FANCAST: HeisenbergSaysRelax's choices for Marvel Studio's 'SPIDER-MAN'

FANCAST: HeisenbergSaysRelax's choices for Marvel Studio's 'SPIDER-MAN'

HeisenbergSaysRelax takes another shot at fan-casting and lets the world know who he would cast in a Spider-Man film if it was being done by Marvel Studios. Check it out!

By HeisenbergSaysRelax - Jul 05, 2014 01:07 PM EST
Filed Under: Fan Fic

Well, here we go. Doing yet another one of these fan-casts. This time I'm gonna tackle Spider-Man. I wanted to see if I could do a Spider-Man fan-cast using actors who are somewhat closer to their character's age than what is normally cast. So read on to find out who I chose to play Spider-Man and all of his amazing friends...and foes...and whatever his Aunt and Uncle are.

Writer: Chris Galletta - Director: Jordan Vogt-Roberts (The Kings Of Summer)

I chose these two because they recently wrote and directed a film called 'The Kings Of Summer' that was released in 2013. The film was basically a coming-of-age comedy about three teenage boys and I felt that, tonally, they had exactly what was needed to handle a Spider-Man film. I also wanted to avoid the ever common Lord and Miller casting because I feel Lord and Miller are a little too far on the comedy side of things. I think Galletta and Vogt-Roberts would be able to pull off a much better comedy-to-drama ratio.


Peter Parker/Spider-Man - Tye Sheridan (Mud, Joe)

I chose Tye Sheridan because he's an up-and-coming young actor who has some serious ability. He's recently starred alongside Brad Pitt, Matthew McConaughey and Nic Cage and has been able to hold his ground alongside each and everyone, sometimes delievering an even better performance than the experienced actors around him.


Gwen Stacy - Erin Moriarty (The Kings Of Summer, True Detective)

I first noticed Erin Moriarty in the 2013 film ' The Kings Of Summer', then noticed her again in the first season of the HBO series ' True Detective'. She excelled in both roles, turning in some great performances. I think she has the right look and she's around the same age as Sheridan.


Mary-Jane Watson - Bella Thorne (Shake It Up, Blended)

I noticed Bella Thorne in the trailers for the film 'Blended' (which I did not actually see because...well, I think it's obvious). She clearly has the look down and I think acting-wise she could pull off the role rather well.


Harry Osborn - Ansel Elgort (Carrie, The Fault In Our Stars)

I saw the terrible 'Carrie' remake earlier this year and I noticed this guy in it. He didn't have a lot to do in the movie but he was still able to make it work. I think he could pull off the "cool" parts of Harry's character and still be able to pull off the tougher father-son drama stuff that would eventually become important.


Flash Thompson - Connor Jessup (Falling Skies)

I chose Connor Jessup because he looks the part to me. I mean, sure, he's a little smaller than the typical Flash casting, but I think when compared to Sheridan, he could be a rather imposing force. He's also properly aged which helps. I always felt that whenever the large, hulking guys come on screen in High School films it's always REALLY obvious that the guy is in his 30's, so I wanted to go with a more believable high schooler.


Uncle Ben - Colin Firth (Kingsman: The Secret Service, The King's Speech)


But he's English!!...Yeah, I know. But he's a really great actor and he's done work with American accents before in the film 'Arthur Newman'. I specifically chose Colin because I wanted a younger Uncle Ben. In my mind, it never made sense that Peter would be a teenager and have such an old Aunt and Uncle. They shouldn't be much older than Peter's normal parents (maybe 7 years older) and Peter's original parents should be young enough to justify having a teenage son. So, in my mind, it always made more sense to have Ben be in his late 50's or very early 60's.


Aunt May - Brooke Sheilds (Nip/Tuck, Hannah Montanna: The Movie)


I figured if I was going to cast a younger-than-normal Uncle Ben, I'd have to do the same with Aunt May. I decided on Brooke Sheilds because she's a rather well-known actress and she seemed like a good pair-up with Colin Firth. It seemed believable to me that they might be married. I also think that with a shorter hairstyle, she might be able to really look the part.


Norman Osborn/The Green Goblin - Ethan Hawke (Before Sunrise, Gattaca, The Purge)


Ethan Hawke is a really good actor. He's been in a couple less-than-amazing films as of late, but he's still an awesome actor. He's done amazing work in the 'Before' trilogy and he was terrific way back when he did 'Gattaca'. He's also shown an ability to play the calm rich-type in films like 'Daybreakers' and 'The Purge'.


The Vulture - Christoph Waltz (Django Unchained, The Green Hornet)


I took a little longer on this one than the rest of the villains, mostly because I couldn't think of anyone old enough that I also thought could bring something different to the role. Then I thought about Waltz. I basically imagined his 'Inglorious Basterds' charcter in a green Vulture costume and it seemed so right.


The Rhino - Woody Harrelson (True Detective, The Hunger Games)


I wanted to go with someone who could play "dumb" well and I thought that Harrleson was a good fit. He's proven to have a great ability to play characters who aren't the sharpest tools. Everyman-type characters. I'm also a big fan of his and I'm always open to an excuse to stick him into a CBM.


Kraven The Hunter - Oscar Isaac (Drive, Inside Llewyn Davis)


I really liked Isaac in the film 'Drive' and then I liked him even more in the film 'Inside Llewyn Davis'. He's also gonna be in the new Star Wars film which is cool. I chose him because I really want to see him do a more athletic action-movie type role and see what he can do with it. He's a fantastic actor and I think he'd kill it as Kraven.


Doctor Octopus - Forest Whitaker (Species, The Butler)


I'll probably catch some flack for this one since I went and changed a character's race, but I've always thought it'd be cool to see Whitaker as Doc Ock. I think Whitaker would do a really amazing job as a mad-scientist slowly decending into insanity. He's a great actor and I think he'd be a great Ock.


Eddie Brock/Venom - Alex Russell (Carrie, Chronicle)


I wanted to avoid chosing a generic blonde actor because I've seen that done so many times and I'm kinda over it. I went with Alex Russell because he did a great job of playing the likable friend in 'Chronicle' and he also did a great job of playing a bad-boy character in 'Carrie' and I think if you were to combine those roles, you'd end up with a really amazing Venom/Brock.


Curt Connors/The Lizard - Matthew Rhys (The Americans)


Matthew Rhys is pretty awesome in 'The Americans'. I chose him because I wanted to go with someone who I hadn't seen cast before and who I thought could bring something new to the character.


Shocker - Troy Baker (The Last Of Us)


I know he's typically a voice-actor, but I thought he'd be a great choice for Shocker. I've always read Shocker's voice in a southern/Texas accent, similar to Baker's character Joel in the video game 'The Last Of Us'. Unlike most voice-actors, this guy has a face that would be easy to transition to the screen. I thin he'd be a really awesome Shocker.


Mysterio - Jerry O'Connell (Sliders, Stand By Me, Joe's Apartment)


Jerry O'Connell isn't the best actor ever. He's kinda over the top and sorta goofy and he hasn't really done much in the last few years. All of those things are reason why I chose him to be Mysterio. I've always thought the best person to play Mysterio would be a B-list or even C-list actor who is kinda sleazy and goofy and that's O'Connell.


Well, there you have it. My Marvel Studio's Spider-Man fancast. I hope you enjoyed the read and I'm curious to hear what you thought so drop a comment down below, hit that thumb button and lemme know what you liked and didn't like. Thanks.
DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created Infinite Crisis Video
Related:

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created "Infinite Crisis" Video

Bill Cosby Says He Wants To Be In A Superhero Film
Recommended For You:

Bill Cosby Says He Wants To Be In A Superhero Film

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

ndwwrestler2
ndwwrestler2 - 7/5/2014, 2:16 PM
I like your cast, it's very original for the most part. The one thing I disagree with is your point about Uncle Ben and Aunt May.

As someone who's been raised by older people, it makes more sense then you might think.

But I like your cast, and hope to see more.
MikeZ
MikeZ - 7/5/2014, 2:25 PM
- Not too sure about Thorne. But I will recognize her doing two gritty R-rated horror films, even though they'll suck. Maybe she could work as MJ if she fills out a little.
- Erin Moriarty looks really cute. I think she'd be better as Gwen Stacy than Emma Stone.
- I'll remain mum regarding Colin Firth as Uncle Ben.
- Fantastic choice for Aunt May!
- Not too sure if I see Ethan Hawke as Norman Osbourne, TBH.
- I think someone bigger than Woody Harrelson should play Rhino.
- Ooh, our new Joker as the Shocker, huh? Sure, why not? Even though I haven't played The Last of Us.
kong
kong - 7/5/2014, 3:04 PM
0mega put it EXACTLY right.
SwanRonson
SwanRonson - 7/5/2014, 5:28 PM
Amazing cast. Seriously. This is coming from a huge fan of the TASM series!

I'd still like to see B.Cranston as Norman Osborn but Ethan Hawke has major chops.
SwanRonson
SwanRonson - 7/5/2014, 5:29 PM
P.S

Your villain picks are the highlight, but the rest are solid too. Whitaker as Ock is fantastic.
SonGoku
SonGoku - 7/5/2014, 5:38 PM
Very original.
CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 7/5/2014, 5:39 PM
Love all of these choices!
Great picks for all of them, especially Peter, Gwen and MJ.
Bella Thorne would be an amazing high school MJ.



She's getting some bigger roles and is so pretty.
canadianturd
canadianturd - 7/6/2014, 12:37 AM
This is definitely one of the better and inspiring Spider-Man fan casts I've seen. Although it looks like you should have swapped your Harry and Flash picks.
Pasto
Pasto - 7/6/2014, 6:26 AM
I too second 0mega's statement.
SidDaAstroSloth
SidDaAstroSloth - 7/6/2014, 7:46 AM
I am not big on Bella Thorn. She doesnt scream MJ to me.

The director is a good choice. He is also the guy who could be doing the Metal Gear Solid movie and that gets me excited!
FlixMentallo21
FlixMentallo21 - 7/6/2014, 9:04 AM
I seriously did not expect Forrest Whitaker as Doc Ock or Jerry O'Connell as Mysterio, but they have the right stuff to pull off those characters. Also, it seemed like I was the only one who used O'Connell in casts, thanks for breaking the streak up a bit.
JillyMcBeam
JillyMcBeam - 7/6/2014, 9:43 AM
Please, if they ever reboot Spiderman, which I hope they never ever do again, PLEASE do not drag out two movies with us having to deal with Gwen Stacey. God Forbid.
Mrcool210
Mrcool210 - 7/6/2014, 10:14 AM
All of these are good choices, but i do have to disagree with one of them, i know ive said it before, but ive got one choice and one choice only for the big ol red head.

CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 7/6/2014, 10:47 AM
I like this cast because they actually look like high schoolers! And are young enough to be high schoolers.
Not some 30 year old pretending to be 17.

Thorne literally is MJ, she doesn't need huge boobs, she actually looks like a supermodel.

Abary
Abary - 7/6/2014, 10:57 AM
Amazing cast Heis. I love that you actually chose young actors for high schoolers, instead of 30 year olds.
Hulksta
Hulksta - 7/6/2014, 11:18 AM
Wow, a fan cast I 100% agree with...

It's perfect :'(
PrinceAwesome
PrinceAwesome - 7/6/2014, 12:56 PM
Lol, I am amazed that of these commentors are calling this cast 'incredible' when in reality, it depicts the very brash essence in which why I am glad that most of these fanboys are not casting agents nor screenplay writers. The only decent choices in this thread are merely Uncle Ben, Mysterio, Shocker and Rhino. As for the rest, you are basically merging the Twilight series into the Spider-Man universe.

Hell, this casting call is so [frick]in terrible that a DISNEY STAR is ACTUALLY being vouched to play a popular role in a SPIDER-MAN film. Jesus Christ, the internet has stooped in such a whole new level of stupidity.

Here would be my cast ...

Spider-Man/Peter Parker: Matt Lanter
Gwen Stacy: Evan Rachelwood
Mary Jane Watson (personally, I wouldn't add in MJ since I believe that Spidey should have only one girl, instead of brushing on Gwen's death as if it were a swarm of dead worms, but if I would ...): Jane Levy
Harry Osborn: Jensen Ackles
Flash Thompson: Garret Hedlund
Uncle Ben: Collin Firth
Aunt May: Hellen Mirren
Norman Osborn: Christopher Meloni
The Vulture: John Malkovich
Rhino: Woody Harrelson
Kraven the Hunter: Gerald Butler (or Michael Fassbender)
Doctor Octopus: Kevin Spacey
Eddie Brock/Venom: Chris Pine
Curt Connors/Lizard: Jude Law



PrinceAwesome
PrinceAwesome - 7/6/2014, 1:00 PM
^^^Edit: Olivia Thirlby would be another choice for Gwen.
HeisenbergSaysRelax
HeisenbergSaysRelax - 7/6/2014, 1:52 PM
@PrinceAwesome

How am I merging the Twilight series with the Spider-Man universe? Is it because I used younger actors (while all your choices are damn near 30)? Or is it because you don't recognize the majority of the younger actors? Tye Sheridan is a skilled actor. Go watch Mud or Joe. He's leaps and bounds above "Twilight" talent. The same goes for Moriarty, Elgort and Russell.

Also, after reading your "list" just now, you have NO room to talk about low-level actors being used. Matt Lanter? Jensen Ackles? Sure, maybe if I was casting a Spider-Man TV series for the CW. OH and you included Fassbender. How original of you.
PrinceAwesome
PrinceAwesome - 7/6/2014, 8:16 PM
@Heisenberg

The acting talent may not be as disastrous as the 'Twilight' series, but how in the flying hell can you mock Trank for his Fantastic Four casting when your implementing a variety of mediocre babyfaces as the characters of a much beloved series. What position are you in to call my cast baffling when you are structuring a Disney Star to play Mary Jane just because she has pretty shiny red hair. Hell, even proclaiming that she has somewhat of a talent in acting greatly defines your bland taste in cinema (still dont believe me? Go watch 'Shake It Up' and then tell me if you want to see some chick like that be a part of a Marvel film).

Oh, and if youre not convinced that Ackles can't play a decent Harry Osborn, go watch 'Under the Red Hood'. If the guy can voice act that damn good, imagine how he would be if he had an acting role that is familiar to that character.

And if you know how to READ, you can see that Fassbender was not my first choice for Kraven, although I mentioned him as my secondary since his physical AND acting aspects in '12 Years A Slave' convinces me that Fassbender can play a raging bulldozer that is obsessed over decapitating his own adversaries. And otherwise, if so unoriginal my casting for Fassbender as Kraven is, tell me the amount of threads that suggest this same ideology and then you'd be correct.

At the end of the day, everyone has a right to their own opinion and my opinion about this dream cast is that it is all shit. Of course, there may be some talent here and there, but all-in-all, just because one has talent, it does not mean that he/she can pull off a role that is iconic to many. And many do not grasp Spidey to be some pathetic douchey-looking babyface with the voice of an anti-social Elton John.

Perhaps many may not concur with my opinion, but growing up as a child, I have never thought that the face residing beneath Spidey's mask would have a face like this:

[IMG]http://i62.tinypic.com/6yfy1s.jpg[/IMG]

HeisenbergSaysRelax
HeisenbergSaysRelax - 7/6/2014, 8:39 PM
@PrinceAwesome

You make a lot of assumptions, kid. Your first assumption is that I "mock" Trank's F4 castings, which more often than not, I'm found defending. I think all four of the actors he's chosen are good at what they do and while I don't agree with certain actors being cast, I don't complain about it because it isn't my cast, it's his.

Your second assumption was that I have "bland taste in cinema" simply because I chose a "Disney star" to portray a character and again, your assumption is wrong. I can assure you that my "taste" in cinema is just fine. I've seen more films that you've probably ever heard of and I'm sure my "taste" in films is far superior to yours...However it's all subjective so it's pointless to debate.

Your third assumption was that I haven't seen "Under The Red Hood", which I have and I still stand by my point that he's a terrible choice for anything but a CW Spider-Man series.

And your fourth assumption was that I don't know how to read, which I do. I never said you cast Fassbender in any role. I simply said that you included him in your list, which you did. Ackles, Fassbender, Pine, Hedlund, Malkovich, Spacey and Butler are some of the MOST OVERUSED choices ever. They're actors that every fanboy sticks into every fancast simply because they like the actor. You're list is basically a giant collection of cliched choices. The only overused actors your didn't include on your list are Charlie Hunnam and Idris Elba. So, as I said earlier, you have no room to talk about shitty fancasting.

And you're correct. Everyone has a right to their own opinion. Even if some people have shitty opinions. I would suggest that in the future you learn how to express yours in a less asshole-y way. You can get the same point across just fine without the arrogance.
BigChinese
BigChinese - 7/6/2014, 9:03 PM
I have to say the casting choice is excellent! The first thing stoke me was - WTF are you trying to make a teen movie? Well, then second thought, you could be right about hiring teenage actors, even I do not know most of them.

The casting choice for the villain is uncanny but great (I cannot agree making Doc Ock black though, not a racist, just...no). I specially like the casting choice of Green Goblin.

Well done and keep it up!~

thebug022
thebug022 - 7/6/2014, 11:48 PM
I respect the crap out of this.

My perfect Peter is still Callan McAuliffe, but Sheridan would do good too.
PrinceAwesome
PrinceAwesome - 7/7/2014, 1:20 PM
@Heisenberg

There is not a doubt in my mind that you have watched a greater quantity of films than I have (after all, I am merely seventeen years old), but my main issue with this thread is the casting of Peter Parker and Mary Jane (two roles in which structures the prospects each and every Spidey story has constructed) is nothing, if not lacking in reverence. I am not saying Sheridan is such a horrendous actor, but what I am implying is that if you are intending to cast the role of Peter Parker with such sheer preponderance, then you need to cast the role with an actor that is EXPERIENCED - in other words, a sixteen-year old cannot pull off such a prominent role if he only has two films listed as the cusp of his resume.

Oh, and just because an actress provides the physical aspects of a certain character, it does not mean that her acting abilities are a phenomena of an actresses' prowess.

Watch this video below, skip til minute one, and then tell me if you STILL want to see a person like that be a part of a franchise in which is beloved by all.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7nhymDoo9sI

CaptainJugular77
CaptainJugular77 - 7/7/2014, 8:37 PM
This is really original. I couldn't agree more about the studios casting actors and actresses much older than their characters (even though I'm a huge fan of Garfield, Stone and co.'s portrayals).
MightyZeus
MightyZeus - 7/8/2014, 12:37 AM
All of your choices are good.

Thumbs up.
View Recorder