POLL: THOR VS The Incredible Hulk (On Screen Versions)!

;P

the way thor takes out the destroyer so quickly,i think the hulk wouldn't be much of a threat.

thor vs hulk,could be the best fight ever put on screen.

it must happen in the avengers.

But Thor is the most powerful one there is .

um...Hulk should be able to beat Thor. Thor looked more impressive in the movie, but in the comics Thor has NEVER beaten the Hulk one on one. And they've fought numerous times.

Thor might be very powerful, but that doesn't matter if none of it really hurts the Hulk that bad.

and if Thor can take out the Hulk by himself, then why would the Avengers need to be there to help? They will make Hulk tougher than Thor, it only makes sense from every way you look at it.

@ Thunderforce

I know you're a huge Thor fan, but come on, Thor has never beaten Hulk by himself. The proof is in the comics.

HULK SMASH!!!!!!!

@tea... WHATCHA GONNA DO BROTHER!!!! WHEN HULKAMANI COMES TO YOU

hulk will kick thor's ass!

Hulk could never lift Thor's hammer.

bazinga!!!

Movie Thor would win based on what we've seen from Incredible Hulk and Thor. Thor was portrayed as pretty much unstoppable with his hammer and if drops the hammer on Hulk like he did with Loki, Hulk's pretty much immobile. Of course, I think if we do see a Thor/Hulk confrontation in the Avengers film, however brief, we'll likely see an inconclusive stalemate or possibly the Hulk looking *slightly* better if it's just a brawl.

In the comics, Thor and Hulk are only really portrayed as equals when Thor fights down to Hulk's level (ie. brawling, keeping things physical). When Thor uses his various powers, though, while Hulk can amp his strength to surpass that of Thor's (though Thor has matched the Hulk's own increasing strength for hours on end before), it's quite obvious that Thor operates on a much larger scale than that of the Hulk.

I will give this to Thor, Hulk should have displayed more powerful in the movie. Besides if u seen Hulk #622 early this year, Hulk got his ass handed to him by Zues!

I say even.

Now i well know that Hulk has bested thor in the comics
But that HULK VS. cartoon was ridiculous. SO its telling me that wolverine can have hulk screaming and on his knees in agony and put up a better fight then Thor? no way.

I think Thor could beat Hulk but only if he really wants to. As someone mentioned, Thor isn't trying to kill Hulk, although Hulk is trying to SMASH (kill) Thor lol So i think Thor holds back.

In the movie Avengers i think they will tie

@ Sagemode: Yeah, there's been a couple of times where Thor was outright pissed and out for blood, but usually it's Thor who's trying to fight the Hulk without endangering innocent people as Hulk's on the rampage. It says a lot about Thor's power if he's able to draw/stalemate an angry Hulk whose strength is constantly increasing for extended periods of time.

And yeah, Zeus beating the crap out of Hulk isn't a mark against him. Just recently, Odin beat up Thor in a brief scuffle and if Thor was replaced by Hulk in that comic, he would lose, too. He did fight for months on end against a Zeus who was testing him, but if Zeus wanted Thor dead, he'd likely kill him about as easy as Odin would.

for the people basing there decision on the movies, what did thor actually do that was any more powerful then TIH?? when i saw the movie most of the fight scenes were shaky as hell and i hate that in movies like bb, and him beating destroyer that quick is wrong , i liked the movie but he didnt come off that strong to me .i actually saw what hulk was doing in his movie .

Hmmmmm ALL of the most recent theories are FLAWED!! HULK is the frigging man. Hmmm let me think Odin put a spell on mjolnir so only those worthy could weild....Hmmm let me think HULK is the only mofo to do that. He is either worthy enough to hold shield...regardless of his rampages...OR...he is strong enough to bypass the spell Odin put on it. On both counts that equates to him being as strong if not stronger than Thor.
Now dont for one second think Im saying it would be a quick fight but it would be an awesome one!!
On a further note...go back over your marvel comics for the last couple of years as well...if you cant be arsed ill remind you cretins:
1.World War Hulk...the only person strong enough to battle HULK was the SENTRY...the MOST POWERFUL BEING IN THE MARVEL UNIVERSE
2. SENTRY...took down ASGARD in one fell swoop and the battle between Thor and Sentry pretty much was stalemated also. But Thor was scared you saw it in his eyes. To be fair they never actually had a one to one either.
3. "HULK is strongest there is"...Even Marvel have said it...Hulk would win eventually...
But its something i would pay to see...

I think you guys are taking his facial expression as fear...well i think its just surprised..and theres a big difference between scared and surprised...lol...he wasnt scared.

When the hell has Hulk ever lifted Mjolnir in the mainstream Marvel 616 continuity? Never. Red Hulk/Rulk used a combination of his absorbing powers and a gravity free environment to pick up Mjolnir, both of which scream "plot device".

As far as feats/accomplishments go, Thor's done more impressive things than Hulk has. There's really no compare. And virtually every time they have fought one another, it's always Thor using his bare hands and Mjolnir as a melee weapon, not Thor using his vast elemental control or Godblast or Antiforce or opening a portal to the sun, etc. And when Thor does use his other powers, he's knocked out Hulk before with lightning and summoned a rain storm (yes, rain) which was so powerful not even Hulk could move in its downpour.

I don't think anyone is disputing that Hulk's strength once he gets angry enough exceeds that of Thor, but if you look at their respective victories and feats and compare them, it's obvious Marvel portrays Thor as being overall more powerful than the Hulk, as strength and power are categorized as two different things.