DOCTOR STRANGE Writer Reveals Why Jessica Chastain Turned Down The Role Of Christine Palmer

DOCTOR STRANGE Writer Reveals Why Jessica Chastain Turned Down The Role Of Christine Palmer

Rachel McAdams ultimately landed the thankless role of Christine Palmer in Doctor Strange, and now the movie's writer, C. Robert Cargill, has revealed why Jessica Chastain decided to say no to that...

By JoshWilding - Mar 28, 2020 03:03 PM EST
Filed Under: Doctor Strange
Source: Junkfood Cinema

Doctor Strange was a fun movie, and a strong introduction for the Marvel Cinematic Universe's Sorcerer Supreme. However, one of its biggest failings (aside from how closely it followed the origin story blueprint set out by Iron Man) was the way it treated Rachel McAdams' Christine Palmer.

Treated as little more than a standard love interest, she wasn't the Night Nurse fans know and love from the comic books, and it was recently revealed that McAdams won't return for the sequel.

During a recent interview with Junkfood Cinema, Doctor Strange writer C. Robert Cargill revealed that Dark Phoenix star Jessica Chastain nearly landed the role! "This is the interesting thing that Hollywood’s starting to find out, is that a lot of the actresses out there want to be superheroes as much as the actors do. I know this happened with Scott [Derrickson]. He went to Jessica Chastain to get her on Doctor Strange, because we were considering her."

"She’s like, ‘Hey, look, this project sounds awesome, and I would love to do it. But I’m only going to get one shot at being in a Marvel film and becoming a Marvel character; and I trained in ballet, and I really want to wear a cape.’ And that was the coolest rejection ever. She wanted to be in a Marvel movie, but she wanted to be the superhero, not the badass doctor Night Nurse."

That desire to "wear a cape" ultimately led to Chastain playing "Smith" in the aforementioned X-Men movie, a decision you have to believe the actress ended up regretting. After all, she may have had superpowers, but the role was a critical and commercial flop, and not what fans were hoping for from her first role in a major comic book blockbuster. 

There is a chance she could get another shot at playing a hero or villain on the big screen, of course, but we've heard nothing which points to that being the case as of right now. 

Who do you think Chastain could play either in the MCU or the DC Extended Universe?

Hit the "Next" button below to check out some MCU
concept art which would have been a game-changer!

 

Valkyrie In Thor: The Dark World

Valkyrie

We were first introduced to the MCU's version of Valkyrie when Tessa Thompson took on the role in Thor: Ragnarok. However, we could have seen the character much sooner in The Dark World!

Details about how she was going to factor into the sequel were never revealed, but Josh Nizzi's version of the character was definitely more in line with her comic book counterpart. Taika Waititi and Tessa Thompson's re-invention of the Asgardian was no bad thing, however, but it's still hard not to wonder about what might have been. 

The God of Thunder could have done with some backup when he took on Malekith, but it was an already very busy movie without adding yet another major comic book character to the mix.
 

Arnim Zola's Ant-Man Return

Zola

Ant-Man kicked off with a flashback to Hank Pym's decision to leave S.H.I.E.L.D. behind him, and it was during that sequence we got to see past versions of characters like Howard Stark and Peggy Carter. However, there was very nearly another founding member of the spy organisation there.

Arnim Zola died shortly after the events of Captain America: The First Avenger, but as The Winter Soldier confirmed, he uploaded his consciousness into a sophisticated computer system.

As a result, we would have seen that comic book accurate version of Zola in Ant-Man sitting alongside the likes of Howard and Peggy (still manipulating S.H.I.E.L.D. on behalf of HYDRA). This would have been very cool to see, but perhaps Marvel Studios decided it was just too weird?
 

The Hulk Busts Out

Giant

In an earlier version of Avengers: Infinity War, Bruce Banner was finally going to come to an agreement with The Hulk and that was set to lead to the emergence of Smart Hulk in Wakanda. 

It wasn't until the last-minute that reshoots changed this as the Russo Brothers decided that a victory for the Jade Giant like this just didn't feel right when Earth's Mightiest Heroes were about to suffer their worst loss to date. As a result, we were robbed of the awesome sight of The Hulk literally busting his way out of the Hulkbuster armour! 

Still, there's no denying that Smart Hulk's introduction in Avengers: Endgame worked really well. 
 

Ant-Man And The Vision Switch Sides

Giant

During the early stages of development on Captain America: Civil War, Marvel Studios hadn't fully decided who was going to be on each side of the divide between Captain America and Iron Man.

Interestingly, an earlier version of the movie would have seen Ant-Man fighting alongside Iron Man, while The Vision was set to be part of Captain America's Secret Avengers. Ultimately, it was decided that it wouldn't make sense for Scott Lang to join Tony Stark given everything his mentor Hank Pym had said about him and his father.

As for The Vision, there was obviously more drama to be mined from him being on a different side to the Scarlet Witch given their romantic relationship. What might have been, though, eh?
 

Scarlet Spider

Spider-Scarlet

When Marvel Studios was tasked with introducing Spider-Man in the MCU, they were faced with the difficult job of redesigning the web-slinger's costume. Sam Raimi's movies stuck closely to the source material, while The Amazing Spider-Man 2's suit looked like it had been lifted straight from the comics.

Well, before going with the version created by Tony Stark, Marvel Studios very nearly went with both of the Scarlet Spider's costumes (a drastic new look for the web-slinger). 

As you can see above, Peter Parker's homemade costume would have been based on the clone's classic hoodie look, while his final suit was going to be what he wore while serving as the Marvel Universe's new Spider-Man. This doesn't mean we were going to see Ben Reilly in the MCU, but using that character as inspiration would have been a clever way to differentiate their version of Spidey. 
 

Thor Vs. The Midgard Serpent(s)

R0coe

Thor's subplot in Avengers: Infinity War was a little weird, and Peter Dinklage's disappointing turn as Eitri really didn't help matters! However, Stormbreaker's origin could have been way more exciting. In an earlier version of the film, the God of Thuner was going to be joined by Rocket and Groot in an epic battle with the Midgard Serpent's children. 

According to Marvel Studios Senior Visual Development Artist Rodney Fuentebella, the axe/hammer would have been buried in the head of the fallen monster, and after the God of Thunder retrieved it, he and the Guardians would have had to battle the World Serpent's children in what sounds like a pretty barmy (and must-see) action sequence.

We don't know why this didn't make the final cut, but it's a damn shame, that's for sure. 
 

Black Widow Becomes Ronin

Ronin2

Very little context was revealed regarding this particular piece of concept art, but Hawkeye clearly wasn't going to be the only one suiting up as "Ronin" in Avengers: Endgame. Whether she did this to track him down or because he was planning to join his mission is sadly hard to say. 

Either scenario would have been fun to see, of course, and Natasha Romanoff heading down a similarly dark path had the potential to be an exciting direction to take her down in this sequel.

Ultimately, it's hard to complain about the story arc Black Widow ended up getting in the movie, but Marvel Studios definitely missed a trick by not further exploring Clint Barton's time as Ronin. With any luck, that will be something the planned Hawkeye series on Disney+ ends up addressing.
 

The Wasp's Scrapped Role In Captain America: Civil War

Wasp

A big part of Ant-Man and The Wasp's story was the fact Scott Lang had gone to Germany to fight alongside Captain America without talking to Hank Pym or Hope Van Dyne beforehand. 

The latter was particularly disappointed that Scott overlooked her, but there was a version of Captain America: Civil War which would have seen her join the battle against...Steve Rogers? Unless Hawkeye was going to side with Tony Stark, both Ant-Man and The Wasp were clearly going to join Iron Man to fight for the enforcement of the Sokovia Accords. 

It's a real shame that The Wasp was overlooked here, but Marvel Studios clearly decided that her transformation into a superhero was better off being save for the Ant-Man sequel.
 

Mega Ultron

Mega-Ultron

Avengers: Age of Ultron came under fire from some fans for its snarky take on the titular android, but the villain was a worthy addition to the MCU, and someone we'd like to see more of.

When that does happen, it would be great to see this gigantic version of the villain made up of literally thousands of drones. As fun as it was to watch Earth's Mightiest Heroes take on his expendable robotic army, watching them take on this gigantic version of him would have no doubt been even more exciting (and like watching the comic books come to life). 

Dubbed "Mega Ultron" by concept artist Phil Saunders, it's hard to say for sure whether this would actually work in live-action, but it might have gone some way in helping Age of Ultron's final act feel like less of a retread by pitting another faceless army against the team of superheroes. 
 

Nebula Unleashes The Power Of The Infinity Gauntlet

Nebula

Nebula played a crucial role in Avengers: Endgame, but fans hoping to see the Guardian of the Galaxy be the one to take down Thanos were disappointed. In the Infinity Gauntlet comic book series, she unleashed the power of that titular weapon to restore her original appearance and get revenge on the Mad Titan, but that simply wasn't something we saw here.

However, this early piece of concept art reveals that the Russo Brothers did briefly consider having Nebula finally get her hands on the Gauntlet to unleash the power of the Infinity Stones.

Given how they were portrayed in the MCU, using them would have likely resulted in Nebula's death, so it makes sense that this was a moment ultimately scrapped from the movie. In some ways, though, Thanos' daughter making the ultimate sacrifice to stop him might have made more sense than Iron Man being the one to do so in the final battle. 
 

Has Denzel Washington REALLY Been Cast As Dormammu In DOCTOR STRANGE 3?
Related:

Has Denzel Washington REALLY Been Cast As Dormammu In DOCTOR STRANGE 3?

DOCTOR STRANGE 3: Sam Raimi Reportedly In Final Talks To Direct IN THE MULTIVERSE OF MADNESS Follow-Up
Recommended For You:

DOCTOR STRANGE 3: Sam Raimi Reportedly In Final Talks To Direct IN THE MULTIVERSE OF MADNESS Follow-Up

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
TheUnworthyThor
TheUnworthyThor - 3/28/2020, 3:26 PM
She may have a agreed to a role in an X-men movie but that still leaves her available to be a MCU movie and we’re hearing that Christine Palmer won’t even be in Doctor Strange 2. So not the worst choice.
Vigor
Vigor - 3/28/2020, 3:30 PM
Blame her agent
He/she should have educated her on the differences in the various marvels (mcu, Sony, fox). A simple decision for all of us fans but for someone who doesn't know...
Origame
Origame - 3/28/2020, 6:52 PM
@Vigor - but how would that change the fact marvel wanted her to play a love interest?
Vigor
Vigor - 3/28/2020, 9:20 PM
@Origame - doesnt but as we can see, marvel is not averse to turning love interests into heroes (Jane, Pepper Potts, gamora). Mcu is the long play but also the smart play either way you slice it
Origame
Origame - 3/29/2020, 3:48 AM
@Vigor - all of those love interests were superheroes in the comics though.
Origame
Origame - 3/29/2020, 3:48 AM
@Vigor - not to mention they arent even using her in the sequel, and may end up never using her again.
tmp3
tmp3 - 3/28/2020, 3:31 PM
She's probably gonna be in the Flash film, based on the director...
ossie85
ossie85 - 3/28/2020, 3:36 PM
Not my first choice... but maybe gunning for Sue Storm?
MUTO123
MUTO123 - 3/28/2020, 3:37 PM
I get that this isn't the worst thing about her character in Dark Phoenix, but did they have to give her a name that sounds so close to "[frick]"?
Kumkani
Kumkani - 3/28/2020, 3:41 PM
@MUTO123 - She had a name? I didn't even remember it.
MUTO123
MUTO123 - 3/28/2020, 3:42 PM
@Necropolitan - Me neither! I had to look it up after the movie was over.
Kumkani
Kumkani - 3/28/2020, 3:40 PM
I watched Dark Phoenix for the first time yesterday. She was actually very close to be awful in that.
Kumkani
Kumkani - 3/28/2020, 3:41 PM
The film was also pretty shit too. I'm not sure if I should rant about it.
tmp3
tmp3 - 3/28/2020, 3:41 PM
@Necropolitan - She was bad in It 2 too. Great in Molly's Game though. She's been pretty inconsistent recently
MUTO123
MUTO123 - 3/28/2020, 3:42 PM
@Necropolitan - Rant.
Kumkani
Kumkani - 3/28/2020, 3:44 PM
@tmp3 - I mean the material in Dark Phoenix is pretty bad so that contributes a lot. The character had a lot of cliche lines, and Kinberg's direction was not great.
tmp3
tmp3 - 3/28/2020, 3:45 PM
@Necropolitan - Kinberg is bad.... but he somehow has a big spy film already wrapped, starring Sebastian Stan, Lupita Nyong'o and Chastain lmao. Dude must have dirt on every Hollywood exec or something.
MUTO123
MUTO123 - 3/28/2020, 3:51 PM
@Necropolitan - The directing in that movie is straight-up incompetent. Kinberg cannot direct scenes, he cannot direct actors, he cannot choreograph ANYTHING. I couldn't figure out what the [frick] was going on in most of the action scenes, even that train fight people said "Well, that's OK" is shot and cut so shittily. He [frick]s up in areas that I don't even pay attention to sometimes (framing and sound design being two of the big ones). Kinberg CANNOT direct.
Kumkani
Kumkani - 3/28/2020, 4:11 PM
@MUTO123 - Okay fine lol. Not like I have anything better to do anyway.

You know what bit absolutely annoyed me the most? It's after the opening sequence with the space mission rescue. When Jean absorbed the solar flare, seemingly almost died, Charles seems pretty oblivious to that and Mystique has an issue Charles' sudden chummy relationship with humans. Because yea, it is [frick]ing weird how these mutants have gone from being feared, hunted, experimented on and some of them being outright terrorists to taking direct calls and orders from the [frick]ing president, isn't it? But I digress.

What annoyed me the most after that extremely rushed sequence is when Raven and Charles are arguing, and she says something to the effect of "It's funny how you haven't been risking anything and all you do is sit in your chair," and I'm like Ooh, low blow but she kinda has a point. You're acting weird, Charles. And then this bitch actually says "And by the way, the women always seem to be saving the men out here. You should think about changing it to X-Women," or something like that. I had to pause it right there, and just take it in. It really hit me how far up its own ass this movie is.

I seriously could not believe they tried to throw in some extremely horrible attempt at feminist dialogue in the middle of a scene it didn't belong. I was actually shocked someone could write something so tone deaf. It was forced, unnatural, and even incorrect. Just a few [frick]ing minutes before that, during the mission Raven herself led, it was Cyclops that slowed down the spacecraft's spinning, Kurt and Peter and saved the crew, Kurt (with Jean) that saved the captain, and Kurt (again) that brought Jean back on board after she passed out. Like what in the goddamn [frick]? Kurt practically saved everyone, and that's the nonsense she says. Of course I blame Kinberg because this is what happens when people that shouldn't be writing things from a certain perspective think they can.

I think every issue I have with Dark Phoenix is found in this scene. Weird or unenthusiastic acting. Absolutely shit dialogue. An extremely pretentious story and movie that thinks it's important but lacks emotional weight or stakes.
LongMayHeReign
LongMayHeReign - 3/28/2020, 4:22 PM
@tmp3 - She must need good direction because we know Kinberg ain't shit and you've been saying dude who directed It 2 was trash so at least there's some correlation there.

Would love to see Chastain in the MCU matched with a good director!
tmp3
tmp3 - 3/28/2020, 4:39 PM
@LongMayHeReign - I'm saying she's bad at picking projects, not that she's a bad actress
Chewtoy
Chewtoy - 3/28/2020, 4:53 PM
@Necropolitan - Yeah, I just watched it on HBO for the first time this week, and it really was bad. The whole thing felt abbreviated... “You all know where we’re going with this, right? We don’t actually have to do the work to get you invested, do we?”

Lord knows Jennifer Lawrence couldn’t have seemed more disinterested in things...
MUTO123
MUTO123 - 3/28/2020, 5:00 PM
@Chewtoy - This movie's so bad I jotted down 3 pages worth of notes on every flaw I could spot while I was watching it (which I don't usually do).
1 2
View Recorder