COMICS: Can Scott Lobdell Save SUPERMAN?

COMICS: Can Scott Lobdell Save SUPERMAN?

DC Comics' Superman title is on its 4th writer since the relaunch and the series number have been less than ideal for such an iconic character. Has DC finally found their man in Lobdell?

By MarkJulian - Jun 12, 2012 08:06 AM EST
Filed Under: DC Comics
Source: Huffington Post

Looking at the sales numbers for DC Comics' big three or Trinity, it's pretty evident that Batman (and his offshoot titles) is the main draw of DC's readership. In fact, over the last four months Batman from Scott Snyder has sold more than the combined totals of both Superman and Wonder Woman. It may seem like a self-explanatory observation with the current success of all-things Batman related abut there was a time when Superman was king of the comic world. Thirty years ago Supes was still sitting on the comic book throne but by the mid 80's he was struggling to crack the top 10 as the X-Men titles from Marvel were absolutely dominating the sales chart. The resurgence brought by the wholesale reboot of the DC Universe last September spiked Big Blue's numbers but that appears to be on a downward trend. Perhaps the answer to this phenomenon lies in the very story told in DC's latest direct-to-video entry "Superman vs. The Elite." A story that seeks to answer is their a place for the small town morals Superman in today's harsher, grayer urban society. Those that have seen the film or are familiar with the original comic run know that it took Superman giving the world a "wake-up call" to remind them of his importance. After George Pérez, Keith Giffen and Dan Jurgens have all been given a crack at revitalizing the Man of Steel, DC now turns to Scott Lobdell to remind readers of that importance.


HuffPo So, are you guys [Lobdell + artist Kenneth Rocafort] on this title for the long haul?

Scott Lobdell: Well the last time I was on a flagship title I stayed on for about five years! So trust me when I say that I am totally committed to writing Superman for at least twice as long.

HuffPo: So you have long-term plans for the book?

SL: I don't work that way. Just like I could not have imagined a year ago that I'd be writing the world's most famous super hero... I like the stories of the characters to mirror the same sense spontaneity and unpredictability that define us in "real life".

Yes, I turned in a 25 page pitch for the series that examined every aspect of Superman, his friends, his enemies and over a dozen story ideas... but I've found over the years that the series often takes on a life of its own once the characters and the conflicts and the interactions start to show up on the page.

Just imagine how boring it would be if you sat down and told me exactly how your life was going to play out every month for the next 12 months -- who you were going to meet, what you were going to say, how they were going to act, what super powers you were going to use to defeat them? Then imagine the likelihood that your life would play out exactly the way you predicted it would over the course of the next twelve months.


HuffPo: Will you be carrying on the continuity, or pulling a new New 52 and tweaking things slightly?

SL: "Pulling a new New 52!? I love your questions, Bryan!

Let me say that there will be tweaking aplenty -- but I think it is going to be in terms of tone and attitude and not in history or continuity. We have no plans to reveal Lois is Superman's daughter from an alternate future or that Perry White is actually an amnesic Jonathon Kent who has been in witness protection.

But yes, you'll see from the very first issue -- in fact, even in the Annual and the Zero issue before it -- a Superman that is going to feel very of the moment.


HuffPo: What is your favorite thing about the Superman character and how do you guys hope to bring that to book?

SL: I like the sheer uniqueness of Superman. The fact he is stuck on a planet of six billion people -- who he is the self-appointed champion of those people -- but that he will never be one of them? How awesome is that? If it were me I would probably take a deep breath and fly into space and find a planet where people were more like me (could you imagine what that would look like) -- maybe a planet that wasn't so reliant on what I did every day. But not Kal El. He's there day-in and day-out putting his life on the line for a people that alternately put him on a pedestal or steer clear of the most famous alien on Earth.

Again, there are over six billion people on the planet, and only one Superman.

(And when you consider that the other two "supers" are a girl who thinks you've gone totally native and a clone of you who was created to be the world's greatest living weapon -- he has more in common with the rest of us than he does with his own 'family'.)

That said, too often Superman is seen by readers as "too perfect" -- that he always makes the right choice. But the truth is, every choice has consequences and when all the choices you make are super choices you have super consequences.

The very first issue is going to see the results of several choices which are going to have ramifications for months to come!


Online Graphing

Sales Chart For DC's Trinity


Welcome the new creative team of Scott Lobdell and Kenneth Rocafort as they take us back to the days when Jor-El learned the truth about Krypton’s imminent destruction! Plus: More on the introduction of the Eradicators!

Written by: Scott Lobdell
Art by: Kenneth Rocafort
Cover by: Kenneth Rocafort
Variant Cover by: Kenneth Rocafort
Color/B&W: Color
Page Count:32
U.S. Price: 2.99
On Sale Date: Sep 26 2012

About The Author:
MarkJulian
Member Since 6/8/2011
CBM writer for a decade+.
DC Reveals First Look At Clayface: Celebrity Dirt, A Batman Universe Noir Horror Comic
Related:

DC Reveals First Look At Clayface: Celebrity Dirt, A Batman Universe Noir Horror Comic

Absolute Batman #19 Reveals Identity Of The Five Absolute Robins Following [Spoiler]'s Death
Recommended For You:

Absolute Batman #19 Reveals Identity Of The Five Absolute Robins Following [Spoiler]'s Death

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
Helena
Helena - 6/12/2012, 8:14 AM
New 52 WW is great. One of the few actually good reboots.
marvel72
marvel72 - 6/12/2012, 8:21 AM
animal man is my favorite book of the new 52,batman by snyder is good haven't read any superman or wonder woman yet.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 6/12/2012, 8:24 AM
Nope. Bringing Superman back and leaving the douchebag out of the comics will save Superman.
marvel72
marvel72 - 6/12/2012, 8:27 AM
@ BattlinMurdock

these are my favorites

-animal man
-aquaman
-batman(snyder)
-the flash
-green lantern
-swamp thing

i've read a couple of issues of red lanterns,i thought it was pretty good.

i heard wonder woman is good as well.
Spidey1996
Spidey1996 - 6/12/2012, 8:28 AM
Is that a Kryptonian suit? Doesn't look that bad.
deanwilkins
deanwilkins - 6/12/2012, 8:30 AM
Just cancel Superman until someone can get it right. The comics have been terrible for years, with minor exceptions.
carrowsboy
carrowsboy - 6/12/2012, 8:34 AM
New 52 WW is the best that book has been in YEARS! Or rather when Rucka left.
Shaman
Shaman - 6/12/2012, 8:38 AM
The problem is not with the writers (Although Perez was indeed atrocius), it lies with their revamped concept of the Man of Steel. People just can't stand him.
Shaman
Shaman - 6/12/2012, 8:45 AM
And i don't agree about Swamp Thing and Animal Man. I find both of them to be mediocre at best. Unless their second story archs are any better then their first that is. They just completely lost me with their Rot/Red/Green concept. Very lazy writing IMHO so i dropped them both.
MarkJulian
MarkJulian - 6/12/2012, 9:04 AM
@Just1Superguy That chart only looks at the solo titles not the supporting ones as well. Good rant though.
musashi
musashi - 6/12/2012, 9:05 AM
@darkmetal. What can be done with those characters that hasn't already been done?

Answer: Make them gay! :-)
Gmoney84
Gmoney84 - 6/12/2012, 9:11 AM
I haven't read a single issue of the New 52. Where should I start?
evyllsummer
evyllsummer - 6/12/2012, 9:13 AM
I hate Scott Lobdell's writing, so, yeah, thanks for the head's up! Pass!!
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 6/12/2012, 9:20 AM
Just1Superguy yep, he is a douchebag. Stories are retells of older stories. Only difference is, now they have a douche Superman...
coolguy
coolguy - 6/12/2012, 9:27 AM
I quite liked judges and giffen so far. It felt like the 90s but it wasnt terrible in my opinion. I don't think that I really like Lobdel though just based off of tt
coolguy
coolguy - 6/12/2012, 9:29 AM
I meant jurgens
SammyG23
SammyG23 - 6/12/2012, 9:33 AM
Bring back the Superman we all know and love. Enough with the tampering and rebooting already.
Shaman
Shaman - 6/12/2012, 9:35 AM
dellamorte1872- I don't care how many times they rehash the same concept, it doesn't make it good in my eyes. In fact, it makes it even more lazy to me.

Just1Superguy- I definitely did read the first wave of the New52 INCLUDING all books featuring Superman and i find him completely different from the Superman he was before the reboot. The short fuse/activist attitude they gave him was just what triggered the snowball effect that made him the character he is right now. You might like him, but plenty of people don't apparently. If he was the same, his book would at least do decently well, like it did before the reboot. I haven't checked the numbers to compare but he never did need "saving" before. And Batman has always outsold Superman.
valeriesghost
valeriesghost - 6/12/2012, 9:56 AM
They should have never given it to Perez in the first place. and I would love to see an Aquaman movie based of the current run.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 6/12/2012, 9:59 AM
"TheManOfSteel1013 - 6/12/2012, 9:53 AM
Report Comment
Maybe they shouldn't have done this stupid relaunch to begin with...there's a thought"

now we are getting somewhere...
Shaman
Shaman - 6/12/2012, 10:16 AM
Intruder- I entirely agree about JMS. He can write Superman as well as he writes Thor. The man understands how to make an overpowered character relatable, without having to turn him into a bitch. And i also agree about Morrison. I'm not a fan of his way of writing Superman.

Nomis- Touché! I forgot all about good ol' Byrne. The previous years of olde i knew about but just chose to disregard ;)

Froggy- The first JL run seemed like a bad "Expendables with Superpowers" script to me. It's not so much that it wasn't up to par with Geoff's higher standards because the only thing i like from him so far is his work on Flash and his Aquaman run. So IMHO, he has proven more than once to be able to write mediocre stories. But i do have to admit, his JL is oceans away from being in the same league as the best New52 book out there; Aquaman. Yes, i find it better than Snyder's Batman but not by much.
Vadakin
Vadakin - 6/12/2012, 10:28 AM
Hooray, another writer who treats Superman as an alien who can never fit in. Yeesh. And DC wonder why they can't catch a break with Superman. Even though nobody from DC will read this, let me impart some wisdom, just in case.

Superman is a human being. He was raised as a human being. He thinks like a human being, he feels like a human being, he acts like a human being. Kal-El died the day Krypton was destroyed. There is no Kal-El personality.

If you treat Superman like an alien god who can't fit in, of course you're going to fail. Because that's not who Superman is. He's the son of a farmer who grew up learning about responsibility and hard work, about right and wrong. Granted, the Kents are the greatest parents in the history of the world but they are fundamentally human. Clark's physiology is irrelevant when talking about what kind of person he is.

The idea of him not fitting in also makes no sense. Yes he has superpowers but he doesn't spend all his time in the Fortress of Solitude, moping over what he can't have. Why? Because he can have it. He does have it. He has a life beyond Superman. He has friends in Pete Ross and Lana Lang. He isn't pretending to be Jimmy's friend to protect his identity. They truly are friends. Let's not forget Lois who ultimately becomes the love of his life.

He loves being Superman but he also loves being a journalist. He loves exposing the bad people of the world for what they are and helping people, either through super feats or some damn fine investigative journalism.

What makes Superman work isn't that he's a stranger from another land. It's that he's lived a human life and understands the human condition. He's an inspiration, not as an alien god, but as a human being who uses his powers to help people simply because he feels it's the right thing to do. He's an example to humanity, an idea of what we can be as people if we stopped being so selfish all the time.

Superman is one of the most human characters in DC and the sooner they realise that, the better off they'll be.
Vadakin
Vadakin - 6/12/2012, 10:41 AM
Or maybe it's because he was taunting the police.
Vadakin
Vadakin - 6/12/2012, 10:46 AM
@Just1Superguy Thank you for posting those panels. Even though you didn't intend it, you've just shown what's wrong with the New 52 Superman.

It's Superman who is supposed to be talking about staying within the law and not being gods. It's Superman that's supposed to be inspiring the other heroes. It's Superman who is supposed to be the one saying how important it is to stay connected to their humanity and to show the world a better way, not to force it on them.
Shaman
Shaman - 6/12/2012, 11:01 AM
Just1Superguy- The article stated it apparently needed "saving", not me. I just figure if they could write the character worth a damn in the first place, it might not. Action Comics sells more than Superman but the thing with that is, they aren't in the same setting to start with. AC works closer to the character's origin and Sup's book deals with the character in the current NEW52 continuity. The different attitude aproach works best in line with a character's NEW origin, not an already established setting where people were used to him acting differently. And as much as i'm not a fan of Morrison, i have to admit he's got a solid following which brings sales to the table.

Not sure what you want me to suck on but my point still stands.
Shaman
Shaman - 6/12/2012, 11:03 AM
Vadakin- THANK YOU!!! You just hit the nail on it's head!
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 6/12/2012, 11:05 AM
Vadakin - my thoughts exactly (on your long but great comment)

1superguy - how about him wanting to control the world? Or him going all "come at me bro" in JL#1?
dnno1
dnno1 - 6/12/2012, 11:08 AM
One thing they could do the help is lower the price to the comic. Right now, it costs $3.99 and they are adding an additional story (like Captain Marvel, for instance) to the book. If Batman is selling so well, maybe they should put the extra stories there and lower the price of the Superman titles. Another point that should be brought up is the fact that Digital comics sales have risen dramatically within the past 3 years. I saw a report that said that there was over $1 million in total sales just in 2009 and last year, Comixology released an app for the Ipad and Iphone.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 6/12/2012, 11:28 AM
Just1Superguy - I'm not even talking about the trunks. My reasons for not liking the DCnU costume goes beyond the trunks.

The panels you showed? With him trying to impose his will over humanity? Yes, I believe that was wrong. To me, he is a "let's help people, but not force them into peace".

And we talked over and over about the "JL#1 incident". I still think Supes should be the guy to calm things down and not jump the gun and hit people before finding out what is really going on.
brokeBatman
brokeBatman - 6/12/2012, 11:45 AM
@Vadakin -Good stuff man. I think people who don't like, or dismiss Our Superman's character, is basically because they don't see those things about him at first glance. I always believed he was allowed so much god like power because he was raised with morals and ideals to handle it without being corrupted. I hope the movie reflects some of that:)
1 2
View Recorder