ALIEN: ROMULUS Includes A Controversial ALIEN Resurrection - SPOILERS

ALIEN: ROMULUS Includes A Controversial ALIEN Resurrection - SPOILERS

Fede Alvarez's Alien: Romulus is now in theaters, and the movie features one particular call-back to Ridley Scott's original Alien that's proved to be highly controversial...

By MarkCassidy - Aug 16, 2024 09:08 AM EST
Filed Under: Alien
Source: Via FearHQ

Alien: Romulus is now in theaters, and while reviews have been very positive for the most part, you may have noticed that quite a few critics mentioned something that didn't work for them (some had no problem spoiling it outright).

Below, we break down what will likely be the most controversial and divisive aspect of the movie.

If you haven't been to see the movie yet, major spoilers follow.

When Rain Carradine and her crew arrive on the derelict space station, they discover that the ship's android is still functional despite clearly being in very bad shape after a Xenomorph attack. They plug him in to discover what happened, and we see that the synthetic (sorry... artificial person) is the same model as Ash from Ridley Scott's original movie.

Yes, the late Ian Holm is resurrected via CGI (AI?), and the results are just as ghastly and unconvincing as they have been pretty much every time any other movie has attempted this. Seriously, it looks like the other characters are standing around chatting to a dummy with a Snapchat filter for a face.

Whichever way you happen to feel about this character's inclusion, the android - who goes by Rook - proves to be an interesting addition to the story, ultimately hacking into Andy's programming and giving him a new prime directive: retrieve the adult Xeno and/or the Prometheus 5 formula, an experimental serum Weyland-Yutani has manufactured to advance human evolution.

This overrides Andy's more compassionate, child-like personality, and he becomes far more cold and ruthless. However, Rook doesn't count on the bond between the android and his human "sister," and things do not go according to the science officer's plan (more on this later).

What did you make of the decision to use Holm's likeness for Rook? Let us know in the comments section down below, and click here to check out our review.

"The sci-fi/horror-thriller takes the phenomenally successful Alien franchise back to its roots: While scavenging the deep ends of a derelict space station, a group of young space colonizers come face to face with the most terrifying life form in the universe."

The film stars Cailee Spaeny (Priscilla), David Jonsson (Agatha Christie’s Murder is Easy), Archie Renaux (Shadow and Bone), Isabela Merced (The Last of Us), Spike Fearn (Aftersun), and Aileen Wu. Fede Alvarez (Evil Dead, Don’t Breathe) directs from a screenplay he wrote with frequent collaborator Rodo Sayagues (Don’t Breathe 2) based on characters created by Dan O’Bannon and Ronald Shusett.

Alien: Romulus is produced by Ridley Scott (Napoleon), who directed the original Alien and produced and directed the series’ entries Prometheus and Alien: Covenant, Michael Pruss (Boston Strangler), and Walter Hill (Alien), with Fede Alvarez, Elizabeth Cantillon (Charlie’s Angels), Brent O’Connor (Bullet Train), and Tom Moran (Unstoppable) serving as executive producers.

ALIEN: ROMULUS Director Fede Álvarez Will Return To Helm A Sequel... Provided There's A Story Worth Telling
Related:

ALIEN: ROMULUS Director Fede Álvarez Will Return To Helm A Sequel... Provided There's A Story Worth Telling

ALIEN: EARTH Teaser Reveals New Xenomorph Footage & An Intriguing Timeline Change
Recommended For You:

ALIEN: EARTH Teaser Reveals New Xenomorph Footage & An Intriguing Timeline Change

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 9:03 AM
This film wasn't great. It somehow makes Covenant and Prometheus feel like far more interesting films than they really are. Romulus has a solid first hour that becomes derivative and honestly boring once they get to the space station because it then becomes a full reboot/remake......a full on Alien remake akin to The Force Awakens. The only good character is Andy....and Rain, although played by a great actor, just felt like discount Ripley unfortunately. She didn't have enough going on in the screenplay emotionally with Andy to really make her stand apart. It's there, but its surface area, shallow...the potential was there but the script never truly develops it far enough to make it stand out. The ending goes full Alien Resurrection and is hilariously dumb. Just a big disappointment.
Vigor
Vigor - 8/16/2024, 9:15 AM
@McMurdo - I'm an outlier in that I adore prometheus and alien resurrection, the latter of which released during my impressionable youth

I was too young or rather, not alive for alien and aliens. So they never resonated with me
Resurrection came out at that ideal age for me just like how phantom menace was for star wars

bobevanz
bobevanz - 8/16/2024, 9:31 AM
@McMurdo - you're allowed your opinions, but this movie is leagues better than Alien 3 and Resurrection, and every movie that came afterwards. There's not much to do in an Alien movie, borrowing from others and improving in it was the only way and it worked for me
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 9:48 AM
@bobevanz - I agree it's better than Resurrections. It's probably on par with Alien 3 in terms of writing. Alien 3 just over stays it's welcome but it at least tried some new things in regards to the environment of the prison. But I don't think Alien 3 is by any means a good film. Resurrections is awful.

Covenant had less idiot scientists doing idiot things seeing as how it consisted couples and colonizers rather than biologists and geologists...still had characters doing dumb things but less so than Prometheus.

Romulus has Andy. That's it. And they drop the ball with him by degrading his intelligence in the final act. It's interesting making him a simpleton synthetic reprogrammed for protection and then he gets upgrades and takes off as a character and morally becomes questionable. That's compelling. The third act botches that aspect.


All the rehashed dialogue from Alien and Aliens. The copy and paste endings of Alien/Resurrection/Prometheus.

This felt like a studio mandated "next up" IP addition.

I think Covenant is the third best Alien film despite it also not being a great movie. It just had more going on and it has David.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 9:56 AM
@Vigor - I enjoyed Prometheus on the philosophical level. That initial trailer is maybe thee single greatest trailer of all time and I don't believe that's hyperbole. The scientists being complete morons ruined the verisimilitude of the film and took me out of the film and it doesn't get better on rewatch unfortunately. It's a beautiful film though and I love the ideas....the script just failed the story.
jst5
jst5 - 8/16/2024, 10:57 AM
@McMurdo - It's not a bad film...worth seeing but it's far from a classic like Alien and Aliens.I did find most of the main characters pretty uninteresting.I do agree about the Rain charcter...she's a Dollar Tree Ripley.The "alien" at the end of the film was pretty freaky...the face hungers and xenomorphs have lost their scary factor at this point.

I actually liked Prometheus was very interested in where that story was going.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 11:38 AM
@JackBurton1 - if you can see it for matinee price id agree. I regret paying 17 bucks to see this in iMax. And the theater of people....no one reacted to any of the scenes. It was a silent theater.
Vigor
Vigor - 8/16/2024, 11:41 AM
@McMurdo - to me the scientists being idiots is that dose of realism I enjoy in a movie. Just because they have degrees doesn't mean they know how to act when faced with one of the greatest discoveries of all time which is fauna on another planet.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 11:48 AM
@Vigor - the biologist tries to pet an alien snake lol. And the geologist literally gets lost in a cave system after being the guy who maps out the cave system.
jst5
jst5 - 8/16/2024, 12:11 PM
@McMurdo - Biologist seemed like a doofus from the start...so wasn't surprised.The geologist mapped out the cave system and the info was sent back to the ship...he had no idea what the mapping looked like.

The worst part of the movie was cutting out the dialog with the Engineers.
Nightmare
Nightmare - 8/16/2024, 1:53 PM
@McMurdo - I knew it. I got thay feeling when I watched the trailer it was doing the same things as the first 2 movies and even Covenant. Nothing new to the table.
rychlec
rychlec - 8/16/2024, 5:23 PM
@McMurdo - Just got back from seeing it and I'm right there with ya.
Spidey91
Spidey91 - 8/16/2024, 9:06 AM
yeah yeah, that was kinda kinda "ehh" from an otherwise really good movie...oh and by the way WHAT IN THE ACTUAL F*CK WAS THAT THING AT THE END? JESUS F. CHRIST.
IAmAHoot
IAmAHoot - 8/16/2024, 9:11 AM
Alien Resurrection?...

User Comment Image
dragon316
dragon316 - 8/16/2024, 5:47 PM
@IAmAHoot - that disgusting looking alien look closely you can person eyeball in costume
ReverseFlasher
ReverseFlasher - 8/16/2024, 9:13 AM
Havent read the article/spoiler but just came to say you really DONT need to be posting this article yet. Nor the ones you posted hours ago on the other forums. I get youre excited to have discussions, but the movie is barely even out and even the censored title kinda spoils something I would very much rather see revealed in the theater.

That is all.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 9:50 AM
@ReverseFlasher - how bout you just....shock, horror, lightning crackle lightning crackle......DONT CLICK ON THE ARTICLE.
ReverseFlasher
ReverseFlasher - 8/16/2024, 10:19 AM
@McMurdo - shock…horror…moron! read more carefully, like i said even the title kinda spoils it IMO, and DID NOT READ THE ARTICLE. But please act superior some more.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 10:48 AM
@ReverseFlasher - Stay off the internet.
TrentCrimm
TrentCrimm - 8/16/2024, 1:43 PM
@ReverseFlasher -

I'm surprised he even waited this long tbh.

Wilding usually has 20 different spoiler articles up before the movie is even released.

Heaven forbid they give people time to actually watch the movie before trying to have a discussion on every spoiler in the movie.
AllsGood
AllsGood - 8/16/2024, 9:20 AM
I saw Alien: Romulus last night. I thought it was Awesome 5 Stars / 5 Stars for me. Now my favorite Alien movie. Will see again this weekend.


User Comment Image
bobevanz
bobevanz - 8/16/2024, 9:32 AM
@AllsGood - okay saying it's better than the first two is sacrilegious lol
Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 8/16/2024, 10:30 AM
@bobevanz - Come on. It's DoubleD. Shills gotta shill.
Shmokey20
Shmokey20 - 8/16/2024, 12:09 PM
@AllsGood - It's my 3rd favorite now after Aliens & Alien, I really loved this movie! It was a Hell of a ride, especially watching it in 4DX!
AllsGood
AllsGood - 8/16/2024, 2:04 PM
@bobevanz - My favorite list for top 3 Alien films.

1) Alien: Romulus
2) Aliens
3) Alien

I was not big fan of Covenant and Prometheus very boring.

Alien: Covenant was 2 Stars out of 5 Stars.

Prometheus was 3 Stars out 5 Stars.
XtremeXFan
XtremeXFan - 8/16/2024, 9:35 AM
saw it yesterday with a buddy off mine, loved the sets, the cast, and the beatifull practical effects.

Its both a good sequel to the OG and Prometheus.

Spoilers: using Ian holmes likeness felt kinda weird, but with him being an andoid it kinda works with the uncanny valley, seeing as he is, not a real human.
XtremeXFan
XtremeXFan - 8/16/2024, 9:41 AM
@XtremeXFan - Ian Holm*
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 9:52 AM
@XtremeXFan - it was bad. Ash poops out his old lines lol. "I prefer artificial being".


Like give me a break. Write your own dialogue.
Shmokey20
Shmokey20 - 8/16/2024, 12:08 PM
@XtremeXFan - Agreed, I loved the film & I was cool with Ian being in the film, it makes sense.
philinterrupted
philinterrupted - 8/16/2024, 1:39 PM
@McMurdo - if he’s an android it would make sense as far as a programming perspective that he’d say the same thing.

Now, on the other hand, the “get a way from her you bitch” call back was completely out of place no matter how you look at it.
TheCoonII
TheCoonII - 8/16/2024, 9:52 AM
I’ll judge it when i see the movie as I always have but sounds like something Michael fassbender or perhaps even lance Henriksen easily could have done
philinterrupted
philinterrupted - 8/16/2024, 1:40 PM
@TheCoonII - I was expecting lance Henriksen, but with the context of the movie in relation to Prometheus, Fassbender would have been perfect.
FinnishDude
FinnishDude - 8/16/2024, 9:54 AM
The movie was kinda the most generic version of an Alien movie. Better than Covenant, Resurrection and AvP2 (really conflicted with myself whenever it's better or worse than the first AvP), but it brought nothing note-worthy to the franchise and the fact that the wording on how Rook was credited makes me really worried that they used A.I. and I'm genuily mad that I was possibly tricked to support the usage of it.
McMurdo
McMurdo - 8/16/2024, 10:00 AM
Btw....they literally telegraph the entire ending so early into the film. "Derrrr OH YOUR'E PREGNANT?!?!?"



yeah no one in the audience thought "I bet that totally doesn't come back up later in the film."
Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 8/16/2024, 10:28 AM
Sounds terrible.
When did Ian Holm give Fox written permission to use his likeness after his death, or did his "estate" do this?
This is an ugly, cheap, and disrespectful tactic and it always comes off as unnecessary and exploitative.
"Modern Hollywood" is a sewer pipe of unoriginality and trash.
User Comment Image
Jacory
Jacory - 8/16/2024, 11:16 AM
The article title is confusing in relation to the main body of the article. I saw the movie yesterday, so I understand the Alien Resurrection reference, but it wasn't spoiled in the article.
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 8/16/2024, 11:22 AM
@Jacory - I was prob trying to be a bit too clever there... I meant that the movie includes a character resurrection from the first Alien.
Nomis929
Nomis929 - 8/16/2024, 12:39 PM
The movie is Very much a tribute to the first 4 Alien movies.

And it's the closest of any of the Alien sequels that look like Ridley Scott had directed it circa 1979.

I give it a 4/5. or B.
TheJester187
TheJester187 - 8/16/2024, 12:58 PM
I enjoyed it! Still love Prometheus but this was a fun trip!
Nomis929
Nomis929 - 8/16/2024, 12:59 PM
By the by, I wouldn't be suprise if David Jonsson get a best supporting actor nod out of his performance as Andy.
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder