IRON MAN: 8 Times The Marvel Cinematic Universe's Tony Stark Was The Absolute Worst Avenger

IRON MAN: 8 Times The Marvel Cinematic Universe's Tony Stark Was The Absolute Worst Avenger

Iron Man proved himself a hero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, even choosing to make the ultimate sacrifice to save reality. However, there were occasions when Tony Stark was the worst Avenger!

Feature Opinion
By HamiltonParker - Sep 16, 2021 10:09 AM EST
Filed Under: Iron Man

At the end of Avengers: Endgame, Iron Man proved himself the ultimate superhero when he sacrificed his life to end Thanos and save reality itself. For that, we'll always respect Tony Stark, but there have been several occasions when this Armored Avenger has been the absolute worst. 

For many, Iron Man became the Marvel Cinematic Universe's mascot and a character Marvel Studios definitely built much of its shared world around as time passed. However, despite his heroic actions, Tony made some big mistakes.

From creating a terrifying villain to letting his ego get in the way of doing the right thing, Iron Man is a long way from being perfect. That's what makes Marvel's superheroes so great in some ways, but Tony's actions have been pretty reprehensible at times, and those moments are what we're highlighting here. 

So, if Captain America is the First Avenger, would it be unfair to name Iron Man the Worst Avenger?
 

8. Mocking Aldrich Killian

2938231e1w12

Tony has a habit of creating his own villains. He was partly responsible for Obidiah Stane's descent into villainy, and mocking Justin Hammer had disastrous consequences. However, the way Tony treated Aldrich Killian at that New Year's Eve party was arguably most damaging to the MCU. 

Tony's cruel rejection of the A.I.M. leader sent him down a dark path that ended only in madness. Had the future Avenger put his arrogance to one side and given Aldrich a chance, it's entirely possible they could have done amazing work together. 

Instead, Killian very nearly brought America to its knees with his fake "Mandarin" and a lot of people died. Even though Tony is dead and gone now, we wouldn't be surprised if A.I.M. one day resurfaces to cause problems in the MCU (with Killian potentially returning as M.O.D.O.K. like in the non-canon Iron Man 3 video game).
 

7. Tony Stark, Arms Dealer

2938231e1w121

Tony might have eventually seen the error of his ways, but it's easy to forget that he was a full-blown arms dealer when we met him in the MCU. 

Everything was a joke to the future Avenger, and despite the fact that he'd just created a devastating missile (the "Jericho") for the U.S. Army to use in the Middle East, he still found time for a drink. Hell, he even promised to throw in some free whiskey for the troops if they were to purchase his weapons. Yes, this Tony was very much a war-monger. 

Had he not been kidnapped by the Ten Rings and received that guidance from Ho Yinsen, chances are Tony would have continued heading down this route. We saw hints of that in What If...? when he teamed with Erik Killmonger to create a robotic army that villain would eventually use to secure the Black Panther mantle for himself. 
 

6. Drunken Party

2938231e1w1213

Despite proving himself a hero in Iron Man, Tony had gone completely off the rails in the sequel. Marvel Studios may have watered down "Demon in the Bottle," but his actions at that birthday party were still pretty deplorable. 

Putting pretty much everyone at risk, it wasn't until Rhodey suited up and intervened that Tony was finally prevented from doing something terrible. We know he was going through a lot at this time, but Iron Man was a jerk throughout the majority of this film regardless of what was going on with his Arc Reactor. 

We learned that he'd shot down Nick Fury's offer to join The Avengers (selfish) and the way he talked about "Natalie Rushman" wouldn't really fly in 2021. Poor Rhodey and Pepper Potts suffered for their friendship with Tony, though he was eventually redeemed to some extent.
 

5. Antagonizing His Teammates

2938231e1w12134

Tony didn't really start off as a team player, and never was that more evident than in The Avengers. Assembling alongside the rest of Earth's Mightiest Heroes, Iron Man wasted no time in antagonising his teammates (with potentially disastrous consequences). 

His daddy issues very nearly led to a clash with Captain America - primarily because he was jealous of the way Howard Stark would talk about Steve Rogers - and his attempts to get Bruce Banner to transform were pure madness. That could have put everyone on the Helicarrier at risk, but as long as Tony got to reel off some jokes, what did he care?

Luckily, by the time the credits rolled, Iron Man stepped up when he willingly flew that nuclear missile into the portal above New York City. This was a turning point for Tony as a hero, but he still found at least a few occasions to be a total jerk...
 

4. Creating Ultron

2938231e1w121344

Ego too often got the best of Tony Stark, and never was that more evident than when he decided to create Ultron. While Iron Man could have never predicted the consequences of trying to build a robotic army to protect the Earth, thinking he could, and should, be the one to do so nearly led to humanity's extinction. 

As if that wasn't bad enough, Tony persisted and created The Vision next despite knowing the consequences could be even more disastrous than what happened with Ultron, and while it was Thor who made the final decision, who knows what could have happened.

The Vision was very much a hero, but his creation had plenty of unintended consequences, including the rise of the Scarlet Witch following WandaVision
 

3. Supporting The Sokovia Accords

2938231e1w1213443

We've established that Tony has made some mistakes and broken a lot of rules, which made it all the more surprising when he decided to support the Sokovia Accords in Captain America: Civil War.

Simply put, he was a hypocrite, and all too quick to turn his back on the rest of The Avengers. Iron Man was the villain of this piece (just like in the comic books), but perhaps his time making weapons for the military can be used to explain why he was willing to become a government lackey? 

We understand why Tony saw red during that battle with Cap after learning The Winter Soldier killed his parents, but his actions in this film just didn't add up and we expected better from this Avenger. 
 

2. Recruiting A Teenager...And Then Taking His Suit

2938231e1w12134433

Desperate to turn the tide against Captain America and his team of Avengers, Tony Stark tracked down Peter Parker and added Spider-Man to his #TeamIronMan roster. 

After placing an inexperienced teenage boy in the firing line, Iron Man basically gaslighted him and ignored Spidey's calls for months. Trying to follow in the footsteps of his mentor, Peter very nearly caused a complete disaster, and Tony had the audacity to then take his costume from him. That led Spider-Man underpowered and more vulnerable than ever while facing The Vulture.

Peter and Tony would eventually form a close bond, and there's no denying that Iron Man cared about his young protege. However, we certainly hope he was a better father to young Morgan than he was a father figure to the wall-crawler at times!
 

1. Not Calling Captain America

2938231e1w121344333

We may never know if Thanos could have been defeated by a united team of Avengers, but it seems likely. However, when the Black Order arrived on Earth, we saw Tony make a conscious decision not to call Captain America and enlist the help of Steve Rogers' "Secret Avengers."

We know time was of the essence here, but we're pretty sure Iron Man could have fit in a quick call! Steve hurt him, but there was once again an element of ego here that ultimately played a role in half of the entire universe being wiped from existence. 

In fairness, we'd say that Tony made up for this by using the Infinity Stones to make the ultimate sacrifice and wipe the Mad Titan out of existence. Iron Man was a hero, and a great one at that, but as we're sure you'll now agree, the Armored Avenger was definitely a flawed individual. 
 

Jeff Bridges On Being So Frustrated With IRON MAN's Unfinished Script & Original Plan For Obadiah Stane
Related:

Jeff Bridges On Being "So Frustrated" With IRON MAN's Unfinished Script & Original Plan For Obadiah Stane

IRON MAN: New Hot Toys Figure Brings The Classic Comic Book Version Of Tony Stark To Life
Recommended For You:

IRON MAN: New Hot Toys Figure Brings The Classic Comic Book Version Of Tony Stark To Life

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
Cap1
Cap1 - 9/16/2021, 9:04 AM
8 Reasons why Josh Wilding is a nuisance
PhoenixBlade
PhoenixBlade - 9/16/2021, 9:26 AM
@Cap1 -
1. List articles
2. Quotes from one interview into multiple articles
3. Casual misogyny a couple times a year
4. His painfully obvious burner account
5. Clickbait headlines
6. Articles where the content is on another site that he wrote the article for
7. Terrible opinion pieces
8. Long headlines that don’t get to the point
Cap1
Cap1 - 9/16/2021, 9:34 AM
@SamaelSaint - burner accounts* add to that list - adding his opinion to articles which don’t need it, his child-like literacy, spoilers in articles with no warning, petty responses, deleting said petty responses, complete lack of any talent
philinterrupted
philinterrupted - 9/16/2021, 10:27 AM
@Cap1 -
JoshWilding
JoshWilding - 9/16/2021, 10:58 AM
@Cap1 - Aww, you're so salty. Thank you, though, as you've become my go-to commenter for a good laugh. 😂

JoshWilding
JoshWilding - 9/16/2021, 11:06 AM
@SamaelSaint -

1. I wouldn't write them if they weren't popular
2. It's beneficial to CBM as it allows us to highlight key pieces of information that other sites will pick up on (between prep time, the interviews themselves, and transcribing, an unbelievable amount of time goes into these things)
3. News to me
4. Also news to me
5. If you say so
6. It's called cross-promotion and is done for the benefits of those websites, not mine
7. Well, that's just your opinion, man
8. It's called SEO
PhoenixBlade
PhoenixBlade - 9/16/2021, 11:27 AM
@JoshWilding -
JoshWilding
JoshWilding - 9/16/2021, 11:38 AM
@SamaelSaint -
Cap1
Cap1 - 9/16/2021, 11:40 AM
@JoshWilding - petty responses ✅
PhoenixBlade
PhoenixBlade - 9/16/2021, 11:50 AM
@JoshWilding - Enough flirting, my room or yours?
JoshWilding
JoshWilding - 9/16/2021, 12:02 PM
@Cap1 - Joking aside, I don't know what's happened/happening in your life to make you so angry, but life is too short to hate on some guy on the internet you're never going to meet, man. I have a great time doing this job, I love being able to speak to people like Jon Bernthal, Andy Serkis, and Katee Sackhoff, and honestly don't know what you're hoping to achieve here. Regardless, I hope you can eventually find something more than hate in yourself. 👊
MyCoolYoung
MyCoolYoung - 9/16/2021, 9:05 AM
He didn’t have a chance to call cap. He opened the phone then the maw came, he should’ve taken his suit because he wasn’t listening, signing the accords made sense in context of what he went through, he thought he was dying why not drink up? Plus he wasn’t an avenger

No ultron, no vision. With no vision we don’t get that love persevering line and that makes tony the greatest.

[frick] killian even if I was a fan of that movie.
ModHaterSLADE
ModHaterSLADE - 9/16/2021, 9:12 AM
Would be nice if the MCU actually did a a proper Demon in a Bottle storyline one day. The drunken party scene just came off as goofy AF.
Footguy6449
Footguy6449 - 9/16/2021, 9:13 AM
Great article JosHamilton Parker.

ptick
ptick - 9/16/2021, 9:15 AM
So, he very clearly wasn't an Avenger yet (as the headline claims) for #8 through #6. #5 is arguable because at what point are they officially "The Avengers" in that movie?

#4 was obviously awful and #2 was indeed absurd (though it got us SM in the MCU) that he would just go and grab a teenager he had seen on YouTube to fight against other Avengers ... #3 is perfectly defensible depending on what "side" you took and #1 ... um ... that always seemed to me like he was literally about to call and then obviously got sidetracked.
ptick
ptick - 9/16/2021, 9:17 AM
(Not to mention that, in #5, most of the characters were asshats to each other when they all first got together.)
thelastson18
thelastson18 - 9/16/2021, 9:25 AM
Slow news day I guess.

Though speaking of iron man, I’d love to see insomniac make an Armor Wars video games where you can make do co-op between Iron Man, War-Machine and other iron clad characters. So hyped for Wolverine!’
Luigi
Luigi - 9/16/2021, 11:15 AM
@thelastson18 - We all love Wolverine but I feel like he was the most boring choice possible to make a game of in terms of powerset and locations. Hope I'm wrong but Iron Man and others would've been great.
DoubleD
DoubleD - 9/16/2021, 9:26 AM
R.I.P. Iron-Man, Captain America and Black Window.

Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 9/16/2021, 9:28 AM
@DoubleD - This has GOTTA be fan made, right? Can you imagine if that kind of spoiler was just dropped in a movie poster months before a release? Lol
philinterrupted
philinterrupted - 9/16/2021, 10:33 AM
@DoubleD - cap’s not dead you silly goose.
marvel72
marvel72 - 9/16/2021, 1:54 PM
@DoubleD - I'll miss Captain America the most.
Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 9/16/2021, 9:32 AM
The thing about this list is you could make it about almost any MCU character of course. That's a part of the appeal and relatability of Marvel's characters: that they are FLAWED. Even literal Gods in this universe have confidence problems and family issues. Take those flaws away and you're left with a dull character like MCU'S Captain Marvel.
Origame
Origame - 9/16/2021, 9:53 AM
At best number 1 is a mistake he made. And one that's kinda reasonable since the moment they were talking about calling cap two super-powered aliens came to attack the city.
dracula
dracula - 9/16/2021, 9:54 AM
Wouldnt really count pre origin stuff. With the exception of Banner and Rogers, they were all different degrees of a hole before becoming heroes
Twenty23Three
Twenty23Three - 9/16/2021, 9:54 AM
Tony wasnt a very good dude. That’s half the character. In the comics I think he does more good than bad whilst being an asshole. Less so in the films
dracula
dracula - 9/16/2021, 9:56 AM
The accords are debatable. Both sides had their points. If this was the comic version of those evente, then sure
bkmeijer2
bkmeijer2 - 9/16/2021, 9:59 AM
In his defence, he was a dick before he choose to fly a nuke through a wormhole. Everything after that was just him doing what he thought was right (except for calling Steve, but that was because there were aliens knocking)
FishyZombie
FishyZombie - 9/16/2021, 10:24 AM
Most of the villains he inspired were just butthurt dicks who were petty about being fired or something. Ultron was the only thing that I really had a problem with. Not because he did it but because besides one angry mom slapping him, I thought he got off too easy. But I sort of blame this on using a Hank Pym story for Tony. It just didn't fit, in my opinion.
itzayaboy
itzayaboy - 9/16/2021, 10:39 AM
What a stupid article. Waste of time to read.
1 2
View Recorder