ecksmanfan Reviews Captain America: The First Avenger

ecksmanfan Reviews Captain America: The First Avenger

Joe Johnston had me a bit nervous. The review embargo didn't help much and I was not really impressed by the many trailers for the film. How does Captain America: The First Avenger hold up to his Avengers counter-parts? Let's find out!

Review Opinion
By ecksmanfan - Jul 23, 2011 11:07 AM EST
Source: GeekBoyMovieNews

Rewind a couple of years to when we first saw Iron Man hit the screens and Marvel's attempt at creating a movie universe took off with flying colors. This is a concept that DC Comics and Marvel alike only dreamed of and most were surprised at how well the idea was accepted. Soon after, other characters were getting their own films, including Thor and Captain America; toss in characters like Black Widow and Hawkeye, who have appeared in Iron Man 2 and Thor respectively, and you have yourself one of the most recognizable teams in comic history: The Avengers. This film is actually teased in the after-credits scene in Captain America. So how does ol' Cappy's film compare to his counter parts? Just fine, if not a little better! Captain America: The First Avenger is a fun, flag-waving war movie that will bring a smile to your face. Which is something that is hard for a comic book movie to pull off now days.

Steve Rogers only wants one thing: to serve his country during World War 2. But his sick-ridden, scrawney body won't allow him to enter into the greatest army in the world. But his strong will and desire to rid the world of bullies catches the eye of the creator of a "Super Soldier" serum and he gets his chance to serve. After an incredible transformation, Rogers, now called Captain America, (a name he received in a rather funny way), heads off to Germany to take down Red Skull, the leader of the Nazi science and development division. Red Skull is a man who is even more delusional than Hitler and will stop at nothing to take over the world. But Captain America and his Howling Commandoes will do all they can to stop him.

Obviously, this story is adapted from the Marvel comic of the same name, and while I've not read these books, I do know a bit of Cap's history and this is a great version of the story, updated a bit to appease today's audiences. The film is well paced and follows a well-tested pattern of action movies that has served Hollywood so well for many years. The best way I can describe this film is a bit of Iron Man and the Rocketeer, tossed in with a bit of Indiana Jones. The way the characters are written and acted, the film has an almost nostalgic feel to it which is both fun and different.

Director Joe Johnston (Wolfman, The Rocketeer) carries over his ability to capture stunning scenery and set pieces, creating a period piece out of a comic book movie; something that is not easy to do successfully. Being that Johnston's film history is rather hit or miss (in the opinion of this geek), he was the element of this film that I was worried about. Luckily, I was proven wrong.

When Chris Evans was announced as the actor who had landed the coveted role of Captain America, fans were divided. Some felt that he was perfect for the role, myself included; others felt that because he had played another comic book movie role in the Human Torch in the Fantastic Four films, he'd had his chance and wanted someone new. Regardless, he pulls this one off very well and I am excited to see him take the role in new directions with the Avengers film and future Captain America films. Tommy Lee Jones, not surprisingly, nearly stole the whole show with his one -liners and perfect delivery, providing for many of the film's comedic moments. Stanley Tucci was perfect casting for the role of Dr. Erskine, creator of the Super Soldier serum, embracing the role with every bit of his being. Hugo Weaving, who seems to own the concept of villainry, takes on Red Skull just as you'd expect him to. Hayley Atwell, who plays Peggy Carter, is not only stunning to look at, but has shown her capabilities as an actress and there is no doubt in my mind she will soon be a leading lady for Hollywood. The rest of the crew is superbly casted, only adding to the powerhouse cast that Johnston and company have set up.

From the moment you see Chris Evans as a scrawny, wanna-be soldier, you knew the rest of the special effects in the film would be top notch. It was both awesome and creepy how they pulled that off in the first scenes of the film; creating a believable look for the character. The enhanced fight scenes and techology for the film were done very well, without making them look cheesy and out of place. The high-tech planes and weapons of Hydra were well designed and well utilized throughout the film, providing a great contrast to the traditional weapons of the American team.

One thing I picked up on throughout the film, specifically during fight scenes, was the attention given to the sound of Cap's shield as he was using it to disarm and take down opponents. The "clang" that came along with these actions was near perfect in my eyes. Not overly obnoxious, but enoough to make it noticeable and unmistakeable. Speaking of sound, Alan Silvestri's score was nothing astounding, but it allowed for a patriotic feeling and ambiance to be created, which is really all it needed.

A complaint that I have had with Marvel Studios films, with the exception of The Incredible Hulk, is that the action scenes leave me wanting more. They are usually over too fast and are almost anti-climactic. Captain America does a better job and improves on that missing piece, but I thing there could still be more. Hopefully, the Avengers will solve that problem.

Overall, Captain America is a fun, action film that happens to be a comic book movie. I enjoyed this one more than I did Thor, but I don't think it was quite up to par with the first Iron Man film. With each film they make, Marvel and company are improving on their stories and films and DC Comics and Warner Bros. should be taking notes. Captain America will be a fun film series and charcter to watch unfold in the coming years, here's to hoping for bigger and better that we've already seen! Now....BRING ON THE AVENGERS!

Grade: B+
THE SHIFT Star Neal McDonough Talks Possible MCU Return As CAPTAIN AMERICA's Dum Dum Dugan (Exclusive)
Related:

THE SHIFT Star Neal McDonough Talks Possible MCU Return As CAPTAIN AMERICA's Dum Dum Dugan (Exclusive)

STAR TREK: DISCOVERY Star Ethan Peck Reveals He Auditioned For Lead Role In CAPTAIN AMERICA: THE FIRST AVENGER
Recommended For You:

STAR TREK: DISCOVERY Star Ethan Peck Reveals He Auditioned For Lead Role In CAPTAIN AMERICA: THE FIRST AVENGER

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

golden123
golden123 - 7/23/2011, 11:51 AM
So you gave this a B+ yet you don't explain this films faults that made it a B+ instead of an A+. I am sorry, but the fact that you only focus on the positive makes this a bad review.
ecksmanfan
ecksmanfan - 7/23/2011, 11:56 AM
The faults? Fight scenes were lacking (as with other Marvel movies), the dialogue was a bit corney at times, the fight "montage" was random and a bit confusing. The film was good, but ti simply is not worthy of an A+ grade, which VERY few films deserve.
Badawi
Badawi - 7/23/2011, 12:02 PM
what's with the greatest army in the world bullsh*t, everybody in their right mind know that WWII was won by the RED army, THE Greatest army in the world at that time!
djohnpi
djohnpi - 7/23/2011, 12:04 PM
I for one would like to here the bad about this film myself. Being a long time fan i just LOVED this movie and i think its THE BEST CBM so far. Like or not i really don't care i loved it. JUST ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AUTISTICSPIDER
AUTISTICSPIDER - 7/23/2011, 12:04 PM
Great flick, really worth the money and the 3D didn't even pull me out of the movie like it usually does. But yes the fight scenes were a bit lacking and the montage needed to be explained further. It completely deserves the B+ rating that you gave it, if not an A-.

And yes B+ is a very good rating for a movie, only the most perfect of movies recieve an A+.
MoonDoggyX
MoonDoggyX - 7/23/2011, 12:05 PM
"Overall, Captain America is a fun, action film that happens to be a comic book movie. I enjoyed this one more than I did Thor, but I don't think it was quite up to par with the first Iron Man film."

Exactly how i feel about it. Iron Man was an A-/B+ and 4 films later, they can't match/top it. But I do give Marvel kudos for at least not making any movies worse than a B. Kinda has me worried about the Avengers... But then I remember its being directed by Joss Wheadon and my worries go away... lol
comicbookjerk
comicbookjerk - 7/23/2011, 12:13 PM
Uhhg I have to read all of that?
comicbookjerk
comicbookjerk - 7/23/2011, 12:14 PM
Damnit ecks lol you took alot of your point of fews from our chat lol But Im glad someone was listening lol
ecksmanfan
ecksmanfan - 7/23/2011, 12:18 PM
@Arrion-It was true! You were just too drunk to get it across!
TheDorkKnight
TheDorkKnight - 7/23/2011, 12:18 PM
Captain America... [frick] yeah. Good review. I agree that the fight scenes were kinda lacking but it was still a good movie overall. On a side note, The Avengers trailer made me jizz in my pants slightly.
comicbookjerk
comicbookjerk - 7/23/2011, 12:22 PM
@ECKmanfan ...When your Right your right :) Being drunk seeing Captain America and then finding out that his new powers made it where he couldnt get drunk made me sad :P

Great Review!
StSharp
StSharp - 7/23/2011, 12:42 PM
Nice review!

Hayley Atwell was gorgeous! :D
warlock
warlock - 7/23/2011, 1:13 PM
I give it a B ALSO BECAUSE THE MOVIE WAS VERY ENJOUABLE. AND I LOVED THE END AND THE AVENGERS TRAILER.
warlock
warlock - 7/23/2011, 1:13 PM
I give it a B ALSO BECAUSE THE MOVIE WAS VERY ENJOUABLE. AND I LOVED THE END AND THE AVENGERS TRAILER.
LFANCH
LFANCH - 7/23/2011, 1:15 PM
gaahhh i can't see this till thursday!!! at least i'll have a cute girl to go with me then though. I agree with you guys about the fight scenes. I thought the first iron mans and hulks were good, the other 2 ended kinda fast. maybe that's because marvel wants to use fights scenes as one of the ways to make avengers blow everybody off their seats
spiderman620
spiderman620 - 7/23/2011, 1:17 PM
Ecksman- I think u missed the point of his original statement he said ur review was bad bc u listed it a B+ but u only list the positive points of the movie, and left out the bad. All he said was learn to be more well thought brother
spiderman620
spiderman620 - 7/23/2011, 1:19 PM
Shit a B+ is still good just list why it was a B+ next time thats all man
CalebBoone
CalebBoone - 7/23/2011, 1:40 PM
Dear Ecksmanfan:

I saw this movie last night.

I noted that the villain had a red face and head, similar to the red-and-black-striped face and head of the karate-fighting villain in one of the Star Wars movies.

I will call last night's villain "Darth Sherbet."

Have a Dovely.

Sincerely yours,
Caleb Boone
Hays, Kansas
[email protected]
BloodRed
BloodRed - 7/23/2011, 1:40 PM
"I enjoyed this one more than I did Thor, but I don't think it was quite up to par with the first Iron Man film. With each film they make, Marvel and company are improving on their stories and films..."

CONTRADICTORY STATEMENTS. How is Marvel improving on their stories with each film, if this isn't on par with the first Iron Man????

The truth of the matter is that Marvel hasn't made a GREAT film SINCE Iron Man.

Deal with that FACT True Believers!

Shunt
Shunt - 7/23/2011, 1:53 PM
so it sounds like DC takes another step behind Marvel.. Thanks a lot WB for not having Balls!!!!
TheMyth
TheMyth - 7/23/2011, 3:01 PM
I loved the film. It was sold out in 3 auditoriums at the Cape West 14 all night and got a standing ovation in my showing, something I haven't seen since Spider-Man 2. I did not find the final battle to be anti-climactic at all. I do agree the combat montage mid film was a bit sudden and confusing lol. I feel like this has been the strongest Marvel film yet emotionally. When Tommy(can't remember his character name right now) gives the file to Peggy I nearly cried, and I didn't even cry when Old Yeller died lol. This film just took the new position of my favorite CBM to date. Not even the great Chris Nolan has touched the level of emotion that can be experienced in this film.
Cheesehead
Cheesehead - 7/23/2011, 3:51 PM
NickKase, I agree with you. I thought Thor was better than this. A little too cheesey for me. But it was good.
gunner
gunner - 7/23/2011, 10:09 PM
I loved it !!
Fun and it did not insult me and my love of the genre.
Marvel and Joe Johnston should be proud , i am !!
gorgeousgeeks
gorgeousgeeks - 7/23/2011, 11:06 PM
The fight with Red Skull was anticlimactic. Cap accidentally defeated him, if you don't consider that Red Skull really defeated himself, the way it was foreshadowed at the beginning of the film. How is that not anticlimactic?
gorgeousgeeks
gorgeousgeeks - 7/23/2011, 11:07 PM
@Nick I enjoyed Thor more.
canvilella
canvilella - 7/23/2011, 11:46 PM
My top cbms this year:

1. Xmen
2. Cap
3. Thor

Still haven't seen GL as it hasn't opened here yet, but i know I'll love it regardless of what the reviews say!!
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 7/24/2011, 4:31 AM
Awesome review dude!!!!

MARVEL STUDIOS is the way to go... not [frick]ing FOX! :p

This and THOR top-notch!

Big thumbs buddy! ; )
View Recorder