9 Times The Marvel Cinematic Universe Elevated Its Source Material

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has a knack for elevating the source material it's adapting. Here, we focus on nine examples of the MCU improving upon the stories the movies are based on...

By DanielKlissmman - Aug 30, 2021 10:08 AM EST

Filed Under: Marvel Studios

Hollywood franchises are tricky ventures. Having one take off is difficult enough on its own, and maintaining a franchise that has already found success is even harder. That is what has made seeing the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s journey this past decade so special. Unlike franchises that found their footing before losing it over the years, the MCU is showing no signs of stopping.

The Marvel Studios saga has been consistently finding both critical and financial success with each one of its installments thanks to their rich stories, relatable characters and eye-popping action. One of the ways the franchise has done this is by taking its source material and making it mainstream, regardless of how “out-there” it may be on the page.

Such a dynamic has often led the MCU to elevate the comic-book stories it’s based on. With that in mind, let’s take a look at 9 times the Marvel Cinematic Universe improved upon its source material.

9. Thanos’ Motivation

There’s no denying that Thanos’ motivation to get the Infinity Gems in the “Infinity Gauntlet” storyline was creepy. The man was in love with Death and wanted to kill half the universe to impress her. While that made for a terrifying baddie, there was not much room left for nuance in his characterization (in that particular story).

In Avengers: Infinity War, Marvel Studios took Thanos' quest and put a fun spin on it. Much like his comic-book counterpart, the Mad Titan also wanted to collect the Infinity Stones to decimate half the universe. However, he wanted to do it in a (misguided) bid to give the remaining half more resources to live plentiful lives.

This new motivation gave Thanos a more nuanced characterization that at times had audiences actually siding with the purple fella. He’s still insane, but his villainous journey is somewhat rooted in a desire to help others. Keep in mind, we’re not saying Thanos’ characterization in the comics is weak. It’s simply that, as mentioned, the films took what was in their source material and improved it.

8. Iron Man 3’s Mandarin

We know, we know. But before getting your pitchforks ready, hear us out. When Iron Man 3 was being marketed, audiences were promised a grounded version of the Mandarin, one of Iron Man’s greatest foes. He didn’t have the mystical powers of the Ten Rings like in the comics, but he was menacing, had an army at his disposal, and was played by Ben Kingsley.

When the film came out, though, it was revealed that the Mandarin (at least, the version played by Kingsley), was actually Trevor Slattery, a failed actor hired to portray the Mandarin by one of Tony’s old rivals. Slattery was shown to be an unstable individual who didn’t even seem aware of what exactly he was doing. The reveal angered many comic-book fans, who demanded to see a proper adaptation of the villain on the big screen. The thing is… the Slattery twist wasn’t bad. In fact, it was quite good.

Revealing Slattery's Mandarin to be a fraud worked not only because it was, admittedly, hilarious, but because it surprised general audiences as well as comic-book fans. Let’s face it, as comic-book readers, it’s often difficult for superhero films to take routes that actually surprise us and leave us in the dark as to what will happen next. By turning what everyone was expecting from the Mandarin on its head, Marvel Studios successfully threw comic-book readers a curveball and made the rest of Iron Man 3 an excitingly unexpected story.

Of course, it’s understandable for fans to have been peeved by the reveal, but it was a fun twist that put a spin on the “bad guy” premise we are, by now, so familiar with. Plus, Marvel Studios eventually brought out the real Mandarin for Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. With that, the Mandarin character was never wasted, but simply used as a fun surprise before his eventual true reveal.

7. Spider-Man’s Relationship with Iron Man

Tony Stark and Peter Parker in Spider-Man Homecoming

Tony Stark’s mentorship of Peter Parker in the MCU has been somewhat controversial, as some fans have clamored to see the young hero be more independent. That is an understandable complaint, especially given how many years we’ve had of Spider-Man having to figure out his life on his own. Here’s the thing, though: Fans' familiarity with Spider-Man’s lonesome nature is also what makes his relationship with Stark in the MCU work so well.

We’ve had many comic books, TV shows and films of Spidey struggling with his powers, jobs and relationships while having essentially no one around to lean on. The MCU, however, asked the question: “What if Peter Parker had some backup for once?”

Much like the Mandarin twist, having Peter Parker have someone to mentor him through the superhero job was special, and allowed us to see what a Spider-Man who had support would look like in live-action. Of course, that’s not to say that Spider-Man being on his own is bad. It’s a staple of the character. Having said that, it’s also fun to have the chance to look at the other side of the coin.

6. Carol Danvers’ Backstory

Much like the other entries on this list, this isn’t a complaint about the comic-book version of Carol Danvers. Her journey in the Marvel Universe has been quite a ride, and it’s been fascinating to see her evolve as a superhero over the decades. This entry is just to say that the MCU took what had been established in the comics and used it to create an even more complex and engaging backstory for the hero.

Presenting Carol Danvers as a powerhouse who’s unable to remember her past and is being used as a weapon by the Kree due to her abilities is a great concept. Such an approach made for an amazing film in 2019’s Captain Marvel, and also opened up countless storyline possibilities for Carol Danvers moving forward.

That backstory also gave Carol’s heroic nature an added level of excitement, as audiences got to see her embrace her identity and come to terms with her life as a human-Kree hybrid.

5. Killmonger’s Family Ties

Imagine this: A villain who is a killing machine with a genius-level intellect and strong enough to beat the Black Panther himself in hand-to-hand combat. Is there a way to make him even more awesome? As Marvel Studios showed with Erik Stevens (a.k.a. Killmonger) in 2018’s Black Panther, there is.

In the comics, Erik Killmonger (born N’Jadaka) has a complicated backstory that has gone through a few retcons, but it boils down to him being a Wakandan who was kidnapped from his country by criminals and taken to the United States. There, he became hell-bent on getting revenge on Wakanda and the Black Panther for turning his back on him. When adapting the villain for Black Panther, Ryan Coogler and Marvel Studios established Killmonger as T’Challa’s long-lost cousin, who was abandoned in the United States after King T’Chaka killed his father.

Making T’Challa and Killmonger blood relatives made their interactions powerful and heartbreaking. It was clear that, if things had gone slightly different between T’Chaka and his brother, Killmonger could have gone to Wakanda and become T’Challa’s partner. That “What if?” scenario is compelling, and shows once again how good of a grasp Marvel Studios has on its characters’ comic book backstories.

4. The Vulture

Adrian Toomes, a.k.a. The Vulture, has been a foil for Spider-Man for decades, and there have been quite a few compelling stories centered around the villain. With so many years’ worth of backstory, it can be tricky to properly reinvent a character for the big screen while also maintaining his essence. That is, however, exactly what Marvel Studios did when it adapted Toomes for Spider-Man: Homecoming.

The film established Adrian Toomes as the father of Peter Parker’s first love, Liz Allan, putting him in a direct and very personal conflict with the Web-Slinger. He was no longer only a criminal desperate for power. He wanted to provide for his family, and crime was the only way he had found to do so. His motivation was strong, and his characterization even stronger thanks to Michael Keaton’s charismatic performance.

Yes, we knew Toomes was a bad guy, but it was also clear that there was a (somewhat) good man underneath the costume and violent antics. The Vulture has often been a joke in comics due to his colorful costume and peculiar abilities, but Marvel Studios cemented him as both a formidable foe and likable presence in the Spider-Man universe.

3. Black Widow’s Sisterhood

Black Widow recently introduced general audiences to Yelena Belova. In the comics, Belova is an adversary of Natasha Romanoff. The film, however, took a different approach that elevated both the character and her relationship with Natasha. 2021’s Black Widow made Belova and Natasha young Russian spies, who were put together in a fake family to steal information for a bad guy known as Dreykov. While the family was a lie, Yelena and Natasha effectively became real-life sisters that were, sadly, eventually torn apart.

The characters’ relationship gave Black Widow a warm dynamic, as both former assassins reconnected after years apart and gradually accepted their love for each other. The way Marvel Studios approached Yelena and her relationship with Natasha avoided making the new Black Widow just an evil/more violent version of Nat, and instead introduced a version of the character that audiences could easily get behind.

2. Hank Pym’s Relationship with Janet

In the comics, Hank Pym is… well, quite unstable. While he’s had his fair share of heroic moments in his different comic-book incarnations throughout the years, he’s also done some despicable things. The character’s most infamous characteristic in both the 616 and Ultimate universes is the fact that he is an abusive partner to Janet Van Dyne.

In the 616 universe, he infamously hit Janet, and in the Ultimate world, he was a serial abuser, subjecting Janet to both physical and emotional pain. Fortunately, when it came time to adapt him for the big screen, Marvel Studios decided to omit Pym's abusive nature from the comics.

In Ant-Man and Ant-Man and the Wasp, Hank Pym was depicted as a loving husband. Janet and Hank were best friends, and there was no indication that Hank was, in any way, abusive. The way Pym was handled in the MCU was smart, because it allowed a character that’s been so recognizable for so many years to not have the despicable characteristics that have made his comic-book counterpart so problematic.

1. Bucky and Captain America's Dynamic

In the “Captain America” comics from the ‘40s, Bucky Barnes was introduced as a Robin-like figure for Steve Rogers. He was a young child who idolized his adult partner and accompanied him in his adventures. Their relationship was a staple of the Captain America mythology for many years, but Marvel Studios decided to put a spin on their dynamic in Captain America: The First Avenger. In the film, not only was Bucky the same age as Steve, but he was also bigger and stronger than him before Rogers received the super-soldier serum.

Seeing Bucky defending and somewhat mentoring Steve before he became Captain America gave the pair a fun, younger-brother-older-brother dynamic and made their interactions a joy to watch. The fact that they knew each other since childhood also gave gravitas to the scenes in which Rogers had to fight Bucky as the Winter Soldier in Captain America: The Winter Soldier.

Andrew Garfield Reflects On Low-Budget SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Experience And Shares Message For The Haters

Recommended For You:

Disney+ Confirms Release Of These THREE Marvel Studios TV Shows In 2024

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

125 Comments

1 2 3 4

RageDriver2401 - 8/30/2021, 11:28 AM

Josh..?

DanielKlissmman - 8/30/2021, 11:56 AM

@RageDriver2401 - Lol, I'm flattered. But I'm not Josh.

Like I replied to another user, my name is Daniel. I've been a writer for a few years for other sites under the pen name "Franco Gucci."

Hope you enjoyed the read!

JonAwesome - 8/30/2021, 12:52 PM

@DanielKlissmman - how is Captain Marvel an “amazing film”?

Razorface1 - 8/30/2021, 12:54 PM

@JonAwesome - Well it was amazing and it was a film so...

Origame - 8/30/2021, 2:37 PM

@Razorface1 - both those words are entirely questionable when it comes to captain marvel.

bkmeijer2 - 8/30/2021, 2:59 PM

@DanielKlissmman - why does Franco Gucci sound like an alternate future mega-conglomerate ruler?

Razorface1 - 8/30/2021, 4:27 PM

@Origame - I disagree.

Origame - 8/30/2021, 5:08 PM

@Razorface1 - well I agree we disagree.

Razorface1 - 8/30/2021, 5:23 PM

@Origame - I disagree with that.

McMurdo - 8/30/2021, 7:05 PM

@DanielKlissmman - LOL right and IM not Josh either. PLEASE.

DanielKlissmman - 8/30/2021, 10:48 PM

@bkmeijer - I mean... who says I'm not? ;)

bkmeijer2 - 8/31/2021, 12:36 AM

@DanielKlissmman - hmm, good point

dracula - 8/30/2021, 11:30 AM

9.Agree
8.Hell no
7.It's nice but wouldn't say it makes any Spiderman or Iron Man stories better, in fact it hurts Spider-man stories.
6.Eh, a bottom of the barrel movie
5.Agree
4.Agree
3.Agree
2.Sure
1.Agree

Really the entire Civil War movie is better than the comic. The Civil War comic is mediocre at best, only remembered for its clickbait moments and stuff that happened in tie in material.

bkmeijer2 - 8/30/2021, 11:33 AM

@dracula - 100% agreed on Civil War. For me, it's definitely up there as one of the best stories the MCU has to offer.

Infinity War is great, but what the Russos and the writers did with Civil War really makes me think they're a good fit for Secret Wars.

tripttwe - 8/30/2021, 11:53 AM

@dracula - my favorite moment in the comic was CW#5 Captain America vs Punisher.

TheWalkingCuban - 8/30/2021, 11:57 AM

@dracula - yeah this Civil War was def better than the last one

bkmeijer2 - 8/30/2021, 11:31 AM

I don't really care as much for 7 and 3, but I agree with the rest for the most part. I'm still a big fan of Mandarin being a fake-out, although I definitely get why it divides the fan base so much

JFerguson - 8/30/2021, 11:33 AM

This was an enjoyable read. No clickbait, provided some insight into things I never would have thought of before, and showed knowledge of both comic book and CBM mediums.

Good job Jos.. I mean Daniel.

DanielKlissmman - 8/30/2021, 11:52 AM

@JFerguson - Hi! I'm glad you enjoyed the article. I'm not Josh. My name is Daniel, and I've been a writer under the pen name "Franco Gucci" for the past six years. I've been a fan of the site for a long time, but this is the first time I've created an account for it :)

ShellHead - 8/30/2021, 11:36 AM

Honestly it's nice to see one of these articles, instead of "15 Times the MCU makes NO SENSE" or "10 Characters FAILED by the MCU"

GhostDog - 8/30/2021, 11:44 AM

5, 4, and 9 are legit. All significantly elevated the lore.

4 has found elements of its material into the modern comics.

McMurdo - 8/30/2021, 11:46 AM

Thanos is far scarier in the comics. His obsession with Death being both literal and metaphorical. A true psychopath. The movie motivations were pure stupid. Having it be about resources pulled me right out of the movie because he could have just created infinite resources.

LongMayHeReign - 8/30/2021, 12:12 PM

@McMurdo - What's your plan for storing infinite resources?

ShimmyShimmyYA - 8/30/2021, 12:14 PM

@LongMayHeReign - everyone must constantly eat food extract minerals and burn fuel at the same time don’t ask me how not my problem

LongMayHeReign - 8/30/2021, 12:21 PM

@ShimmyShimmyYA - In an alternate timeline where Thanos creates infinite resources every living thing has diabetes and the air is covered in smog!

McMurdo - 8/30/2021, 12:41 PM

@LongMayHeReign - easy. Snap some planets into existence as part of your resources boosting plan. Better yet, create resources that strictly never deplete. He had the power of creation and all he could think of was wiping out half the universe only to eventually come right back to the same damn problem.

Itwasme - 8/30/2021, 12:45 PM

@McMurdo - Thanos scarier in the comics? Really? The guy was a clown, so much so the main heroes just sat around the whole time because Warlock know Thanos was such a fool he'd be his own downfall.

ShimmyShimmyYA - 8/30/2021, 2:58 PM

@McMurdo - Infinite planets ? Also that’s why he’s the mad titan because he thought genocide was the only way

bkmeijer2 - 8/30/2021, 3:03 PM

@McMurdo - maybe not infinite resources, but if I were Thanos I would just evolve photosynthesis up to the point plants grow atleast twice as quickly. More plants means more food, which also means more animals can be fed and eventually killed for its meat too

McMurdo - 8/30/2021, 7:07 PM

@bkmeijer - there’s ten thousand options that make him seem less like a purple bafoon

Slotherin - 8/30/2021, 7:28 PM

@McMurdo - damn, you've got a point

Armageddon26 - 8/30/2021, 11:48 AM

10: So far, Kang.

His comic origins are a convoluted mess. Having Kang’s origin be explored with the introduction to the multiverse makes introducing and explaining all the versions of him so much easier to follow.

McMurdo - 8/30/2021, 11:56 AM

@Armageddon26 - can dig it yep

heyy1 - 8/30/2021, 5:20 PM

@Armageddon26 - i found his backstory in Loki very clear which is surprising for a multiversal time-traveling villain. Although I don’t understand how killing him opened the multiverse. The TVA are still there closing branches.

ScottSummers - 8/30/2021, 11:51 AM

@TheDoctor1225
@BlackBeltJones
@Origame

This is precisely the kind of content I was talking about.

Well done, Daniel Klissman. Here's hoping for many more!

DanielKlissmman - 8/30/2021, 11:57 AM

@FortWaba - Thanks, my friend! Much appreciated :)

GhostDog - 8/30/2021, 1:13 PM

@FortWaba - nice!

bkmeijer2 - 8/30/2021, 3:05 PM

@FortWaba - if instead of listing the things something does wrong, you want content that talks about what it does right, then I agree with you

1 2 3 4

9 Times The Marvel Cinematic Universe Elevated Its Source Material

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has a knack for elevating the source material it's adapting. Here, we focus on nine examples of the MCU improving upon the stories the movies are based on...

9. Thanos’ Motivation

8. Iron Man 3’s Mandarin

7. Spider-Man’s Relationship with Iron Man

6. Carol Danvers’ Backstory

5. Killmonger’s Family Ties

4. The Vulture

3. Black Widow’s Sisterhood

2. Hank Pym’s Relationship with Janet

1. Bucky and Captain America's Dynamic

Andrew Garfield Reflects On "Low-Budget" SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Experience And Shares Message For The Haters

Disney+ Confirms Release Of These THREE Marvel Studios TV Shows In 2024

Disney+ Confirms Release Of These THREE Marvel Studios TV Shows In 2024

10 Worst Marvel And DC Comic Book Movies Of All-Time According To Rotten Tomatoes

Bob Iger Responds To Claims That Disney Has A "Woke" Agenda; Says Company Is Making Too Many Sequels

Disney+ Confirms Release Of These THREE Marvel Studios TV Shows In 2024

10 Worst Marvel And DC Comic Book Movies Of All-Time According To Rotten Tomatoes

Bob Iger Responds To Claims That Disney Has A "Woke" Agenda; Says Company Is Making Too Many Sequels

Marvel Studios Rumored To Be Considering Multi-Season TV Shows For GHOST RIDER, PUNISHER, X-MEN, And More

10 MCU Heroes And Villains Who Were Killed Off By Marvel Studios Way Too Soon

Marvel Studios' SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS Expected To Be Shelved Moving Forward Amid Ongoing MCU Changes

Popular Headlines

Comic Book Store Owner Is Going Viral For His Comments That Modern Writers Don't Actually Love Superheroes

DEADPOOL 3 Is Rumored To Introduce A Major Wolverine Supporting Character - Possible SPOILERS

TASM Star Emma Stone's Bella Baxter Has A Frank Conversation About Her "Whoring" In New POOR THINGS Clip

Rachel Zegler On SNOW WHITE Backlash: "They're Probably Having A Hard Day... And I'm Putting Out A Movie"

DEADPOOL 3 Promo Art May Hint At Another X-MEN Cameo Appearance - Possible SPOILERS

DEADPOOL 3 Rumored To Make A Fan-Pleasing Change To Wolverine's Suit In The Movie - Possible SPOILERS

WHAT IF...? Season 2 Promo Art Reveals A VERY Different Nebula Variant And Newly Created Kahhori - SPOILERS

SPIDER-MAN: ACROSS THE SPIDER-VERSE Almost Didn't Include Spider-Punk But Could A Spin-Off Now Happen?

DEADPOOL 3 Rumored To Make A Fan-Pleasing Change To Wolverine's Suit In The Movie - Possible SPOILERS

WHAT IF...? Season 2 Promo Art Reveals A VERY Different Nebula Variant And Newly Created Kahhori - SPOILERS

SPIDER-MAN: ACROSS THE SPIDER-VERSE Almost Didn't Include Spider-Punk But Could A Spin-Off Now Happen?

DOCTOR WHO Features Shocking Regeneration Twist As First Look At Christmas Special Is Revealed - SPOILERS

THE MANDALORIAN: Lucasfilm May Be Developing Season 4 As A Movie After All

Ratings For The LOKI Season 2 Premiere May Have Been Down But What About The Show's Epic Season Finale?

Hot Headlines

Rachel Zegler On SNOW WHITE Backlash: "They're Probably Having A Hard Day... And I'm Putting Out A Movie"

Comic Book Store Owner Is Going Viral For His Comments That Modern Writers Don't Actually Love Superheroes

SUPERGIRL: Rumored Details Revealed About DCU's New Woman Of Tomorrow; "White" Actress To Replace Sasha Calle

GOTG VOL. 3 Actor Sean Gunn Has Been Cast As Maxwell Lord In The DCU

SUPERGIRL Rumored To Appear In SUPERMAN: LEGACY; Sasha Calle Will NOT Reprise The Role

Popular Headlines

Hot Headlines

Rachel Zegler On SNOW WHITE Backlash: "They're Probably Having A Hard Day... And I'm Putting Out A Movie"

Comic Book Store Owner Is Going Viral For His Comments That Modern Writers Don't Actually Love Superheroes

SUPERGIRL: Rumored Details Revealed About DCU's New Woman Of Tomorrow; "White" Actress To Replace Sasha Calle

GOTG VOL. 3 Actor Sean Gunn Has Been Cast As Maxwell Lord In The DCU

SUPERGIRL Rumored To Appear In SUPERMAN: LEGACY; Sasha Calle Will NOT Reprise The Role