSE Writer

MarkJulian

5 days ago

ZOOTOPIA 2 Reached Billion Milestone Faster Than Any Other Animated PG Film

ZOOTOPIA 2 Reached Billion Milestone Faster Than Any Other Animated PG Film

GabeReisinger

5 days ago

ZOOTOPIA 2 Co-Director Jared Bush Celebrates Billion Dollar Milestone With Fan Q&A

ZOOTOPIA 2 Co-Director Jared Bush Celebrates Billion Dollar Milestone With Fan Q&A

MarkJulian

Dec 13, 2025 03:12 PM

Radio Flyer Studios' MAX & MAPLE: THE CAN-DO KIDS Wants To Fill The Narrative Kids Content Void

Radio Flyer Studios' MAX & MAPLE: THE CAN-DO KIDS Wants To Fill The Narrative Kids Content Void

GabeReisinger

Dec 13, 2025 10:12 AM

ZOOTOPIA 2 Officially Passes $1 Billion At The Global Box Office After Just 17 Days In Theaters

ZOOTOPIA 2 Officially Passes $1 Billion At The Global Box Office After Just 17 Days In Theaters

MarkCassidy

Dec 12, 2025 12:12 PM

More Cartoons & Animated ►

Tom Cruise Is DIGGER In First Look Teaser & Poster At Alejandro G. Iñárritu's Next Film

Tom Cruise Is DIGGER In First Look Teaser & Poster At Alejandro G. Iñárritu's Next Film

RohanPatel

2 days ago

Despair, Cannibals, And Martial Arts: LONE SAMURAI Is Now Available On Digital

Despair, Cannibals, And Martial Arts: LONE SAMURAI Is Now Available On Digital

MarkJulian

Dec 13, 2025 02:12 PM

Tom Cruise Reportedly “Grew Unhappy” With Paramount CEO David Ellison Over MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE

Tom Cruise Reportedly “Grew Unhappy” With Paramount CEO David Ellison Over MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE

DanielKlissmman

Dec 05, 2025 01:12 PM

First SPARTACUS: HOUSE OF ASHUR Reviews Illuminate High Quality Action And Storytelling

First SPARTACUS: HOUSE OF ASHUR Reviews Illuminate High Quality Action And Storytelling

MarkJulian

Dec 04, 2025 07:12 AM

RUSH HOUR 4 Is Reportedly Considered A Bad Idea By Many In Hollywood

RUSH HOUR 4 Is Reportedly Considered A Bad Idea By Many In Hollywood

DanielKlissmman

Dec 03, 2025 06:12 PM

SHELTER: Jason Statham Is An Elite, Former Assassin On The Run

SHELTER: Jason Statham Is An Elite, Former Assassin On The Run

MarkJulian

Dec 03, 2025 08:12 AM

More Action Movies & TV ►

SPOILERS! AEW DYNAMITE ON 34th STREET Results: December 24, 2025 - Diamond Ring Final & More

SPOILERS! AEW DYNAMITE ON 34th STREET Results: December 24, 2025 - Diamond Ring Final & More

AnthonyMango

9 hours ago

AAA GUERRA DE TITANES Results: Dominik Mysterio & El Grande Americano vs Rey Mysterio & Rey Fenix

AAA GUERRA DE TITANES Results: Dominik Mysterio & El Grande Americano vs Rey Mysterio & Rey Fenix

AnthonyMango

12 hours ago

Footage Of Title Change, Austin Theory's New Look, And More Leak From Pre-Taped 12/22 RAW and 12/26 SMACKDOWN

Footage Of Title Change, Austin Theory's New Look, And More Leak From Pre-Taped 12/22 RAW and 12/26 SMACKDOWN

JoshWilding

22 hours ago

TITLE CHANGE & Next Week's WWE SMACKDOWN SPOILERS! Results For December 26, 2025 - Joe Hendry vs The Miz

TITLE CHANGE & Next Week's WWE SMACKDOWN SPOILERS! Results For December 26, 2025 - Joe Hendry vs The Miz

AnthonyMango

1 day ago

Next Week's WWE MONDAY NIGHT RAW SPOILERS! Results For December 22, 2025 - Rhea Ripley vs Asuka & More

Next Week's WWE MONDAY NIGHT RAW SPOILERS! Results For December 22, 2025 - Rhea Ripley vs Asuka & More

AnthonyMango

1 day ago

John Cena Shares His Brutally Honest Take On The Rock And Travis Scott After They Vanished From WWE

John Cena Shares His Brutally Honest Take On The Rock And Travis Scott After They Vanished From WWE

JoshWilding

1 day ago

More Pro Wrestling ►

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Officially Announces Who Will Play Brainiac (And You Probably Don't Know Him)

THE ODYSSEY Leaked Trailer Teases Odysseus' Epic Journey And The Movie's Mythological Creatures

SPIDER-MAN Just Killed [SPOILER] In One Of The Most Heartbreaking Moments In Marvel Comics History

RUMOR: Seth Rogen's Mystery Role In DC Studios' SUPERGIRL Has Been Revealed - Possible SPOILERS

RUMOR: Deadpool's Role In AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Has Been Revealed - Possible SPOILERS

96 comments

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Officially Announces Who Will Play Brainiac (And You Probably Don't Know Him)

JoshWilding

19 hours ago EST

83 comments

James Gunn And Peter Safran Confirmed To Be Staying On As DC Studios CEOs Following Netflix-WBD Merger

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago EST

56 comments

AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Trailer: Video Shows Fans Screaming And Cheering While Watching First Teaser In Theaters

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

47 comments

RUMOR: Seth Rogen's Mystery Role In DC Studios' SUPERGIRL Has Been Revealed - Possible SPOILERS

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

43 comments

YouTube Finally Shuts Down Established Deceptive Fake Trailer Makers

GabeReisinger

1 day ago EST

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Home | Index | Site Map | About | Terms Of Service | Community Guidelines | Privacy | Copyright | Trademark Contact | Advertise

© 2025 ComicBookMovie.com®. All Rights Reserved.

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site, ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions. Content herein has been submitted by users who have agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. ComicBookMovie.com and Best Little Sites LLC are not liable for inaccuracies, errors, or omissions.

Learn more about our copyright and trademark policies

Contact Us for removal of copyrighted images, trademarks, or other issues.

View Recorder